Resources

In crystal field and ionic solid theory, the transition between stable coordination geometries for rock-salt (NaCl\text{NaCl}, 66-coordinate octahedral) and cesium chloride (CsCl\text{CsCl}, 88-coordinate cubic) lattices is governed by critical radius ratio rules (r+/r−r_+ / r_-). Determine the exact geometric threshold radius ratio r+/r−r_+ / r_- below which an 88-coordinate cubic lattice undergoes cation-anion contact loss and becomes unstable relative to a 66-coordinate octahedral geometry. Express your final answer as an exact radical expression and rounded to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

r+r−=3−1≈0.732\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 0.732.

Steps

01

Understanding the Limiting Condition in an 8-Coordinate Cubic Lattice

In a body-centered cubic-like arrangement (such as the CsCl\ce{CsCl} structure), a central cation of radius r+r_+ is coordinated by 88 anions of radius r−r_- positioned at the corners of a cube.

For the structure to remain mechanically and electrostatically stable, the central cation must remain in direct contact with all 88 surrounding anions. The critical lower boundary (threshold) occurs when the corner anions simultaneously touch each other along the cube edges while just maintaining contact with the central cation along the body diagonal:

  • If r+/r−r_+ / r_- drops below this threshold, the cation is too small to fill the central cavity; the anions touch each other and prevent further inward contraction, breaking cation-anion contact and making the 8-coordinate arrangement unstable compared to a 6-coordinate (octahedral) geometry.

02

Relating Cube Dimensions to Ionic Radii

Let aa represent the edge length of the cubic unit cell.

  1. Along the cube edge (anion-anion contact):
    At the critical limiting condition, adjacent anions just touch along each edge of length aa: a=2r−a = 2r_-
  2. Along the body diagonal (cation-anion contact):
    The body diagonal of a cube with edge length aa is given by: d=a2+a2+a2=a3d = \sqrt{a^2 + a^2 + a^2} = a\sqrt{3} Along this diagonal, two anions at opposite corners touch the central cation between them: d=2r++2r−=2(r++r−)d = 2r_+ + 2r_- = 2(r_+ + r_-)

03

Calculating the Critical Radius Ratio

Equating the two expressions for the body diagonal: 2(r++r−)=a32(r_+ + r_-) = a\sqrt{3}

Substitute a=2r−a = 2r_- into the equation: 2(r++r−)=(2r−)32(r_+ + r_-) = (2r_-)\sqrt{3}

Divide both sides by 2r−2r_-: r++r−r−=3\frac{r_+ + r_-}{r_-} = \sqrt{3}

r+r−+1=3\frac{r_+}{r_-} + 1 = \sqrt{3}

Subtract 11 from both sides: r+r−=3−1\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1


04

Numerical Evaluation

Using the approximation 3≈1.73205\sqrt{3} \approx 1.73205: r+r−=1.73205−1≈0.732\frac{r_+}{r_-} = 1.73205 - 1 \approx 0.732

Therefore, the exact threshold radius ratio is 3−1\sqrt{3} - 1, which is approximately 0.7320.732 to three significant figures.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the body-diagonal contact of a cube with face-diagonal contact, leading to the octahedral threshold √2 - 1 instead of the 8-coordinate cubic threshold.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2r−=a2r_- = a

  2. Step 2

    2(r++r−)=2a2(r_+ + r_-) = \sqrt{2}a

    Correct

    2(r++r−)=3a2(r_+ + r_-) = \sqrt{3}a

    In an 8-coordinate cubic lattice, the central cation sits at the body center of the cube and touches the corner anions along the body diagonal of length a2+a2+a2=3a\sqrt{a^2 + a^2 + a^2} = \sqrt{3}a, not along a face diagonal 2a\sqrt{2}a.

  3. Step 3

    2(r++r−)=2(2r−)2(r_+ + r_-) = \sqrt{2}(2r_-)

    Correct

    2(r++r−)=3(2r−)2(r_+ + r_-) = \sqrt{3}(2r_-)

    You substituted your edge relation correctly, but the equation carried over the incorrect diagonal factor.

  4. Step 4

    r+/r−=2−1≈0.414r_+/r_- = \sqrt{2}-1 \approx 0.414

    Correct

    r+/r−=3−1≈0.732r_+/r_- = \sqrt{3}-1 \approx 0.732

    Your algebraic rearrangement was executed properly, but it evaluated to the minimum radius ratio for 66-coordinate octahedral coordination rather than 88-coordinate cubic coordination.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the anion-anion contact along the unit cell edge (a=2r−a = 2r_-).

You correctly recognized that the diagonal distance spanning opposite corners across the central cation equals 2(r++r−)2(r_+ + r_-).

You completed the algebraic isolation of the radius ratio r+/r−r_+/r_- accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing face diagonal with body diagonal in cubic coordination

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied the 2D face diagonal formula (d=2ad = \sqrt{2}a) instead of the 3D body diagonal formula (d=3ad = \sqrt{3}a) when determining the contact line passing through the central cation in an 8-coordinate cubic geometry.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Coordination Geometry & Contact Path
  • For an 88-coordinate cubic site, the central cation lies at the center of a cube, so cation-anion contact lies along the body diagonal: dbody=a2+a2+a2=a3d_{\text{body}} = \sqrt{a^2+a^2+a^2} = a\sqrt{3}.

  • Identify the spatial line containing the center of both ions: 2D face diagonal gives 2a\sqrt{2}a (octahedral square plane), while 3D body diagonal gives 3a\sqrt{3}a (cubic).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. The body diagonal passing through the cube center is d=3a=2(r++r−)d = \sqrt{3}a = 2(r_+ + r_-).

  2. Substitute a=2r−a = 2r_- into the diagonal equation: 2(r++r−)=2r−32(r_+ + r_-) = 2r_-\sqrt{3}.

  3. Divide both sides by 2r−2r_-: r++r−r−=r+r−+1=3\frac{r_+ + r_-}{r_-} = \frac{r_+}{r_-} + 1 = \sqrt{3}.

  4. Subtract 11 to find the exact ratio: r+r−=3−1\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1.

  5. Evaluate numerically to three significant figures: 3−1≈1.732−1=0.732\sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 1.732 - 1 = 0.732.

Final answer

r+r−=3−1≈0.732\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 0.732

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always sketch the unit cell and draw the line of cation-anion contact to verify whether it traverses a face diagonal (2a\sqrt{2}a) or a body diagonal (3a\sqrt{3}a).

  • Memorize the landmark critical radius ratios: 0.2250.225 (tetrahedral, 4-coordinate), 0.4140.414 (octahedral, 6-coordinate), and 0.7320.732 (cubic, 8-coordinate).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly assumes the cube body diagonal equals 2a rather than √3 a, yielding a flawed ratio of 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2r−=a2r_- = a

  2. Step 2

    2(r++r−)=2a2(r_+ + r_-) = 2a

    Correct

    2(r++r−)=a32(r_+ + r_-) = a\sqrt{3}

    In a cubic unit cell of side length aa, the length of the body diagonal is a2+a2+a2=a3\sqrt{a^2 + a^2 + a^2} = a\sqrt{3}, not 2a2a.

  3. Step 3

    r++r−=2r−  ⟹  r+r−=1r_+ + r_- = 2r_- \implies \frac{r_+}{r_-} = 1

    Correct

    2(r++r−)=2r−3  ⟹  r+r−=3−1≈0.7322(r_+ + r_-) = 2r_-\sqrt{3} \implies \frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 0.732

    This step followed logically from your previous expression by substituting a=2r−a = 2r_-, but it inherits the geometric error from step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the limiting condition involves anions touching along the cube edge (a=2r−a = 2r_-).

You correctly recognized that cation and anion touch along the body diagonal of the cube (2(r++r−)2(r_+ + r_-)).

You accurately carried out the algebraic substitution and isolation of the ratio based on your equations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Cube Body Diagonal Geometry Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the formula for the body diagonal of a cube with 2a2a rather than deriving it from the 3D Pythagorean theorem (d=a2+a2+a2=a3d = \sqrt{a^2 + a^2 + a^2} = a\sqrt{3}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cube Diagonal Dimensions
  • For a cube of edge length aa, the face diagonal is a2a\sqrt{2} and the interior body diagonal is a3a\sqrt{3}.

  • Always apply the three-dimensional Pythagorean theorem (d2=a2+a2+a2d^2 = a^2 + a^2 + a^2) when finding distances across opposite corners of a cubic unit cell.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the body diagonal of the cube to the sum of the ionic diameters along that line: 2(r++r−)=a32(r_+ + r_-) = a\sqrt{3}.

  2. Substitute the edge contact condition a=2r−a = 2r_- into the diagonal equation: 2(r++r−)=(2r−)32(r_+ + r_-) = (2r_-)\sqrt{3}.

  3. Divide both sides by 2r−2r_-: r++r−r−=3  ⟹  r+r−+1=3\frac{r_+ + r_-}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} \implies \frac{r_+}{r_-} + 1 = \sqrt{3}.

  4. Subtract 11 from both sides to isolate the radius ratio: r+r−=3−1≈0.732\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 0.732.

Final answer

r+r−=3−1≈0.732\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 0.732

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review three-dimensional unit cell geometry, particularly distinguishing face diagonals (a2a\sqrt{2}) from body diagonals (a3a\sqrt{3}).

  • Practice deriving radius ratio limits for 44-coordinate (tetrahedral) and 66-coordinate (octahedral) geometries to reinforce contact line analysis.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the radius ratio expression by dividing r₋ by r₊ during algebraic simplification, solving for r₋/r₊ = √3 - 1 and obtaining r₊/r₋ = 1/(√3 - 1) = (√3 + 1)/2 ≈ 1.37.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2(r++r−)=3a  ⟹  a=2r−  ⟹  r++r−=3r−2(r_+ + r_-) = \sqrt{3}a \implies a = 2r_- \implies r_+ + r_- = \sqrt{3}r_-

  2. Step 2

    r−r+=3−1\frac{r_-}{r_+} = \sqrt{3} - 1

    Correct

    r+r−=3−1\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1

    When dividing both sides of r+=(3−1)r−r_+ = (\sqrt{3} - 1)r_- by r−r_-, the resulting ratio is r+r−\frac{r_+}{r_-}, not r−r+\frac{r_-}{r_+}. Dividing by r+r_+ would yield r−r+=13−1\frac{r_-}{r_+} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3} - 1}.

  3. Step 3

    r+r−=13−1=3+12≈1.37\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}-1} = \frac{\sqrt{3}+1}{2} \approx 1.37

    Correct

    r+r−=3−1≈0.732\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 0.732

    This step followed logically from your inverted ratio in the previous step, but produced an incorrect final value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that corner anions touch along the cube edge (a=2r−a = 2r_-).

You correctly formulated the body diagonal contact relationship (2(r++r−)=a32(r_+ + r_-) = a\sqrt{3}).

You correctly substituted aa into the diagonal equation to obtain r++r−=3r−r_+ + r_- = \sqrt{3}r_-.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio inversion error

You solved r+=(3−1)r−r_+ = (\sqrt{3} - 1)r_- for r−r+\frac{r_-}{r_+} instead of r+r−\frac{r_+}{r_-}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting the target fraction during algebraic rearrangement, combined with overlooking the physical sense check that a smaller central cation must give a critical radius ratio r+/r−<1r_+ / r_- < 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating the Target Ratio
  • To find r+r−\frac{r_+}{r_-} from r++r−=3r−r_+ + r_- = \sqrt{3}r_-, divide each term directly by r−r_-: r+r−+1=3\frac{r_+}{r_-} + 1 = \sqrt{3}.

  • Divide directly by the denominator term (r−r_-) across the equation rather than cross-multiplying or moving terms manually.

Physical Reality Check
  • In standard ionic radius ratio rules, cations are smaller than anions (r+<r−r_+ < r_-), meaning r+/r−<1r_+ / r_- < 1 for critical geometric thresholds.

  • Always verify that your calculated threshold ratio is less than 11 whenever the cation occupies interstitial cavities between larger anions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract r−r_- from both sides: r+=(3−1)r−r_+ = (\sqrt{3} - 1)r_-.

  2. Divide both sides by r−r_- to isolate r+r−\frac{r_+}{r_-}: r+r−=3−1\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1.

  3. Evaluate numerically: 3−1≈1.732−1=0.732\sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 1.732 - 1 = 0.732.

Final answer

r+r−=3−1≈0.732\frac{r_+}{r_-} = \sqrt{3} - 1 \approx 0.732

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Divide equations directly by the intended denominator variable to avoid accidental inversion.

  • Perform a magnitude sanity check: verify that r+/r−<1r_+ / r_- < 1 for interstitial cavity thresholds.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A simple cubic anion array has an edge length of a=380 pma = 380\text{ pm} at the critical contact limit where anions just touch along each edge. Calculate the radius of the central interstitial cation that fits perfectly without expanding the lattice. Express your answer in picometers rounded to one decimal place.

Answer

The edge condition is 2r−=a=380 pm2r_- = a = 380\text{ pm}, so r−=190 pmr_- = 190\text{ pm}. The critical ratio for an 8-coordinate cubic cavity is r+/r−=3−1r_+/r_- = \sqrt{3}-1. Therefore, r+=190(3−1)≈190×0.73205=139.1 pmr_+ = 190(\sqrt{3}-1) \approx 190 \times 0.73205 = 139.1\text{ pm}.

02

In a hypothetical ionic compound AX\ce{AX}, the radius of AX+\ce{A+} is 148 pm148\text{ pm} and the radius of XX−\ce{X-} is 181 pm181\text{ pm}. Based purely on the radius ratio rules, predict whether this compound prefers a 66-coordinate rock-salt geometry or an 88-coordinate cesium chloride geometry, and state the critical threshold that decides this.

Answer

Calculate the radius ratio: r+/r−=148/181≈0.818r_+/r_- = 148 / 181 \approx 0.818. Because 0.8180.818 exceeds the threshold 3−1≈0.732\sqrt{3}-1 \approx 0.732, the cation is sufficiently large to maintain 8-coordinate cubic contact without anion-anion overlap. Thus, it prefers an 88-coordinate cesium chloride structure.

03

Derive the exact minimum radius ratio r+/r−r_+/r_- for an octahedral (66-coordinate) site where 66 anions of radius r−r_- surround a central cation of radius r+r_+. Show the geometric relationship in the square equatorial plane.

Answer

In the equatorial square cross-section, 44 anions touch the central cation along the face diagonal: dface=2(r++r−)d_{\text{face}} = 2(r_+ + r_-). The side length of the square is defined by touching adjacent anions: a=2r−a = 2r_-. By the Pythagorean theorem, dface=a2=2r−2d_{\text{face}} = a\sqrt{2} = 2r_-\sqrt{2}. Equating these gives 2(r++r−)=2r−2  ⟹  r+/r−=2−1≈0.4142(r_+ + r_-) = 2r_-\sqrt{2} \implies r_+/r_- = \sqrt{2} - 1 \approx 0.414.

Loading workspace…