Resources

A student attempts to assign the group and valence electron count for Arsenic (Z=33Z = 33, configuration [Ar] 4s2 3d10 4p3[\text{Ar}]\,4s^2\,3d^{10}\,4p^3). The student writes: 'Because Arsenic is in Group 15 and has 15 total electrons past Argon, it has 15 valence electrons and forms an ion with a −3-3 formal charge by gaining 3 electrons to complete its valence count of 18.' (a) Identify the misconception regarding the 3d103d^{10} subshell when counting valence electrons for main-group elements. (b) State the correct number of valence electrons, the correct highest principal quantum number (nn), and the conventional core charge (effective nuclear charge approximation Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S, using core electrons SS) experienced by the valence electrons of Arsenic.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) For main-group (pp-block) elements, the completely filled (n−1)d10(n-1)d^{10} subshell lies lower in energy and belongs to the core; it does not count toward the valence electrons; (b) Arsenic has 55 valence electrons (4s2 4p34s^2\,4p^3), highest principal quantum number n=4n = 4, and core charge (simple ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) of 33−28=+533 - 28 = +5.

Steps

(a) Misconception Regarding the (n−1)d10(n-1)d^{10} Subshell

  • Definition of Valence Electrons: For main-group (ss- and pp-block) elements, valence electrons are defined as the electrons residing in the outermost shell, which corresponds to the highest principal quantum number (nn).
  • Role of the 3d103d^{10} Subshell: In Arsenic ([Ar] 4s2 3d10 4p3[\ce{Ar}]\,4s^2\,3d^{10}\,4p^3), the highest principal quantum number is n=4n = 4. Although the 3d3d subshell is filled after 4s4s in the Aufbau order, once filled, the (n−1)d=3d(n-1)d = 3d subshell drops in energy below the n=4n = 4 subshells. It forms a stable, closed inner pseudo-noble-gas core.
  • The Pitfall: The student mistakenly assumes that all electrons added after the previous noble gas ([Ar][\ce{Ar}]) are valence electrons. Because the completely filled 3d103d^{10} subshell belongs to the inner core and does not participate in typical bonding, it must not be counted toward valence electrons.

(b) Correct Counts and Core Charge Calculation

  1. Highest Principal Quantum Number (nn):

    • The valence shell corresponds to the highest energy level occupied, which is n=4n = 4 (containing the 4s4s and 4p4p subshells).
  2. Number of Valence Electrons:

    • Only the electrons in the n=4n = 4 shell are valence electrons: Valence electrons=4s2+4p3=2+3=5\text{Valence electrons} = 4s^2 + 4p^3 = 2 + 3 = 5
    • This is consistent with Arsenic being a Group 15 (Group 5A) element. It needs 33 additional electrons to achieve an octet (88 valence electrons, forming AsX3−\ce{As^3-}), not 1818.
  3. Core Charge / Effective Nuclear Charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}):

    • Total electrons (ZZ): 3333
    • Core electrons (SS): All non-valence electrons, consisting of the argon core (18 e−18\text{ e}^-) plus the full 3d103d^{10} subshell (10 e−10\text{ e}^-): S=18+10=28S = 18 + 10 = 28
    • Core charge approximation (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}): Zeff=Z−S=33−28=+5Z_{\text{eff}} = Z - S = 33 - 28 = +5
    • Each valence electron effectively experiences an attractive net charge of +5+5 from the shielded nucleus.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student incorrectly includes the 3d electrons in the valence count while identifying core electrons solely as the noble gas core [Ar], leading to 15 valence electrons and an incorrect core charge of +15.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    The student counted the 3d electrons as valence electrons because they are added after Argon. Only the noble gas core [Ar] should be counted as core electrons.

    Correct

    For main-group (pp-block) elements, the completely filled (n−1)d10(n-1)d^{10} subshell drops lower in energy once filled and belongs to the inner core, so it does not count toward valence electrons.

    You stated that only the noble gas core [Ar][\ce{Ar}] counts as core electrons. However, in main-group elements, completely filled inner dd subshells such as 3d103d^{10} are part of the non-reactive inner core.

  2. Step 2

    Valence electrons = 15

    Correct

    Valence electrons=5\text{Valence electrons} = 5 (from 4s2 4p34s^2\,4p^3)

    You counted all 1515 electrons beyond Argon. Valence electrons for main-group elements are only those residing in the outermost shell (n=4n = 4), which gives 2+3=52 + 3 = 5 electrons.

  3. Step 3

    Highest principal quantum number n=4n = 4

  4. Step 4

    Core electrons \text{Core electrons } S = 18   ⟹  \implies Z_{eff\text{eff}} = 33 - 18 = +15_

    Correct

    S = 18 + 10 = 28   ⟹  \implies Z_{eff\text{eff}} = 33 - 28 = +5_

    You assigned only the 1818 electrons from [Ar][\ce{Ar}] to the core shielding SS. Because the 1010 electrons in 3d103d^{10} also belong to the inner core, the total core electron count is S=28S = 28, yielding an effective nuclear charge of Zeff=33−28=+5Z_{\text{eff}} = 33 - 28 = +5.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the highest principal quantum number of Arsenic as n=4n = 4.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inclusion of filled (n-1)d subshell in valence electron count

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the definition of core electrons as strictly the preceding noble gas configuration [Ar][\ce{Ar}], overlooking that completely filled (n−1)d10(n-1)d^{10} subshells in main-group elements lie inside the valence shell and function as core shielding electrons.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Main-group valence definition
  • For main-group (ss- and pp-block) elements, valence electrons occupy only the highest principal quantum level (nn), while any filled (n−1)d10(n-1)d^{10} subshell belongs to the core.

  • Always identify the maximum nn in the electron configuration and count only the electrons with that principal quantum number (ns+npns + np).

Core electron summation
  • Core electrons \text{Core electrons } (S) = Total electrons \text{Total electrons } (Z) - Valence electrons\text{Valence electrons}

  • Include all filled inner subshells, including 3d103d^{10}, when computing the shielding constant SS.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that in [Ar] 4s2 3d10 4p3[\ce{Ar}]\,4s^2\,3d^{10}\,4p^3, the valence shell corresponds strictly to n=4n = 4, containing 4s24s^2 and 4p34p^3.

  2. Count the valence electrons: 2+3=52 + 3 = 5.

  3. Sum the inner core electrons: [Ar][\ce{Ar}] (1818) +3d10+ 3d^{10} (1010) =28= 28 electrons.

  4. Calculate the core charge / simple ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}: Zeff=Z−S=33−28=+5Z_{\text{eff}} = Z - S = 33 - 28 = +5.

Final answer

Arsenic has 55 valence electrons (4s2 4p34s^2\,4p^3), highest principal quantum number n=4n = 4, and core charge Zeff=33−28=+5Z_{\text{eff}} = 33 - 28 = +5.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying valence electrons for other Period 4 main-group elements such as Ga\ce{Ga}, Ge\ce{Ge}, Se\ce{Se}, and Br\ce{Br}.

  • Verify that your calculated valence electron count always matches the element's traditional group number (5A5\text{A} for Arsenic).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student counts only the outermost 4p electrons as valence electrons while ignoring the 4s subshell, resulting in 3 valence electrons and an incorrect core charge of +3.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    The 3d103d^{10} subshell is completely filled and part of the inner core... Filled d subshells are core electrons and do not count toward valence.

  2. Step 2

    Valence electrons=3\text{Valence electrons} = 3

    Correct

    Valence electrons=2 (4s)+3 (4p)=5\text{Valence electrons} = 2\,(4s) + 3\,(4p) = 5

    You counted only the 4p34p^3 electrons and omitted the 4s24s^2 electrons. For main-group elements, all electrons with the highest principal quantum number (n=4n = 4), which includes both 4s4s and 4p4p, are valence electrons.

  3. Step 3

    Highest principal quantum number n=4n = 4

  4. Step 4

    Core electrons S=30  ⟹  Zeff=33−30=+3S = 30 \implies Z_{\text{eff}} = 33 - 30 = +3

    Correct

    S=18 ([Ar])+10 (3d10)=28  ⟹  Zeff=33−28=+5S = 18\,([\text{Ar}]) + 10\,(3d^{10}) = 28 \implies Z_{\text{eff}} = 33 - 28 = +5

    Because you classified the 4s24s^2 electrons as core rather than valence, your core electron count SS was 3030 instead of 2828, giving an incorrect core charge of +3+3 instead of +5+5.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the filled 3d103d^{10} subshell acts as core shielding rather than valence electrons.

You correctly identified the highest principal quantum number as n=4n = 4.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of outermost s-subshell in valence count

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined valence electrons as only the electrons residing in the outermost open subshell (4p34p^3), forgetting that valence electrons for main-group elements encompass all electrons in the highest principal energy level (n=4n = 4, both nsns and npnp).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Main-Group Valence Definition
  • For any main-group element, valence electrons are all electrons with the highest principal quantum number nn (the nsns and npnp electrons).

  • Always include the ns2ns^2 electrons alongside any npnp electrons when determining the valence count of a pp-block element.

Core Electron Count ($S$)
  • Core electrons include all inner completed noble-gas cores plus any completely filled (n−1)d10(n-1)d^{10} subshells; they never include electrons in the outermost nn shell.

  • Check that core electrons S+valence electrons=Z\text{core electrons } S + \text{valence electrons} = Z (28+5=3328 + 5 = 33).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the highest principal quantum number: n=4n = 4.

  2. Sum all electrons occupying the n=4n = 4 level: 2 (4s)+3 (4p)=5 valence electrons2\,(4s) + 3\,(4p) = 5\text{ valence electrons}.

  3. Determine core electrons by subtracting valence from total atomic number: S=33−5=28 core electronsS = 33 - 5 = 28\text{ core electrons}.

  4. Calculate the core charge (effective nuclear charge approximation): Zeff=Z−S=33−28=+5Z_{\text{eff}} = Z - S = 33 - 28 = +5.

Final answer

(a) The filled 3d103d^{10} subshell lies lower in energy than the n=4n = 4 shell and forms part of the core, so it does not count toward valence electrons; (b) Arsenic has 55 valence electrons (4s2 4p34s^2\,4p^3), highest principal quantum number n=4n = 4, and core charge Zeff=33−28=+5Z_{\text{eff}} = 33 - 28 = +5.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice writing out all subshells with the highest nn value together before counting valence electrons.

  • Verify that the number of valence electrons matches the element's group number under the Roman numeral/A-B system (Group 15 = Group 5A = 5 valence electrons).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine the number of valence electrons, core electrons, and simple effective nuclear charge (Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S) for Germanium (Z=32Z = 32, [Ar] 4s2 3d10 4p2[\ce{Ar}]\,4s^2\,3d^{10}\,4p^2).

Answer

Valence electrons: 44 (4s2 4p24s^2\,4p^2). Core electrons: S=18 ([Ar])+10 (3d10)=28S = 18\,([\ce{Ar}]) + 10\,(3d^{10}) = 28. Zeff=32−28=+4Z_{\text{eff}} = 32 - 28 = +4.

02

Bromine (Z=35Z = 35) has the electron configuration [Ar] 4s2 3d10 4p5[\ce{Ar}]\,4s^2\,3d^{10}\,4p^5. Explain why Bromine forms a BrX−\ce{Br-} ion by gaining 11 electron rather than gaining 33 electrons to complete an 'octet of 18'.

Answer

Bromine has only 77 valence electrons in its outermost shell (n=4n = 4: 4s2 4p54s^2\,4p^5). The 3d103d^{10} subshell is already completely filled and part of the core. Bromine requires just 11 electron to complete its n=4n = 4 valence octet (4s2 4p64s^2\,4p^6), forming BrX−\ce{Br-}.

03

Indium (Z=49Z = 49) has the electron configuration [Kr] 5s2 4d10 5p1[\ce{Kr}]\,5s^2\,4d^{10}\,5p^1. (a) State the highest principal quantum number (nn). (b) Identify the core electrons and compute simple ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}. (c) State the number of valence electrons.

Answer

(a) n=5n = 5. (b) Core electrons include [Kr][\ce{Kr}] (3636) plus 4d104d^{10} (1010), giving S=46S = 46; simple Zeff=49−46=+3Z_{\text{eff}} = 49 - 46 = +3. (c) Valence electrons =2+1=3= 2 + 1 = 3 (5s2 5p15s^2\,5p^1).

Loading workspace…