Resources

A chemistry student attempts to demonstrate the common-ion effect by comparing the molar solubility of silver chloride, AgCl\text{AgCl} (Ksp=1.77×10−10K_{\text{sp}} = 1.77 \times 10^{-10}), in pure water versus in a 0.100 M0.100\text{ M} aqueous sodium nitrate solution, NaNO3\text{NaNO}_3. The student predicts that adding NaNO3\text{NaNO}_3 will decrease the molar solubility of AgCl\text{AgCl} due to the common-ion effect. Evaluate whether a common ion exists in this mixture, calculate the true molar solubility of AgCl\text{AgCl} in pure water at 25∘C25^\circ\text{C}, and identify the actual effect of the Na+\text{Na}^+ and NO3−\text{NO}_3^- spectator ions on AgCl\text{AgCl} solubility in real ionic solutions.

Answer and steps

Final answer

No common ion exists; the molar solubility of AgCl\text{AgCl} in pure water is 1.33×10−5 M1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}, and inert spectator ions actually increase solubility slightly via the ionic strength (diverse-ion or salt) effect rather than decreasing it via the common-ion effect.

Steps

01

Evaluate the Presence of a Common Ion

The common-ion effect occurs when a compound containing an ion already present in the equilibrium mixture is added, shifting the equilibrium according to Le Chatelier's principle.

Write the dissolution equations for both solutes: AgCl(s)⇌AgX+(aq)+ClX−(aq)\ce{AgCl(s) <=> Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq)} NaNOX3(aq)→NaX+(aq)+NOX3X−(aq)\ce{NaNO3(aq) -> Na+(aq) + NO3-(aq)}

The ions produced by the sparingly soluble salt AgCl\ce{AgCl} are AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-}. The ions supplied by the fully soluble salt NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3} are NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}. Because none of the ions from NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3} are identical to AgX+\ce{Ag+} or ClX−\ce{Cl-}, no common ion exists in this mixture. Therefore, the common-ion effect cannot decrease the solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl}.


02

Calculate the Molar Solubility in Pure Water

Let ss be the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} in pure water in units of mol/L\text{mol/L} (M\text{M}). At equilibrium:

  • [AgX+]=s[\ce{Ag+}] = s
  • [ClX−]=s[\ce{Cl-}] = s

Write the solubility product expression: Ksp=[AgX+][ClX−]=s⋅s=s2K_{\text{sp}} = [\ce{Ag+}][\ce{Cl-}] = s \cdot s = s^2

Substitute the given value Ksp=1.77×10−10K_{\text{sp}} = 1.77 \times 10^{-10}: s=Ksp=1.77×10−10≈1.33×10−5 Ms = \sqrt{K_{\text{sp}}} = \sqrt{1.77 \times 10^{-10}} \approx 1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}


03

Determine the Effect of the Spectator Ions (Diverse-Ion Effect)

In an aqueous solution containing 0.100 M NaNOX30.100\text{ M }\ce{NaNO3}, the concentration of non-reacting spectator ions (NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}) creates an ionic atmosphere around the dissolved AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-} ions:

  1. Each AgX+\ce{Ag+} cation is surrounded on average by a loose primary sphere of NOX3X−\ce{NO3-} anions.
  2. Each ClX−\ce{Cl-} anion is surrounded by a loose primary sphere of NaX+\ce{Na+} cations.

This ionic shielding reduces the effective electrostatic attraction between free AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-} ions, hindering them from recombining to precipitate as solid AgCl\ce{AgCl}. Consequently, their effective concentrations (activities) decrease relative to their true molar concentrations, shifting the dissolution equilibrium slightly to the right.

This phenomenon is known as the diverse-ion effect (or salt effect / ionic strength effect), which increases the solubility of a sparingly soluble salt rather than decreasing it.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies any added ionic salt as providing a common ion, falsely concluding that NaNO3 suppresses solubility via Le Chatelier's principle.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    AgCl(s)⇌AgX+(aq)+ClX−(aq)  ⟹  NaNOX3(aq)→NaX+(aq)+NOX3X−(aq)\ce{AgCl(s) <=> Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq)} \implies \ce{NaNO3(aq) -> Na+(aq) + NO3-(aq)}

  2. Step 2

    A common ion exists because both compounds are 1:1 electrolytes in the same aqueous solution. Therefore, adding NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3} decreases the solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} due to the common-ion effect.

    Correct

    No common ion exists because NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3} produces NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}, neither of which is identical to AgX+\ce{Ag+} or ClX−\ce{Cl-}.

    A common ion must be the exact same chemical species already participating in the equilibrium (either AgX+\ce{Ag+} or ClX−\ce{Cl-}). Sharing a 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio does not make ions 'common' ions.

  3. Step 3

    Ksp=[AgX+][ClX−]=s2  ⟹  1.77×10−10=s2  ⟹  s=1.77×10−10  ⟹  s=1.33×10−5 MK_{\text{sp}} = [\ce{Ag+}][\ce{Cl-}] = s^2 \implies 1.77 \times 10^{-10} = s^2 \implies s = \sqrt{1.77 \times 10^{-10}} \implies s = 1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}

  4. Step 4

    Because NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-} act as common ions, they shift the equilibrium to the left. The actual effect is a decrease in AgCl\ce{AgCl} solubility.

    Correct

    The inert spectator ions (NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}) increase the ionic strength of the solution, creating an ionic atmosphere that shields AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-}, which slightly increases AgCl\ce{AgCl} solubility via the diverse-ion effect.

    Because NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-} are inert spectator ions with respect to AgCl\ce{AgCl}, they do not shift the equilibrium to the left. Instead, their presence increases the ionic strength, screening the charges of AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-} and slightly increasing solubility.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly represented the equilibrium dissociation of AgCl\ce{AgCl} and the strong dissociation of NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3}.

You successfully related the solubility product constant KspK_{\text{sp}} to the molar solubility ss in pure water and calculated 1.33×10−5 M1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Common-Ion Identification Fallacy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined a 'common ion' by electrolyte classification (1:11:1 charge ratio) rather than literal chemical identity, confusing spectator ions in a high ionic strength medium with ions directly participating in the chemical equilibrium.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Literal Chemical Identity Check
  • An ion is 'common' if and only if its formula and charge are identical to one of the ions in the equilibrium reaction.

  • List the ions produced by the added salt and compare their chemical formulas directly to the ions in the equilibrium.

Diverse-Ion (Salt) Effect
  • Added non-common spectator ions increase ionic strength, shielding dissolved ions and increasing solubility slightly.

  • When added ions are non-common spectators, recognize that electrostatic shielding shifts the equilibrium right, not left.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare ions from AgCl\ce{AgCl} (AgX+\ce{Ag+}, ClX−\ce{Cl-}) with ions from NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3} (NaX+\ce{Na+}, NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}): none are identical, so no common ion exists.

  2. Because no common ion is present, Le Chatelier's principle does not shift the equilibrium toward AgCl(s)\ce{AgCl(s)}.

  3. Recognize that adding 0.100 M NaNOX30.100\text{ M }\ce{NaNO3} increases the solution's ionic strength, creating ionic atmospheres around AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-} that lower their activities and slightly increase solubility.

Final answer

No common ion exists; the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} in pure water is 1.33×10−5 M1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}, and the added spectator ions slightly increase solubility via the diverse-ion effect.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the strict chemical definition of a common ion: it must share the exact chemical formula of an ion in the KspK_{\text{sp}} expression.

  • Contrast the common-ion effect (which suppresses solubility) with the diverse-ion effect (which slightly enhances solubility due to ionic shielding).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to take the square root when solving s² = Ksp, reporting the Ksp value itself or confusing Ksp with s.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    AgCl\text{AgCl} dissociates into Ag+\text{Ag}^+ and Cl−\text{Cl}^-, while NaNO3\text{NaNO}_3 yields Na+\text{Na}^+ and NO3−\text{NO}_3^-. None of these ions are shared between the two salts, so no common ion exists.

  2. Step 2

    AgCl(s)⇌AgX+(aq)+ClX−(aq)  ⟹  Ksp=[AgX+][ClX−]=s2\ce{AgCl(s) <=> Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq)} \implies K_{\text{sp}} = [\ce{Ag+}][\ce{Cl-}] = s^2

  3. Step 3

    s=1.77×10−10 Ms = 1.77 \times 10^{-10}\text{ M}

    Correct

    s=Ksp=1.77×10−10≈1.33×10−5 Ms = \sqrt{K_{\text{sp}}} = \sqrt{1.77 \times 10^{-10}} \approx 1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}

    You set ss equal to the numerical value of KspK_{\text{sp}} instead of taking the square root to solve s2=Ksps^2 = K_{\text{sp}}.

  4. Step 4

    Adding NaNO3\text{NaNO}_3 increases the ionic strength of the solution. Lower activity coefficients result in an increase in the solubility of AgCl\text{AgCl}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly evaluated that no common ion exists in the mixture.

You properly formulated the solubility equilibrium expression as Ksp=s2K_{\text{sp}} = s^2.

You accurately explained the diverse-ion effect using ionic strength and activity coefficients.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of radical when solving power relation

You skipped taking the square root of KspK_{\text{sp}} after correctly establishing Ksp=s2K_{\text{sp}} = s^2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the equilibrium constant KspK_{\text{sp}} with the equilibrium concentration variable ss, leading to forgetting the final inversion step (s=Ksps = \sqrt{K_{\text{sp}}}) required by the quadratic algebraic relation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating solubility from power expressions
  • When Ksp=snK_{\text{sp}} = s^n, solving for ss requires taking the nn-th root: s=Kspns = \sqrt[n]{K_{\text{sp}}}.

  • Always write the isolated variable step, such as s=Ksps = \sqrt{K_{\text{sp}}}, before substituting numbers into your calculator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. s2=1.77×10−10s^2 = 1.77 \times 10^{-10}

  2. s=1.77×10−10s = \sqrt{1.77 \times 10^{-10}}

  3. s≈1.33×10−5 Ms \approx 1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}

Final answer

No common ion exists; the molar solubility of AgCl\text{AgCl} in pure water is 1.33×10−5 M1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}; and the spectator ions increase solubility via the diverse-ion (salt) effect.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving for ss from various stoichiometric ratios (s2s^2, 4s34s^3, 27s427s^4).

  • Always perform a quick sanity check: since Ksp≪1K_{\text{sp}} \ll 1, s=Ksps = \sqrt{K_{\text{sp}}} must be several orders of magnitude larger than KspK_{\text{sp}} itself.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes inert spectator ions have zero interaction with sparingly soluble ions in real solutions, concluding the solubility remains completely unchanged.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    AgCl\ce{AgCl} produces AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-}; NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3} produces NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}.   ⟹  \implies There is no common ion shared between AgCl\ce{AgCl} and NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3}.

  2. Step 2

    Ksp=s2=1.77×10−10  ⟹  s=1.77×10−10  ⟹  s=1.33×10−5 MK_{\text{sp}} = s^2 = 1.77 \times 10^{-10} \implies s = \sqrt{1.77 \times 10^{-10}} \implies s = 1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}

  3. Step 3

    Because NaX+\ce{Na+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-} are purely inert spectator ions that do not react with AgX+\ce{Ag+} or ClX−\ce{Cl-}, they exert no force on the equilibrium.   ⟹  \implies The solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} in 0.100 M NaNOX30.100\text{ M }\ce{NaNO3} remains unchanged at 1.33×10−5 M1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}.

    Correct

    In real electrolyte solutions, spectator ions increase ionic strength. An ionic atmosphere of opposite charges shields AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-}, lowering their activity coefficients and shifting equilibrium to the right, which slightly increases the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} (the diverse-ion effect).

    Even non-reacting ions increase the solution's ionic strength. The resulting ionic shielding lowers the activity coefficients of AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-}, decreasing their effective concentrations and shifting the dissolution equilibrium to the right to dissolve more solid.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You identified all constituent ions and correctly verified that no common ion is present.

You set up and evaluated the solubility product calculation for pure water with accurate numerical results.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Spectator Ion Shielding Misconception

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated spectator ions in solution as entirely non-interacting ideal particles, neglecting the electrostatic atmosphere they form (ionic strength effect), which shields dissolving ions and increases salt solubility.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate Common Ions vs. Diverse Ions
  • Adding an ion that is part of the precipitate decreases solubility (common-ion effect). Adding inert ions that are not part of the precipitate increases ionic strength and enhances solubility (diverse-ion effect).

  • Check whether the added ions match any ions in the solid's equilibrium before deciding which effect applies.

Account for Ionic Strength and Activity
  • Thermodynamic equilibrium depends on activities (ai=γi[i]a_i = \gamma_i [i]). Increasing ionic strength reduces activity coefficients (γi<1\gamma_i < 1), requiring higher molar concentrations [i][i] to satisfy KspK_{\text{sp}}.

  • Conclude that adding an inert strong electrolyte shifts the dissolution equilibrium rightward, increasing molar solubility.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate or recognize the increase in ionic strength: I=12∑cizi2=0.100 MI = \frac{1}{2}\sum c_i z_i^2 = 0.100\text{ M}.

  2. Identify that NaX+\ce{Na+} cations surround ClX−\ce{Cl-} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-} anions surround AgX+\ce{Ag+}, forming an ionic atmosphere.

  3. Note that this electrostatic screening lowers the activity coefficients (γAgX+<1\gamma_{\ce{Ag+}} < 1 and γClX−<1\gamma_{\ce{Cl-}} < 1).

  4. Because Ksp=γAgX+[AgX+] γClX−[ClX−]K_{\text{sp}} = \gamma_{\ce{Ag+}}[\ce{Ag+}]\,\gamma_{\ce{Cl-}}[\ce{Cl-}], the molar concentrations [AgX+][\ce{Ag+}] and [ClX−][\ce{Cl-}] must increase to maintain equilibrium.

Final answer

No common ion exists; the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} in pure water is 1.33×10−5 M1.33 \times 10^{-5}\text{ M}, and spectator ions slightly increase its solubility via the diverse-ion (salt) effect.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between the common-ion effect (Le Chatelier shift left) and the diverse-ion effect (activity coefficient decrease, shift right).

  • Practice qualitative questions on how adding strong, non-reacting electrolytes affects sparingly soluble salts.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A student adds 0.050 M AgNOX30.050\text{ M }\ce{AgNO3} to a saturated solution of AgCl(s)\ce{AgCl(s)} (Ksp=1.77×10−10K_{\text{sp}} = 1.77 \times 10^{-10}). Identify whether a common ion exists, determine the direction of the equilibrium shift, and state whether the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} increases, decreases, or stays the same.

Answer

A common ion exists (AgX+\ce{Ag+}). By Le Chatelier's principle, the addition of AgX+\ce{Ag+} shifts AgCl(s)⇌AgX+(aq)+ClX−(aq)\ce{AgCl(s) <=> Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq)} to the left, which decreases the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl}.

02

Calculate the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} (Ksp=1.77×10−10K_{\text{sp}} = 1.77 \times 10^{-10}) in a 0.020 M CaClX20.020\text{ M }\ce{CaCl2} solution, assuming ideal solution behavior.

Answer

4.4×10−9 M4.4 \times 10^{-9}\text{ M}. Key steps: CaClX2\ce{CaCl2} dissociates to give [ClX−]=2×0.020 M=0.040 M[\ce{Cl-}] = 2 \times 0.020\text{ M} = 0.040\text{ M}. Setting Ksp=[AgX+][ClX−]≈s(0.040)=1.77×10−10K_{\text{sp}} = [\ce{Ag+}][\ce{Cl-}] \approx s(0.040) = 1.77 \times 10^{-10} yields s=1.77×10−100.040=4.4×10−9 Ms = \frac{1.77 \times 10^{-10}}{0.040} = 4.4 \times 10^{-9}\text{ M}.

03

Equal concentrations (0.10 M0.10\text{ M}) of NaCl\ce{NaCl}, NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3}, and pure water are tested as solvents for AgCl(s)\ce{AgCl(s)}. Rank the molar solubility of AgCl\ce{AgCl} in these three media from lowest to highest, and justify the relative order using equilibrium and solution concepts.

Answer

Lowest to highest: 0.10 M NaCl<pure water<0.10 M NaNOX30.10\text{ M }\ce{NaCl} < \text{pure water} < 0.10\text{ M }\ce{NaNO3}. In NaCl\ce{NaCl}, the common ion ClX−\ce{Cl-} suppresses solubility via Le Chatelier's principle. In NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3}, no common ion exists, but the increased ionic strength creates an ionic shielding atmosphere around AgX+\ce{Ag+} and ClX−\ce{Cl-}, slightly enhancing solubility above that in pure water (the diverse-ion or salt effect).

Loading workspace…