Resources

Consider the formation of calcium carbonate precipitate in an aqueous system: Ca2+(aq)+CO32−(aq)→CaCO3(s)\text{Ca}^{2+}(aq) + \text{CO}_3^{2-}(aq) \rightarrow \text{CaCO}_3(s) A reaction vessel initially contains 1.00 L1.00\text{ L} of an aqueous solution with 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} of Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+}. A solution containing carbonate ions is continuously introduced such that the total moles of added CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} approaches infinity (nCO32−→∞n_{\text{CO}_3^{2-}} \rightarrow \infty). Assuming negligible solubility of CaCO3\text{CaCO}_3, identify the limiting reactant under this asymptotic condition, and state the limiting horizontal asymptote for the total mass (in grams) of CaCO3\text{CaCO}_3 precipitate (molar mass =100.09 g/mol= 100.09\text{ g/mol}) produced.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Limiting reactant: Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+}; Asymptotic mass of CaCO3=5.00 g\text{CaCO}_3 = 5.00\text{ g}

Steps

01

Analyze the Reaction Stoichiometry

The balanced precipitation reaction is: CaX2+(aq)+COX3X2−(aq)→CaCOX3(s)\ce{Ca^{2+}(aq) + CO3^{2-}(aq) -> CaCO3(s)}

From the balanced equation, CaX2+\ce{Ca^{2+}} and COX3X2−\ce{CO3^{2-}} react in a 1:11:1 stoichiometric mole ratio to produce solid calcium carbonate, CaCOX3\ce{CaCO3}.

02

Determine the Limiting Reactant

  • The initial amount of calcium ions present in the system is fixed at: nCaX2+=0.0500 moln_{\ce{Ca^{2+}}} = 0.0500\text{ mol}
  • The carbonate ions are continuously added such that: nCOX3X2−→∞n_{\ce{CO3^{2-}}} \to \infty

Since the mole ratio required is 1:11:1, only 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} of COX3X2−\ce{CO3^{2-}} is needed to react completely with all the available CaX2+\ce{Ca^{2+}} ions. Because the amount of COX3X2−\ce{CO3^{2-}} added far exceeds this requirement (nCOX3X2−≫0.0500 moln_{\ce{CO3^{2-}}} \gg 0.0500\text{ mol}), COX3X2−\ce{CO3^{2-}} is in vast excess.

Therefore, CaX2+\ce{Ca^{2+}} is the limiting reactant.

03

Calculate the Theoretical Maximum Yield of Precipitate

Because CaX2+\ce{Ca^{2+}} completely dictates the extent of the reaction and CaCOX3\ce{CaCO3} has negligible solubility, precipitation ceases once all CaX2+\ce{Ca^{2+}} is consumed: nCaCOX3, max=nCaX2+=0.0500 moln_{\ce{CaCO3}\text{, max}} = n_{\ce{Ca^{2+}}} = 0.0500\text{ mol}

04

Calculate the Limiting Mass (Horizontal Asymptote)

To find the asymptotic total mass of precipitate formed, multiply the maximum moles of CaCOX3\ce{CaCO3} by its molar mass (M=100.09 g/molM = 100.09\text{ g/mol}): mCaCOX3=nCaCOX3, max⋅Mm_{\ce{CaCO3}} = n_{\ce{CaCO3}\text{, max}} \cdot M mCaCOX3=0.0500 mol⋅100.09 g/mol=5.0045 gm_{\ce{CaCO3}} = 0.0500\text{ mol} \cdot 100.09\text{ g/mol} = 5.0045\text{ g}

Rounding to three significant figures gives: Asymptotic mass of CaCOX3=5.00 g\text{Asymptotic mass of }\ce{CaCO3} = 5.00\text{ g}

Common Pitfall: Do not assume that adding an infinite amount of reactant will continuously produce more precipitate. The production is strictly bounded by the finite initial quantity of the limiting reactant, creating a horizontal plateau (asymptote) on a mass versus added reactant curve.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the continually added reactant as the limiting factor or confuses the source of continuous addition, concluding that CO₃²⁻ limits the reaction and precipitate mass increases without bound.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} is added continuously into the vessel. The reactant being added gradually is limiting, so CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} is the limiting reactant.

    Correct

    Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} is present in a fixed amount of 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol}, whereas nCO32−→∞n_{\text{CO}_3^{2-}} \to \infty. Therefore, Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} is the limiting reactant.

    A limiting reactant is the substance that runs out first and limits the total theoretical yield, not the reagent being added over time. Because the total moles of added CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} approach infinity (nCO32−≫0.0500 moln_{\text{CO}_3^{2-}} \gg 0.0500\text{ mol}), carbonate is in vast excess and calcium ions run out first.

  2. Step 2

    Because CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} is added infinitely, precipitation continues indefinitely. As n(CO32−)→∞n(\text{CO}_3^{2-}) \to \infty, mass of CaCO3→∞\text{mass of }\text{CaCO}_3 \to \infty.

    Correct

    nCaCO3,max=nCa2+=0.0500 mol  ⟹  mCaCO3=0.0500 mol×100.09 g/mol=5.00 gn_{\text{CaCO}_3,\text{max}} = n_{\text{Ca}^{2+}} = 0.0500\text{ mol} \implies m_{\text{CaCO}_3} = 0.0500\text{ mol} \times 100.09\text{ g/mol} = 5.00\text{ g}

    Because precipitation requires both Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} and CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-}, reaction stops as soon as all 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} of Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} is consumed. Beyond that point, adding more CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} cannot produce any more solid, so the mass curve reaches a horizontal asymptote at 5.00 g5.00\text{ g}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that carbonate ions are being continuously added to the reaction vessel.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Limiting Reactant Under Asymptotic Addition
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the physical method of continuous addition with stoichiometric limitation, assuming that an incoming stream of reactant must be limiting and that precipitation can continue without the second reactant.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Limiting Reactant Definition
  • The limiting reactant is determined by total stoichiometric mole availability, not by the order, rate, or method of addition.

  • Compare the total moles of each reactant required by the balanced equation to find which one runs out first.

Reaction Ceases at Depletion
  • When one reactant in an irreversible or low-solubility precipitation reaction reaches zero, product formation stops regardless of how much excess reactant is added.

  • Base the maximum product yield solely on the moles of the limiting reactant: mproduct=nlimiting×Mproductm_{\text{product}} = n_{\text{limiting}} \times M_{\text{product}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the available moles of each reactant: fixed nCa2+=0.0500 moln_{\text{Ca}^{2+}} = 0.0500\text{ mol}, while nCO32−→∞n_{\text{CO}_3^{2-}} \to \infty.

  2. Compare stoichiometric amounts: the 1:11:1 reaction consumes at most 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} of CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-}, meaning CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} is in large excess and Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} is the limiting reactant.

  3. Calculate maximum precipitate moles: nCaCO3,max=nCa2+=0.0500 moln_{\text{CaCO}_3,\text{max}} = n_{\text{Ca}^{2+}} = 0.0500\text{ mol}.

  4. Convert maximum moles to mass: mCaCO3=0.0500 mol×100.09 g/mol=5.0045 g≈5.00 gm_{\text{CaCO}_3} = 0.0500\text{ mol} \times 100.09\text{ g/mol} = 5.0045\text{ g} \approx 5.00\text{ g}.

Final answer

Limiting reactant: Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+}; Asymptotic mass of CaCO3=5.00 g\text{CaCO}_3 = 5.00\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always find the total moles available for both species before assigning the limiting reactant.

  • Remember that adding excess reagent after the limiting reagent is depleted does not yield more product; the yield curve plateaus at a horizontal asymptote.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student correctly identifies Ca²⁺ as limiting but forgets to multiply by molar mass or uses the volume of solution instead of moles to calculate the final mass, obtaining 0.0500 g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n(CO32−)→∞n(\text{CO}_3^{2-}) \rightarrow \infty, so CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} is in large excess   ⟹  \implies Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} is the limiting reactant.

  2. Step 2

    Max moles of CaCO3=0.0500 mol\text{Max moles of }\text{CaCO}_3 = 0.0500\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    Mass of CaCO3=0.0500 g\text{Mass of }\text{CaCO}_3 = 0.0500\text{ g}

    Correct

    mCaCO3=n⋅M=0.0500 mol×100.09 g/mol=5.00 gm_{\text{CaCO}_3} = n \cdot M = 0.0500\text{ mol} \times 100.09\text{ g/mol} = 5.00\text{ g}

    You wrote the numerical mole value with units of grams rather than converting moles to mass using the formula m=n⋅Mm = n \cdot M.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the limiting reactant under the asymptotic condition.

You used the correct 1:11:1 stoichiometric mole ratio to determine the maximum moles of precipitate.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit conversion omitted (mole to gram)

You found 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} of precipitate but directly attached the unit g\text{g} without multiplying by the molar mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated moles and grams as interchangeable quantities at the final step, omitting the dimensional conversion m=n×Mm = n \times M.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Converting Moles to Mass
  • Mass and amount of substance are related by m=n⋅Mm = n \cdot M, where MM is molar mass in g/mol\text{g/mol}.

  • Always multiply the calculated number of moles by the compound's molar mass before reporting an answer in grams.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the theoretical maximum amount of precipitate: nCaCO3=0.0500 moln_{\text{CaCO}_3} = 0.0500\text{ mol}.

  2. Apply the molar mass relationship: m=n⋅M=0.0500 mol×100.09 g/molm = n \cdot M = 0.0500\text{ mol} \times 100.09\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Calculate the final mass: m=5.0045 g≈5.00 gm = 5.0045\text{ g} \approx 5.00\text{ g}.

Final answer

Limiting reactant: Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+}; Asymptotic mass of CaCO3=5.00 g\text{CaCO}_3 = 5.00\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check that units cancel correctly via dimensional analysis before stating your final answer.

  • Remember that 1 mol1\text{ mol} of a substance only equals 1 g1\text{ g} if its molar mass is exactly 1 g/mol1\text{ g/mol}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A beaker contains 0.0400 mol0.0400\text{ mol} of Ba2+(aq)\text{Ba}^{2+}(aq). A solution of SO42−(aq)\text{SO}_4^{2-}(aq) is continuously added until 0.200 mol0.200\text{ mol} of sulfate has entered the beaker. Assuming BaSO4\text{BaSO}_4 precipitates completely (M=233.39 g/molM = 233.39\text{ g/mol}), identify the limiting reactant and calculate the mass of precipitate formed.

Answer

Limiting reactant: Ba2+\text{Ba}^{2+}. Because Ba2+\text{Ba}^{2+} and SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-} react 1:11:1, the 0.0400 mol0.0400\text{ mol} of Ba2+\text{Ba}^{2+} requires only 0.0400 mol0.0400\text{ mol} of SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-}, leaving sulfate in excess. mBaSO4=0.0400 mol×233.39 g/mol=9.34 gm_{\text{BaSO}_4} = 0.0400\text{ mol} \times 233.39\text{ g/mol} = 9.34\text{ g}.

02

In the precipitation reaction Pb2+(aq)+2I−(aq)→PbI2(s)\text{Pb}^{2+}(aq) + 2\text{I}^-(aq) \to \text{PbI}_2(s), a flask begins with 0.0150 mol0.0150\text{ mol} of Pb2+\text{Pb}^{2+}. Potassium iodide solution is added continuously such that nI−→∞n_{\text{I}^-} \to \infty. State the limiting reactant and find the horizontal asymptote for the mass of PbI2\text{PbI}_2 (M=461.01 g/molM = 461.01\text{ g/mol}) formed.

Answer

Limiting reactant: Pb2+\text{Pb}^{2+}. With iodide added indefinitely, Pb2+\text{Pb}^{2+} is exhausted first. nPbI2,max=nPb2+=0.0150 moln_{\text{PbI}_2,\text{max}} = n_{\text{Pb}^{2+}} = 0.0150\text{ mol}. mPbI2=0.0150 mol×461.01 g/mol=6.92 gm_{\text{PbI}_2} = 0.0150\text{ mol} \times 461.01\text{ g/mol} = 6.92\text{ g}.

03

A 500.0 mL500.0\text{ mL} solution of 0.0800 M AgNO30.0800\text{ M } \text{AgNO}_3 is treated with a steady drip of 0.100 M NaCl0.100\text{ M } \text{NaCl}. Sketch or describe the graph of AgCl(s)\text{AgCl}(s) mass (yy-axis) versus volume of NaCl\text{NaCl} added (xx-axis) as VNaCl→∞V_{\text{NaCl}} \to \infty. Specify the coordinates (V,m)(V, m) of the plateau point and the asymptotic value. (MAgCl=143.32 g/molM_{\text{AgCl}} = 143.32\text{ g/mol})

Answer

Initial nAg+=0.5000 L×0.0800 M=0.0400 moln_{\text{Ag}^+} = 0.5000\text{ L} \times 0.0800\text{ M} = 0.0400\text{ mol}. Equivalence occurs at VNaCl=0.0400 mol0.100 M=0.400 L=400 mLV_{\text{NaCl}} = \frac{0.0400\text{ mol}}{0.100\text{ M}} = 0.400\text{ L} = 400\text{ mL}. Maximum mass =0.0400 mol×143.32 g/mol=5.73 g= 0.0400\text{ mol} \times 143.32\text{ g/mol} = 5.73\text{ g}. The graph rises linearly from (0,0)(0, 0) to (400 mL,5.73 g)(400\text{ mL}, 5.73\text{ g}), after which it becomes a flat horizontal line (asymptote at y=5.73 gy = 5.73\text{ g}) as VNaCl→∞V_{\text{NaCl}} \to \infty.

Loading workspace…