Resources
The octet rule is strictly enforced for Period 2 elements but can be violated via electron deficiency in Group 13 elements. Consider monomeric boron trifluoride, . (a) Construct the standard Lewis structure where all three fluorine atoms form single bonds with boron, and determine the formal charges on boron and fluorine. (b) Draw the hypothetical resonance contributor in which one bond is a double bond to fulfill boron's octet, and determine the formal charges on the boron atom and the double-bonded fluorine atom. (c) Based on electronegativity differences (, ), state which structure represents the dominant resonance contributor and why.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) In the single-bonded structure: Formal charge on ; Formal charge on each ; (b) In the double-bonded resonance structure: Formal charge on ; Formal charge on double-bonded ; (c) The incomplete octet structure (all single bonds) is the dominant contributor because fluorine is the most electronegative element in the periodic table and placing a positive formal charge on is energetically highly unfavorable.
Steps
Total Valence Electrons
To draw the Lewis structure of boron trifluoride ():
- Boron () is in Group 13 and contributes valence electrons.
- Each fluorine () is in Group 17 and contributes valence electrons.
(a) Structure with Incomplete Octet (All Single Bonds)
-
Bonding and Lone Pairs:
- Place in the center and connect it to each of the three atoms with a single covalent bond ( bonding electrons used).
- Distribute the remaining electrons () as three lone pairs ( nonbonding electrons) on each of the three atoms.
- Boron has no lone pairs and shares electrons, giving it an electron-deficient incomplete octet.
-
Formal Charge Calculation: where is the number of valence electrons in the free neutral atom, is the number of nonbonding valence electrons, and is the number of covalent bonds.
- Boron ():
- Each Fluorine ():
Every atom carries a formal charge of .
(b) Structure with Complete Octet (One Double Bond)
-
Bonding and Lone Pairs:
- One fluorine atom shares one of its lone pairs with boron to form a double bond ().
- Boron now participates in bonds ( shared electrons), fulfilling its octet.
- The double-bonded fluorine atom retains lone pairs ( nonbonding electrons).
- The remaining two fluorine atoms remain single-bonded with lone pairs ( nonbonding electrons) each.
-
Formal Charge Calculation:
- Boron ():
- Double-bonded Fluorine ():
- Single-bonded Fluorines ():
(c) Dominant Resonance Contributor
- In the all-single-bonded structure, every atom has a formal charge of , though boron has an incomplete octet of electrons.
- In the double-bonded resonance form, the octet rule is satisfied, but non-zero formal charges are introduced: a charge on and a charge on .
- Fluorine is the most electronegative element (), while boron is significantly less electronegative (). Placing a positive formal charge on an extremely electronegative element and a negative charge on a more electropositive atom is energetically unfavorable.
Therefore, the incomplete octet structure (all single bonds) is the dominant resonance contributor.
Typical errors
01 The student prioritizes the octet rule over formal charge minimization and electronegativity, incorrectly concluding that the double-bonded structure is dominant.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Three single bonds, each has lone pairs ,
- Step 2
One double bond, two single bonds Double-bonded has lone pairs; single-bonded atoms have lone pairs ,
- Step 3
The double-bonded structure is the dominant contributor because it fulfills the octet rule for boron, which is preferred over an incomplete octet.
CorrectThe all-single-bonded structure (incomplete octet) is the dominant contributor because it maintains a formal charge of on all atoms, whereas the double-bonded contributor places an unfavorable formal charge on the most electronegative element () and a formal charge on less electronegative boron.
You prioritized the octet rule without considering that placing a positive formal charge on fluorine () is energetically highly disfavored compared to an electron-deficient boron with zero formal charges.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the total number of valence electrons as .
You accurately calculated the formal charges for all atoms in both resonance structures.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that satisfying the octet rule always overrides formal charge minimization, overlooking that placing a positive formal charge on the most electronegative element (fluorine) creates an energetically unfavorable resonance contributor.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluating Resonance Dominance for Group 13 Trihalides
When evaluating resonance contributors for electron-deficient species like , formal charges of zero on all atoms are preferred over octet fulfillment if fulfilling the octet requires placing a positive formal charge on an extremely electronegative halogen like fluorine.
Check whether satisfying the central atom's octet forces a positive formal charge onto an electronegative terminal atom; if so, the incomplete-octet structure with all-zero formal charges is the dominant contributor.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the formal charges of both resonance forms: all-single-bonded has on all atoms, while the double-bonded form has and .
Consider electronegativities: fluorine is the most electronegative element () and strongly resists carrying a positive formal charge.
Conclude that minimizing formal charges and avoiding a positive charge on fluorine outweighs octet completion for boron.
The all-single-bonded structure with an incomplete octet is the dominant resonance contributor.
02 The student confuses the sign conventions when calculating formal charges, assigning positive charge to boron and negative charge to fluorine in the double-bonded structure.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Valence electrons ⟹ Central with single bonds to , lone pairs on each ⟹ ⟹
- Step 2
has one double bond and two single bonds to ⟹ Double-bonded has lone pairs ⟹ ⟹
Correct;
You inverted the order of subtraction in the formal charge formula: . For boron, it should be , and for the double-bonded fluorine, .
- Step 3
The single-bonded structure is dominant because all atoms have zero formal charge rather than charge separation.
CorrectThe incomplete octet structure is dominant because fluorine is the most electronegative element (); placing a positive formal charge on and a negative formal charge on () is energetically unfavorable.
While your choice of the single-bonded structure is correct, your explanation omitted the required electronegativity comparison. Because of the inverted charges in part (b), you could not see that the double-bonded structure erroneously places a charge on the most electronegative atom ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the total valence electrons for boron trifluoride.
You correctly calculated zero formal charges for all atoms in the single-bonded structure.
You correctly identified the single-bonded structure as the dominant contributor.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou subtracted the valence electrons from assigned electrons instead of subtracting assigned electrons from valence electrons.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisReversing the standard formal charge formula led to flipped signs ( on boron and on fluorine), obscuring the severe electronegativity mismatch of having positive fluorine.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Formal Charge Definition
Always start with the neutral group valence number and subtract assigned electrons.
- Electronegativity Resonance Rule
Negative formal charges belong on more electronegative atoms; positive formal charges on less electronegative atoms.
Check if a resonance contributor forces a positive formal charge onto an extremely electronegative element such as or .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify valence electrons () for free atoms: has , has .
Count nonbonding electrons () and shared bonds (): Boron has ; double-bonded fluorine has .
Apply : and .
Evaluate using electronegativity: Fluorine () is much more electronegative than boron (), so placing a charge on fluorine is highly disfavored, making the incomplete octet structure with zero formal charges dominant.
In the double-bonded form, and . The single-bonded form is dominant because placing a formal charge on highly electronegative fluorine is energetically unfavorable.
Lock it in
What is the formal charge rule regarding electronegative atoms in resonance contributors?
Negative formal charges should reside on the most electronegative atoms, and positive formal charges should never reside on highly electronegative atoms like fluorine.
Similar question
Consider monomeric boron trichloride, . Determine the formal charges on boron and chlorine in the all-single-bonded Lewis structure, and state whether boron has a complete octet.
Answer
; . Boron has an incomplete octet (shares electrons).
In the thiocyanate ion, two possible Lewis structures are and (or with negative charge on sulfur: ). Compare the formal charges of and , and identify the dominant contributor using electronegativity values (, ).
Answer
For , , , . For , , , . The dominant contributor is because nitrogen is more electronegative than sulfur, so the negative formal charge is more stably held on nitrogen.
Monomeric beryllium dihydride () has only four valence electrons around beryllium in its standard Lewis structure. Explain why does not form double bonds with hydrogen to achieve an octet.
Answer
Hydrogen has only a orbital and can form at most one single bond (a duet of electrons). A double bond would require electrons on hydrogen, which is impossible. Thus, must remain electron-deficient with valence electrons around beryllium.