Resources
In a materials science laboratory, four polished metal disks—Silver (Ag), Copper (Cu), Polished Aluminum (Al), and Lead (Pb)—are evaluated for electrical conductivity using a four-point collinear probe apparatus, and surface luster using a specular glossmeter at a incident angle. The four-point probe delivers a current and measures potential differences across outer to inner pins on specimens of equal thickness (sheet resistance formula , conductivity ). Specimen 1 yields and gloss value ; Specimen 2 yields and rapidly develops a dull gray tarnish (); Specimen 3 yields and gloss . (a) Calculate the electrical conductivity for Specimen 1 and Specimen 2. (b) Correctly assign the identities of Ag, Cu, and Pb among Specimens 1, 2, and 3, and explain the chemical cause for the loss of luster in Specimen 2.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Specimen 1: ; Specimen 2: ; (b) Specimen 1 is Silver (Ag), Specimen 2 is Lead (Pb), Specimen 3 is Copper (Cu); Lead loses its metallic luster because spontaneous surface oxidation forms an incoherent, non-metallic passivating oxide/carbonate film (/) that scatters incident light diffusely instead of specularly.
Steps
Specimen 1
Part (a): Calculating Electrical Conductivity ()
The four-point probe method relates the sheet resistance , specimen thickness , and bulk electrical conductivity via: Given parameters:
- Current:
- Thickness:
- Geometric constant factor:
Substitute :
Specimen 2
Substitute :
Part (b): Metal Assignment and Cause of Tarnishing
Assigning Metal Identities
Conductivity in metals is governed by the electron-sea model, depending on the density and mean free path of delocalized valence electrons. The intrinsic electrical conductivities of the metals follow the trend:
- Specimen 1 has the lowest measured voltage drop (), giving the highest conductivity (). This identifies Specimen 1 as Silver ().
- Specimen 3 has a slightly larger voltage drop (), corresponding to , which is characteristic of the second-most conductive metal, Copper ().
- Specimen 2 displays a much larger voltage drop (), yielding a conductivity an order of magnitude lower (). This corresponds to the post-transition metal Lead ().
Chemical Mechanism for Loss of Luster in Specimen 2
- Metallic Luster Mechanism: In clean metals, mobile conduction electrons absorb incident light frequencies and re-emit them in phase, creating high specular reflection (mirror-like gloss).
- Tarnish Formation: Lead () reacts spontaneously with atmospheric , moisture, and :
- The resulting non-conductive, ionic/covalent layer of and lacks the free electron density needed for specular reflection. Instead, its microcrystalline roughness causes diffuse light scattering, resulting in a rapid drop in measured gloss from a metallic sheen down to a dull gray tarnish ().
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to convert microvolts to volts, yielding conductivity values that are off by a factor of 10⁶.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You substituted the voltage as rather than converting to . Because microvolts were not converted to base SI units, your result is understated by a factor of .
- Step 3Correct
You repeated the unit conversion omission by substituting instead of , which gave a value times too small.
- Step 4
Specimen 1 has highest conductivity so it is Ag. Specimen 3 has intermediate conductivity so it is Cu. Specimen 2 has lowest conductivity so it is Pb. Specimen 2 tarnishes because lead oxidizes in air to form a dull lead oxide coating.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou algebraically set up the relationship between bulk conductivity, sheet resistance, and four-point probe parameters correctly.
You converted current and thickness into proper base SI units ( and ).
You accurately ranked the conductivities to identify Silver, Copper, and Lead.
You correctly explained that lead's loss of luster is caused by the formation of an oxide layer.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated microvolts directly as volts during numerical substitution.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the metric prefix () when moving from the given experimental data to the formula substitution, leading to calculated values that were off by six orders of magnitude.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- SI Prefix Verification
Always write out each given quantity in scientific notation with base SI units before substituting into physical equations.
- Physical Reality Check for Metals
Good conductors like and have electrical conductivities on the order of .
Compare calculated values against typical reference scales: a value of corresponds to poorly conducting electrolytes, not metallic conductors.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert measured voltage drops from microvolts to volts: and .
Evaluate .
Evaluate .
(a) Specimen 1: ; Specimen 2: . (b) Specimen 1 is , Specimen 2 is , Specimen 3 is ; Specimen 2 tarnishes because spontaneous oxidation in air produces a non-metallic coating that diffusely scatters light.
02 The student misinterprets higher measured voltage as indicating higher conductivity rather than higher resistance, reversing the metal assignments.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Higher voltage drop means higher conductivity. Specimen 2 has the largest , so Specimen 2 is . Specimen 3 has , so Specimen 3 is . Specimen 1 has the lowest , so Specimen 1 is .
CorrectBecause at constant current and geometry, a lower potential difference indicates higher electrical conductivity. Since intrinsic conductivity follows , Specimen 1 (lowest , highest ) is , Specimen 3 is , and Specimen 2 (highest , lowest ) is .
You inverted the relationship between voltage drop and conductivity. From Ohm's law, a larger potential drop across a given current indicates greater resistance, which means lower conductivity.
- Step 3
Specimen 2 loses luster due to surface reaction forming an oxide layer.
CorrectLead (Specimen 2) loses its metallic luster because spontaneous reaction with atmospheric and forms an incoherent, non-metallic / surface film that causes diffuse scattering of incident light rather than specular reflection.
You correctly recognized that tarnishing is caused by a surface reaction forming an oxide layer, but this explanation applies chemically to Lead (), not Silver ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou derived and correctly set up the reciprocal relationship for conductivity from sheet resistance.
You accurately carried out the numerical calculations for both specimens with correct scientific notation and units.
You identified that oxidation reactions at the metal surface cause tarnishing.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated measured voltage drop as directly proportional to electrical conductivity instead of inversely proportional to it, overlooking that for a fixed test current, means higher corresponds to greater resistance and lower conductivity.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Voltage-Conductivity Relationship
For a constant current , .
Always associate a larger voltage drop with higher electrical resistance and lower conductivity.
- Intrinsic Metal Conductivity Ranking
Among common conductive metals, conductivity decreases in the order .
Assign the metal with the smallest measured to the most conductive metal (Silver).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that , which shows that is inversely proportional to .
Rank the specimens by conductivity: Specimen 1 (, highest ) > Specimen 3 () > Specimen 2 (, lowest ).
Match with the known conductivity trend to identify Specimen 1 as , Specimen 3 as , and Specimen 2 as .
Explain that spontaneously oxidizes in air to form an amorphous/microcrystalline layer lacking free conduction electrons, converting specular reflection into diffuse scattering.
(a) Specimen 1: ; Specimen 2: . (b) Specimen 1 is , Specimen 2 is , and Specimen 3 is ; Lead loses luster because a non-conductive surface layer of forms and scatters light diffusely rather than specularly.
Lock it in
What multiplier does the SI prefix micro () represent when converting to a base unit?
. For example, and .
Similar question
A copper wire with cross-sectional area and length carries a current of with an observed voltage drop of . Calculate the electrical conductivity of the wire in .
Answer
. Convert units: and . Using , then .
An aluminum thin film of thickness is measured with a collinear four-point probe (). At , the recorded voltage is . Determine (a) the sheet resistance and (b) the bulk electrical conductivity .
Answer
(a) ; (b) . Convert , , and . Calculate . Then .
Two metallic specimens, A and B, are tested. Specimen A maintains a specular gloss of after prolonged air exposure and exhibits conductivity . Specimen B initially has but drops to over 48 hours, with conductivity . Identify which metal is Lead (Pb) and which is Silver (Ag), and contrast the microscopic optical behavior of their surfaces after 48 hours.
Answer
Specimen A is Silver (Ag); Specimen B is Lead (Pb). Silver resists rapid spontaneous oxidation in clean air, maintaining an unoxidized electron-sea surface that produces specular (mirror-like) light reflection (). Lead rapidly reacts with atmospheric and to form an irregular, non-metallic layer that diffusely scatters incoming light in all directions, dropping gloss to .