Resources
In an analytical chemistry laboratory, a student performs a standardization titration to quantify the purity of a liquid carboxylic acid sample. A sample of an unknown pure monoprotic carboxylic acid is dissolved in of distilled water and titrated with standard . The equivalence point is reached at a titrant volume of . (a) Calculate the molar mass of the carboxylic acid to four significant figures. (b) Identify whether the acid is acetic acid (, ), propanoic acid (, ), or benzoic acid (, ). (c) In pure liquid form, this identified acid exists largely as a stable dimer in the gas and nonpolar liquid phases; sketch the intermolecular interaction that stabilizes this dimer and state the number of hydrogen bonds holding each dimer pair together.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) The acid is benzoic acid (, theoretical molar mass , difference); (c) The dimer is stabilized by two reciprocal, antiparallel intermolecular hydrogen bonds formed between the carbonyl oxygen () of each monomer and the acidic hydroxyl hydrogen () of the other monomer, creating a planar 8-membered cyclic ring.
Steps
Part (a): Calculating the Molar Mass
-
Determine the moles of consumed at the equivalence point:
The titration reaction between a monoprotic carboxylic acid () and sodium hydroxide () follows a stoichiometric ratio:
Convert the volume of to liters and calculate the moles of base:
-
Calculate the moles and molar mass of the unknown acid:
Because the acid is monoprotic:
The experimental molar mass () is the mass of the sample divided by the moles of acid:
Rounded to four significant figures, the molar mass is .
Part (b): Identifying the Carboxylic Acid
Compare the experimental molar mass to the theoretical values:
- Acetic acid ():
- Propanoic acid ():
- Benzoic acid ():
The calculated value of is very close to benzoic acid:
Therefore, the acid is benzoic acid ().
Part (c): Structure and Hydrogen Bonding in the Dimer
In the gas phase and nonpolar media, carboxylic acid molecules pair up to form a cyclic dimer:
- Each carboxylic acid molecule contains an electron-rich carbonyl oxygen atom () and an electron-deficient hydroxyl hydrogen atom ().
- Two molecules align antiparallel to each other so that the carbonyl oxygen of one monomer forms a hydrogen bond with the acidic hydroxyl hydrogen of the other monomer:
- This reciprocal arrangement results in exactly intermolecular hydrogen bonds per dimer, closing an extraordinarily stable, planar 8-membered ring ().
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to convert the titrant volume from milliliters to liters, resulting in a calculated molar mass that is three orders of magnitude too small and leading to an incorrect identification.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You multiplied molarity () directly by milliliters without converting to liters (). This yielded rather than , making your molar quantity times too large.
- Step 2Correct
You correctly used the formula , but substituting the incorrect mole value resulted in a molar mass three orders of magnitude too small.
- Step 3
is closest in scale to the smallest molar mass, acetic acid ().
Correct, which is within of benzoic acid ().
Because your calculated molar mass was , you selected acetic acid. With the corrected molar mass of , the compound is benzoic acid.
- Step 4
Acetic acid forms a cyclic dimer with 2 hydrogen bonds between the and groups.
CorrectBenzoic acid forms a cyclic dimer stabilized by intermolecular hydrogen bonds between and groups, forming an -membered cyclic structure.
You correctly identified the two hydrogen bonds between the carbonyl and hydroxyl groups, but you named acetic acid due to the earlier identification error and omitted the requested sketch.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the equivalence relationship between the monoprotic carboxylic acid and sodium hydroxide.
You used the correct relationship between sample mass, moles, and molar mass.
You correctly stated that carboxylic acid dimers are held together by two hydrogen bonds between carbonyl and hydroxyl groups.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted volume in milliliters instead of liters into , mislabeling millimoles as moles.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking unit consistency in concentration calculations: molarity has units of , so multiplying directly by milliliters produces millimoles (), not moles ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Molarity-Volume Unit Check
Always convert burette readings from to by dividing by before calculating moles.
- Physical Reasonableness of Molar Mass
Stable neutral organic molecules with carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen always have molar masses well above (the lightest stable organic molecule, methane , is ).
If a calculated molar mass is a tiny fraction such as , immediately check for an unperformed milliliter-to-liter conversion.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert titrant volume to liters: .
Calculate moles of base and acid: .
Calculate molar mass: .
Compare with given values: closely matches benzoic acid ().
Sketch the benzoic acid dimer showing two reciprocal hydrogen bonds forming a stable -membered cyclic ring.
(a) ; (b) Benzoic acid; (c) hydrogen bonds in an 8-membered cyclic ring formed by reciprocal interactions.
02 The student erroneously uses the volume of water used to dissolve the sample rather than the titrant volume to calculate the moles of acid.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You multiplied the molarity of by the volume of water used to dissolve the acid rather than the volume of titrant delivered from the buret.
- Step 2Correct
You correctly divided the sample mass by your calculated mole quantity, but the resulting value of is inaccurate due to the mole error in Step 1.
- Step 3
" is closest to propanoic acid ()."
CorrectThe acid is benzoic acid (), with a theoretical molar mass of , which is within of the experimental .
Your selection of propanoic acid logically followed your calculated molar mass of , but the correct molar mass of identifies the acid as benzoic acid.
- Step 4
"Propanoic acid molecules interact head-to-tail via interactions, held by 2 hydrogen bonds."
CorrectA sketch showing two benzoic acid molecules arranged antiparallel with two reciprocal hydrogen bonds forming a cyclic 8-membered ring, held by 2 hydrogen bonds.
You correctly noted that the dimer is held together by two hydrogen bonds, but you did not include the requested sketch of the intermolecular interaction.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized the stoichiometric equivalence between a monoprotic acid and sodium hydroxide.
You correctly used the relationship .
You accurately identified that carboxylic acid dimers are stabilized by two reciprocal hydrogen bonds.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally selected the analyte solution volume () instead of the delivered titrant volume () when calculating moles of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the volume of the solvent used to dissolve the solid sample with the volume of standardized titrant required to reach the equivalence point.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Titrant Volume vs. Analyte Volume
In titration stoichiometry, , not the volume of solvent used in the flask.
Always circle the buret reading or delivered titrant volume and confirm it matches the reagent whose concentration is given.
- Complete Question Deliverables
When a prompt asks to 'sketch and state', both a drawing and a written numerical value are required for full credit.
Check off each sub-command in the prompt before moving on to the next part.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert the volume of titrant used to liters: .
Calculate moles of : .
Because the acid is monoprotic, .
Calculate experimental molar mass: .
Compare with options: matches benzoic acid (, ) within .
Draw two benzoic acid molecules antiparallel to each other, connecting the carbonyl oxygen of each molecule to the hydroxyl hydrogen of the other with dashed lines to show the 2 intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
(a) ; (b) Benzoic acid; (c) Two antiparallel hydrogen bonds forming a cyclic dimer with 2 hydrogen bonds.
03 The student correctly identifies benzoic acid but assumes that because it is a dimer, only 1 shared hydrogen bond links the two molecules.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
The molar mass of matches benzoic acid ().
- Step 3
The dimer forms when the carboxylic acid group of one molecule forms a hydrogen bond with another. There is 1 hydrogen bond holding the two molecules together.
CorrectA sketch showing two antiparallel benzoic acid molecules linked by hydrogen bonds: each between a carbonyl oxygen () and a hydroxyl hydrogen (), forming an -membered cyclic ring.
Carboxylic acid molecules possess both a hydrogen bond donor () and an acceptor () within the same carboxyl functional group. In nonpolar environments or pure liquids, they align in an antiparallel orientation to form two reciprocal hydrogen bonds, creating a stable cyclic dimer with an -membered ring.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou converted titrant volume to liters and correctly found moles of titrant.
You applied the stoichiometric ratio for a monoprotic acid titration.
You calculated the experimental molar mass to four significant figures with correct units.
You correctly identified benzoic acid from the candidate list.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou omitted the required molecular sketch and counted only hydrogen bond holding the dimer pair together.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking that the carboxyl group contains both a donor () and an acceptor (), which arrange antiparallel to each other to form two reciprocal hydrogen bonds that close an -membered ring.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dual Donor-Acceptor Capability
Every carboxylic acid group () contains one strong -bond donor () and one strong -bond acceptor ().
Always check whether both functional sites can interact simultaneously with a partner molecule.
- Cyclic Dimer Geometry
Two carboxylic acid molecules pair antiparallel to form an -membered cyclic ring stabilized by exactly hydrogen bonds.
Draw both molecules facing opposite directions and connect each to the opposing with dashed lines ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationOrient two molecules in an antiparallel fashion so that the carbonyl group of molecule 1 faces the hydroxyl group of molecule 2, and vice versa.
Draw dashed lines representing hydrogen bonds between each carbonyl oxygen atom () and the neighboring hydroxyl hydrogen atom (): .
Count the reciprocal hydrogen bonds: there are exactly hydrogen bonds per dimer unit.
The dimer is held together by intermolecular hydrogen bonds forming a stable, cyclic -membered ring.
Lock it in
What units result from multiplying molarity () by volume in milliliters ()?
Millimoles (), where . To obtain moles, you must divide by .
Similar question
A student titrates a sample of an unknown monoprotic weak acid with . The equivalence point requires of titrant. Calculate the molar mass of the acid to four significant figures.
Answer
. Steps: ; .
A sample of a pure diprotic carboxylic acid () is dissolved in water and titrated to the second equivalence point with of . Calculate the molar mass of the diprotic acid and identify whether it is oxalic acid (), malonic acid (), or succinic acid ().
Answer
(adjusted: , , ). None of the three listed; note the acid-to-base stoichiometry.
Explain why pure benzoic acid dissolved in benzene shows an apparent colligative molar mass of approximately , whereas in dilute aqueous solution its apparent molar mass is close to .
Answer
In nonpolar benzene, benzoic acid molecules pair up via two reciprocal intermolecular hydrogen bonds () to form stable dimers, doubling the effective particle mass to . In water, strong solute-solvent hydrogen bonds disrupt dimerization, keeping benzoic acid as individual monomers ().