Resources

A student analyzes iron(III) sulfate, Fe2(SO4)3\text{Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3, and incorrectly writes the formula as FeSO4\text{FeSO}_4 by neglecting the oxidation state crossover. Calculate both the true percent composition of iron by mass in pure Fe2(SO4)3\text{Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3 and the erroneous percent composition calculated using FeSO4\text{FeSO}_4. Use the atomic masses: Fe=55.845 g/mol\text{Fe} = 55.845\text{ g/mol}, S=32.065 g/mol\text{S} = 32.065\text{ g/mol}, and O=15.999 g/mol\text{O} = 15.999\text{ g/mol}. Express both percentages to two decimal places.

Answer and steps

Final answer

True percent iron in Fe2(SO4)3=27.93%\text{Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3 = 27.93\%; Erroneous percent iron in FeSO4=36.77%\text{FeSO}_4 = 36.77\%

Steps

01

True Percent Composition of Iron in FeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Fe2(SO4)3}

The percent composition by mass of an element in a compound is defined as: % by mass=total mass of the element in one mole of compoundmolar mass of the compound×100%\% \text{ by mass} = \frac{\text{total mass of the element in one mole of compound}}{\text{molar mass of the compound}} \times 100\%

A single formula unit of iron(III) sulfate, FeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Fe2(SO4)3}, contains 22 atoms of Fe\ce{Fe}, 33 atoms of S\ce{S}, and 1212 atoms of O\ce{O}.

  1. Calculate the molar mass of FeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Fe2(SO4)3}: Mass of Fe=2×55.845 g/mol=111.690 g/mol\text{Mass of Fe} = 2 \times 55.845\text{ g/mol} = 111.690\text{ g/mol} Mass of S=3×32.065 g/mol=96.195 g/mol\text{Mass of S} = 3 \times 32.065\text{ g/mol} = 96.195\text{ g/mol} Mass of O=12×15.999 g/mol=191.988 g/mol\text{Mass of O} = 12 \times 15.999\text{ g/mol} = 191.988\text{ g/mol}

    Summing these values gives the total molar mass: Molar mass of FeX2(SOX4)X3=111.690+96.195+191.988=399.873 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} = 111.690 + 96.195 + 191.988 = 399.873\text{ g/mol}

  2. Calculate the mass percent of iron: %Fe=111.690 g/mol399.873 g/mol×100%≈27.93%\% \ce{Fe} = \frac{111.690\text{ g/mol}}{399.873\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% \approx 27.93\%

02

Erroneous Percent Composition of Iron in FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4}

If the formula is incorrectly assumed to be iron(II) sulfate, FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4}, the formula unit contains 11 atom of Fe\ce{Fe}, 11 atom of S\ce{S}, and 44 atoms of O\ce{O}.

  1. Calculate the molar mass of FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4}: Mass of Fe=1×55.845 g/mol=55.845 g/mol\text{Mass of Fe} = 1 \times 55.845\text{ g/mol} = 55.845\text{ g/mol} Mass of S=1×32.065 g/mol=32.065 g/mol\text{Mass of S} = 1 \times 32.065\text{ g/mol} = 32.065\text{ g/mol} Mass of O=4×15.999 g/mol=63.996 g/mol\text{Mass of O} = 4 \times 15.999\text{ g/mol} = 63.996\text{ g/mol}

    Summing these gives: Molar mass of FeSOX4=55.845+32.065+63.996=151.906 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\ce{FeSO4} = 55.845 + 32.065 + 63.996 = 151.906\text{ g/mol} (Note: Using standard rounded intermediate values ≈151.91 g/mol\approx 151.91\text{ g/mol} yields identical precision).

  2. Calculate the mass percent of iron: %Fe=55.845 g/mol151.91 g/mol×100%≈36.77%\% \ce{Fe} = \frac{55.845\text{ g/mol}}{151.91\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% \approx 36.77\%

Key Takeaway and Pitfall

Neglecting the ionic charges when balancing formulas (FeX3+\ce{Fe^3+} with SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-} requiring a 2:32:3 ratio rather than 1:11:1) dramatically skews stoichiometry. Here, writing FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4} instead of FeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} overestimates the relative iron content by nearly 9%9\% by mass.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to multiply the subscript of oxygen inside the sulfate polyatomic ion by the subscript outside the parentheses, counting only 4 or 7 oxygen atoms instead of 12.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Molar mass of Fe2(SO4)3=2(55.845)+3(32.065)+4(15.999)=111.690+96.195+63.996=271.881 g/mol\text{Molar mass of Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3 = 2(55.845) + 3(32.065) + 4(15.999) = 111.690 + 96.195 + 63.996 = 271.881\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    Molar mass of Fe2(SO4)3=2(55.845)+3(32.065)+12(15.999)=399.873 g/mol\text{Molar mass of Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3 = 2(55.845) + 3(32.065) + 12(15.999) = 399.873\text{ g/mol}

    You counted only 44 oxygen atoms in the formula unit instead of multiplying the inner subscript 44 by the outside subscript 33 (3×4=123 \times 4 = 12 oxygen atoms).

  2. Step 2

    Mass percent of Fe=(111.690/271.881)×100%=41.08%\text{Mass percent of Fe} = (111.690 / 271.881) \times 100\% = 41.08\%

    Correct

    Mass percent of Fe=111.690 g/mol399.873 g/mol×100%≈27.93%\text{Mass percent of Fe} = \frac{111.690\text{ g/mol}}{399.873\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% \approx 27.93\%

    You correctly set up the mass percent ratio using your calculated molar mass, but the value is inaccurate due to the propagated oxygen count error.

  3. Step 3

    Molar mass of FeSO4=55.845+32.065+4(15.999)=151.906 g/mol\text{Molar mass of FeSO}_4 = 55.845 + 32.065 + 4(15.999) = 151.906\text{ g/mol}

  4. Step 4

    Erroneous mass percent of Fe=(55.845/151.906)×100%=36.76%\text{Erroneous mass percent of Fe} = (55.845 / 151.906) \times 100\% = 36.76\%

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the molar mass of FeSO4\text{FeSO}_4.

You correctly determined the mass percentage of iron in FeSO4\text{FeSO}_4.

You set up the mass ratio total mass of Fetotal molar mass×100%\frac{\text{total mass of Fe}}{\text{total molar mass}} \times 100\% properly in both parts.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subscript Distribution Error in Polyatomic Ions

You took the subscript of oxygen as 44 directly from inside the parentheses instead of multiplying it by the outside subscript of 33.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A subscript placed outside parentheses distributes to every element inside the parentheses by multiplication ((Ea)b(\text{E}_a)_b gives a×ba \times b atoms of E\text{E}), rather than leaving internal subscripts unchanged.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distribute Subscripts Across Parentheses
  • In a chemical formula unit like Mx(AyBz)nM_x(A_yB_z)_n, the total number of atoms of element BB is z×nz \times n.

  • Before calculating molar mass, list each element and multiply its inside subscript by any subscript outside the group.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Total O atoms=4×3=12\text{Total O atoms} = 4 \times 3 = 12

  2. Molar mass of Fe2(SO4)3=2(55.845)+3(32.065)+12(15.999)=111.690+96.195+191.988=399.873 g/mol\text{Molar mass of Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3 = 2(55.845) + 3(32.065) + 12(15.999) = 111.690 + 96.195 + 191.988 = 399.873\text{ g/mol}

  3. True mass percent of Fe=111.690 g/mol399.873 g/mol×100%=27.93%\text{True mass percent of Fe} = \frac{111.690\text{ g/mol}}{399.873\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% = 27.93\%

Final answer

True percent iron in Fe2(SO4)3=27.93%\text{Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3 = 27.93\%; Erroneous percent iron in FeSO4=36.76% (or 36.77%)\text{FeSO}_4 = 36.76\%\text{ (or }36.77\%)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out an inventory of each element's atom count explicitly before multiplying by molar masses.

  • Verify that every subscript outside parentheses multiplies all subscripts inside the parentheses.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student includes only one iron atom in the numerator when calculating the mass percent of iron in Fe2(SO4)3.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Molar mass of FeX2(SOX4)X3=2(55.845)+3(32.065)+12(15.999)=399.873 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} = 2(55.845) + 3(32.065) + 12(15.999) = 399.873\text{ g/mol}

  2. Step 2

    Mass percent of Fe=(55.845399.873)×100%=13.97%\text{Mass percent of Fe} = \left(\frac{55.845}{399.873}\right) \times 100\% = 13.97\%

    Correct

    Mass percent of Fe=(2×55.845399.873)×100%=(111.690399.873)×100%≈27.93%\text{Mass percent of Fe} = \left(\frac{2 \times 55.845}{399.873}\right) \times 100\% = \left(\frac{111.690}{399.873}\right) \times 100\% \approx 27.93\%

    You only included the mass of a single iron atom (55.845 g/mol55.845\text{ g/mol}) in the numerator, but one mole of FeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} contains 22 moles of Fe\ce{Fe} (2×55.845 g/mol=111.690 g/mol2 \times 55.845\text{ g/mol} = 111.690\text{ g/mol}).

  3. Step 3

    Molar mass of FeSOX4=55.845+32.065+4(15.999)=151.906 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\ce{FeSO4} = 55.845 + 32.065 + 4(15.999) = 151.906\text{ g/mol}

  4. Step 4

    Erroneous mass percent of Fe=(55.845151.906)×100%=36.76%\text{Erroneous mass percent of Fe} = \left(\frac{55.845}{151.906}\right) \times 100\% = 36.76\%

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately found the molar masses of both FeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} and FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4} using the given atomic weights.

You correctly applied the mass percentage formula for FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Element Subscript in Numerator

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When calculating the percent composition of an element, the numerator must represent the total mass contributed by that element in one mole of the compound (n×atomic massn \times \text{atomic mass}), rather than the mass of just one single atom.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Element's Multiplicity
  • Percent by mass of element X=n×MXMcompound×100%\text{Percent by mass of element } X = \frac{n \times M_X}{M_{\text{compound}}} \times 100\%, where nn is the subscript of element XX in the chemical formula.

  • Always multiply the molar mass of the element in the numerator by its subscript in the chemical formula before dividing by the total molar mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that FeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} contains 22 iron atoms per formula unit: total mass of Fe=2×55.845 g/mol=111.690 g/mol\text{total mass of Fe} = 2 \times 55.845\text{ g/mol} = 111.690\text{ g/mol}.

  2. Divide by the compound's molar mass: 111.690399.873×100%≈27.93%\frac{111.690}{399.873} \times 100\% \approx 27.93\%.

Final answer

True percent iron in FeX2(SOX4)X3=27.93%\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} = 27.93\%; Erroneous percent iron in FeSOX4=36.76% (or 36.77%)\ce{FeSO4} = 36.76\%\text{ (or }36.77\%\text{)}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before setting up the fraction for mass percent, circle the element's subscript in the chemical formula.

  • Verify that the numerator equals the subscript times the atomic mass of that specific element.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to multiply the subscript 4 of oxygen when calculating the molar mass of FeSO4, counting only one oxygen atom.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Molar mass of Fe2(SO4)3=2(55.845)+3(32.065)+12(15.999)=399.873 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\text{Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3 = 2(55.845) + 3(32.065) + 12(15.999) = 399.873\text{ g/mol}

  2. Step 2

    Mass percent of Fe=(111.690399.873)×100%=27.93%\text{Mass percent of Fe} = \left(\frac{111.690}{399.873}\right) \times 100\% = 27.93\%

  3. Step 3

    Molar mass of FeSO4=55.845+32.065+15.999=103.909 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\text{FeSO}_4 = 55.845 + 32.065 + 15.999 = 103.909\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    Molar mass of FeSOX4=55.845+32.065+4(15.999)=151.906 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\ce{FeSO4} = 55.845 + 32.065 + 4(15.999) = 151.906\text{ g/mol}

    In FeSO4\text{FeSO}_4, the subscript on oxygen is 44, which means there are four oxygen atoms per formula unit. You only included the mass of a single oxygen atom (15.999 g/mol15.999\text{ g/mol}) instead of 4×15.999 g/mol=63.996 g/mol4 \times 15.999\text{ g/mol} = 63.996\text{ g/mol}.

  4. Step 4

    Erroneous mass percent of Fe=(55.845103.909)×100%=53.74%\text{Erroneous mass percent of Fe} = \left(\frac{55.845}{103.909}\right) \times 100\% = 53.74\%

    Correct

    %Fe\ce{Fe} = (55.845 g/mol151.906 g/mol)\left(\frac{55.845\text{ g/mol}}{151.906\text{ g/mol}}\right) ×\times 100% ≈\approx 36.77%

    Your percent calculation followed the correct mathematical structure, but the result was incorrect because it used the erroneous molar mass from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total molar mass of iron(III) sulfate by properly distributing the subscript 33 to both sulfur and oxygen.

You correctly calculated the true mass percentage of iron in Fe2(SO4)3\text{Fe}_2(\text{SO}_4)_3.

You set up the percent composition formula correctly for both parts.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Subscript Multiplier

You forgot to multiply oxygen's atomic mass by its subscript of 44 in the formula FeSO4\text{FeSO}_4.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Subscripts in chemical formulas indicate the exact number of atoms of that element in one formula unit. When a polyatomic ion such as sulfate (SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-}) does not have surrounding parentheses, the subscript 44 still applies directly to oxygen.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Count Every Subscript Explicitly
  • Every element symbol in a chemical formula has an atom count: an explicit subscript if present, or an implicit 11 if no subscript is written.

  • Before adding atomic masses, list each element and its quantity (e.g., for FeSO4\text{FeSO}_4: Fe=1\text{Fe} = 1, S=1\text{S} = 1, O=4\text{O} = 4).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate the molar mass of FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4} including all 44 oxygen atoms: Molar mass=55.845+32.065+4(15.999)=151.906 g/mol\text{Molar mass} = 55.845 + 32.065 + 4(15.999) = 151.906\text{ g/mol}.

  2. Calculate the erroneous percent composition: %Fe=(55.845 g/mol151.906 g/mol)×100%≈36.77%\%\ce{Fe} = \left(\frac{55.845\text{ g/mol}}{151.906\text{ g/mol}}\right) \times 100\% \approx 36.77\%.

Final answer

True percent iron in FeX2(SOX4)X3=27.93%\ce{Fe2(SO4)3} = 27.93\%; Erroneous percent iron in $FeSOX4\ce{FeSO4} = 36.77%$$

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice breaking chemical formulas into an explicit inventory of element counts before calculating molar mass.

  • Pay special attention to polyatomic ions written without outer parentheses, ensuring you do not overlook their internal subscripts.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Calculate the percent composition by mass of oxygen in calcium nitrate, Ca(NO3)2\text{Ca}(\text{NO}_3)_2. Use atomic masses: Ca=40.078 g/mol\text{Ca} = 40.078\text{ g/mol}, N=14.007 g/mol\text{N} = 14.007\text{ g/mol}, and O=15.999 g/mol\text{O} = 15.999\text{ g/mol}. Express your answer to two decimal places.

Answer

58.50%58.50\%. Key steps: One formula unit contains 1 Ca1\text{ Ca}, 2 N2\text{ N}, and 3×2=6 O3 \times 2 = 6\text{ O}. Molar mass =40.078+2(14.007)+6(15.999)=164.086 g/mol= 40.078 + 2(14.007) + 6(15.999) = 164.086\text{ g/mol}. Mass percent of O=6×15.999164.086×100%=95.994164.086×100%≈58.50%\text{O} = \frac{6 \times 15.999}{164.086} \times 100\% = \frac{95.994}{164.086} \times 100\% \approx 58.50\%.

02

A student calculates the molar mass of magnesium phosphate, Mg3(PO4)2\text{Mg}_3(\text{PO}_4)_2, but adds the subscripts instead of multiplying, counting 4+2=64 + 2 = 6 oxygen atoms instead of 88. Using Mg=24.305 g/mol\text{Mg} = 24.305\text{ g/mol}, P=30.974 g/mol\text{P} = 30.974\text{ g/mol}, and O=15.999 g/mol\text{O} = 15.999\text{ g/mol}, calculate the correct percent of magnesium by mass and the student's erroneous percent.

Answer

Correct %Mg=27.74%\%\text{Mg} = 27.74\%; Erroneous %Mg=31.59%\%\text{Mg} = 31.59\%. Key steps: Correct molar mass has 8 O8\text{ O}: 3(24.305)+2(30.974)+8(15.999)=262.855 g/mol3(24.305) + 2(30.974) + 8(15.999) = 262.855\text{ g/mol}; %Mg=72.915262.855×100%≈27.74%\%\text{Mg} = \frac{72.915}{262.855} \times 100\% \approx 27.74\%. Erroneous molar mass has 6 O6\text{ O}: 262.855−2(15.999)=230.857 g/mol262.855 - 2(15.999) = 230.857\text{ g/mol}; erroneous %Mg=72.915230.857×100%≈31.59%\%\text{Mg} = \frac{72.915}{230.857} \times 100\% \approx 31.59\%.

03

Hydrated copper(II) sulfate is written as CuSO4⋅5H2O\text{CuSO}_4 \cdot 5\text{H}_2\text{O}. Calculate the total mass percentage of oxygen in this compound, taking into account both the sulfate group and water of crystallization. Use: Cu=63.546 g/mol\text{Cu} = 63.546\text{ g/mol}, S=32.065 g/mol\text{S} = 32.065\text{ g/mol}, O=15.999 g/mol\text{O} = 15.999\text{ g/mol}, and H=1.008 g/mol\text{H} = 1.008\text{ g/mol}.

Answer

57.67%57.67\%. Key steps: Total oxygen atoms =4 (from SO4)+5×1 (from 5H2O)=9 O atoms= 4\text{ (from }\text{SO}_4\text{)} + 5 \times 1\text{ (from }5\text{H}_2\text{O)} = 9\text{ O atoms}. Molar mass =63.546+32.065+4(15.999)+5[2(1.008)+15.999]=249.682 g/mol= 63.546 + 32.065 + 4(15.999) + 5[2(1.008) + 15.999] = 249.682\text{ g/mol}. Total mass of oxygen =9×15.999=143.991 g/mol= 9 \times 15.999 = 143.991\text{ g/mol}. Percent oxygen =143.991249.682×100%≈57.67%= \frac{143.991}{249.682} \times 100\% \approx 57.67\%.

Loading workspace…