Resources
Consider the vaporization of a volatile liquid in a sealed container as the ambient pressure approaches zero (the deep vacuum limit). At a constant temperature of , diethyl ether has an equilibrium vapor pressure of . If a open beaker of diethyl ether (density , molar mass ) is placed inside an ultra-high vacuum chamber continuously pumped down to an asymptotic pressure limit of , explain whether a true dynamic boiling equilibrium can be established and determine the state of the liquid assuming the pump capacity exceeds the vaporization rate.
Answer and steps
Final answer
No equilibrium is established; the liquid undergoes continuous, uninhibited boiling/flash vaporization until complete dryout.
Steps
Condition for Boiling
Boiling occurs throughout the bulk of a liquid when its saturated vapor pressure () equals or exceeds the external ambient pressure ():
At , the equilibrium vapor pressure of diethyl ether is:
The chamber is maintained at an ultra-low pressure:
Because , the internal pressure of vapor bubbles exceeds the surrounding pressure by more than eight orders of magnitude. As a result, vapor bubbles nucleate and expand effortlessly throughout the liquid, causing vigorous, spontaneous boiling (flash boiling).
Condition for Dynamic Phase Equilibrium
A true dynamic phase equilibrium () requires two criteria:
- The system must be effectively closed so that vapor molecules cannot escape into an infinite sink.
- The partial pressure of the vapor above the liquid must reach the saturation vapor pressure (), allowing the rate of condensation to match the rate of vaporization:
In this scenario:
- The chamber is continuously evacuated by an active vacuum pump whose capacity exceeds the vaporization rate.
- Ether molecules entering the vapor phase are immediately removed from the system before they can collide with the liquid surface and recondense.
- The vapor pressure never approaches , meaning the condensation rate remains negligible ().
Therefore, no dynamic equilibrium can be established.
Ultimate State of the Liquid
Because the phase transition is completely driven in the forward direction () and heat is supplied to maintain a constant temperature of :
- The diethyl ether undergoes rapid, uninhibited boiling and flash vaporization.
- Vaporization persists without reaching a steady-state liquid volume.
- The liquid phase diminishes continuously until all is evacuated, resulting in complete dryout.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses boiling occurring at an external pressure with reaching a thermodynamic dynamic equilibrium, incorrectly concluding that an equilibrium is established at the pump's base pressure.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is less than , so the liquid boils.
- Step 2
Because the pump maintains a constant steady pressure of , a dynamic boiling equilibrium is established at this pressure.
CorrectBecause the chamber is continuously evacuated and vapor is pumped away before it can recondense, , so no dynamic equilibrium can be established.
You treated a steady-state ambient vacuum pressure as a dynamic thermodynamic equilibrium. A dynamic phase equilibrium requires an enclosed vapor phase where , requiring the partial pressure of vapor to reach the saturation vapor pressure ().
- Step 3
The liquid reaches a steady boiling state where both liquid and vapor coexist in equilibrium. A portion of diethyl ether remains in the liquid state coexisting with vapor at .
CorrectContinuous flash vaporization occurs until all liquid diethyl ether is completely vaporized (complete dryout).
Because this conclusion stems directly from the assumption of equilibrium, it is affected by the error in Step 2. With continuous boiling and negligible condensation, the liquid volume decreases continuously to zero.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that a liquid boils when its vapor pressure exceeds the surrounding pressure.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNone.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that maintaining a constant chamber pressure satisfies the condition for a dynamic phase equilibrium, overlooking that dynamic equilibrium strictly requires balanced forward and reverse rates () in an enclosed system.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dynamic Phase Equilibrium vs. Steady State
A dynamic phase equilibrium between liquid and vapor requires , which only occurs in a closed system when the vapor partial pressure reaches .
Check whether vapor molecules can return and condense onto the liquid surface or if they are actively removed by an open boundary or pump.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAt , diethyl ether requires a partial pressure of to establish an equal rate of condensation.
Because the vacuum pump continuously evacuates vapor faster than the vaporization rate, the partial pressure of diethyl ether vapor remains negligible (), meaning condensation cannot balance vaporization.
With , the net phase change proceeds unidirectionally from liquid to vapor.
No dynamic boiling equilibrium is established; the liquid undergoes continuous, uninhibited boiling until complete dryout.
02 The student misinterprets continuous evacuation as a closed system that stops boiling once vapor pressure drops, mistakenly concluding that the liquid remains intact after cooling stops boiling.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
A dynamic equilibrium cannot be established because the system is open and vapor is continuously evacuated. ⟹ Equilibrium requires condensation to equal vaporization in a sealed environment.
- Step 2
Vaporization cools the liquid until its vapor pressure matches and boiling halts.
CorrectBecause the temperature is held constant at , the equilibrium vapor pressure remains , driving continuous boiling.
You assumed that evaporative cooling decreases the liquid's temperature, but the problem specifies that the process occurs at a constant temperature of .
- Step 3
The remaining diethyl ether stays in the liquid state inside the beaker at a lower temperature.
CorrectAll of diethyl ether boils away completely, leaving no liquid remaining (complete dryout).
Because the constant temperature keeps the vapor pressure far higher than the chamber pressure, the liquid continues to boil vigorously until it is entirely depleted.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that continuous evacuation prevents condensation from balancing vaporization.
You stated the essential condition required for dynamic phase equilibrium.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou introduced unprompted evaporative cooling despite the problem specifying a constant temperature of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the scenario as an isolated system experiencing thermal loss rather than an isothermal system with an external heat source maintaining . With temperature fixed, the driving force for boiling () never diminishes.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Isothermal Constraints
If a problem states 'at a constant temperature', assume heat transfer from the surroundings is sufficient to offset the latent heat of vaporization.
Keep the vapor pressure fixed at the value corresponding to that temperature () instead of letting it drop due to cooling.
- Compare Driving Pressures
Boiling continues as long as .
Since and is constant, conclude that uninhibited boiling persists until all liquid is vaporized.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that the temperature is maintained constant at , meaning heat is continuously supplied to balance the enthalpy of vaporization.
Because temperature is fixed, the vapor pressure remains constant at .
Compare the vapor pressure with the external pressure: .
Deduce that boiling never halts and continues uninhibited as the pump continuously removes vapor.
No dynamic equilibrium is established; uninhibited boiling and flash vaporization continue until complete dryout occurs (no liquid remains).
Lock it in
What microscopic condition must be met for a liquid-vapor system to be in true dynamic equilibrium?
The rate of vaporization must equal the rate of condensation (). This requires an enclosed space where vapor can accumulate to its saturation vapor pressure.
Similar question
A sample of pure ethanol ( at ) is placed in an open container inside a vacuum desiccator continuously pumped to . State whether dynamic equilibrium is reached and explain what happens to the liquid over time.
Answer
No dynamic equilibrium is reached. Because the pump continuously removes ethanol vapor, condensation cannot match vaporization (). Since , the ethanol boils vigorously and undergoes continuous vaporization until complete dryout.
A volatile liquid with is kept in a rigid, sealed, evacuated container at constant temperature. Contrast the outcome in this closed container with that of an actively pumped vacuum chamber.
Answer
In the sealed container, vapor accumulates until its partial pressure reaches , at which point and a true dynamic equilibrium is established (liquid and vapor coexist). In the continuously pumped chamber, vapor molecules are evacuated, preventing saturation, so no equilibrium is reached and the liquid completely vaporizes.
Water at () is subjected to a vacuum pump. At what external pressure does boiling initiate, and why does throttling the pump to keep the pressure at exactly in an open flow system still fail to represent a static, closed-system phase equilibrium?
Answer
Boiling initiates when . Even if external pressure is held at , an open flowing system continuously expels mass; true thermodynamic equilibrium requires zero net mass transfer across boundaries and a static closed system with balanced microscopic fluxes.