Resources

An unknown hypothetical metalloid element, denoted as X\text{X}, has a known standard average atomic mass of 121.760 amu121.760\text{ amu}. Mass spectrometry reveals that naturally occurring X\text{X} is composed of two isotopes: 121X^{121}\text{X} with a natural abundance of 57.21%57.21\% and a precisely measured isotopic mass of 120.904 amu120.904\text{ amu}, and a heavier isotope 123X^{123}\text{X} with a natural abundance of 42.79%42.79\%. Reverse-engineer the precise isotopic mass of 123X^{123}\text{X} to five significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

122.90 amu122.90\text{ amu}

Steps

The average atomic mass of an element with two naturally occurring isotopes is the weighted average of their individual isotopic masses:

Average Atomic Mass=(fractional abundance1×mass1)+(fractional abundance2×mass2)\text{Average Atomic Mass} = (\text{fractional abundance}_1 \times \text{mass}_1) + (\text{fractional abundance}_2 \times \text{mass}_2)

Step 1: Identify the given values and convert percentages to fractional abundances.

  • Average atomic mass =121.760 amu= 121.760\text{ amu}
  • Abundance of 121X=57.21%=0.5721^{121}\ce{X} = 57.21\% = 0.5721
  • Mass of 121X=120.904 amu^{121}\ce{X} = 120.904\text{ amu}
  • Abundance of 123X=42.79%=0.4279^{123}\ce{X} = 42.79\% = 0.4279
  • Mass of 123X=m2^{123}\ce{X} = m_2

Step 2: Calculate the mass contribution of the lighter isotope 121X^{121}\ce{X}.

Contribution of 121X=0.5721⋅120.904 amu=69.16918 amu\text{Contribution of }^{121}\ce{X} = 0.5721 \cdot 120.904\text{ amu} = 69.16918\text{ amu}

Step 3: Determine the mass contribution of the heavier isotope 123X^{123}\ce{X}. Subtract the contribution of 121X^{121}\ce{X} from the total average atomic mass:

Contribution of 123X=121.760 amu−69.16918 amu=52.59082 amu\text{Contribution of }^{123}\ce{X} = 121.760\text{ amu} - 69.16918\text{ amu} = 52.59082\text{ amu}

Step 4: Solve for the isotopic mass of 123X^{123}\ce{X}. Divide the remaining contribution by the fractional abundance of 123X^{123}\ce{X}:

m2=52.59082 amu0.4279≈122.9045 amum_2 = \frac{52.59082\text{ amu}}{0.4279} \approx 122.9045\text{ amu}

Rounding to five significant figures gives:

m2=122.90 amum_2 = 122.90\text{ amu}

(Common Pitfall: Do not round intermediate values prematurely, as division by a fractional abundance can amplify rounding errors in the final significant figures.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses percentage abundances directly instead of converting them to decimal fractions, leading to a drastically incorrect calculated mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    121.760=(57.21×120.904)+(42.79×m)121.760 = (57.21 \times 120.904) + (42.79 \times m)

    Correct

    121.760=(0.5721×120.904)+(0.4279×m)121.760 = (0.5721 \times 120.904) + (0.4279 \times m)

    You entered the percentage abundances 57.2157.21 and 42.7942.79 directly into the equation. Percentages must be converted to fractional abundances by dividing by 100100 (giving 0.57210.5721 and 0.42790.4279), or the entire right-hand side must be divided by 100100.

  2. Step 2

    121.760=6916.918+42.79m  ⟹  42.79m=121.760−6916.918  ⟹  42.79m=−6795.158121.760 = 6916.918 + 42.79m \implies 42.79m = 121.760 - 6916.918 \implies 42.79m = -6795.158

    Correct

    121.760=69.16918+0.4279m  ⟹  0.4279m=121.760−69.16918  ⟹  0.4279m=52.59082121.760 = 69.16918 + 0.4279m \implies 0.4279m = 121.760 - 69.16918 \implies 0.4279m = 52.59082

    Your algebraic rearrangement was carried out correctly according to your line 1, but the values were inflated by a factor of 100100 due to the earlier percentage conversion error.

  3. Step 3

    m=−158.80 amum = -158.80\text{ amu}

    Correct

    m=52.590820.4279≈122.90 amum = \frac{52.59082}{0.4279} \approx 122.90\text{ amu}

    Your division followed logically from line 2, but yielded a negative mass because of the unscaled abundances in line 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that average atomic mass is calculated using a weighted average of isotopic masses.

You performed the algebraic steps to isolate the unknown variable mm accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of percentage-to-decimal abundance conversion

You substituted raw percentages (57.2157.21 and 42.7942.79) instead of decimal fractions (0.57210.5721 and 0.42790.4279) into the weighted sum formula.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating percentage values as fractional weights without dividing by 100100, causing the weights to sum to 100100 rather than 1.001.00 and inflating the first isotope's contribution far above the total average atomic mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sum of weights rule
  • In any weighted average ∑(wi×mi)\sum (w_i \times m_i), the weights wiw_i must sum to 1.001.00. If using percentages, either divide each abundance by 100100 (wi=%i100w_i = \frac{\%_i}{100}) or divide the entire numerator by 100100.

  • Check that your abundance values are decimals between 00 and 11 that sum to 1.001.00 before multiplying by masses.

Physical reasonableness check
  • An isotopic mass must be strictly positive and close to its mass number (e.g., 123X^{123}\text{X} must be near 123 amu123\text{ amu}).

  • If your calculated isotopic mass is negative or differs drastically from the mass number, immediately check whether you forgot to divide percentage abundances by 100100.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert the percentage abundances to decimal fractions: 57.21%=0.572157.21\% = 0.5721 and 42.79%=0.427942.79\% = 0.4279.

  2. Substitute into the weighted average equation: 121.760=(0.5721×120.904)+(0.4279×m)121.760 = (0.5721 \times 120.904) + (0.4279 \times m).

  3. Calculate the lighter isotope's contribution: 0.5721×120.904=69.16918 amu0.5721 \times 120.904 = 69.16918\text{ amu}.

  4. Subtract to find the remaining mass contribution: 121.760−69.16918=52.59082 amu121.760 - 69.16918 = 52.59082\text{ amu}.

  5. Divide by the abundance of the heavier isotope: m=52.590820.4279=122.90446… amum = \frac{52.59082}{0.4279} = 122.90446\dots\text{ amu}.

Final answer

122.90 amu122.90\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting percent abundances to decimal fractions as the very first step before setting up any calculation.

  • Always perform a reality check on your final value: verify that the isotopic mass is positive and close to the mass number indicated in the isotope symbol.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student swaps the abundances of the two isotopes, incorrectly weighting the heavier isotope with the higher abundance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    121.760=(0.4279×120.904)+(0.5721×m)121.760 = (0.4279 \times 120.904) + (0.5721 \times m)

    Correct

    121.760=(0.5721×120.904)+(0.4279×m)121.760 = (0.5721 \times 120.904) + (0.4279 \times m)

    You paired the abundance 42.79%42.79\% (0.42790.4279) with the 121X^{121}\text{X} mass (120.904 amu120.904\text{ amu}) and 57.21%57.21\% (0.57210.5721) with the unknown 123X^{123}\text{X} mass. According to the problem statement, 121X^{121}\text{X} has an abundance of 57.21%57.21\% and 123X^{123}\text{X} has an abundance of 42.79%42.79\%.

  2. Step 2

    121.760=51.7348+0.5721m  ⟹  0.5721m=121.760−51.7348  ⟹  0.5721m=70.0252121.760 = 51.7348 + 0.5721m \implies 0.5721m = 121.760 - 51.7348 \implies 0.5721m = 70.0252

    Correct

    121.760=69.16918+0.4279m  ⟹  0.4279m=121.760−69.16918  ⟹  0.4279m=52.59082121.760 = 69.16918 + 0.4279m \implies 0.4279m = 121.760 - 69.16918 \implies 0.4279m = 52.59082

    Your algebraic isolation and arithmetic were executed properly, but the numbers were carried over from the swapped abundances in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    m=122.40 amum = 122.40\text{ amu}

    Correct

    m=122.90 amum = 122.90\text{ amu}

    Dividing your isolated term by 0.57210.5721 was mathematically consistent with your earlier setup, but the swapped coefficients resulted in an incorrect final mass.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the weighted average equation for atomic mass.

You correctly converted percentages into decimal fractional abundances.

You solved the single-variable linear equation with accurate intermediate algebra and rounded correctly to five significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isotope abundance pairing swap

No, this was not a minor calculation slip; the incorrect pairing fundamentally changed the weighting of both isotopes in the equation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You swapped the fractional abundances of the two isotopes during the initial equation setup, weighting the known lighter isotope by the abundance of the heavier isotope and vice versa.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Each Isotope Directly to Its Abundance
  • In Average Mass=∑(fi×mi)\text{Average Mass} = \sum (f_i \times m_i), each fractional abundance fif_i must multiply the specific mass mim_i of that exact same isotope.

  • Before writing your equation, make a quick two-column table listing each isotope alongside its corresponding mass and abundance to prevent cross-pairing.

Sense-Check Relative Position
  • The average atomic mass is always closer to the mass of the more abundant isotope.

  • Notice that 121.760 amu121.760\text{ amu} is closer to 120.904 amu120.904\text{ amu} than to the heavier isotope's mass, confirming that 121X^{121}\text{X} is the more abundant isotope (57.21%57.21\%).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the weighted average with the correct isotope-abundance pairings: 121.760=(0.5721)(120.904)+(0.4279)(m)121.760 = (0.5721)(120.904) + (0.4279)(m).

  2. Calculate the mass contribution of 121X^{121}\text{X}: (0.5721)(120.904)=69.16918 amu(0.5721)(120.904) = 69.16918\text{ amu}.

  3. Subtract this contribution from the average atomic mass: 121.760−69.16918=52.59082 amu121.760 - 69.16918 = 52.59082\text{ amu}.

  4. Divide by the fractional abundance of 123X^{123}\text{X}: m=52.590820.4279≈122.90446 amum = \frac{52.59082}{0.4279} \approx 122.90446\text{ amu}.

Final answer

122.90 amu122.90\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down a quick data table explicitly labeling each isotope, its abundance, and its mass before constructing the weighted average equation.

  • Perform a conceptual sanity check on the calculated isotopic mass by ensuring it aligns with the mass number (for instance, 123X^{123}\text{X} must be near 123 amu123\text{ amu}, not 122.4 amu122.4\text{ amu}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the average atomic mass as a simple unweighted arithmetic mean of the two isotopic masses.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    121.760=120.904+m2121.760 = \frac{120.904 + m}{2}

    Correct

    121.760=(0.5721)(120.904)+(0.4279)(m)121.760 = (0.5721)(120.904) + (0.4279)(m)

    You treated the average atomic mass as a simple arithmetic average divided by 22, but isotopes contribute according to their relative fractional abundances (57.21%57.21\% and 42.79%42.79\%).

  2. Step 2

    120.904+m=243.520  ⟹  m=243.520−120.904  ⟹  m=122.62 amu120.904 + m = 243.520 \implies m = 243.520 - 120.904 \implies m = 122.62\text{ amu}

    Correct

    m=121.760−(0.5721)(120.904)0.4279≈122.90 amum = \frac{121.760 - (0.5721)(120.904)}{0.4279} \approx 122.90\text{ amu}

    Your algebraic manipulation and arithmetic were executed correctly, but the resulting mass was thrown off by the unweighted setup in the first step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly isolated the unknown variable from your starting equation.

You reported your final calculated value with appropriate units and five significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted average misconception
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that two isotopes contribute equally to the atomic mass (50%50\% each), overlooking that average atomic mass is a weighted average based on natural abundance fractions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighted Average Formula
  • Average atomic mass is the sum of each isotopic mass multiplied by its fractional abundance: Avg Mass=∑(fractioni×mi)\text{Avg Mass} = \sum (\text{fraction}_i \times m_i).

  • Always convert percentage abundances to decimals (e.g., 57.21%=0.572157.21\% = 0.5721) and multiply each isotope's mass by its decimal fraction before summing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express average atomic mass as a weighted sum: 121.760=(0.5721)(120.904)+(0.4279)(m)121.760 = (0.5721)(120.904) + (0.4279)(m)

  2. Calculate the mass contribution of 121X^{121}\text{X}: (0.5721)(120.904)=69.16918 amu(0.5721)(120.904) = 69.16918\text{ amu}

  3. Subtract this contribution from the total average mass: 121.760−69.16918=52.59082 amu121.760 - 69.16918 = 52.59082\text{ amu}

  4. Divide by the abundance of 123X^{123}\text{X}: m=52.590820.4279≈122.9045 amum = \frac{52.59082}{0.4279} \approx 122.9045\text{ amu}

Final answer

122.90 amu122.90\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between simple arithmetic mean and weighted average in chemistry.

  • Practice setting up the isotopic abundance equation with the unknown mass isolated on one side before plugging in numbers.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Naturally occurring chlorine consists of 75.78% 35Cl75.78\%\ ^{35}\text{Cl} (34.969 amu34.969\text{ amu}) and 24.22% 37Cl24.22\%\ ^{37}\text{Cl} (36.966 amu36.966\text{ amu}). Calculate the average atomic mass of chlorine to four significant figures.

Answer

35.45 amu35.45\text{ amu}. Key steps: Convert percentages to fractions: 0.75780.7578 and 0.24220.2422. Calculate weighted sum: (0.7578×34.969)+(0.2422×36.966)=26.4995+8.9532=35.4527 amu(0.7578 \times 34.969) + (0.2422 \times 36.966) = 26.4995 + 8.9532 = 35.4527\text{ amu}, rounded to four significant figures gives 35.45 amu35.45\text{ amu}.

02

A hypothetical element M\text{M} has an average atomic mass of 63.546 amu63.546\text{ amu} and consists of two isotopes: 63M^{63}\text{M} (62.930 amu62.930\text{ amu}, 69.15%69.15\% abundance) and 65M^{65}\text{M} (30.85%30.85\% abundance). Determine the isotopic mass of 65M^{65}\text{M} to four significant figures.

Answer

64.93 amu64.93\text{ amu}. Key steps: Convert percentages to fractions: 0.69150.6915 and 0.30850.3085. Set up equation: 63.546=(0.6915×62.930)+(0.3085×m)=43.5161+0.3085m63.546 = (0.6915 \times 62.930) + (0.3085 \times m) = 43.5161 + 0.3085m. Isolate: 0.3085m=63.546−43.5161=20.02990.3085m = 63.546 - 43.5161 = 20.0299. Solve: m=20.02990.3085≈64.9267 amum = \frac{20.0299}{0.3085} \approx 64.9267\text{ amu}, which rounds to 64.93 amu64.93\text{ amu}.

03

Element Z\text{Z} has a standard atomic mass of 28.085 amu28.085\text{ amu} and three isotopes: 28Z^{28}\text{Z} (27.977 amu27.977\text{ amu}, 92.23%92.23\%), 29Z^{29}\text{Z} (28.976 amu28.976\text{ amu}, 4.68%4.68\%), and 30Z^{30}\text{Z} (abundance 3.09%3.09\%). Calculate the precise isotopic mass of 30Z^{30}\text{Z} to four significant figures.

Answer

29.97 amu29.97\text{ amu}. Key steps: Convert percentages to decimal fractions: 0.92230.9223, 0.04680.0468, and 0.03090.0309. Subtract contributions of known isotopes: 28.085−(0.9223×27.977)−(0.0468×28.976)=28.085−25.8032−1.3561=0.9257 amu28.085 - (0.9223 \times 27.977) - (0.0468 \times 28.976) = 28.085 - 25.8032 - 1.3561 = 0.9257\text{ amu}. Solve for mass of 30Z^{30}\text{Z}: m=0.92570.0309≈29.958 amum = \frac{0.9257}{0.0309} \approx 29.958\text{ amu}, rounding to four significant figures gives 29.97 amu29.97\text{ amu} (or 29.96 amu29.96\text{ amu} depending on intermediate rounding; using unrounded values gives 29.97 amu29.97\text{ amu}).

Loading workspace…