Resources

A galvanic cell consists of a silver strip immersed in 1.0 M AgNO3(aq)1.0\text{ M } \text{AgNO}_3(aq) and an iron strip immersed in 1.0 M Fe(NO3)2(aq)1.0\text{ M } \text{Fe(NO}_3)_2(aq), connected by a salt bridge and an external circuit. The standard reduction potentials are E∘(Ag+/Ag)=+0.80 VE^\circ(\text{Ag}^+/\text{Ag}) = +0.80\text{ V} and E∘(Fe2+/Fe)=−0.44 VE^\circ(\text{Fe}^{2+}/\text{Fe}) = -0.44\text{ V}. During continuous operation, oxidation and reduction cause mass changes at the electrodes. Calculate the theoretical ratio of the mass gained at the cathode to the mass lost at the anode (Δmcathode/∣Δmanode∣\Delta m_{\text{cathode}} / |\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|) based on stoichiometric electron transfer.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = 3.86 (or 3.86:13.86 : 1, since 2 mol Ag2\text{ mol } \text{Ag} deposits per 1 mol Fe1\text{ mol } \text{Fe} dissolved, yielding 2×107.87 g/mol55.85 g/mol≈3.86\frac{2 \times 107.87\text{ g/mol}}{55.85\text{ g/mol}} \approx 3.86).

Steps

01

Identify the Anode and Cathode

In a galvanic cell, reduction occurs spontaneously at the electrode with the higher (more positive) standard reduction potential, while oxidation occurs at the electrode with the lower standard reduction potential:

  • E∘(AgX+/Ag)=+0.80 VE^\circ(\ce{Ag+}/\ce{Ag}) = +0.80\text{ V}
  • E∘(FeX2+/Fe)=−0.44 VE^\circ(\ce{Fe^{2+}}/\ce{Fe}) = -0.44\text{ V}

Because +0.80 V>−0.44 V+0.80\text{ V} > -0.44\text{ V}:

  • Cathode (reduction): AgX+(aq)+eX−→Ag(s)\ce{Ag+(aq) + e- -> Ag(s)}
  • Anode (oxidation): Fe(s)→FeX2+(aq)+2 eX−\ce{Fe(s) -> Fe^{2+}(aq) + 2e-}

Electrons flow from the iron anode to the silver cathode through the external circuit. As a result, the silver cathode gains mass due to the deposition of solid silver, and the iron anode loses mass as solid iron dissolves into FeX2+\ce{Fe^{2+}} ions.


02

Establish the Stoichiometric Relationship via Electron Transfer

To maintain charge balance, the moles of electrons lost by iron must equal the moles of electrons gained by silver:

  • Oxidation: 1 mol of Fe1\text{ mol of }\ce{Fe} loses 2 mol of eX−2\text{ mol of }\ce{e-}.
  • Reduction: 1 mol of AgX+1\text{ mol of }\ce{Ag+} gains 1 mol of eX−1\text{ mol of }\ce{e-}.

Multiplying the reduction half-reaction by 22 gives the balanced cell reaction: Fe(s)+2 AgX+(aq)→FeX2+(aq)+2 Ag(s)\ce{Fe(s) + 2Ag+(aq) -> Fe^{2+}(aq) + 2Ag(s)}

This stoichiometric relationship means that for every 1 mol1\text{ mol} of Fe\ce{Fe} oxidized (dissolved), 2 mol2\text{ mol} of Ag\ce{Ag} are reduced (deposited): nAgnFe=21\frac{n_{\ce{Ag}}}{n_{\ce{Fe}}} = \frac{2}{1}


03

Calculate the Mass Ratio

Using the standard molar masses M(Ag)≈107.87 g/molM(\ce{Ag}) \approx 107.87\text{ g/mol} and M(Fe)≈55.85 g/molM(\ce{Fe}) \approx 55.85\text{ g/mol}:

  • Mass gained at the cathode per 2 mol of eX−2\text{ mol of } \ce{e-}: Δmcathode=nAg⋅M(Ag)=2 mol×107.87 g/mol=215.74 g\Delta m_{\text{cathode}} = n_{\ce{Ag}} \cdot M(\ce{Ag}) = 2\text{ mol} \times 107.87\text{ g/mol} = 215.74\text{ g}
  • Mass lost at the anode per 2 mol of eX−2\text{ mol of } \ce{e-}: ∣Δmanode∣=nFe⋅M(Fe)=1 mol×55.85 g/mol=55.85 g|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}| = n_{\ce{Fe}} \cdot M(\ce{Fe}) = 1\text{ mol} \times 55.85\text{ g/mol} = 55.85\text{ g}

Taking the ratio: Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=2×107.87 g/mol55.85 g/mol=215.7455.85≈3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{2 \times 107.87\text{ g/mol}}{55.85\text{ g/mol}} = \frac{215.74}{55.85} \approx 3.86

Common Pitfall: Forgetting to account for the difference in valence (1 e-1\text{ e-} for AgX+\ce{Ag+} vs. 2 e-2\text{ e-} for FeX2+\ce{Fe^{2+}}) leads to an incorrect 1:11:1 mole ratio, which falsely gives M(Ag)/M(Fe)≈1.93M(\ce{Ag})/M(\ce{Fe}) \approx 1.93. Always balance the electron transfer before converting to mass.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the 1:2 stoichiometric mole ratio between Fe and Ag dictated by electron transfer and computes the simple ratio of their molar masses.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Cathode: \text{Cathode: } AgX++eX−→Ag\ce{Ag+ + e- -> Ag} \ Anode: \text{Anode: } Fe→FeX2++2 eX−\ce{Fe -> Fe^{2+} + 2e-}

  2. Step 2

    M(Ag\ce{Ag}) = 107.87 g/mol\text{ g/mol} \ M(Fe\ce{Fe}) = 55.85 g/mol\text{ g/mol}

  3. Step 3

    Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=107.8755.85≈1.93\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{107.87}{55.85} \approx 1.93

    Correct

    Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = 2×107.87 g/mol1×55.85 g/mol\frac{2 \times 107.87\text{ g/mol}}{1 \times 55.85\text{ g/mol}} ≈\approx 3.86

    You took the simple ratio of molar masses, which assumes 1 mol of Ag1\text{ mol of } \ce{Ag} deposits for every 1 mol of Fe1\text{ mol of } \ce{Fe} dissolved. Because oxidation of Fe\ce{Fe} yields 2 e-2\text{ e-}, each mole of dissolved iron reduces 2 mol of AgX+2\text{ mol of } \ce{Ag+}. Multiplying by this 2:12:1 mole ratio gives ≈3.86\approx 3.86.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified which electrode serves as the cathode and which serves as the anode.

You wrote balanced half-reactions for both electrode processes.

You correctly retrieved the molar masses of silver and iron.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ignoring electron stoichiometry in mass calculations

You directly divided the molar mass of silver by that of iron without accounting for the number of electrons transferred per metal atom.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the molar mass ratio with the electrode mass change ratio by forgetting to balance the transferred electrons (neX−n_{\ce{e-}}) between the two half-cells.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conserve Transferred Electrons
  • Electrons lost in oxidation must equal electrons gained in reduction: neX−=z1⋅n1=z2⋅n2n_{\ce{e-}} = z_1 \cdot n_1 = z_2 \cdot n_2.

  • Always find the least common multiple of electrons transferred to determine the mole ratio ncathode:nanoden_{\text{cathode}} : n_{\text{anode}} before converting to grams.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Balance the electrons between the two half-reactions: 1 mol of Fe1\text{ mol of }\ce{Fe} produces 2 mol of eX−2\text{ mol of }\ce{e-}, which deposits 2 mol of Ag2\text{ mol of }\ce{Ag}.

  2. Calculate the mass deposited at the cathode: Δmcathode=2 mol×107.87 g/mol=215.74 g\Delta m_{\text{cathode}} = 2\text{ mol} \times 107.87\text{ g/mol} = 215.74\text{ g}.

  3. Calculate the mass lost at the anode: ∣Δmanode∣=1 mol×55.85 g/mol=55.85 g|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}| = 1\text{ mol} \times 55.85\text{ g/mol} = 55.85\text{ g}.

  4. Compute the ratio: 215.74 g55.85 g≈3.86\frac{215.74\text{ g}}{55.85\text{ g}} \approx 3.86.

Final answer

Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣≈3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} \approx 3.86

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Multiply each half-reaction so both sides involve the exact same number of electrons before calculating mass ratios.

  • Practice setting up the formula Δm=M⋅I⋅tz⋅F\Delta m = \frac{M \cdot I \cdot t}{z \cdot F} or Δm1Δm2=M1/z1M2/z2\frac{\Delta m_1}{\Delta m_2} = \frac{M_1 / z_1}{M_2 / z_2} directly.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the stoichiometric mole ratio by multiplying the anode mass by 2 instead of the cathode mass, obtaining a ratio four times smaller than correct.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Cathode: AgX++eX−→Ag\ce{Ag+ + e- -> Ag}   ⟹  \implies Anode: Fe→FeX2++2 eX−\ce{Fe -> Fe^{2+} + 2e-}

  2. Step 2

    2 mol eX− transfers 1 mol Ag per 2 mol Fe2\text{ mol } \ce{e-} \text{ transfers } 1\text{ mol Ag per } 2\text{ mol Fe}

    Correct

    2 mol eX− transfers 2 mol Ag per 1 mol Fe2\text{ mol } \ce{e-} \text{ transfers } 2\text{ mol Ag per } 1\text{ mol Fe}

    Because each Fe\ce{Fe} atom loses 2 e-2\text{ e-} and each AgX+\ce{Ag+} ion gains 1 e-1\text{ e-}, transferring 2 mol of electrons2\text{ mol of electrons} reduces 2 mol of Ag2\text{ mol of } \ce{Ag} while dissolving only 1 mol of Fe1\text{ mol of } \ce{Fe}. You swapped these two stoichiometric amounts.

  3. Step 3

    Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=107.872×55.85=107.87111.7≈0.97\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{107.87}{2 \times 55.85} = \frac{107.87}{111.7} \approx 0.97

    Correct

    Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=2×107.87 g/mol1×55.85 g/mol≈3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{2 \times 107.87\text{ g/mol}}{1 \times 55.85\text{ g/mol}} \approx 3.86

    This step correctly evaluated the ratio using your stoichiometry, but the numerical result is four times too small because the factor of 22 was placed on iron in the denominator rather than silver in the numerator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the reduction and oxidation half-reactions at each electrode.

You used the correct standard molar masses for silver and iron.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted stoichiometric mole ratio in redox transfer

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the multiplier 22 from the electron charge with the species releasing two electrons (iron) rather than cross-multiplying to balance the species accepting only one electron (silver).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Balance the Overall Reaction First
  • Total electrons lost in oxidation must equal total electrons gained in reduction: ne=nAg×1=nFe×2n_e = n_{\ce{Ag}} \times 1 = n_{\ce{Fe}} \times 2.

  • Always write the balanced overall equation Fe(s)+2 AgX+(aq)→FeX2+(aq)+2 Ag(s)\ce{Fe(s) + 2Ag+(aq) -> Fe^{2+}(aq) + 2Ag(s)} before substituting quantities into a mass ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the electron equality: ne=1⋅nAg=2⋅nFen_e = 1 \cdot n_{\ce{Ag}} = 2 \cdot n_{\ce{Fe}}, which gives nAg=2nFen_{\ce{Ag}} = 2 n_{\ce{Fe}}.

  2. Express the mass ratio using moles and molar masses: Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=nAg⋅M(Ag)nFe⋅M(Fe)=2⋅107.87 g/mol1⋅55.85 g/mol\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{n_{\ce{Ag}} \cdot M(\ce{Ag})}{n_{\ce{Fe}} \cdot M(\ce{Fe})} = \frac{2 \cdot 107.87\text{ g/mol}}{1 \cdot 55.85\text{ g/mol}}.

  3. Compute the numerical value: 215.7455.85≈3.86\frac{215.74}{55.85} \approx 3.86.

Final answer

Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = 3.86

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice combining half-reactions into balanced net ionic redox equations before calculating mass or charge changes.

  • Verify your mole relationships with the rule: a species requiring fewer electrons per ion yields more moles of metal deposited per mole of electrons.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student reverses the identity of cathode and anode based on standard reduction potential values, calculating the ratio as |Δm_lost| / Δm_gained inverted.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Oxidation at Ag: Ag→AgX++eX−\ce{Ag -> Ag+ + e-}   ⟹  \implies Reduction at Fe: FeX2++2 eX−→Fe\ce{Fe^{2+} + 2e- -> Fe}   ⟹  \implies Cathode is Fe and Anode is Ag.

    Correct

    Cathode (reduction): AgX++eX−→Ag\ce{Ag+ + e- -> Ag}; Anode (oxidation): Fe→FeX2++2 eX−\ce{Fe -> Fe^{2+} + 2e-}

    In a spontaneous galvanic cell, the half-cell with the more positive (higher) reduction potential undergoes reduction at the cathode. Because E∘(AgX+/Ag)=+0.80 V>E∘(FeX2+/Fe)=−0.44 VE^\circ(\ce{Ag+}/\ce{Ag}) = +0.80\text{ V} > E^\circ(\ce{Fe^{2+}}/\ce{Fe}) = -0.44\text{ V}, silver ions are reduced at the silver cathode, while solid iron is oxidized at the iron anode.

  2. Step 2

    Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=55.852×107.87=55.85215.74≈0.26\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{55.85}{2 \times 107.87} = \frac{55.85}{215.74} \approx 0.26

    Correct

    Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=2×107.87 g/mol55.85 g/mol≈3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{2 \times 107.87\text{ g/mol}}{55.85\text{ g/mol}} \approx 3.86

    Your stoichiometry and molar-mass arithmetic were completely sound, but because you inverted the cathode and anode, you calculated ∣ΔmFe∣ΔmAg\frac{|\Delta m_{\ce{Fe}}|}{\Delta m_{\ce{Ag}}} instead of ΔmAg∣ΔmFe∣\frac{\Delta m_{\ce{Ag}}}{|\Delta m_{\ce{Fe}}|}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly balanced the transfer of electrons by accounting for the 2 e−2\text{ e}^- transferred per Fe\ce{Fe} atom compared to 1 e−1\text{ e}^- per Ag\ce{Ag} atom.

You properly used the molar masses of iron (55.85 g/mol55.85\text{ g/mol}) and silver (107.87 g/mol107.87\text{ g/mol}) to connect stoichiometric moles to mass changes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed cathode and anode assignment based on reduction potentials

You assigned oxidation to the electrode with the more positive standard reduction potential instead of reduction.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You may be confusing standard reduction potentials with oxidation tendencies. A higher (more positive) E∘E^\circ indicates a greater driving force to gain electrons (reduction), meaning that half-cell must serve as the cathode in a spontaneous galvanic cell.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Compare Reduction Potentials
  • In a galvanic cell (Ecell∘>0E^\circ_{\text{cell}} > 0), the electrode with the more positive E∘E^\circ is reduced (Cathode), and the one with the more negative E∘E^\circ is oxidized (Anode).

  • Write down both standard reduction potentials side by side: +0.80 V>−0.44 V+0.80\text{ V} > -0.44\text{ V}, so label Ag\ce{Ag} as the cathode and Fe\ce{Fe} as the anode before writing the reactions.

Pair Half-Reactions with Electrodes
  • An Ox and Red Cat: Anode is Oxidation, Reduction is Cathode.

  • Reverse the less positive half-reaction to show oxidation at the anode (Fe→FeX2++2 eX−\ce{Fe -> Fe^{2+} + 2e-}), while keeping the more positive half-reaction as reduction at the cathode (AgX++eX−→Ag\ce{Ag+ + e- -> Ag}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the reduction potentials: E∘(AgX+/Ag)=+0.80 VE^\circ(\ce{Ag+}/\ce{Ag}) = +0.80\text{ V} is greater than E∘(FeX2+/Fe)=−0.44 VE^\circ(\ce{Fe^{2+}}/\ce{Fe}) = -0.44\text{ V}. Therefore, silver is reduced at the cathode, and iron is oxidized at the anode.

  2. Write the balanced cell reaction to find the stoichiometric mole ratio: Fe(s)+2 AgX+(aq)→FeX2+(aq)+2 Ag(s)\ce{Fe(s) + 2Ag+(aq) -> Fe^{2+}(aq) + 2Ag(s)}, showing that 2 mol of Ag2\text{ mol of }\ce{Ag} deposit at the cathode for every 1 mol of Fe1\text{ mol of }\ce{Fe} dissolved at the anode.

  3. Calculate the mass ratio: Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣=nAg×M(Ag)nFe×M(Fe)=2×107.87 g/mol1×55.85 g/mol=215.7455.85≈3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} = \frac{n_{\ce{Ag}} \times M(\ce{Ag})}{n_{\ce{Fe}} \times M(\ce{Fe})} = \frac{2 \times 107.87\text{ g/mol}}{1 \times 55.85\text{ g/mol}} = \frac{215.74}{55.85} \approx 3.86.

Final answer

Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣≈3.86\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|} \approx 3.86

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying the cathode and anode directly from standard reduction potential tables before writing out any calculations.

  • Use the mnemonic 'Red Cat' (Reduction at Cathode) and remember that larger positive E∘E^\circ values always favor reduction.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A galvanic cell pairs a zinc anode (Zn→ZnX2++2 eX−\ce{Zn -> Zn^{2+} + 2e-}, M=65.38 g/molM = 65.38\text{ g/mol}) with a silver cathode (AgX++eX−→Ag\ce{Ag+ + e- -> Ag}, M=107.87 g/molM = 107.87\text{ g/mol}). Calculate the theoretical ratio Δmcathode∣Δmanode∣\frac{\Delta m_{\text{cathode}}}{|\Delta m_{\text{anode}}|}.

Answer

3.303.30. Key steps: Each mole of Zn\ce{Zn} oxidized releases 2 mol of eX−2\text{ mol of } \ce{e-}, depositing 2 mol of Ag2\text{ mol of } \ce{Ag}. The mass ratio is 2×107.871×65.38=215.7465.38≈3.30\frac{2 \times 107.87}{1 \times 65.38} = \frac{215.74}{65.38} \approx 3.30.

02

In a cell operating with an aluminum anode (Al→AlX3++3 eX−\ce{Al -> Al^{3+} + 3e-}, M=26.98 g/molM = 26.98\text{ g/mol}) and a copper cathode (CuX2++2 eX−→Cu\ce{Cu^{2+} + 2e- -> Cu}, M=63.55 g/molM = 63.55\text{ g/mol}), calculate the mass of copper deposited when the aluminum anode loses 0.540 g0.540\text{ g}.

Answer

1.91 g1.91\text{ g}. Key steps: nAl=0.540 g26.98 g/mol≈0.0200 moln_{\ce{Al}} = \frac{0.540\text{ g}}{26.98\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.0200\text{ mol}. Total electrons transferred: neX−=3×0.0200=0.0600 moln_{\ce{e-}} = 3 \times 0.0200 = 0.0600\text{ mol}. Moles of copper reduced: nCu=0.06002=0.0300 moln_{\ce{Cu}} = \frac{0.0600}{2} = 0.0300\text{ mol}. Deposited mass: mCu=0.0300 mol×63.55 g/mol≈1.91 gm_{\ce{Cu}} = 0.0300\text{ mol} \times 63.55\text{ g/mol} \approx 1.91\text{ g}.

03

A voltaic cell consists of a chromium anode (Cr→CrX3++3 eX−\ce{Cr -> Cr^{3+} + 3e-}) and a metal M\ce{M} cathode (MX2++2 eX−→M\ce{M^{2+} + 2e- -> M}). During operation, the cathode gains 4.16 g4.16\text{ g} while the anode loses 1.04 g1.04\text{ g}. Given M(Cr)=52.00 g/molM(\ce{Cr}) = 52.00\text{ g/mol}, determine the identity of metal M\ce{M}.

Answer

Lead (Pb\ce{Pb}, M≈207.2 g/molM \approx 207.2\text{ g/mol} or acceptable experimental identification). Key steps: nCr=1.0452.00=0.0200 moln_{\ce{Cr}} = \frac{1.04}{52.00} = 0.0200\text{ mol}, yielding neX−=3×0.0200=0.0600 moln_{\ce{e-}} = 3 \times 0.0200 = 0.0600\text{ mol}. Then nM=0.06002=0.0300 moln_{\ce{M}} = \frac{0.0600}{2} = 0.0300\text{ mol}. Molar mass M(M)=4.16 g0.0300 mol≈138.7 g/molM(\ce{M}) = \frac{4.16\text{ g}}{0.0300\text{ mol}} \approx 138.7\text{ g/mol} (or if interpreted as another divalent cation; for M≈139 g/molM \approx 139\text{ g/mol}, lanthanum/barium depending on standard states; if purely calculated: M=138.7 g/molM = 138.7\text{ g/mol}).

Loading workspace…