Resources
In an analytical chemistry laboratory, a student titrates a aliquot of hydrochloric acid () with sodium hydroxide (). After the equivalence point is reached, the solution contains dissociated hydrated and ions. Using periodic trends and effective nuclear charge, (a) determine which species in the solution has a smaller ionic radius: () or (), and (b) contrast the Pauling electronegativity of the neutral parent atoms (, ) to explain why their bond in crystalline undergoes complete dissociation in aqueous media.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) has a smaller ionic radius () than () because has electrons only through while has electrons filled through ; (b) The large electronegativity difference () produces a predominantly ionic lattice, allowing polar water dipoles to overcome the lattice energy via high hydration enthalpy and cause complete electrolytic dissociation.
Steps
Part (a): Comparing the Ionic Radii of and
-
Determine Electron Configurations:
- Sodium (, ): The sodium cation has electrons occupying energy levels up to , with protons in the nucleus.
- Chlorine (, ): The chloride anion has electrons occupying energy levels up to , with protons in the nucleus.
-
Evaluate Principal Energy Level () and Effective Nuclear Charge ():
- Number of Shells: The outermost valence electrons in occupy the third principal shell (), which is farther from the nucleus than the outermost electrons of , which occupy only the second principal shell (). The addition of an entire shell introduces greater electron shielding and a larger average radial distance.
- Proton-to-Electron Ratio: In , protons attract only electrons (), yielding a high effective nuclear charge that draws the electron cloud inward tightly. In , protons attract electrons (), where inter-electronic repulsions slightly expand the cloud.
- Therefore, has a significantly smaller ionic radius () than ().
Pitfall to Avoid: Do not assume that a higher atomic number () always implies a smaller radius due to stronger nuclear pull. While effective nuclear charge reduces radius across a single period, the principal quantum number (the number of occupied shells) is the dominant factor across different periods.
Part (b): Electronegativity Difference and Dissociation in Aqueous Media
- Calculate the Electronegativity Difference (): On the Pauling scale, a difference indicates that the bond possesses predominantly ionic character ( ionic). Rather than sharing electron density covalently, sodium transfers its valence electron almost completely to chlorine, forming an alternating three-dimensional lattice of distinct cations () and anions ( held by non-directional electrostatic forces).
-
Mechanism of Aqueous Dissociation:
- Liquid water is a highly polar solvent featuring strong permanent dipoles ( on oxygen and on hydrogen).
- When crystalline is introduced into water, the negative dipoles of water molecules orient toward ions, while the positive dipoles orient toward ions, forming strong ion-dipole interactions.
- The combined enthalpy of hydration () released by these ion-dipole attractions provides sufficient energy to overcome the solid's lattice energy (): Because the lattice consists of discrete ions rather than shared covalent bonds, this hydration process leads to complete electrolytic dissociation into freely moving hydrated ions.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses nuclear charge with ionic radius, incorrectly assuming that higher atomic number Z always creates a smaller ion regardless of the principal quantum shell.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
has and has . has protons compared to protons in , so it has a much higher nuclear charge. The stronger nuclear pull draws the electrons closer, so has a smaller ionic radius than .
Correcthas electron configuration (valence electrons in ), whereas has configuration (valence electrons in ). Because principal quantum shell is the dominant factor across different periods, has fewer shells and is much smaller () than ().
You compared only nuclear charge () without looking at the electron configurations. While higher contracts electron clouds within the same shell, adding an entire principal energy shell ( for vs. for ) places valence electrons at a much greater average distance from the nucleus.
- Step 2
Electronegativity difference is . A large difference () means the bond in is predominantly ionic.
- Step 3
In water, strong ion-dipole attractions between water molecules and ions overcome the lattice energy, causing complete dissociation into hydrated ions.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the Pauling electronegativity difference accurately and identified the predominantly ionic character of .
You connected the solvent polarity of water to ion-dipole interactions overcoming crystal lattice energy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that a higher atomic number () always pulls electrons closer to yield a smaller radius, overlooking that the principal quantum number () and shielding of outer shells override nuclear charge differences across different periods.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hierarchy of Ionic Size Determination
When comparing ionic radii, the number of occupied principal energy levels () is always the primary factor. Nuclear charge () or proton-to-electron ratio is only used as the decisive factor when ions have the same number of shells (isoelectronic species).
Always write out the complete electron configuration of each ion first to check the highest occupied principal shell () before comparing proton count ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the electron configurations: (outer shell ); (outer shell ).
Compare the principal quantum shells: electrons in the shell reside at a much greater average distance from the nucleus than electrons in due to screening by inner core electrons.
Conclude that has a significantly smaller ionic radius () than ().
(a) has a smaller ionic radius than ; (b) gives predominantly ionic bonding, allowing polar water molecules to overcome lattice energy through hydration enthalpy and dissociate the ions.
02 The student misinterprets the large electronegativity difference as forming an exceptionally strong covalent bond that hydrolyzes rather than an ionic lattice that dissolves via hydration.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
has electron configuration (). has electron configuration (). Because has only occupied shells compared to shells in , has a smaller ionic radius.
- Step 2
Electronegativity difference is . This large difference creates an extremely polar covalent bond where chlorine shares electrons unequally.
Correct, which indicates that the bond is predominantly ionic rather than polar covalent, forming an electrostatic lattice of discrete and ions.
An electronegativity difference greater than approximately signifies an electron transfer that yields an ionic bond, not an extremely polar covalent bond.
- Step 3
Water reacts chemically with this covalent molecule to break the covalent bond into ions rather than separating an existing ionic lattice.
CorrectBecause crystalline exists as a rigid lattice of cations and anions, polar water molecules hydrate the individual ions via strong ion-dipole interactions, releasing sufficient hydration enthalpy to overcome the lattice energy.
Because you assumed was a covalent molecule, you described a chemical bond-breaking reaction rather than physical dissolution where polar water dipoles hydrate and separate pre-existing ions in a crystal lattice.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly derived the electron configurations for both ions.
You used principal energy levels () accurately to deduce that has a smaller ionic radius than .
You accurately calculated the Pauling electronegativity difference as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted a very large electronegativity difference as creating an unequal sharing of electrons (covalent bonding) rather than a complete valence electron transfer that produces an ionic lattice.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Pauling Electronegativity Difference Threshold
A bond between atoms with has predominantly ionic character ( ionic), whereas is nonpolar covalent and is polar covalent.
Whenever , treat the solid as an ionic lattice of distinct cations and anions rather than discrete covalent molecules.
- Aqueous Dissolution of Ionic Solids
Dissolving an ionic solid does not break covalent bonds; polar water molecules form stabilizing ion-dipole attractions that compensate for the lattice energy.
Describe dissolution in water as the separation and hydration of pre-existing ions by water's permanent dipoles.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that corresponds to predominantly ionic bonding where transfers its valence electron to .
Recognize that crystalline forms a three-dimensional ionic crystal lattice rather than individual covalent molecules.
Explain that water's polar dipoles orient around each ion (negative oxygen toward , positive hydrogen toward ) via ion-dipole interactions, providing hydration enthalpy that overcomes the lattice energy to allow complete dissociation.
(a) is smaller than because has valence electrons in while has valence electrons in ; (b) The large electronegativity difference () establishes an ionic lattice of and ions that dissociates in water due to favorable ion-dipole hydration.
Lock it in
When comparing the sizes of two ions from different periods, what is the primary factor that determines radius?
The principal quantum number () of the valence shell. More occupied electron shells mean a larger radius, regardless of nuclear charge.
Similar question
Determine which species has a smaller ionic radius: () or (). Justify using electron configurations.
Answer
is smaller. has configuration (valence shell , radius ), whereas has configuration (valence shell , radius ). The smaller principal quantum number of gives it a smaller radius despite its lower atomic number.
Compare the ionic radii of the isoelectronic pair () and (). Explain which factor is decisive here and which ion is smaller.
Answer
is smaller. Both ions are isoelectronic with electrons (, ). Because the shell number is identical, nuclear charge () becomes decisive: has protons pulling on electrons, creating a higher and drawing the cloud closer than the protons in .
Rank the following four species in order of increasing radius: , , , and . State the two-step evaluation process used.
Answer
Order: . Step 1 (Shell count): and occupy (), making them smaller than and which occupy (). Step 2 (Nuclear charge within isoelectronic groups): For , () is smaller than (). For , () is smaller than ().