Resources

An unknown neutral interhalogen molecule of formula XY3\text{XY}_3 consists of a central halogen atom X\text{X} bonded to three identical halogen atoms Y\text{Y}. Experimental dielectric constant and microwave spectroscopy measurements confirm that XY3\text{XY}_3 possesses a permanent net dipole moment of μ=0.60 D\mu = 0.60\text{ D}. Working backwards from this observed permanent polarity: (a) identify the number of nonbonding electron pairs residing on the central atom X\text{X}; (b) deduce the VSEPR molecular geometry of XY3\text{XY}_3 and explain why a planar trigonal arrangement is mathematically ruled out; and (c) identify the specific compound if Y\text{Y} is fluorine (atomic mass ≈19.00 g/mol\approx 19.00\text{ g/mol}) and the total molecular molar mass is approximately 92.45 g/mol92.45\text{ g/mol}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The central atom X\text{X} possesses exactly 22 nonbonding lone pairs (steric number =3 bonds+2 lone pairs=5= 3\text{ bonds} + 2\text{ lone pairs} = 5). (b) The molecular geometry is T-shaped (distorted C2vC_{2v}). A symmetric trigonal planar geometry (D3hD_{3h}) is ruled out because three identical coplanar bond dipole vectors separated by 120∘120^\circ would strictly cancel, yielding μ=0 D\mu = 0\text{ D}, which contradicts the experimental finding of μ=0.60 D\mu = 0.60\text{ D}. (c) With three fluorines contributing 3×18.998 g/mol=56.99 g/mol3 \times 18.998\text{ g/mol} = 56.99\text{ g/mol}, the central atom has molar mass 92.45−56.99=35.46 g/mol92.45 - 56.99 = 35.46\text{ g/mol}, identifying X\text{X} as chlorine (Cl\text{Cl}). The molecule is chlorine trifluoride (ClF3\text{ClF}_3).

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Number of Nonbonding Electron Pairs on Central Atom X\ce{X}

  1. Valence electron count of interhalogen compounds: In an interhalogen molecule XYX3\ce{XY3}, both X\ce{X} and Y\ce{Y} are Group 17 (halogen) elements. Each isolated neutral halogen atom contributes 77 valence electrons: Total valence electrons=7+3(7)=28 electrons\text{Total valence electrons} = 7 + 3(7) = 28\text{ electrons}
  2. Electron distribution in the Lewis structure:

    • The central atom X\ce{X} forms 33 single covalent bonds with the three terminal Y\ce{Y} atoms, using 3×2=63 \times 2 = 6 bonding electrons.
    • Each of the three terminal Y\ce{Y} atoms completes an octet with 33 lone pairs (3×6=183 \times 6 = 18 electrons).
    • The remaining valence electrons reside on the central atom X\ce{X}: Nonbonding electrons on X=28−(6+18)=4 electrons\text{Nonbonding electrons on X} = 28 - (6 + 18) = 4\text{ electrons}
    • Four nonbonding electrons correspond to: 42=2 nonbonding lone pairs\frac{4}{2} = 2\text{ nonbonding lone pairs}
  3. Steric number: The steric number (SN\text{SN}) of the central atom is the sum of bonded atoms and lone pairs: SN=3 bonded atoms+2 lone pairs=5\text{SN} = 3\text{ bonded atoms} + 2\text{ lone pairs} = 5

Part (b): Molecular Geometry and Vector Analysis

  1. Electron-pair and molecular geometry:

    • A steric number of 55 corresponds to a trigonal bipyramidal electron-pair geometry.
    • According to VSEPR theory, lone pairs experience less electron-electron repulsion in the less crowded equatorial positions (120∘120^\circ interactions) than in the axial positions (90∘90^\circ interactions). Therefore, both lone pairs occupy equatorial sites.
    • The remaining positions—two axial and one equatorial—are occupied by the three Y\ce{Y} atoms, giving the molecule a T-shaped geometry (distorted C2vC_{2v} symmetry due to lone pair-bonding pair repulsion pushing the axial bonds slightly toward the equatorial bond).
  2. Mathematical elimination of trigonal planar geometry:

    • In an ideal trigonal planar geometry (D3hD_{3h} symmetry), three identical X−Y\ce{X-Y} bonds lie in the same plane separated by equal angles of 120∘120^\circ.
    • Defining the three bond dipole vectors μ⃗1,μ⃗2,μ⃗3\vec{\mu}_1, \vec{\mu}_2, \vec{\mu}_3 of equal magnitude μX−Y\mu_{\ce{X-Y}}: μ⃗1=μX−Y(10),μ⃗2=μX−Y(cos⁡120∘sin⁡120∘)=μX−Y(−1/23/2),μ⃗3=μX−Y(cos⁡240∘sin⁡240∘)=μX−Y(−1/2−3/2)\vec{\mu}_1 = \mu_{\ce{X-Y}}\begin{pmatrix} 1 \\ 0 \end{pmatrix}, \quad \vec{\mu}_2 = \mu_{\ce{X-Y}}\begin{pmatrix} \cos 120^\circ \\ \sin 120^\circ \end{pmatrix} = \mu_{\ce{X-Y}}\begin{pmatrix} -1/2 \\ \sqrt{3}/2 \end{pmatrix}, \quad \vec{\mu}_3 = \mu_{\ce{X-Y}}\begin{pmatrix} \cos 240^\circ \\ \sin 240^\circ \end{pmatrix} = \mu_{\ce{X-Y}}\begin{pmatrix} -1/2 \\ -\sqrt{3}/2 \end{pmatrix}
    • Summing these vectors yields: μ⃗net=μ⃗1+μ⃗2+μ⃗3=μX−Y(1−1/2−1/20+3/2−3/2)=(00)\vec{\mu}_{\text{net}} = \vec{\mu}_1 + \vec{\mu}_2 + \vec{\mu}_3 = \mu_{\ce{X-Y}}\begin{pmatrix} 1 - 1/2 - 1/2 \\ 0 + \sqrt{3}/2 - \sqrt{3}/2 \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} 0 \\ 0 \end{pmatrix}
    • Because the vector sum strictly equals zero (μ=0 D\mu = 0\text{ D}), a symmetric trigonal planar molecule cannot have a permanent dipole moment. This directly contradicts the experimentally measured value of μ=0.60 D\mu = 0.60\text{ D}.
    • In contrast, the asymmetric T-shaped geometry creates an imbalance where the bond dipoles and the equatorial lone pairs do not cancel, producing the observed nonzero dipole moment (μ=0.60 D\mu = 0.60\text{ D}).

Part (c): Identification of the Interhalogen Compound

  1. Molar mass of the terminal halogen (Y\ce{Y}): Given that Y\ce{Y} is fluorine (F\ce{F}), with an atomic mass of approximately 19.00 g/mol19.00\text{ g/mol} (specifically 18.998 g/mol18.998\text{ g/mol}): Mass from 3F=3×18.998 g/mol=56.99 g/mol\text{Mass from } 3\ce{F} = 3 \times 18.998\text{ g/mol} = 56.99\text{ g/mol}
  2. Molar mass of the central atom (X\ce{X}): Subtract the mass of the three fluorine atoms from the total molecular molar mass: Molar mass of X=92.45 g/mol−56.99 g/mol=35.46 g/mol\text{Molar mass of X} = 92.45\text{ g/mol} - 56.99\text{ g/mol} = 35.46\text{ g/mol}
  3. Identification: An atomic mass of 35.46 g/mol35.46\text{ g/mol} corresponds directly to chlorine (Cl\ce{Cl}, standard atomic weight ≈35.45 g/mol\approx 35.45\text{ g/mol}). Therefore, the unknown compound is chlorine trifluoride (ClFX3\ce{ClF3}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the electron-pair geometry with the molecular geometry, misclassifying the shape as trigonal bipyramidal rather than T-shaped.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Valence electrons=7+3(7)=28  ⟹  Bonds=3, nonbonding pairs on X=(7−3)/2=2\text{Valence electrons} = 7 + 3(7) = 28 \implies \text{Bonds} = 3, \text{ nonbonding pairs on X} = (7-3)/2 = 2

  2. Step 2

    Steric number=3 bonding pairs+2 lone pairs=5  ⟹  Molecular geometry is trigonal bipyramidal\text{Steric number} = 3\text{ bonding pairs} + 2\text{ lone pairs} = 5 \implies \text{Molecular geometry is trigonal bipyramidal}

    Correct

    Steric number=5\text{Steric number} = 5 with 33 bonding pairs and 22 lone pairs   ⟹  \implies Electron-pair geometry is trigonal bipyramidal, but molecular geometry is T-shaped.

    You determined the correct steric number of 55, but you named the electron-pair geometry rather than the molecular geometry. Molecular geometry describes only the spatial arrangement of the bonded atoms, which forms a T-shaped geometry because the two lone pairs reside in equatorial positions.

  3. Step 3

    Trigonal planar geometry has bond angles of 120∘ and symmetric dipoles summing to zero, which contradicts μ=0.60 D\text{Trigonal planar geometry has bond angles of } 120^\circ \text{ and symmetric dipoles summing to zero, which contradicts } \mu = 0.60\text{ D}

  4. Step 4

    Mass of X=92.45−3(19.00)=35.45 g/mol  ⟹  X is Cl, so the compound is ClF3\text{Mass of X} = 92.45 - 3(19.00) = 35.45\text{ g/mol} \implies \text{X is Cl, so the compound is } \text{ClF}_3

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated that the central atom holds 22 nonbonding electron pairs.

You accurately ruled out a trigonal planar shape by showing that identical symmetric dipoles at 120∘120^\circ would cancel to zero.

You correctly calculated the molar mass of the unknown central atom and identified the formula as ClF3\text{ClF}_3.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Geometry Classification Trap: Electron-Domain vs. Molecular Geometry

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the electron-pair (electron-domain) geometry with the molecular geometry. Steric number 55 defines a trigonal bipyramidal arrangement of all electron pairs, but the molecular geometry accounts only for the positions of the atomic nuclei around the central atom, which yields a T-shaped structure for an AX3E2\text{AX}_3\text{E}_2 system.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Electron-Domain Geometry vs. Molecular Geometry
  • Electron-pair geometry accounts for all electron domains (bonds and lone pairs); molecular geometry describes only the spatial arrangement of the bonded atoms.

  • Always subtract the positions occupied by lone pairs from the overall electron-pair framework when naming the final molecular shape.

Equatorial Preference in Trigonal Bipyramidal Systems
  • In a steric number 55 system, lone pairs occupy equatorial positions to minimize 90∘90^\circ electron-electron repulsions.

  • Place the 22 lone pairs on the equatorial triangle, leaving 22 axial atoms and 11 equatorial atom, which produces a T-shaped molecule.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the steric number: SN=3 bonds+2 lone pairs=5\text{SN} = 3\text{ bonds} + 2\text{ lone pairs} = 5.

  2. Identify the electron-pair geometry as trigonal bipyramidal.

  3. Place the 22 nonbonding pairs into equatorial sites to minimize repulsions.

  4. Observe the arrangement of the 33 terminal atoms: two occupy axial positions and one occupies an equatorial position, forming a T-shape.

Final answer

The molecular geometry of XY3\text{XY}_3 is T-shaped (distorted C2vC_{2v}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between electron-pair geometry and molecular geometry for molecules with steric numbers 44, 55, and 66.

  • Practice naming the molecular geometry for AXnEm\text{AX}_n\text{E}_m designations where m≥1m \ge 1, ensuring you ignore lone pairs when naming the shape formed by the nuclei.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to account for nonbonding pairs and assumes octet rule without expansion, deducing only 1 lone pair and a trigonal pyramidal shape.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    X needs 8 electrons for an octet  ⟹  Nonbonding electron pairs on X=1\text{X needs } 8 \text{ electrons for an octet} \implies \text{Nonbonding electron pairs on X} = 1

    Correct

    Total valence electrons=7+3(7)=28  ⟹  Nonbonding electrons on X=28−(6+18)=4  ⟹  2 lone pairs\text{Total valence electrons} = 7 + 3(7) = 28 \implies \text{Nonbonding electrons on X} = 28 - (6 + 18) = 4 \implies 2\text{ lone pairs}

    You assumed that the central atom X\text{X} must strictly satisfy an octet of 88 electrons. Because both X\text{X} and Y\text{Y} are halogens (Group 17), the neutral molecule XY3\text{XY}_3 has 7+3(7)=287 + 3(7) = 28 valence electrons. Distributing 66 electrons into the three single bonds and 1818 electrons as three octet-completing lone pairs on each terminal Y\text{Y} leaves 44 electrons (22 lone pairs) on X\text{X}, meaning X\text{X} expands its octet to 1010 electrons.

  2. Step 2

    Steric number=3+1=4  ⟹  Molecular geometry is trigonal pyramidal  ⟹  A planar trigonal molecule has a net dipole moment of zero by symmetry, which contradicts μ=0.60 D\text{Steric number} = 3 + 1 = 4 \implies \text{Molecular geometry is trigonal pyramidal} \implies \text{A planar trigonal molecule has a net dipole moment of zero by symmetry, which contradicts } \mu = 0.60\text{ D}

    Correct

    Steric number=3+2=5  ⟹  Molecular geometry is T-shaped  ⟹  A planar trigonal molecule has μ=0 D by symmetry, contradicting μ=0.60 D\text{Steric number} = 3 + 2 = 5 \implies \text{Molecular geometry is T-shaped} \implies \text{A planar trigonal molecule has } \mu = 0\text{ D} \text{ by symmetry, contradicting } \mu = 0.60\text{ D}

    Your reasoning that a trigonal planar arrangement gives μ=0 D\mu = 0\text{ D} by vector symmetry is completely correct. However, because you carried over the single lone pair from part (a), your steric number was 44 instead of 55. With 33 bonding pairs and 22 equatorial lone pairs in a trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry, the true molecular geometry is T-shaped.

  3. Step 3

    Mass of X=92.45−3(19.00)=35.45 g/mol  ⟹  X is Cl, so the compound is ClF3\text{Mass of X} = 92.45 - 3(19.00) = 35.45\text{ g/mol} \implies \text{X is Cl, so the compound is } \text{ClF}_3

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the molar mass of atom X\text{X} and identified the molecule as ClF3\text{ClF}_3.

You correctly reasoned that three identical coplanar bond dipoles at 120∘120^\circ cancel to zero by vector symmetry.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Octet expansion omission in hypervalent central atom

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the central halogen as being constrained by the standard octet rule rather than calculating total available valence electrons and assigning the remaining electrons as lone pairs to an expanded valence shell on the Period 3 central atom.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Total Valence Electron Tally
  • For neutral interhalogen molecules XYn\text{XY}_n, calculate total valence electrons directly as V=7+n(7)V = 7 + n(7).

  • Always sum the valence electrons before assigning lone pairs instead of assuming the central atom stops at 8 electrons.

Assigning Leftover Electrons
  • After forming single bonds and completing terminal atom octets, place all remaining valence electrons onto the central atom.

  • Check whether the central atom belongs to Period 3 or higher, where expanded octets (10 or 12 valence electrons) are common.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Count the total valence electrons: each halogen contributes 77, giving 7+3(7)=28 e−7 + 3(7) = 28\text{ e}^-.

  2. Form 33 single bonds (using 6 e−6\text{ e}^-) and complete the terminal Y\text{Y} atom octets with 3×6=18 e−3 \times 6 = 18\text{ e}^-, consuming 24 e−24\text{ e}^- total.

  3. Place the remaining 28−24=4 e−28 - 24 = 4\text{ e}^- on the central atom X\text{X} as 22 nonbonding lone pairs.

  4. Determine steric number: SN=3 bonds+2 lone pairs=5\text{SN} = 3\text{ bonds} + 2\text{ lone pairs} = 5 (trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry).

  5. Place both lone pairs in equatorial positions to minimize 90∘90^\circ repulsions, yielding a T-shaped molecular geometry.

Final answer

(a) 22 nonbonding electron pairs; (b) T-shaped molecular geometry, with planar trigonal excluded because symmetric coplanar vectors cancel to μ=0 D\mu = 0\text{ D}; (c) ClF3\text{ClF}_3.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing Lewis structures by counting total valence electrons first rather than assuming the central atom adheres strictly to an octet.

  • Review VSEPR geometries for steric numbers 5 and 6, paying close attention to lone-pair placement in equatorial vs. axial positions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts the mass of only one fluorine atom instead of three when computing the atomic mass of X, resulting in an incorrect element identification.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Valence electrons=7+3(7)=28  ⟹  Central halogen X has 2 nonbonding electron pairs\text{Valence electrons} = 7 + 3(7) = 28 \implies \text{Central halogen X has 2 nonbonding electron pairs}

  2. Step 2

    Steric number=3+2=5  ⟹  Molecular geometry is T-shaped\text{Steric number} = 3 + 2 = 5 \implies \text{Molecular geometry is T-shaped}

  3. Step 3

    Trigonal planar geometry is nonpolar because the three equal bond dipoles at 120∘ cancel to give μ=0 D\text{Trigonal planar geometry is nonpolar because the three equal bond dipoles at } 120^\circ \text{ cancel to give } \mu = 0\text{ D}

  4. Step 4

    Mass of X=92.45−19.00=73.45 g/mol  ⟹  X is approximately Ge, so the compound is GeF3\text{Mass of X} = 92.45 - 19.00 = 73.45\text{ g/mol} \implies \text{X is approximately Ge, so the compound is GeF}_3

    Correct

    Molar mass of X=92.45−3(19.00)=35.45 g/mol  ⟹  X is Cl, compound is ClF3\text{Molar mass of X} = 92.45 - 3(19.00) = 35.45\text{ g/mol} \implies \text{X is Cl, compound is ClF}_3

    The chemical formula is XY3\text{XY}_3, which contains three Y\text{Y} atoms. You subtracted only one fluorine atom (19.00 g/mol19.00\text{ g/mol}) rather than three (3×19.00 g/mol=57.00 g/mol3 \times 19.00\text{ g/mol} = 57.00\text{ g/mol}). Furthermore, the problem specifies that X\text{X} is a halogen, which rules out germanium (Ge\text{Ge}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately counted the total valence electrons and found the correct number of central lone pairs.

You applied VSEPR theory correctly to establish the steric number of 55 and the T-shaped geometry.

You used vector symmetry to explain why an ideal trigonal planar arrangement cannot possess a permanent dipole moment.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric Subscript Omission in Molar Mass Calculation

You forgot to multiply the atomic mass of fluorine by the subscript 33 when subtracting the ligand masses from the molecular molar mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the chemical formula subscript during algebraic mass subtraction, compounded by neglecting the given constraint that central atom X\text{X} must be a halogen.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for Stoichiometric Subscripts
  • For a neutral molecule XaYb\text{X}_a\text{Y}_b, the total molar mass is M=a⋅MX+b⋅MYM = a \cdot M_{\text{X}} + b \cdot M_{\text{Y}}.

  • Multiply the atomic mass of each constituent element by its subscript in the chemical formula before subtracting from the total molar mass.

Verify Chemical Family Constraints
  • Interhalogen compounds consist exclusively of halogen atoms (Group 17: F, Cl, Br, I, At\text{F, Cl, Br, I, At}).

  • Check whether your calculated atomic mass matches a known halogen when the problem specifies an interhalogen species.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the molar mass expression for XY3\text{XY}_3: M(XY3)=MX+3⋅MYM(\text{XY}_3) = M_{\text{X}} + 3 \cdot M_{\text{Y}}.

  2. Substitute the given values for fluorine and the total mass: MX=92.45 g/mol−3(18.998 g/mol)=92.45 g/mol−56.99 g/mol=35.46 g/molM_{\text{X}} = 92.45\text{ g/mol} - 3(18.998\text{ g/mol}) = 92.45\text{ g/mol} - 56.99\text{ g/mol} = 35.46\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Identify the halogen with standard atomic weight near 35.46 g/mol35.46\text{ g/mol} as chlorine (Cl\text{Cl}).

Final answer

The central atom has molar mass 35.46 g/mol35.46\text{ g/mol}, identifying X\text{X} as chlorine (Cl\text{Cl}), so the specific compound is chlorine trifluoride (ClF3\text{ClF}_3).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that all chemical formula subscripts are included when calculating constituent masses from a total molar mass.

  • Cross-reference the deduced element against group/family constraints stated in the problem (e.g., interhalogen means Group 17).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A neutral molecule has the formula SF4\text{SF}_4. Determine the steric number, identify the electron-domain geometry, and state the molecular geometry.

Answer

Steric number is 55 (44 single bonds +1+ 1 lone pair). The electron-domain geometry is trigonal bipyramidal. Because the lone pair occupies an equatorial position, the molecular geometry is seesaw.

02

The triiodide ion, I3−\text{I}_3^-, has a central iodine atom bonded to two terminal iodine atoms. (a) Determine the number of lone pairs on the central iodine. (b) State the electron-domain geometry and the molecular geometry.

Answer

(a) Total valence electrons = 7×3+1=227 \times 3 + 1 = 22. Two bonds use 44 electrons, terminal iodines use 1212, leaving 66 electrons (33 lone pairs) on the central iodine. (b) Steric number is 2+3=52 + 3 = 5, so the electron-domain geometry is trigonal bipyramidal. With all three equatorial positions filled by lone pairs, the molecular geometry is linear.

03

Consider xenon difluoride (XeF2\text{XeF}_2) and sulfur dioxide (SO2\text{SO}_2). Predict which molecule possesses a permanent net dipole moment (mu>0\\mu > 0), and explain your choice using VSEPR molecular geometry and vector symmetry.

Answer

Only SO2\text{SO}_2 has a permanent dipole moment. SO2\text{SO}_2 has 22 bonds and 11 lone pair on sulfur (steric number 33), giving a bent molecular geometry with C2vC_{2v} symmetry where the bond dipoles do not cancel. In contrast, XeF2\text{XeF}_2 has steric number 55 (22 bonds and 33 equatorial lone pairs), giving a linear molecular geometry (D∞hD_{\infty h}) where the two equal axial Xe-F\text{Xe-F} bond dipoles point in opposite directions (180∘180^\circ) and cancel completely to zero.

Loading workspace…