Resources

A chemical reaction takes place inside a rigid, closed cylinder fitted with a fixed piston. During the reaction, the mixture releases 145 kJ145\text{ kJ} of thermal energy to the surrounding water bath, while the volume of the cylinder remains strictly constant at 2.50 L2.50\text{ L}. (a) Define the system and the surroundings. (b) Determine the values of heat (qq), work (ww), and the change in internal energy (ΔU\Delta U) for the system, including appropriate algebraic signs.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) System: the reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder; Surroundings: the rigid cylinder walls, the piston, and the external water bath. (b) q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}, w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}, and ΔU=−145 kJ\Delta U = -145\text{ kJ}.

Steps

Part (a): Identifying the System and the Surroundings

  1. The System: In thermodynamics, the system is the specific part of the universe chosen for study. Here, the process of interest is the chemical transformation occurring inside the cylinder: System=the reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder\text{System} = \text{the reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder}
  2. The Surroundings: The surroundings comprise everything in the universe outside the system that can interact with it by exchanging energy or matter. In this setup, this includes: Surroundings=the cylinder walls, the fixed piston, and the external water bath\text{Surroundings} = \text{the cylinder walls, the fixed piston, and the external water bath}

Part (b): Calculating qq, ww, and ΔU\Delta U with Proper Signs

  1. Determining Heat (qq):

    • Sign convention: Heat absorbed by the system from the surroundings is positive (q>0q > 0); heat released by the system to the surroundings is negative (q<0q < 0).
    • The problem states that the mixture releases 145 kJ145\text{ kJ} of thermal energy to the surroundings. Therefore: q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}
  2. Determining Work (ww):

    • Pressure-volume work is given by the relation: w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V
    • Because the cylinder is rigid and the piston is fixed, the volume cannot change (ΔV=0 L\Delta V = 0\text{ L}).
    • With no change in volume, no expansion or compression work is done on or by the system: w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}
  3. Determining the Change in Internal Energy (ΔU\Delta U):

    • According to the First Law of Thermodynamics: ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w
    • Substituting the values obtained for qq and ww: ΔU=−145 kJ+0 kJ=−145 kJ\Delta U = -145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = -145\text{ kJ}

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the sign of heat (qq). Always view energy flow from the system's perspective: if the system loses energy to the water bath, energy leaves the system, so both qq and ΔU\Delta U must be negative.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets heat released by the system as a positive quantity from the perspective of the surroundings, resulting in an incorrect sign for q and ΔU.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    System: Chemical reaction mixture inside the cylinder.\text{System: Chemical reaction mixture inside the cylinder.} ⟹ Surroundings: Water bath, cylinder, and fixed piston.\text{Surroundings: Water bath, cylinder, and fixed piston.}

  2. Step 2

    Thermal energy released means q=+145 kJ\text{Thermal energy released means } q = +145\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}

    Thermodynamic quantities are defined from the perspective of the system. Because thermal energy flows out of the system into the surroundings, heat must be negative (q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}).

  3. Step 3

    Fixed piston means ΔV=0, so w=0 kJ\text{Fixed piston means } \Delta V = 0\text{, so } w = 0\text{ kJ}

  4. Step 4

    ΔU=q+w=145 kJ+0 kJ=+145 kJ\Delta U = q + w = 145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = +145\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔU=q+w=−145 kJ+0 kJ=−145 kJ\Delta U = q + w = -145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = -145\text{ kJ}

    You applied the First Law of Thermodynamics correctly, but the result carried over the incorrect positive sign from your value of qq.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly distinguished between the thermodynamic system and its surroundings.

You correctly identified that a rigid, fixed-volume container performs no pressure-volume work (w=0w = 0).

You stated and applied the First Law of Thermodynamics formula, ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Thermodynamic Sign Convention Misapplication

You treated the released heat as a positive value, viewing the energy transfer from the perspective of the surroundings rather than the system.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the direction of energy flow with its algebraic sign: by convention in chemistry, all thermodynamic signs must reflect the perspective of the system (energy exiting is negative, energy entering is positive).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
System-Centric Sign Convention
  • Always view qq and ww as changes to the system's energy bank: energy gained by the system is positive (++); energy lost by the system to the surroundings is negative (−-).

  • Whenever a problem says thermal energy is 'released', 'evolved', or 'lost' by the system, immediately write q<0q < 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Since the system releases 145 kJ145\text{ kJ} to the water bath, heat leaves the system: q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}.

  2. Substitute the corrected heat value and w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ} into the First Law: ΔU=q+w=−145 kJ+0 kJ=−145 kJ\Delta U = q + w = -145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = -145\text{ kJ}.

Final answer

(a) System: the reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder; Surroundings: the water bath, cylinder, and fixed piston. (b) q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}, w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}, and ΔU=−145 kJ\Delta U = -145\text{ kJ}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the sign conventions for exothermic (q<0q < 0) versus endothermic (q>0q > 0) processes.

  • Practice checking thermodynamic signs by imagining an internal energy balance: if energy leaves the system, its total internal energy must decrease.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates work using pressure-volume expansion with the given volume instead of the change in volume, incorrectly producing non-zero work.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    System: Reaction mixture inside the cylinder.\text{System: Reaction mixture inside the cylinder.}\newlineSurroundings: The cylinder, fixed piston, and water bath.\text{Surroundings: The cylinder, fixed piston, and water bath.}

  2. Step 2

    q = -145 kJ\text{ kJ}

  3. Step 3

    w = -PΔ\Delta V = -(101.3 kPa\text{ kPa})(2.50 L\text{ L}) = -0.253 kJ\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    w = -P_{ext\text{ext}}Δ\Delta V = -P_{ext\text{ext}}(0 L\text{ L}) = 0 kJ\text{ kJ}

    Because the cylinder is rigid and the piston is fixed, the volume does not change (ΔV=0 L\Delta V = 0\text{ L}). You substituted the total volume V=2.50 LV = 2.50\text{ L} instead of the change in volume ΔV\Delta V.

  4. Step 4

    Δ\Delta U = q + w = -145 kJ\text{ kJ} - 0.253 kJ\text{ kJ} = -145.253 kJ\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    Δ\Delta U = q + w = -145 kJ\text{ kJ} + 0 kJ\text{ kJ} = -145 kJ\text{ kJ}

    You correctly applied the First Law of Thermodynamics (ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w), but the numerical value was affected by the non-zero work calculation in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly distinguished the thermodynamic system from its surroundings.

You assigned the correct negative sign to the heat released by the system.

You correctly recalled and set up the First Law equation ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Volume with Change in Volume

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the given cylinder volume (V=2.50 LV = 2.50\text{ L}) as the change in volume (ΔV\Delta V) when calculating pressure-volume work, overlooking that a fixed piston in a rigid container cannot undergo any volume change (ΔV=0\Delta V = 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Rigid Boundary Condition
  • Pressure-volume work is defined as w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V. If a container is rigid or has a fixed piston, ΔV=0\Delta V = 0, so w=0w = 0.

  • Always check whether boundaries move before calculating work; if volume is constant, work is automatically zero regardless of the total volume.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that the container is rigid with a fixed piston, so the change in volume is ΔV=Vf−Vi=0 L\Delta V = V_f - V_i = 0\text{ L}.

  2. Substitute ΔV=0 L\Delta V = 0\text{ L} into the work equation: w=−Pext(0 L)=0 kJw = -P_{\text{ext}}(0\text{ L}) = 0\text{ kJ}.

  3. Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics: ΔU=q+w=−145 kJ+0 kJ=−145 kJ\Delta U = q + w = -145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = -145\text{ kJ}.

Final answer

(a) System: reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder; Surroundings: cylinder walls, fixed piston, and water bath. (b) q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}, w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}, and ΔU=−145 kJ\Delta U = -145\text{ kJ}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between a state variable (VV) and a process change (ΔV\Delta V).

  • Practice identifying keywords like 'rigid container', 'fixed volume', or 'isochoric' that immediately imply w=0w = 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student swaps the definitions of system and surroundings, treating the surrounding water bath as the system.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    System: The water bath surrounding the cylinder. ⟹ Surroundings: The reaction mixture inside the cylinder.

    Correct

    System: the reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder; Surroundings: the cylinder walls, the piston, and the external water bath.

    You defined the external water bath as the system and the reaction mixture as the surroundings. The thermodynamic system is the specific substance or process being studied—here, the chemical reaction inside the cylinder. Everything else interacting with it, including the cylinder walls and water bath, forms the surroundings.

  2. Step 2

    Water bath absorbs heat, so q=+145 kJq = +145\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}

    Thermodynamic state functions and energy transfers must be evaluated from the perspective of the system (the reaction mixture). Because the mixture releases 145 kJ145\text{ kJ} of heat to the surroundings, energy leaves the system, so qq must be negative: q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}.

  3. Step 3

    Volume of bath does not change, so w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}

  4. Step 4

    ΔU=q+w=+145 kJ+0 kJ=+145 kJ\Delta U = q + w = +145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = +145\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    ΔU=q+w=−145 kJ+0 kJ=−145 kJ\Delta U = q + w = -145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = -145\text{ kJ}

    You applied the First Law of Thermodynamics (ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w) correctly, but the resulting sign was positive because it propagated the incorrect sign of qq from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that a constant-volume process results in zero expansion work (w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}).

You correctly stated and applied the First Law of Thermodynamics relation ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed System and Surroundings Perspective

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the object of study (the reacting chemicals) with the measurement medium (the surrounding water bath), assigning the sign of heat from the receiver's viewpoint rather than the system's viewpoint.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
System Identification
  • The system is the reaction mixture itself; containers, solvents acting as heat sinks, and water baths are part of the surroundings.

  • Always anchor your vantage point inside the reaction vessel as the system before assigning signs to qq and ww.

Thermodynamic Sign Convention
  • Energy entering the system is positive (++, endothermic / work done on system); energy leaving the system is negative (−-, exothermic / work done by system).

  • Check whether the system gained or lost energy: 'releases thermal energy' means q<0q < 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Define the reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder as the system.

  2. Define the cylinder walls, piston, and external water bath as the surroundings.

  3. Express heat from the system's perspective: releasing 145 kJ145\text{ kJ} gives q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}.

  4. Confirm work is zero because the rigid cylinder maintains constant volume (ΔV=0\Delta V = 0), so w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}.

  5. Sum the quantities via the First Law: ΔU=q+w=−145 kJ+0 kJ=−145 kJ\Delta U = q + w = -145\text{ kJ} + 0\text{ kJ} = -145\text{ kJ}.

Final answer

(a) System: the reacting chemical mixture inside the cylinder; Surroundings: the cylinder walls, the piston, and the external water bath. (b) q=−145 kJq = -145\text{ kJ}, w=0 kJw = 0\text{ kJ}, and ΔU=−145 kJ\Delta U = -145\text{ kJ}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before writing any numbers, write down 'System = reacting molecules' at the top of your paper to anchor your sign conventions.

  • Practice distinguishing between the temperature change of a calorimeter/bath and the sign of qrxnq_{\text{rxn}} (qsys=−qsurrq_{\text{sys}} = -q_{\text{surr}}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of gas in a flexible balloon absorbs 85 J85\text{ J} of heat from the surroundings while expanding against atmospheric pressure, performing 30 J30\text{ J} of work on the surroundings. Calculate qq, ww, and ΔU\Delta U for the gas.

Answer

q=+85 Jq = +85\text{ J}, w=−30 Jw = -30\text{ J}, and ΔU=+55 J\Delta U = +55\text{ J}. Heat absorbed by the gas is positive (+85 J+85\text{ J}); work done by the gas in expanding is negative (−30 J-30\text{ J}). By the First Law, ΔU=q+w=85 J+(−30 J)=+55 J\Delta U = q + w = 85\text{ J} + (-30\text{ J}) = +55\text{ J}.

02

An ideal gas is compressed in an insulated cylinder (q=0q = 0) by an external force that does 420 J420\text{ J} of work on the gas. (a) What are the values of qq, ww, and ΔU\Delta U? (b) Does the internal energy of the gas increase or decrease?

Answer

(a) q=0 Jq = 0\text{ J}, w=+420 Jw = +420\text{ J}, and ΔU=+420 J\Delta U = +420\text{ J}. (b) The internal energy increases by 420 J420\text{ J}. Because the surroundings do work on the system, energy is added to the system (w>0w > 0).

03

During a constant-volume combustion in a bomb calorimeter, a chemical reaction mixture releases 2.45 kJ2.45\text{ kJ} of heat. The calorimeter water temperature rises as a result. Determine qsysq_{\text{sys}}, wsysw_{\text{sys}}, ΔUsys\Delta U_{\text{sys}}, and state whether ΔUsurr\Delta U_{\text{surr}} is positive or negative.

Answer

qsys=−2.45 kJq_{\text{sys}} = -2.45\text{ kJ}, wsys=0 kJw_{\text{sys}} = 0\text{ kJ} (constant volume means ΔV=0\Delta V = 0), and ΔUsys=−2.45 kJ\Delta U_{\text{sys}} = -2.45\text{ kJ}. Since energy lost by the system is gained by the surroundings, ΔUsurr=+2.45 kJ\Delta U_{\text{surr}} = +2.45\text{ kJ} (positive).

Loading workspace…