Resources

A student incorrectly assumes that diamond is more thermodynamically stable than graphite at standard temperature and pressure because diamond is significantly harder and more dense, asserting that the phase transformation C(s, graphite)→C(s, diamond)\text{C}(\text{s, graphite}) \rightarrow \text{C}(\text{s, diamond}) must therefore be exothermic (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0). Evaluate the validity of this assertion by using Hess's Law to calculate the true standard enthalpy of transition, ΔHtrans∘\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}}, for: C(s, graphite)→C(s, diamond)\text{C}(\text{s, graphite}) \rightarrow \text{C}(\text{s, diamond}) from the standard enthalpies of combustion: (1) C(s, graphite)+O2(g)→CO2(g)ΔH1∘=−393.51 kJ/mol\text{C}(\text{s, graphite}) + \text{O}_2(\text{g}) \rightarrow \text{CO}_2(\text{g}) \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} (2) C(s, diamond)+O2(g)→CO2(g)ΔH2∘=−395.40 kJ/mol\text{C}(\text{s, diamond}) + \text{O}_2(\text{g}) \rightarrow \text{CO}_2(\text{g}) \quad \Delta H_2^\circ = -395.40\text{ kJ/mol} State whether the phase transition is endothermic or exothermic at standard conditions.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ΔHtrans∘=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}; Endothermic

Steps

01

Identify the Target Reaction and Given Equations

The target reaction for the phase transition of carbon from graphite to diamond is: C(s,graphite)→C(s,diamond)ΔHtrans∘=?\ce{C(s, graphite) -> C(s, diamond)} \quad \Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = ?

We are given two combustion reactions:

  1. C(s,graphite)+OX2(g)→COX2(g)ΔH1∘=−393.51 kJ/mol\ce{C(s, graphite) + O2(g) -> CO2(g)} \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol}
  2. C(s,diamond)+OX2(g)→COX2(g)ΔH2∘=−395.40 kJ/mol\ce{C(s, diamond) + O2(g) -> CO2(g)} \quad \Delta H_2^\circ = -395.40\text{ kJ/mol}

02

Apply Hess's Law

According to Hess's Law, the total enthalpy change for a chemical process is independent of the pathway taken. We can manipulate and combine the given equations to yield the target equation:

  1. Keep reaction (1) as written, because C(s,graphite)\ce{C(s, graphite)} is a reactant: C(s,graphite)+OX2(g)→COX2(g)ΔH1∘=−393.51 kJ/mol\ce{C(s, graphite) + O2(g) -> CO2(g)} \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol}
  2. Reverse reaction (2) so that C(s,diamond)\ce{C(s, diamond)} appears on the product side. Reversing a reaction changes the sign of its enthalpy change: COX2(g)→C(s,diamond)+OX2(g)−ΔH2∘=−(−395.40 kJ/mol)=+395.40 kJ/mol\ce{CO2(g) -> C(s, diamond) + O2(g)} \quad -\Delta H_2^\circ = -(-395.40\text{ kJ/mol}) = +395.40\text{ kJ/mol}

03

Add the Equations and Enthalpies

Adding the two equations together: C(s,graphite)+OX2(g)+COX2(g)→COX2(g)+C(s,diamond)+OX2(g)\ce{C(s, graphite) + O2(g) + CO2(g) -> CO2(g) + C(s, diamond) + O2(g)}

Canceling the common species (OX2(g)\ce{O2(g)} and COX2(g)\ce{CO2(g)}) from both sides gives the net target reaction: C(s,graphite)→C(s,diamond)\ce{C(s, graphite) -> C(s, diamond)}

Now, sum the corresponding enthalpy changes: ΔHtrans∘=ΔH1∘+(−ΔH2∘)\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_1^\circ + (-\Delta H_2^\circ) ΔHtrans∘=−393.51 kJ/mol+395.40 kJ/mol=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} + 395.40\text{ kJ/mol} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}


04

Evaluate the Student's Claim

  • Because ΔHtrans∘>0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} > 0 (+1.89 kJ/mol+1.89\text{ kJ/mol}), the transition from graphite to diamond is endothermic, absorbing heat from the surroundings.
  • Pitfall to avoid: Mechanical properties like hardness or density do not dictate thermodynamic stability. Diamond releases more heat upon combustion than graphite does (∣−395.40∣>∣−393.51∣\left|-395.40\right| > \left|-393.51\right|), which means diamond sits at a higher energy level than graphite. Therefore, graphite is the more thermodynamically stable allotrope at standard temperature and pressure, and the student's assertion is incorrect.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student adds the two combustion enthalpies directly without reversing the combustion reaction of diamond.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔHtrans∘=ΔH1∘+ΔH2∘  ⟹  ΔHtrans∘=−393.51 kJ/mol+(−395.40 kJ/mol)  ⟹  ΔHtrans∘=−788.91 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_1^\circ + \Delta H_2^\circ \implies \Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} + (-395.40\text{ kJ/mol}) \implies \Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -788.91\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔHtrans∘=ΔH1∘−ΔH2∘=−393.51 kJ/mol−(−395.40 kJ/mol)=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_1^\circ - \Delta H_2^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} - (-395.40\text{ kJ/mol}) = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}

    In your first line, you added ΔH2∘\Delta H_2^\circ directly. Because C(s,diamond)\ce{C(s, diamond)} is a reactant in reaction (2) but must be a product in the target transition reaction C(s,graphite)→C(s,diamond)\ce{C(s, graphite) -> C(s, diamond)}, reaction (2) must be reversed, changing the sign of ΔH2∘\Delta H_2^\circ from negative to positive.

  2. Step 2

    The transition is exothermic.

    Correct

    The transition is endothermic.

    Because ΔHtrans∘=+1.89 kJ/mol>0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol} > 0, the forward transition absorbs energy and is endothermic, not exothermic.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the combustion reactions could be combined to find the transition enthalpy.

You performed the addition arithmetic correctly according to your written formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error / failure to reverse reaction in Hess's Law

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated all given thermochemical equations as additive without matching whether target species appear as reactants or products.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Reaction Sides
  • If a target species appears on the product side of the target reaction, any given reaction containing that species on the reactant side must be reversed.

  • Always check the position of each substance in the target equation against the given thermochemical equations before summing enthalpy values.

Reverse Reaction Sign Change
  • Reversing a chemical equation reverses the sign of its enthalpy change: ΔHreverse=−ΔHforward\Delta H_{\text{reverse}} = -\Delta H_{\text{forward}}.

  • Change the sign of ΔH2∘\Delta H_2^\circ from −395.40 kJ/mol-395.40\text{ kJ/mol} to +395.40 kJ/mol+395.40\text{ kJ/mol} when writing COX2(g)→C(s,diamond)+OX2(g)\ce{CO2(g) -> C(s, diamond) + O2(g)}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Keep reaction (1) as written: C(s,graphite)+OX2(g)→COX2(g)ΔH1∘=−393.51 kJ/mol\ce{C(s, graphite) + O2(g) -> CO2(g)} \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol}.

  2. Reverse reaction (2) so diamond becomes a product: COX2(g)→C(s,diamond)+OX2(g)−ΔH2∘=+395.40 kJ/mol\ce{CO2(g) -> C(s, diamond) + O2(g)} \quad -\Delta H_2^\circ = +395.40\text{ kJ/mol}.

  3. Add the two equations and cancel OX2(g)\ce{O2(g)} and COX2(g)\ce{CO2(g)}: C(s,graphite)→C(s,diamond)\ce{C(s, graphite) -> C(s, diamond)}.

  4. Sum the adjusted enthalpy values: ΔHtrans∘=−393.51 kJ/mol+395.40 kJ/mol=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} + 395.40\text{ kJ/mol} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}.

Final answer

ΔHtrans∘=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}; Endothermic

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full balanced chemical equation for each step after reversing or multiplying, ensuring intermediate species cancel completely.

  • Verify that ΔH>0\Delta H > 0 corresponds to an endothermic process and ΔH<0\Delta H < 0 corresponds to an exothermic process.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student reverses the direction of subtraction by calculating ΔH2° - ΔH1° instead of ΔH1° - ΔH2°, incorrectly concluding that the transition is exothermic.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔHtrans∘=ΔH2∘−ΔH1∘  ⟹  ΔHtrans∘=−395.40 kJ/mol−(−393.51 kJ/mol)  ⟹  ΔHtrans∘=−1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_2^\circ - \Delta H_1^\circ \implies \Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -395.40\text{ kJ/mol} - (-393.51\text{ kJ/mol}) \implies \Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -1.89\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔHtrans∘=ΔH1∘−ΔH2∘=−393.51 kJ/mol−(−395.40 kJ/mol)=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_1^\circ - \Delta H_2^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} - (-395.40\text{ kJ/mol}) = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}

    To obtain the target reaction C(s,graphite)→C(s,diamond)\ce{C(s, graphite) -> C(s, diamond)}, reaction (1) must remain as written because graphite is a reactant, while reaction (2) must be reversed because diamond is a product. Reversing reaction (2) changes its sign to −ΔH2∘-\Delta H_2^\circ, giving ΔH1∘−ΔH2∘\Delta H_1^\circ - \Delta H_2^\circ, not ΔH2∘−ΔH1∘\Delta H_2^\circ - \Delta H_1^\circ.

  2. Step 2

    The transition is exothermic.\text{The transition is exothermic.}

    Correct

    The transition is endothermic.\text{The transition is endothermic.}

    Because the correct enthalpy change is positive (ΔHtrans∘=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}), the phase transition absorbs heat and is endothermic.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the given numerical enthalpy values into your subtraction.

You carried out the signed arithmetic accurately according to your chosen formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed reaction order in Hess's Law

You subtracted the reactant combustion enthalpy from the product combustion enthalpy instead of subtracting the product combustion reaction.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating standard enthalpies of combustion with standard enthalpies of formation. While enthalpies of formation follow ΔH∘=∑ΔHf∘(products)−∑ΔHf∘(reactants)\Delta H^\circ = \sum \Delta H_f^\circ(\text{products}) - \sum \Delta H_f^\circ(\text{reactants}), combustion-based Hess's Law calculations require reversing the product combustion reaction, which yields ∑ΔHc∘(reactants)−∑ΔHc∘(products)\sum \Delta H_c^\circ(\text{reactants}) - \sum \Delta H_c^\circ(\text{products}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Target Equation Alignment
  • Each component of the target equation must appear on the correct side (reactant vs. product).

  • Keep reaction (1) with graphite on the left; reverse reaction (2) so diamond appears on the right.

Sign Reversal Rule
  • Reversing a chemical equation inverts the sign of its ΔH∘\Delta H^\circ.

  • Change +ΔH2∘+ \Delta H_2^\circ to −ΔH2∘-\Delta H_2^\circ when flipping the diamond combustion reaction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ΔHtrans∘=ΔH1∘+(−ΔH2∘)\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_1^\circ + (-\Delta H_2^\circ)

  2. ΔHtrans∘=−393.51 kJ/mol+395.40 kJ/mol=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} + 395.40\text{ kJ/mol} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}

  3. Since ΔHtrans∘>0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} > 0, the process absorbs heat.

Final answer

ΔHtrans∘=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}; Endothermic

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the manipulated chemical equations explicitly and cancel matching species before summing their ΔH\Delta H values.

  • Remember that combustion reactions use ΔH∘=∑ΔHc∘(reactants)−∑ΔHc∘(products)\Delta H^\circ = \sum \Delta H_c^\circ(\text{reactants}) - \sum \Delta H_c^\circ(\text{products}), the reverse order of formation reactions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to change the sign of ΔH2° when reversing equation (2), resulting in subtracting a positive magnitude.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    C(s,graphite)+OX2(g)→COX2(g),ΔH1∘=−393.51 kJ/mol  ⟹  COX2(g)→C(s,diamond)+OX2(g),ΔH=−395.40 kJ/mol\ce{C(s, graphite) + O2(g) -> CO2(g)},\quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} \implies \ce{CO2(g) -> C(s, diamond) + O2(g)},\quad \Delta H = -395.40\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    COX2(g)→C(s,diamond)+OX2(g),ΔH=−ΔH2∘=+395.40 kJ/mol\ce{CO2(g) -> C(s, diamond) + O2(g)},\quad \Delta H = -\Delta H_2^\circ = +395.40\text{ kJ/mol}

    You correctly reversed the chemical equation to place diamond on the product side, but when a chemical reaction is reversed, the sign of its enthalpy change must also be reversed from negative to positive.

  2. Step 2

    ΔHtrans∘=−393.51 kJ/mol−395.40 kJ/mol  ⟹  ΔHtrans∘=−788.91 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} - 395.40\text{ kJ/mol} \implies \Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -788.91\text{ kJ/mol}

    Correct

    ΔHtrans∘=−393.51 kJ/mol+395.40 kJ/mol=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} + 395.40\text{ kJ/mol} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}

    You added your written enthalpy values correctly, but your sum inherited the incorrect sign from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    The transition is exothermic.\text{The transition is exothermic.}

    Correct

    Because ΔHtrans∘>0, the transition is endothermic.\text{Because } \Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} > 0\text{, the transition is endothermic.}

    Your conclusion followed your calculated negative value, but the true standard enthalpy of transition is positive, meaning the transition absorbs heat.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that reversing reaction (2) yields C(s,diamond)\ce{C(s, diamond)} as a product.

You correctly canceled spectator species (OX2\ce{O2} and COX2\ce{CO2}) to target the net phase transition.

You correctly added your intermediate enthalpies according to Hess's Law.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error on reversing reaction enthalpy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When manipulating thermochemical equations under Hess's Law, reversing the direction of a reaction requires multiplying its enthalpy change by −1-1. Forgetting this sign change treats both forward and reverse processes as releasing heat.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Hess's Law Reversal Rule
  • If a reaction has enthalpy change ΔH\Delta H, reversing the equation yields −ΔH-\Delta H.

  • Whenever you flip reactants and products, immediately cross out the original sign and write the opposite sign next to ΔH\Delta H.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. C(s,graphite)+OX2(g)→COX2(g)ΔH1∘=−393.51 kJ/mol\ce{C(s, graphite) + O2(g) -> CO2(g)} \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol}

  2. COX2(g)→C(s,diamond)+OX2(g)−ΔH2∘=−(−395.40 kJ/mol)=+395.40 kJ/mol\ce{CO2(g) -> C(s, diamond) + O2(g)} \quad -\Delta H_2^\circ = -(-395.40\text{ kJ/mol}) = +395.40\text{ kJ/mol}

  3. ΔHtrans∘=ΔH1∘+(−ΔH2∘)=−393.51 kJ/mol+395.40 kJ/mol=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_1^\circ + (-\Delta H_2^\circ) = -393.51\text{ kJ/mol} + 395.40\text{ kJ/mol} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}

  4. Because ΔHtrans∘>0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} > 0, the phase transition is endothermic.

Final answer

ΔHtrans∘=+1.89 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = +1.89\text{ kJ/mol}; Endothermic

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always pair the physical reversal of an equation with multiplying ΔH\Delta H by −1-1.

  • Compare combustion enthalpies to evaluate stability: diamond releases more heat upon combustion than graphite, showing that diamond sits at a higher enthalpy level and graphite is more stable.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Use the following combustion data to find the standard enthalpy of transition from white phosphorus to red phosphorus, P(s,white)→P(s,red)\ce{P(s, white) -> P(s, red)}: (1) P(s,white)+54OX2(g)→14PX4OX10(s)ΔH1∘=−743.0 kJ/mol\ce{P(s, white) + \frac{5}{4}O2(g) -> \frac{1}{4}P4O10(s)} \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -743.0\text{ kJ/mol} (2) P(s,red)+54OX2(g)→14PX4OX10(s)ΔH2∘=−725.5 kJ/mol\ce{P(s, red) + \frac{5}{4}O2(g) -> \frac{1}{4}P4O10(s)} \quad \Delta H_2^\circ = -725.5\text{ kJ/mol} State whether the transition is exothermic or endothermic.

Answer

ΔHtrans∘=−17.5 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = -17.5\text{ kJ/mol}; Exothermic. Keep reaction (1) and reverse reaction (2): ΔHtrans∘=ΔH1∘−ΔH2∘=−743.0−(−725.5)=−17.5 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{trans}} = \Delta H_1^\circ - \Delta H_2^\circ = -743.0 - (-725.5) = -17.5\text{ kJ/mol}. Because ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0, it is exothermic.

02

Calculate the standard enthalpy of reaction for NX2HX4(l)+CHX4O(l)→CHX2O(g)+NX2(g)+3 HX2(g)\ce{N2H4(l) + CH4O(l) -> CH2O(g) + N2(g) + 3H2(g)} using: (1) 2 NHX3(g)→NX2HX4(l)+HX2(g)ΔH1∘=+22.5 kJ\ce{2NH3(g) -> N2H4(l) + H2(g)} \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = +22.5\text{ kJ} (2) 2 NHX3(g)→NX2(g)+3 HX2(g)ΔH2∘=+92.2 kJ\ce{2NH3(g) -> N2(g) + 3H2(g)} \quad \Delta H_2^\circ = +92.2\text{ kJ} (3) CHX2O(g)+HX2(g)→CHX4O(l)ΔH3∘=−65.3 kJ\ce{CH2O(g) + H2(g) -> CH4O(l)} \quad \Delta H_3^\circ = -65.3\text{ kJ}

Answer

ΔH∘=+135.0 kJ\Delta H^\circ = +135.0\text{ kJ}. Reverse reaction (1) (−ΔH1∘=−22.5 kJ-\Delta H_1^\circ = -22.5\text{ kJ}), keep reaction (2) (+ΔH2∘=+92.2 kJ+\Delta H_2^\circ = +92.2\text{ kJ}), and reverse reaction (3) (−ΔH3∘=+65.3 kJ-\Delta H_3^\circ = +65.3\text{ kJ}). Summing gives ΔH∘=−22.5+92.2+65.3=+135.0 kJ\Delta H^\circ = -22.5 + 92.2 + 65.3 = +135.0\text{ kJ}.

03

Given the following thermochemical data: (1) 2 Al(s)+32OX2(g)→AlX2OX3(s)ΔH1∘=−1675.7 kJ/mol\ce{2Al(s) + \frac{3}{2}O2(g) -> Al2O3(s)} \quad \Delta H_1^\circ = -1675.7\text{ kJ/mol} (2) 2 Fe(s)+32OX2(g)→FeX2OX3(s)ΔH2∘=−824.2 kJ/mol\ce{2Fe(s) + \frac{3}{2}O2(g) -> Fe2O3(s)} \quad \Delta H_2^\circ = -824.2\text{ kJ/mol} Calculate ΔH∘\Delta H^\circ for the thermite reaction: 2 Al(s)+FeX2OX3(s)→AlX2OX3(s)+2 Fe(s)\ce{2Al(s) + Fe2O3(s) -> Al2O3(s) + 2Fe(s)}. Is the reaction endothermic or exothermic?

Answer

ΔH∘=−851.5 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ = -851.5\text{ kJ/mol}; Exothermic. Target requires reaction (1) minus reaction (2): ΔH∘=ΔH1∘−ΔH2∘=−1675.7−(−824.2)=−851.5 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ = \Delta H_1^\circ - \Delta H_2^\circ = -1675.7 - (-824.2) = -851.5\text{ kJ/mol}. Because ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0, it is exothermic.

Loading workspace…