Resources
An introductory textbook formula states that the of a strong acid solution is modeled exclusively by . A researcher evaluates this model at the asymptotic limit of extreme dilution by preparing an ultra-dilute solution with at (). The naive model predicts , indicating a basic solution. Evaluate the physical impossibility of this conclusion, set up the rigorous charge-balance equation accounting for the autoionization of water, and calculate the true of the solution.
Answer and steps
Final answer
The naive model's prediction of violates physical reality because adding an acid to pure neutral water cannot decrease below or make the solution basic. The rigorous charge-balance condition requires . Multiplying by yields . Solving via the quadratic formula gives . The true equilibrium is .
Steps
Physical Impossibility of the Naive Prediction
Pure liquid water at autoionizes according to the equilibrium:
In pure neutral water, , corresponding to .
Hydrochloric acid () is a strong acid that dissociates completely into hydronium ions () and chloride ions (). Adding an acidic solute to neutral water introduces additional ions into the system. Under Le Chatelier's principle, the added suppresses the autoionization of water, but the total concentration of cannot drop below the neutral concentration of .
Therefore, predicting implies a basic solution with , which is physically impossible when adding an acid to pure neutral water.
Setting Up the Rigorous Charge-Balance Equation
In any aqueous solution, macroscopic electrical neutrality must be maintained. The sum of positive charges equals the sum of negative charges:
Because dissociates completely:
From the autoionization equilibrium of water, the hydroxide concentration can be expressed in terms of :
Substitute these expressions into the electroneutrality condition:
Multiply both sides by to form a standard quadratic equation:
Substituting the numerical values and :
Solving for and True
Apply the quadratic formula, taking the positive root since concentration must be positive:
Substitute the values:
Now calculate the true :
The resulting of is slightly below , correctly showing a faintly acidic solution that accurately accounts for both the dissolved strong acid and the autoionization of water.
Typical errors
01 The student directly adds the neutral water concentration of 1.00 × 10⁻⁷ M to the acid concentration without accounting for Le Chatelier's suppression of water autoionization.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Adding acid to pure water cannot make the solution basic with because water already provides ions. The naive formula fails because it neglects the autoionization of water.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You substituted the neutral water concentration of for . Because the added shifts the water autoionization equilibrium to the left by Le Chatelier's principle, drops below . You need to substitute and solve the resulting quadratic equation.
- Step 4Correct
You correctly took the negative logarithm of your hydronium concentration, but the numerical result was affected by the unsuppressed autoionization assumption in Step 3.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly reasoned that an acidic solution cannot have a basic .
You accurately identified the charge-balance equation .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated water's contribution to as a fixed constant () instead of an equilibrium variable coupled via .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating water autoionization as an additive static background concentration rather than a dynamic equilibrium subject to Le Chatelier's principle ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Equilibrium Coupling vs. Static Addition
In aqueous solutions, and are always coupled by .
Whenever acid is added to water, express as rather than assuming .
- Quadratic Formulation
For dilute strong acids (), rearranges to .
Use the quadratic formula to find the true equilibrium hydronium concentration.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubstitute and into the charge-balance equation: .
Multiply both sides by to obtain the quadratic form: .
Apply the quadratic formula taking the positive root: .
Calculate the true : .
02 The student sets up an incorrect sign in the charge-balance quadratic equation by writing [H⁺] + [Cl⁻] = [OH⁻] instead of balancing positive and negative charges.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
A solution of strong acid cannot have at because adding hydronium ions must keep the solution acidic with . The textbook formula ignores the contribution of from water autoionization at extreme dilution.
- Step 2Correct
In electroneutrality, the sum of all positive ion concentrations must equal the sum of all negative ion concentrations. Because is an anion, it must be on the same side as , not with the cation .
- Step 3Correct
Your algebraic rearrangement followed correctly from your previous charge-balance line, but the linear coefficient inherited the incorrect positive sign.
- Step 4Correct
You executed the quadratic formula accurately for your equation, but the leading term should have been rather than .
- Step 5Correct
Your logarithm calculation correctly followed from your concentration, but the resulting is still basic, reflecting the upstream charge-balance error.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly explained the physical impossibility of obtaining a basic by adding an acid to pure water.
You correctly substituted the water autoionization relation .
You carried out the quadratic formula and logarithm steps with correct arithmetic.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally grouped on the left-hand side with instead of placing all anions together on the opposite side of all cations.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the electroneutrality (charge-balance) principle with mass balance or an additive equilibrium expression led you to add the acid counterion to rather than setting .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Electroneutrality Setup
Every charge-balance equation sets the total positive molar charge equal to the total negative molar charge: .
Always write separate headers for 'Cations' and 'Anions' before placing species into the equation: .
- Sanity-Checking Quadratic Roots
Dissolving an acid into pure neutral water must result in and at .
If your calculated is less than or for an acid solution, immediately inspect the signs in your charge-balance and quadratic expressions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState electroneutrality: .
Substitute and to obtain .
Multiply through by : .
Solve for the positive root: .
Lock it in
In an aqueous solution containing an added strong acid, why is strictly less than at ?
By Le Chatelier's principle, the additional from the acid shifts water autoionization to the left, suppressing so that is maintained.
Similar question
Calculate the of an ultra-dilute strong acid solution with at ().
Answer
Set up the charge balance: , which gives . Solving the quadratic yields . Thus, .
Calculate the equilibrium concentration of hydroxide ions, , and the in a solution at ().
Answer
By charge balance, , leading to . Solving gives . Then , so .
At what concentration of a strong monoprotic acid does water autoionization contribute exactly of the total at ()?
Answer
The water contribution is . Setting gives , so . Since , we find .