Resources

Rank the following three crystalline ionic compounds in order of increasing melting point based on periodic trends in lattice energy: NaCl\text{NaCl}, MgO\text{MgO}, and KCl\text{KCl}. Explain your ranking by explicitly evaluating ionic charges (q1,q2q_1, q_2) and internuclear cation-anion separation distances (r0r_0).

Answer and steps

Final answer

KCl<NaCl<MgO\text{KCl} < \text{NaCl} < \text{MgO}. MgO\text{MgO} has divalent ions (q1q2=(+2)(−2)=−4q_1 q_2 = (+2)(-2) = -4) yielding the largest lattice energy and highest melting point (∼2852 ∘C\sim 2852\,^\circ\text{C}). Both NaCl\text{NaCl} and KCl\text{KCl} are monovalent (q1q2=(+1)(−1)=−1q_1 q_2 = (+1)(-1) = -1), but K+\text{K}^+ has a larger ionic radius (138 pm138\,\text{pm}) than Na+\text{Na}^+ (102 pm102\,\text{pm}), making r0(KCl)>r0(NaCl)r_0(\text{KCl}) > r_0(\text{NaCl}), which gives KCl\text{KCl} a lower lattice energy and lower melting point.

Steps

01

The Relationship Between Lattice Energy and Melting Point

For crystalline ionic solids with similar structures, the melting point is largely determined by the lattice energy (ΔHlattice\Delta H_{\text{lattice}}), which is the energy required to completely separate one mole of a solid ionic compound into gaseous ions. A higher lattice energy requires more thermal energy to disrupt the crystal lattice, leading to a higher melting point.

According to Coulomb's Law, the electrostatic attraction between oppositely charged ions is given approximately by:

Lattice Energy∝∣q1⋅q2∣r0\text{Lattice Energy} \propto \frac{|q_1 \cdot q_2|}{r_0}

where:

  • q1q_1 and q2q_2 are the integer charges of the cation and anion.
  • r0=rcation+ranionr_0 = r_{\text{cation}} + r_{\text{anion}} is the internuclear distance (the sum of the ionic radii).

Because the product of charges can double, triple, or quadruple, ionic charge is the dominant factor, while the internuclear distance (r0r_0) serves as the deciding factor when compounds have the same charge product.


02

Evaluating Ionic Charges (q1,q2q_1, q_2)

Determine the oxidation states and charge products for each compound:

  • MgO\ce{MgO}: composed of MgX2+\ce{Mg^2+} (q1=+2q_1 = +2) and OX2−\ce{O^2-} (q2=−2q_2 = -2). ∣q1⋅q2∣=∣(+2)(−2)∣=4|q_1 \cdot q_2| = |(+2)(-2)| = 4
  • NaCl\ce{NaCl}: composed of NaX+\ce{Na^+} (q1=+1q_1 = +1) and ClX−\ce{Cl^-} (q2=−1q_2 = -1). ∣q1⋅q2∣=∣(+1)(−1)∣=1|q_1 \cdot q_2| = |(+1)(-1)| = 1
  • KCl\ce{KCl}: composed of KX+\ce{K^+} (q1=+1q_1 = +1) and ClX−\ce{Cl^-} (q2=−1q_2 = -1). ∣q1⋅q2∣=∣(+1)(−1)∣=1|q_1 \cdot q_2| = |(+1)(-1)| = 1

The charge product for MgO\ce{MgO} is four times greater than that of NaCl\ce{NaCl} and KCl\ce{KCl}. This large increase in electrostatic attraction makes the lattice energy of MgO\ce{MgO} substantially higher than that of either alkali halide. Therefore, MgO\ce{MgO} has the highest melting point.


03

Evaluating Internuclear Separation (r0r_0) for NaCl\ce{NaCl} and KCl\ce{KCl}

Both NaCl\ce{NaCl} and KCl\ce{KCl} have the same charge product (∣q1⋅q2∣=1|q_1 \cdot q_2| = 1) and share the same anion (ClX−\ce{Cl^-}). Their relative lattice energies depend on the cation radius:

  • Potassium (K\ce{K}) is located in Period 4, below Sodium (Na\ce{Na}) in Period 3 of Group 1.
  • Because KX+\ce{K^+} has an additional occupied electron shell compared to NaX+\ce{Na^+}, it has a larger ionic radius: r(KX+)>r(NaX+)r(\ce{K^+}) > r(\ce{Na^+})
  • Consequently, the internuclear separation is larger in KCl\ce{KCl} than in NaCl\ce{NaCl}: r0(KCl)>r0(NaCl)r_0(\ce{KCl}) > r_0(\ce{NaCl})

Because lattice energy is inversely proportional to r0r_0, the larger distance in KCl\ce{KCl} weakens the electrostatic attraction:

ΔHlattice(KCl)<ΔHlattice(NaCl)\Delta H_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{KCl}) < \Delta H_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{NaCl})

Thus, KCl\ce{KCl} melts at a lower temperature than NaCl\ce{NaCl}.


04

Final Ranking

Combining the charge and size considerations:

KCl<NaCl<MgO\ce{KCl} < \ce{NaCl} < \ce{MgO}

(Common Pitfall: Do not compare ion sizes before comparing charges. The difference between single and double charges creates a much larger effect on lattice energy than the small percentage differences in ionic radii across adjacent periods.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses ionic radius trends with atomic number or mass, incorrectly assuming larger ionic radius increases lattice energy and melting point.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Lattice energy depends on ∣q1⋅q2∣r0\text{Lattice energy depends on } \frac{|q_1 \cdot q_2|}{r_0}

  2. Step 2

    For MgO, charges are +2 and −2, so ∣q1⋅q2∣=4.  ⟹  For NaCl and KCl, charges are +1 and −1, so ∣q1⋅q2∣=1.  ⟹  MgO has the highest lattice energy because of its +2/−2 charges.\text{For MgO, charges are } +2 \text{ and } -2, \text{ so } |q_1 \cdot q_2| = 4. \implies \text{For NaCl and KCl, charges are } +1 \text{ and } -1, \text{ so } |q_1 \cdot q_2| = 1. \implies \text{MgO has the highest lattice energy because of its } +2/-2 \text{ charges.}

  3. Step 3

    Comparing NaCl and KCl, KX+ has 4 shells while NaX+ has 3 shells, so r0(KCl)>r0(NaCl).\text{Comparing NaCl and KCl, } \ce{K^+} \text{ has 4 shells while } \ce{Na^+} \text{ has 3 shells, so } r_0(\text{KCl}) > r_0(\text{NaCl}).

  4. Step 4

    A larger distance r0 gives stronger lattice attraction and higher melting point, so NaCl<KCl.\text{A larger distance } r_0 \text{ gives stronger lattice attraction and higher melting point, so } \text{NaCl} < \text{KCl}.

    Correct

    Since r0 is in the denominator, a larger distance weakens electrostatic attraction, so Lattice Energy(KCl)<Lattice Energy(NaCl)  ⟹  KCl<NaCl.\text{Since } r_0 \text{ is in the denominator, a larger distance weakens electrostatic attraction, so } \text{Lattice Energy}(\text{KCl}) < \text{Lattice Energy}(\text{NaCl}) \implies \text{KCl} < \text{NaCl}.

    Because r0r_0 is in the denominator of Coulomb's law, electrostatic attraction decreases as internuclear distance increases. A larger distance results in a weaker lattice and a lower melting point.

  5. Step 5

    Order of increasing melting point: NaCl<KCl<MgO\text{Order of increasing melting point: } \text{NaCl} < \text{KCl} < \text{MgO}

    Correct

    KCl<NaCl<MgO\text{KCl} < \text{NaCl} < \text{MgO}

    This final ranking was affected by the inversion error in Step 4.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that lattice energy depends on ∣q1⋅q2∣r0\frac{|q_1 \cdot q_2|}{r_0}.

You correctly determined that MgO\text{MgO} has the highest melting point because its divalent ions produce a fourfold greater charge product than the alkali halides.

You correctly deduced that r0(KCl)>r0(NaCl)r_0(\text{KCl}) > r_0(\text{NaCl}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse proportionality confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the internuclear separation distance r0r_0 as directly proportional to electrostatic attraction instead of inversely proportional.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator in Coulomb's Law
  • Electrostatic attraction is inversely proportional to internuclear distance (E∝1r0E \propto \frac{1}{r_0}).

  • Always recall that as ions get larger and farther apart, electrostatic attraction weakens, lowering the lattice energy and melting point.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Since r0r_0 is in the denominator of ∣q1⋅q2∣r0\frac{|q_1 \cdot q_2|}{r_0}, a larger separation distance r0r_0 weakens lattice attraction.

  2. Because r0(KCl)>r0(NaCl)r_0(\text{KCl}) > r_0(\text{NaCl}), KCl\text{KCl} has a lower lattice energy and therefore a lower melting point than NaCl\text{NaCl}.

Final answer

KCl<NaCl<MgO\text{KCl} < \text{NaCl} < \text{MgO}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Coulomb's law to reinforce why variables in the denominator decrease the overall force/energy as they increase.

  • Practice comparing ionic compound pairs with identical charges by checking which cation/anion has the smaller radius to identify the higher melting point.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student prioritizes ionic size over ionic charge, concluding that smaller ion separation produces higher lattice energy regardless of the higher charge magnitude on MgO.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Lattice energy depends on ionic radius distance r0  ⟹  Na+ and Cl− are smaller than Mg2+ and O2−, so r0 is smallest for NaCl.\text{Lattice energy depends on ionic radius distance } r_0 \implies \text{Na}^+ \text{ and } \text{Cl}^- \text{ are smaller than } \text{Mg}^{2+} \text{ and } \text{O}^{2-}, \text{ so } r_0 \text{ is smallest for } \text{NaCl}.

    Correct

    Lattice energy ∝∣q1q2∣r0;r(Mg2+)<r(Na+) and r(O2−)<r(Cl−), so r0(MgO)<r0(NaCl)<r0(KCl).\text{Lattice energy } \propto \frac{|q_1 q_2|}{r_0}; \quad r(\text{Mg}^{2+}) < r(\text{Na}^+) \text{ and } r(\text{O}^{2-}) < r(\text{Cl}^-), \text{ so } r_0(\text{MgO}) < r_0(\text{NaCl}) < r_0(\text{KCl}).

    You correctly recalled that internuclear separation affects lattice energy, but your comparison of ion sizes is inverted. Magnesium (Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+}) is isoelectronic with and smaller than sodium (Na+\text{Na}^+), and oxide (O2−\text{O}^{2-}, Period 2) has fewer electron shells than chloride (Cl−\text{Cl}^-, Period 3), meaning MgO\text{MgO} has a much smaller internuclear distance (r0r_0) than NaCl\text{NaCl}.

  2. Step 2

    Smaller distance r0 dominates over charge magnitude in determining melting point.\text{Smaller distance } r_0 \text{ dominates over charge magnitude in determining melting point}.

    Correct

    Ionic charge product ∣q1q2∣ dominates over distance r0 because charges double or quadruple, while ionic radii vary by much smaller percentages.\text{Ionic charge product } |q_1 q_2| \text{ dominates over distance } r_0 \text{ because charges double or quadruple, while ionic radii vary by much smaller percentages}.

    You assumed that distance outweighs charge magnitude, but Coulomb's law shows that lattice energy is primarily dictated by the charge product ∣q1q2∣|q_1 q_2|. In MgO\text{MgO}, the divalent ions give ∣(+2)(−2)∣=4|(+2)(-2)| = 4, which is four times the charge product of monovalent NaCl\text{NaCl} and KCl\text{KCl} (∣(+1)(−1)∣=1|(+1)(-1)| = 1). Charge magnitude is always the primary factor.

  3. Step 3

    Order of increasing melting point: KCl<MgO<NaCl\text{Order of increasing melting point: } \text{KCl} < \text{MgO} < \text{NaCl}

    Correct

    KCl<NaCl<MgO\text{KCl} < \text{NaCl} < \text{MgO}

    Because of the previous two errors, your final ranking placed MgO\text{MgO} below NaCl\text{NaCl}. With the highest charge product and the smallest internuclear distance, MgO\text{MgO} has by far the largest lattice energy and highest melting point.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You connected melting point directly to lattice energy and internuclear distance.

You correctly identified that KCl\text{KCl} has a larger internuclear distance and lower melting point than NaCl\text{NaCl}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Prioritizing ionic size over ionic charge in lattice energy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated internuclear separation as the primary factor over ionic charge magnitude, while also inverting periodic trends in ionic radii.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Hierarchy of Factors in Lattice Energy
  • Lattice energy is proportional to ∣q1q2∣r0\frac{|q_1 q_2|}{r_0}. Always evaluate the charge product ∣q1q2∣|q_1 q_2| first because it varies by integer multiples (e.g., 11 vs. 44), whereas internuclear distances (r0r_0) typically differ by only 10–30%10\text{--}30\%.

  • Sort ionic solids first into tiers by their charge product ∣q1q2∣|q_1 q_2|. Only compare r0r_0 (ionic radii) to break ties among compounds in the same charge tier.

Periodic Trends in Ionic Radii
  • Cation and anion radii decrease across a period for isoelectronic ions as nuclear charge (ZZ) increases, and increase down a group as principal energy levels (nn) are added.

  • Compare Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+} (Z=12Z=12) and Na+\text{Na}^+ (Z=11Z=11) using effective nuclear charge: Mg2+<Na+\text{Mg}^{2+} < \text{Na}^+. Compare O2−\text{O}^{2-} (n=2n=2) and Cl−\text{Cl}^- (n=3n=3) using shell number: O2−<Cl−\text{O}^{2-} < \text{Cl}^-.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate charge products: for MgO\text{MgO}, ∣q1q2∣=∣(+2)(−2)∣=4|q_1 q_2| = |(+2)(-2)| = 4; for NaCl\text{NaCl} and KCl\text{KCl}, ∣q1q2∣=∣(+1)(−1)∣=1|q_1 q_2| = |(+1)(-1)| = 1.

  2. Because ∣q1q2∣=4|q_1 q_2| = 4 is four times larger than 11, MgO\text{MgO} has the largest lattice energy and the highest melting point.

  3. Break the tie between NaCl\text{NaCl} and KCl\text{KCl} using ionic radius: K+\text{K}^+ is below Na+\text{Na}^+ in Group 1, so r(K+)>r(Na+)r(\text{K}^+) > r(\text{Na}^+), meaning r0(KCl)>r0(NaCl)r_0(\text{KCl}) > r_0(\text{NaCl}).

  4. A larger separation distance weakens electrostatic attraction, so the lattice energy of KCl\text{KCl} is less than that of NaCl\text{NaCl}.

Final answer

KCl<NaCl<MgO\text{KCl} < \text{NaCl} < \text{MgO}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Coulomb's law for ionic lattices, making it a rule to check the ionic charge product before looking at ionic size.

  • Practice comparing ionic radii across isoelectronic species (e.g., O2−,F−,Na+,Mg2+\text{O}^{2-}, \text{F}^-, \text{Na}^+, \text{Mg}^{2+}) using nuclear charge ZZ.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student reverses the requested order and ranks the compounds in order of decreasing melting point instead of increasing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Lattice energy∝∣q1⋅q2∣r0  ⟹  MgO has charges +2 and −2, so ∣q1⋅q2∣=4, giving it the highest melting point.\text{Lattice energy} \propto \frac{|q_1 \cdot q_2|}{r_0} \implies \ce{MgO}\text{ has charges }+2\text{ and }-2\text{, so }|q_1 \cdot q_2| = 4\text{, giving it the highest melting point.}

  2. Step 2

    NaCl and KCl have charges +1 and −1, so ∣q1⋅q2∣=1  ⟹  Since KX+ has a larger radius than NaX+, r0(KCl)>r0(NaCl), meaning NaCl has higher lattice energy than KCl.\ce{NaCl}\text{ and }\ce{KCl}\text{ have charges }+1\text{ and }-1\text{, so }|q_1 \cdot q_2| = 1 \implies \text{Since }\ce{K^+}\text{ has a larger radius than }\ce{Na^+}\text{, }r_0(\ce{KCl}) > r_0(\ce{NaCl})\text{, meaning }\ce{NaCl}\text{ has higher lattice energy than }\ce{KCl}.

  3. Step 3

    Order of melting point: MgO>NaCl>KCl\text{Order of melting point: }\ce{MgO} > \ce{NaCl} > \ce{KCl}

    Correct

    KCl<NaCl<MgO\ce{KCl} < \ce{NaCl} < \ce{MgO}

    You listed the compounds in decreasing order (highest to lowest), but the prompt asked for increasing order (lowest to highest).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Coulomb's Law to determine lattice energy trends.

You recognized that ionic charge is the primary factor and correctly prioritized MgO\ce{MgO}.

You used ionic radius trends to properly distinguish the lattice energies of NaCl\ce{NaCl} and KCl\ce{KCl}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Ranking Order

You solved the physical chemistry relationship perfectly, but wrote the sequence from highest to lowest rather than from lowest to highest.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the specific ordering term 'increasing' in the prompt, defaulting to the intuitive habit of listing the strongest compound first.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Ordering
  • 'Increasing order' means starting from the smallest value and moving to the largest (A<B<CA < B < C).

  • Always circle or underline keywords like 'increasing' or 'decreasing' before writing down your final inequality.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the lowest melting point among the three compounds: KCl\ce{KCl} has monovalent charges and the largest internuclear separation r0r_0, so it has the lowest melting point.

  2. Identify the intermediate compound: NaCl\ce{NaCl} has monovalent charges but a smaller r0r_0 than KCl\ce{KCl}, placing it in the middle.

  3. Identify the highest melting point: MgO\ce{MgO} has divalent charges (∣q1q2∣=4|q_1 q_2| = 4), giving it the largest lattice energy and highest melting point.

  4. Assemble the sequence from smallest to largest using '<' signs: KCl<NaCl<MgO\ce{KCl} < \ce{NaCl} < \ce{MgO}.

Final answer

KCl<NaCl<MgO\ce{KCl} < \ce{NaCl} < \ce{MgO}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check prompt keywords: confirm whether 'increasing' (<<) or 'decreasing' (>>) is required.

  • Practice rewriting comparative series into formal inequalities before submitting your final line.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Rank the following alkali halides in order of increasing melting point: LiF\text{LiF}, CsF\text{CsF}, and NaF\text{NaF}.

Answer

CsF<NaF<LiF\text{CsF} < \text{NaF} < \text{LiF}. All three share the same charges (+1,−1+1, -1) and common anion FX−\ce{F^-}. Cation radii increase down Group 1: r(LiX+)<r(NaX+)<r(CsX+)r(\ce{Li^+}) < r(\ce{Na^+}) < r(\ce{Cs^+}). Smaller internuclear distance r0r_0 yields higher lattice energy and a higher melting point.

02

Rank the following compounds in order of increasing melting point: CaO\text{CaO}, NaCl\text{NaCl}, and BaO\text{BaO}.

Answer

NaCl<BaO<CaO\text{NaCl} < \text{BaO} < \text{CaO}. NaCl\text{NaCl} has monovalent ions (∣q1q2∣=1|q_1 q_2| = 1), giving it the lowest lattice energy. CaO\text{CaO} and BaO\text{BaO} have divalent ions (∣q1q2∣=4|q_1 q_2| = 4). Between the oxides, CaX2+\ce{Ca^2+} has a smaller ionic radius than BaX2+\ce{Ba^2+}, making r0(CaO)<r0(BaO)r_0(\text{CaO}) < r_0(\text{BaO}) and giving CaO\text{CaO} the highest melting point.

03

Predict which substance has a higher melting point: MgF2\text{MgF}_2 or SrF2\text{SrF}_2. Explain your choice using Coulomb's law.

Answer

MgF2\text{MgF}_2 has a higher melting point. Both compounds have the same cation-to-anion charge product (+2+2 and −1-1). Because MgX2+\ce{Mg^2+} is in Period 3 and SrX2+\ce{Sr^2+} is in Period 5, r(MgX2+)<r(SrX2+)r(\ce{Mg^2+}) < r(\ce{Sr^2+}). The smaller internuclear distance r0r_0 in MgF2\text{MgF}_2 results in stronger electrostatic attraction and higher lattice energy.

Loading workspace…