Resources

A student uses a pycnometer to measure the density of an organic solvent. The accepted density of the solvent is 0.789 g/mL0.789\text{ g/mL}. The departmental laboratory grading rubric establishes a strict tolerance threshold: an experiment passes with full credit if and only if the absolute percent error is within 1.50%1.50\%. Determine the precise upper and lower boundary limits for the experimental density (in g/mL\text{g/mL}) that will satisfy this threshold requirement.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Lower boundary: 0.777 g/mL0.777\text{ g/mL}; Upper boundary: 0.801 g/mL0.801\text{ g/mL}

Steps

01

Recall the Formula for Percent Error

To find the acceptable range of experimental density values, we use the definition of percent error.

Percent error compares an experimental measurement (dexpd_{\text{exp}}) to the known or accepted value (dacceptedd_{\text{accepted}}):

Percent Error=∣dexp−daccepted∣daccepted×100%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{|d_{\text{exp}} - d_{\text{accepted}}|}{d_{\text{accepted}}} \times 100\%

For the measurement to pass within the allowable tolerance threshold, the absolute percent error must satisfy:

∣dexp−daccepted∣daccepted×100%≤1.50%\frac{|d_{\text{exp}} - d_{\text{accepted}}|}{d_{\text{accepted}}} \times 100\% \le 1.50\%

02

Determine the Maximum Allowable Absolute Deviation

Rearrange the inequality to solve for the maximum allowable absolute deviation (Δd=∣dexp−daccepted∣\Delta d = |d_{\text{exp}} - d_{\text{accepted}}|):

Δd=daccepted×1.50%100%\Delta d = d_{\text{accepted}} \times \frac{1.50\%}{100\%}

Substitute the accepted density of 0.789 g/mL0.789\text{ g/mL}:

Δd=0.789 g/mL×0.0150=0.011835 g/mL\Delta d = 0.789\text{ g/mL} \times 0.0150 = 0.011835\text{ g/mL}

03

Calculate the Boundary Limits

The experimental density must lie in the interval [daccepted−Δd,  daccepted+Δd][d_{\text{accepted}} - \Delta d,\; d_{\text{accepted}} + \Delta d]:

  • Lower boundary: dlower=0.789 g/mL−0.011835 g/mL=0.777165 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.789\text{ g/mL} - 0.011835\text{ g/mL} = 0.777165\text{ g/mL} Rounding to three decimal places (consistent with three significant figures from the given values) yields: dlower=0.777 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.777\text{ g/mL}
  • Upper boundary: dupper=0.789 g/mL+0.011835 g/mL=0.800835 g/mLd_{\text{upper}} = 0.789\text{ g/mL} + 0.011835\text{ g/mL} = 0.800835\text{ g/mL} Rounding to three decimal places yields: dupper=0.801 g/mLd_{\text{upper}} = 0.801\text{ g/mL}

Common Pitfall: Be careful to divide the absolute deviation by the accepted value, not an assumed experimental value, when setting up percent error calculations.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the 1.50% threshold as an absolute additive deviation of 0.0150 g/mL rather than a relative percentage of the accepted density, leading to boundaries of 0.774 g/mL and 0.804 g/mL.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Tolerance=1.50%=0.0150 g/mL\text{Tolerance} = 1.50\% = 0.0150\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    Δd=0.0150×0.789 g/mL=0.011835 g/mL\Delta d = 0.0150 \times 0.789\text{ g/mL} = 0.011835\text{ g/mL}

    You converted 1.50%1.50\% directly to 0.0150 g/mL0.0150\text{ g/mL} as if it were an absolute deviation. Percent error is relative to the accepted value, so the maximum deviation must be calculated as 1.50%1.50\% of 0.789 g/mL0.789\text{ g/mL}.

  2. Step 2

    Lower limit=0.789−0.0150=0.774 g/mL  ⟹  Upper limit=0.789+0.0150=0.804 g/mL\text{Lower limit} = 0.789 - 0.0150 = 0.774\text{ g/mL} \implies \text{Upper limit} = 0.789 + 0.0150 = 0.804\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    dlower=0.789−0.011835=0.777 g/mL  ⟹  dupper=0.789+0.011835=0.801 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.789 - 0.011835 = 0.777\text{ g/mL} \implies d_{\text{upper}} = 0.789 + 0.011835 = 0.801\text{ g/mL}

    Your method of subtracting and adding the tolerance to the accepted value is sound, but this step yields incorrect boundaries because it inherits the incorrect deviation from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that the boundary limits are found by subtracting and adding an allowable tolerance to the accepted density.

You correctly converted the percentage 1.50%1.50\% into decimal form (0.01500.0150).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Relative vs. Absolute Tolerance Confusion

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated a relative percentage (1.50%1.50\%) as an absolute quantity with units of g/mL\text{g/mL}, forgetting to multiply the decimal fraction by the accepted density to determine the actual allowable deviation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Percent Error Definition
  • Percent Error=∣dexp−daccepted∣daccepted×100%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{|d_{\text{exp}} - d_{\text{accepted}}|}{d_{\text{accepted}}} \times 100\%

  • Multiply the accepted value by the decimal percentage (%100\frac{\%}{100}) to determine the maximum absolute allowable error Δd\Delta d.

Applying Symmetrical Boundaries
  • d∈[daccepted−Δd,  daccepted+Δd]d \in [d_{\text{accepted}} - \Delta d,\; d_{\text{accepted}} + \Delta d]

  • Add and subtract the calculated relative margin Δd\Delta d from the accepted value, then round according to the appropriate precision.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the allowable absolute deviation: Δd=0.789 g/mL×0.0150=0.011835 g/mL\Delta d = 0.789\text{ g/mL} \times 0.0150 = 0.011835\text{ g/mL}.

  2. Calculate the lower limit: dlower=0.789 g/mL−0.011835 g/mL=0.777165 g/mL≈0.777 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.789\text{ g/mL} - 0.011835\text{ g/mL} = 0.777165\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.777\text{ g/mL}.

  3. Calculate the upper limit: dupper=0.789 g/mL+0.011835 g/mL=0.800835 g/mL≈0.801 g/mLd_{\text{upper}} = 0.789\text{ g/mL} + 0.011835\text{ g/mL} = 0.800835\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.801\text{ g/mL}.

Final answer

Lower boundary: 0.777 g/mL0.777\text{ g/mL}; Upper boundary: 0.801 g/mL0.801\text{ g/mL}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that percentages are dimensionless ratios; always multiply by the base value to get an actual deviation with physical units.

  • Practice converting relative percentage tolerances into absolute intervals before computing experimental acceptance ranges.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides by 10 instead of 100 when converting 1.50% to a decimal, using 0.150 instead of 0.0150 and yielding an allowed deviation ten times too large.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Allowed error=0.150×0.789=0.11835 g/mL\text{Allowed error} = 0.150 \times 0.789 = 0.11835\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    Δd=0.0150×0.789 g/mL=0.011835 g/mL\Delta d = 0.0150 \times 0.789\text{ g/mL} = 0.011835\text{ g/mL}

    To convert a percentage to a decimal, you must divide by 100100: 1.50%=1.50100=0.01501.50\% = \frac{1.50}{100} = 0.0150. Multiplying by 0.1500.150 corresponds to 15.0%15.0\%, making the calculated error margin ten times larger than allowed.

  2. Step 2

    Lower limit=0.789−0.11835=0.67065 g/mL\text{Lower limit} = 0.789 - 0.11835 = 0.67065\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    dlower=0.789−0.011835=0.777 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.789 - 0.011835 = 0.777\text{ g/mL}

    Your subtraction method was correct, but the result was thrown off because you carried forward the incorrect deviation from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Upper limit=0.789+0.11835=0.90735 g/mL\text{Upper limit} = 0.789 + 0.11835 = 0.90735\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    dupper=0.789+0.011835=0.801 g/mLd_{\text{upper}} = 0.789 + 0.011835 = 0.801\text{ g/mL}

    Your addition method was correct, but the result was thrown off because you carried forward the incorrect deviation from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the tolerance interval is symmetric around the accepted density value.

You set up the boundary calculations by subtracting and adding the allowed deviation to the accepted value.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Percent-to-Decimal Conversion Error

You divided by 1010 instead of 100100 when converting 1.50%1.50\% into decimal form, writing 0.1500.150 rather than 0.01500.0150.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing percent values that have a single leading digit or a decimal component with whole tens (e.g., mistaking 1.5%1.5\% for 15%15\%), resulting in shifting the decimal point one place to the left instead of two.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Two-Place Decimal Shift
  • Converting from a percentage to a decimal always requires dividing by 100100, which moves the decimal point two places to the left: x%=x100x\% = \frac{x}{100}.

  • Before multiplying, write out 1.50100=0.0150\frac{1.50}{100} = 0.0150 explicitly to verify that two decimal places were shifted.

Magnitude Reality Check
  • A small percentage error (such as 1.5%1.5\%) on a density near 0.8 g/mL0.8\text{ g/mL} should produce a tiny deviation around the hundredths place (≈0.01 g/mL{\approx}0.01\text{ g/mL}), not over 0.1 g/mL0.1\text{ g/mL}.

  • Compare your computed deviation Δd\Delta d to 10%10\% and 1%1\% of the accepted value to confirm its order of magnitude before adding or subtracting.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert 1.50%1.50\% to decimal form: 1.50100=0.0150\frac{1.50}{100} = 0.0150.

  2. Calculate the maximum allowable deviation: Δd=0.0150×0.789 g/mL=0.011835 g/mL\Delta d = 0.0150 \times 0.789\text{ g/mL} = 0.011835\text{ g/mL}.

  3. Determine the lower boundary: dlower=0.789 g/mL−0.011835 g/mL=0.777165 g/mL≈0.777 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.789\text{ g/mL} - 0.011835\text{ g/mL} = 0.777165\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.777\text{ g/mL}.

  4. Determine the upper boundary: dupper=0.789 g/mL+0.011835 g/mL=0.800835 g/mL≈0.801 g/mLd_{\text{upper}} = 0.789\text{ g/mL} + 0.011835\text{ g/mL} = 0.800835\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.801\text{ g/mL}.

Final answer

Lower boundary: 0.777 g/mL0.777\text{ g/mL}; Upper boundary: 0.801 g/mL0.801\text{ g/mL}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to convert single-digit percentages and decimal percentages into standard decimals by shifting the decimal point two places left.

  • Practice using order-of-magnitude estimations (checking 1%1\% vs. 10%10\%) to catch scale errors early.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates percent error relative to the experimental value rather than the accepted value, setting (0.789 - d) / d = 0.0150 to find the boundaries.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ∣d−0.789∣d≤0.0150\frac{|d - 0.789|}{d} \le 0.0150

    Correct

    ∣d−0.789∣0.789≤0.0150\frac{|d - 0.789|}{0.789} \le 0.0150

    You divided by the experimental density dd rather than the accepted density 0.789 g/mL0.789\text{ g/mL}. In percent error calculations, the reference base in the denominator is always the accepted (true) value.

  2. Step 2

    dupper:d−0.789d=0.0150  ⟹  0.985d=0.789  ⟹  d=0.801015 g/mLd_{\text{upper}}: \frac{d - 0.789}{d} = 0.0150 \implies 0.985d = 0.789 \implies d = 0.801015\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    dupper=0.789+(0.789×0.0150)=0.800835 g/mL≈0.801 g/mLd_{\text{upper}} = 0.789 + (0.789 \times 0.0150) = 0.800835\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.801\text{ g/mL}

    Your algebraic rearrangement was executed correctly based on your equation, but the expression propagated the incorrect denominator.

  3. Step 3

    dlower:0.789−dd=0.0150  ⟹  1.015d=0.789  ⟹  d=0.777340 g/mLd_{\text{lower}}: \frac{0.789 - d}{d} = 0.0150 \implies 1.015d = 0.789 \implies d = 0.777340\text{ g/mL}

    Correct

    dlower=0.789−(0.789×0.0150)=0.777165 g/mL≈0.777 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.789 - (0.789 \times 0.0150) = 0.777165\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.777\text{ g/mL}

    Your algebraic solving for the lower bound was mathematically valid for your setup, but it relied on the initial incorrect reference base.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed 1.50%1.50\% as the decimal 0.01500.0150.

You set up the absolute deviation ∣d−0.789∣|d - 0.789| properly for both upper and lower bounds.

You accurately solved linear equations involving fractions and variables.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect denominator in percent error

You placed the unknown experimental density dd in the denominator instead of the accepted standard 0.789 g/mL0.789\text{ g/mL}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the reference standard (accepted value) with the measured variable (experimental value) when defining relative deviation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator of Percent Error
  • Percent Error=∣Experimental−Accepted∣Accepted×100%\text{Percent Error} = \frac{|\text{Experimental} - \text{Accepted}|}{\text{Accepted}} \times 100\%

  • Always identify the accepted, true, or theoretical value and place it in the denominator as your fixed reference.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the maximum allowable deviation using the accepted value as the base: ∣d−0.789∣≤0.789×0.0150=0.011835 g/mL|d - 0.789| \le 0.789 \times 0.0150 = 0.011835\text{ g/mL}.

  2. Add the deviation to find the upper limit: dupper=0.789+0.011835=0.800835 g/mL≈0.801 g/mLd_{\text{upper}} = 0.789 + 0.011835 = 0.800835\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.801\text{ g/mL}.

  3. Subtract the deviation to find the lower limit: dlower=0.789−0.011835=0.777165 g/mL≈0.777 g/mLd_{\text{lower}} = 0.789 - 0.011835 = 0.777165\text{ g/mL} \approx 0.777\text{ g/mL}.

Final answer

Lower boundary: 0.777 g/mL0.777\text{ g/mL}; Upper boundary: 0.801 g/mL0.801\text{ g/mL}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full formula with variable labels (∣xexp−xtrue∣/xtrue|x_{\text{exp}} - x_{\text{true}}| / x_{\text{true}}) before substituting numbers.

  • Double-check that your denominator is a fixed constant rather than the variable you are solving for.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An analytical balance is calibrated against a standard 5.000 g5.000\text{ g} mass. The lab standard allows a maximum absolute percent error of 0.20%0.20\%. Calculate the minimum and maximum acceptable mass readings for this balance.

Answer

Minimum: 4.990 g4.990\text{ g}; Maximum: 5.010 g5.010\text{ g}. Absolute deviation is Δm=5.000 g×0.0020=0.010 g\Delta m = 5.000\text{ g} \times 0.0020 = 0.010\text{ g}. Boundaries are 5.000−0.010=4.990 g5.000 - 0.010 = 4.990\text{ g} and 5.000+0.010=5.010 g5.000 + 0.010 = 5.010\text{ g}.

02

A chemistry student measures the molarity of a standard HCl\text{HCl} solution with an accepted concentration of 0.1042 M0.1042\text{ M}. If the experiment requires a percent error within 1.25%1.25\%, what is the acceptable concentration range for full marks?

Answer

0.1029 M0.1029\text{ M} to 0.1055 M0.1055\text{ M}. Absolute deviation is ΔC=0.1042 M×0.0125=0.0013025 M\Delta C = 0.1042\text{ M} \times 0.0125 = 0.0013025\text{ M}. Lower limit: 0.1042−0.0013025=0.1029 M0.1042 - 0.0013025 = 0.1029\text{ M}; Upper limit: 0.1042+0.0013025=0.1055 M0.1042 + 0.0013025 = 0.1055\text{ M}.

03

An unknown liquid has a reported theoretical density of 1.260 g/cm31.260\text{ g/cm}^3. In an advanced lab evaluation, a student's trial produces an experimental value of 1.242 g/cm31.242\text{ g/cm}^3. If the threshold for passing is an absolute percent error ≤1.50%\le 1.50\%, determine whether the trial passes and state the allowable boundary values.

Answer

The trial does not pass (fails). Allowable boundaries are 1.241 g/cm31.241\text{ g/cm}^3 to 1.279 g/cm31.279\text{ g/cm}^3 if using Δd=1.260×0.0150=0.0189 g/cm3\Delta d = 1.260 \times 0.0150 = 0.0189\text{ g/cm}^3. The student's percent error is ∣1.242−1.260∣1.260×100%=1.43%≤1.50%\frac{|1.242 - 1.260|}{1.260} \times 100\% = 1.43\% \le 1.50\%, so the student trial actually passes. Boundaries: Lower =1.260−0.0189=1.241 g/cm3= 1.260 - 0.0189 = 1.241\text{ g/cm}^3, Upper =1.260+0.0189=1.279 g/cm3= 1.260 + 0.0189 = 1.279\text{ g/cm}^3.

Loading workspace…