Resources

Consider the behavior of real helium gas as pressure approaches zero (P→0P \rightarrow 0) versus high pressure (P=500 atmP = 500\text{ atm}) at T=273.15 KT = 273.15\text{ K}. The compressibility factor is defined as Z=PVmRTZ = \frac{PV_{\text{m}}}{RT}. For helium, van der Waals constants are a=0.0346 L2⋅atm/mol2a = 0.0346\text{ L}^2\cdot\text{atm/mol}^2 and b=0.0238 L/molb = 0.0238\text{ L/mol}. (a) Using the van der Waals equation truncated to the second virial coefficient, Z≈1+(b−aRT)PRTZ \approx 1 + \left(b - \frac{a}{RT}\right)\frac{P}{RT}, calculate the value of ZZ at P=500 atmP = 500\text{ atm}. (b) Evaluate lim⁡P→0Z\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z and describe the asymptotic microscopic state: specifically, what happens to the ratio of excluded molecular volume to container volume, and what happens to the mean free path λ=kBT2πd2P\lambda = \frac{k_{\text{B}} T}{\sqrt{2}\pi d^2 P} as P→0P \rightarrow 0?

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) At T=273.15 KT = 273.15\text{ K}, RT=(0.08206)(273.15)=22.414 L⋅atm/molRT = (0.08206)(273.15) = 22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}. The term b−aRT=0.0238−0.034622.414=0.0238−0.00154=+0.02226 L/molb - \frac{a}{RT} = 0.0238 - \frac{0.0346}{22.414} = 0.0238 - 0.00154 = +0.02226\text{ L/mol}. Thus, Z≈1+(0.02226 L/mol)(500 atm22.414 L⋅atm/mol)=1+0.4965=1.50Z \approx 1 + (0.02226\text{ L/mol})\left(\frac{500\text{ atm}}{22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}}\right) = 1 + 0.4965 = 1.50. (b) As P→0P \rightarrow 0, lim⁡P→0Z=1.00\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z = 1.00. Microscopically, the container volume approaches infinity, rendering the finite volume occupied by the gas particles entirely negligible relative to the free volume (Vfree≈VcontainerV_{\text{free}} \approx V_{\text{container}}); intermolecular separations become so vast that attractive/repulsive potentials approach zero, and the mean free path λ\lambda diverges asymptotically to infinity (lim⁡P→0λ=∞\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} \lambda = \infty).

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Compressibility Factor ZZ at High Pressure

  1. Calculate the thermal energy factor RTRT: Using the ideal gas constant R=0.08206 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K)R = 0.08206\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}) and temperature T=273.15 KT = 273.15\text{ K}: RT=(0.08206 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K))(273.15 K)=22.414 L⋅atm/molRT = (0.08206\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(273.15\text{ K}) = 22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}
  2. Evaluate the second virial coefficient contribution (b−aRT)\left(b - \frac{a}{RT}\right): The parameter aa accounts for attractive intermolecular forces, while bb accounts for the finite volume of the particles (repulsive/excluded volume effects). aRT=0.0346 L2⋅atm/mol222.414 L⋅atm/mol≈0.00154 L/mol\frac{a}{RT} = \frac{0.0346\text{ L}^2\cdot\text{atm/mol}^2}{22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}} \approx 0.00154\text{ L/mol} b−aRT=0.0238 L/mol−0.00154 L/mol=+0.02226 L/molb - \frac{a}{RT} = 0.0238\text{ L/mol} - 0.00154\text{ L/mol} = +0.02226\text{ L/mol} Because b>aRTb > \frac{a}{RT}, the excluded volume term dominates over the attractive forces even at moderate pressures, which is characteristic of helium due to its tiny polarizability.
  3. Compute the compressibility factor ZZ: Substitute the values into the truncated virial equation: Z≈1+(b−aRT)PRTZ \approx 1 + \left(b - \frac{a}{RT}\right)\frac{P}{RT} Z≈1+(0.02226 L/mol)(500 atm22.414 L⋅atm/mol)Z \approx 1 + (0.02226\text{ L/mol})\left(\frac{500\text{ atm}}{22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}}\right) Z≈1+0.4965≈1.50Z \approx 1 + 0.4965 \approx 1.50

A value of Z>1Z > 1 confirms that real helium gas is less compressible than an ideal gas at this pressure because molecular volume exclusion resists further compression.


Part (b): Asymptotic Behavior as Pressure Approaches Zero (P→0P \rightarrow 0)

  1. Limit of the Compressibility Factor: Taking the mathematical limit of the equation as P→0P \rightarrow 0: lim⁡P→0Z=lim⁡P→0[1+(b−aRT)PRT]=1.00\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z = \lim_{P \rightarrow 0} \left[1 + \left(b - \frac{a}{RT}\right)\frac{P}{RT}\right] = 1.00 This indicates that real helium approaches ideal gas behavior in the low-pressure limit.
  2. Ratio of Excluded Volume to Container Volume:

    • As P→0P \rightarrow 0 at constant temperature, the molar volume expands infinitely (Vm→∞V_{\text{m}} \rightarrow \infty).
    • The excluded volume of the molecules (NA⋅bN_{\text{A}} \cdot b) remains constant and finite.
    • Therefore, the ratio of molecular excluded volume to total container volume approaches zero: lim⁡P→0VexcludedVcontainer=0\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} \frac{V_{\text{excluded}}}{V_{\text{container}}} = 0 The gas particles effectively act as point masses relative to the immense volume of empty space.
  3. Mean Free Path (λ\lambda):

    • The mean free path is given by: λ=kBT2πd2P\lambda = \frac{k_{\text{B}} T}{\sqrt{2}\pi d^2 P}
    • As pressure approaches zero (P→0P \rightarrow 0), the collision frequency approaches zero, and the average distance traveled by a particle between successive collisions diverges to infinity: lim⁡P→0λ=∞\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} \lambda = \infty Microscopically, particles are separated by vast distances where both attractive and repulsive intermolecular potentials vanish entirely.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the sign of the attraction term in the second virial coefficient, using b + a/(RT) instead of b - a/(RT).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    RT=0.08206×273.15=22.414 L⋅atm/molRT = 0.08206 \times 273.15 = 22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}

  2. Step 2

    B=b+aRT=0.0238+0.034622.414=0.02534 L/molB = b + \frac{a}{RT} = 0.0238 + \frac{0.0346}{22.414} = 0.02534\text{ L/mol}

    Correct

    b−aRT=0.0238 L/mol−0.0346 L2⋅atm/mol222.414 L⋅atm/mol=+0.02226 L/molb - \frac{a}{RT} = 0.0238\text{ L/mol} - \frac{0.0346\text{ L}^2\cdot\text{atm/mol}^2}{22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}} = +0.02226\text{ L/mol}

    You added the attraction correction aRT\frac{a}{RT} to bb instead of subtracting it. Attractive forces reduce pressure, contributing a negative term −aRT-\frac{a}{RT} to the second virial coefficient.

  3. Step 3

    Z=1+0.02534×(50022.414)=1.57Z = 1 + 0.02534 \times \left(\frac{500}{22.414}\right) = 1.57

    Correct

    Z≈1+(0.02226 L/mol)(500 atm22.414 L⋅atm/mol)≈1.50Z \approx 1 + (0.02226\text{ L/mol})\left(\frac{500\text{ atm}}{22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}}\right) \approx 1.50

    Your arithmetic was carried out accurately, but the resulting value of ZZ is slightly too high due to the sign error in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    lim⁡P→0Z=1  ⟹  Excluded volume to container volume ratio approaches 0 because container volume becomes infinite.  ⟹  As P→0,λ approaches infinity because collision frequency approaches 0.\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z = 1 \implies \text{Excluded volume to container volume ratio approaches } 0 \text{ because container volume becomes infinite.} \implies \text{As } P \rightarrow 0, \lambda \text{ approaches infinity because collision frequency approaches } 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the RTRT product using the appropriate gas constant.

You clearly evaluated the mathematical limit as P→0P \rightarrow 0.

You accurately explained the microscopic implications for both molecular excluded volume and mean free path.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign inversion in virial coefficient

You used a plus sign between bb and aRT\frac{a}{RT} instead of a minus sign.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the additive nature of the van der Waals volume exclusion parameter bb and attraction parameter aa in the equation of state with their opposing effects on the compressibility factor. Attractive intermolecular forces pull particles inward, lowering the pressure and contributing negatively (−aRT-\frac{a}{RT}) to ZZ.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Intermolecular Forces in the Virial Expansion
  • In the expansion Z=1+B2(T)PRT+…Z = 1 + B_2(T)\frac{P}{RT} + \dots, finite molecular size (repulsion) increases ZZ (+b+b), while attractive intermolecular forces decrease ZZ (−aRT-\frac{a}{RT}).

  • Always verify that the attractive parameter aa enters the second virial coefficient with a negative sign: B2(T)=b−aRTB_2(T) = b - \frac{a}{RT}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract the attraction term from the excluded volume parameter: b−aRT=0.0238−0.034622.414=0.0238−0.00154=+0.02226 L/molb - \frac{a}{RT} = 0.0238 - \frac{0.0346}{22.414} = 0.0238 - 0.00154 = +0.02226\text{ L/mol}.

  2. Substitute this correct coefficient into the truncated virial equation: Z≈1+(0.02226)(50022.414)=1+0.4965Z \approx 1 + (0.02226)\left(\frac{500}{22.414}\right) = 1 + 0.4965.

Final answer

(a) Z≈1.50Z \approx 1.50; (b) lim⁡P→0Z=1.00\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z = 1.00, VexcludedVcontainer→0\frac{V_{\text{excluded}}}{V_{\text{container}}} \rightarrow 0, and λ→∞\lambda \rightarrow \infty.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check signs against physical intuition: repulsive excluded volume raises Z>1Z > 1, whereas attractive forces lower Z<1Z < 1.

  • Practice expanding (P+aVm2)(Vm−b)=RT\left(P + \frac{a}{V_{\text{m}}^2}\right)(V_{\text{m}} - b) = RT into virial form to reinforce why the attraction term acquires a negative sign.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the pressure dependence of the mean free path, incorrectly concluding that mean free path approaches zero as pressure approaches zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    RT=0.08206×273.15=22.414 L⋅atm/mol  ⟹  B=0.0238−0.034622.414=0.02226 L/mol  ⟹  Z=1+0.02226×(50022.414)=1.50RT = 0.08206 \times 273.15 = 22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol} \implies B = 0.0238 - \frac{0.0346}{22.414} = 0.02226\text{ L/mol} \implies Z = 1 + 0.02226 \times \left(\frac{500}{22.414}\right) = 1.50

  2. Step 2

    lim⁡P→0Z=1  ⟹  The ratio of excluded volume to container volume approaches 0.\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z = 1 \implies \text{The ratio of excluded volume to container volume approaches } 0.

  3. Step 3

    λ=kBT2πd2P  ⟹  As P→0, λ approaches 0 because the gas disappears.\lambda = \frac{k_{\text{B}} T}{\sqrt{2}\pi d^2 P} \implies \text{As } P \rightarrow 0\text{, } \lambda \text{ approaches } 0 \text{ because the gas disappears.}

    Correct

    lim⁡P→0λ=lim⁡P→0kBT2πd2P=∞\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} \lambda = \lim_{P \rightarrow 0} \frac{k_{\text{B}} T}{\sqrt{2}\pi d^2 P} = \infty

    Because pressure PP appears in the denominator of the mean free path formula, taking the limit as P→0P \rightarrow 0 yields λ→∞\lambda \rightarrow \infty. Physically, as gas density drops toward zero, collisions become exceedingly rare, meaning a molecule travels an arbitrarily large distance before hitting another particle.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You substituted the van der Waals parameters into the truncated virial equation accurately to find Z=1.50Z = 1.50.

You correctly recognized that ideal gas behavior is recovered as P→0P \rightarrow 0, giving lim⁡P→0Z=1\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z = 1.

You correctly reasoned that the finite particle volume becomes negligible compared to the total container volume at zero pressure.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mean free path pressure dependence inversion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated mean free path as directly proportional to particle abundance rather than inversely proportional to collision frequency and particle number density.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator Limiting Behavior
  • For a positive quantity y=Cxy = \frac{C}{x} where C>0C > 0, as x→0+x \rightarrow 0^+, y→∞y \rightarrow \infty.

  • Always check the algebraic position of the variable: when the variable approaching zero is in the denominator, the fraction diverges to positive infinity.

Physical Meaning of Mean Free Path
  • Mean free path λ\lambda represents the average distance a particle travels between successive collisions.

  • Remember that lower pressure means fewer surrounding molecules and rarer collisions, which allows particles to travel farther between impacts.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the relation for mean free path: λ=kBT2πd2P\lambda = \frac{k_{\text{B}} T}{\sqrt{2}\pi d^2 P}.

  2. Evaluate the limit as pressure approaches zero: lim⁡P→0+kBT2πd2P=∞\lim_{P \rightarrow 0^+} \frac{k_{\text{B}} T}{\sqrt{2}\pi d^2 P} = \infty.

  3. Interpret the microscopic result: in an ultra-dilute gas, particle density approaches zero, collisions cease, and molecules travel infinitely far without colliding.

Final answer

(a) Z≈1.50Z \approx 1.50; (b) lim⁡P→0Z=1.00\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} Z = 1.00, the ratio VexcludedVcontainer→0\frac{V_{\text{excluded}}}{V_{\text{container}}} \rightarrow 0, and lim⁡P→0λ=∞\lim_{P \rightarrow 0} \lambda = \infty.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the inverse relationship between mean free path λ\lambda and number density n/Vn/V or pressure PP.

  • Practice taking limits of physical transport properties as pressure approaches both the high-pressure and low-pressure extremes.

  • Distinguish between collision frequency Zcoll∝PZ_{\text{coll}} \propto P (which approaches 0) and mean free path λ∝1/P\lambda \propto 1/P (which approaches ∞\infty).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes that as pressure approaches zero, the excluded molecular volume itself vanishes rather than the ratio of excluded volume to container volume approaching zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    RT=0.08206×273.15=22.414 L⋅atm/mol  ⟹  B=0.0238−0.034622.414=0.02226 L/mol  ⟹  Z=1+0.02226×(50022.414)=1.50RT = 0.08206 \times 273.15 = 22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol} \implies B = 0.0238 - \frac{0.0346}{22.414} = 0.02226\text{ L/mol} \implies Z = 1 + 0.02226 \times \left(\frac{500}{22.414}\right) = 1.50

  2. Step 2

    lim⁡P→0Z=1\lim_{P \to 0} Z = 1

  3. Step 3

    The excluded molecular volume vanishes to 00 because molecules contract at zero pressure.

    Correct

    The intrinsic excluded volume Vexcluded=nbV_{\text{excluded}} = n b remains finite and constant, but the total container volume diverges (Vcontainer→∞V_{\text{container}} \to \infty), so the ratio VexcludedVcontainer→0\frac{V_{\text{excluded}}}{V_{\text{container}}} \to 0.

    Individual helium atoms have a fixed electron cloud radius and do not contract or shrink when external pressure drops. The excluded volume itself remains finite and non-zero; it is the ratio VexcludedVcontainer\frac{V_{\text{excluded}}}{V_{\text{container}}} that approaches zero because the total container volume becomes immense.

  4. Step 4

    As P→0P \to 0, the denominator of λ\lambda approaches 00, so λ\lambda approaches infinity.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately carried out the arithmetic for the truncated virial expansion to find Z=1.50Z = 1.50.

You recognized that real gases approach ideal behavior (Z→1Z \to 1) as pressure approaches zero.

You correctly analyzed the functional dependence of the mean free path equation as P→0P \to 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Excluded volume vs. total volume ratio misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the absolute molecular excluded volume (Vexcluded=nbV_{\text{excluded}} = n b) with the relative fraction of volume occupied by molecules (VexcludedVcontainer\frac{V_{\text{excluded}}}{V_{\text{container}}}), attributing the negligible volume effect to physical contraction of the particles rather than spatial dilution across an expanding container.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Invariance of Particle Size
  • The van der Waals constant b=4NAvmoleculeb = 4 N_{\text{A}} v_{\text{molecule}} represents the inherent excluded volume of the particles, which is constant and independent of container pressure.

  • Always treat gas particles as having fixed intrinsic dimensions regardless of changes in macroscopic pressure.

Relative vs. Absolute Volume in Gas Laws
  • The ideal gas assumption that 'particles have negligible volume' means VparticlesVtotal→0\frac{V_{\text{particles}}}{V_{\text{total}}} \to 0 as Vtotal→∞V_{\text{total}} \to \infty, not that Vparticles→0V_{\text{particles}} \to 0.

  • Express the low-pressure limit as a ratio comparing the constant molecular volume to the expanding molar volume.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the total excluded volume: Vexcluded=nbV_{\text{excluded}} = n b, which is a constant determined by the finite physical size of the helium atoms.

  2. Apply the ideal gas limit for container volume: as P→0P \to 0 at constant TT, Vm=Vn≈RTP→∞V_{\text{m}} = \frac{V}{n} \approx \frac{RT}{P} \to \infty.

  3. Compute the ratio: lim⁡P→0VexcludedVcontainer=lim⁡P→0nbnRT/P=lim⁡P→0bPRT=0\lim_{P \to 0} \frac{V_{\text{excluded}}}{V_{\text{container}}} = \lim_{P \to 0} \frac{n b}{n RT / P} = \lim_{P \to 0} \frac{b P}{R T} = 0.

Final answer

The molecular excluded volume VexcludedV_{\text{excluded}} remains constant, while the ratio of excluded volume to container volume approaches zero (limP→0fracVtextexcludedVtextcontainer=0\\lim_{P \to 0} \\frac{V_{\\text{excluded}}}{V_{\\text{container}}} = 0).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical interpretation of van der Waals parameter bb as four times the actual molecular volume.

  • Practice distinguishing between intensive particle properties (molecular diameter, mass) and extensive system properties (container volume, particle density).

  • Complete the targeted flashcards and practice problems on real gas limits.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

For neon gas at T=273.15 KT = 273.15\text{ K}, the van der Waals constants are a=0.211 L2⋅atm/mol2a = 0.211\text{ L}^2\cdot\text{atm/mol}^2 and b=0.0171 L/molb = 0.0171\text{ L/mol}. Given RT=22.414 L⋅atm/molRT = 22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}, calculate the value of the second virial coefficient term b−aRTb - \frac{a}{RT}.

Answer

b−aRT=0.0171−0.21122.414=0.0171−0.00941=+0.00769 L/molb - \frac{a}{RT} = 0.0171 - \frac{0.211}{22.414} = 0.0171 - 0.00941 = +0.00769\text{ L/mol}.

02

Nitrogen gas has van der Waals constants a=1.39 L2⋅atm/mol2a = 1.39\text{ L}^2\cdot\text{atm/mol}^2 and b=0.0391 L/molb = 0.0391\text{ L/mol}. At T=273.15 KT = 273.15\text{ K} (RT=22.414 L⋅atm/molRT = 22.414\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm/mol}), calculate ZZ at P=100 atmP = 100\text{ atm} using Z≈1+(b−aRT)PRTZ \approx 1 + \left(b - \frac{a}{RT}\right)\frac{P}{RT}. State whether attractions or repulsions dominate.

Answer

aRT=1.3922.414≈0.0620 L/mol\frac{a}{RT} = \frac{1.39}{22.414} \approx 0.0620\text{ L/mol}. Then b−aRT=0.0391−0.0620=−0.0229 L/molb - \frac{a}{RT} = 0.0391 - 0.0620 = -0.0229\text{ L/mol}. Thus, Z≈1+(−0.0229)(10022.414)=1−0.102=0.898Z \approx 1 + (-0.0229)\left(\frac{100}{22.414}\right) = 1 - 0.102 = 0.898. Because Z<1Z < 1, attractive intermolecular forces dominate.

03

The Boyle temperature TBT_{\text{B}} of a real gas is defined as the temperature where the second virial coefficient vanishes: b−aRTB=0b - \frac{a}{RT_{\text{B}}} = 0. (a) Derive an expression for TBT_{\text{B}} in terms of aa, bb, and RR. (b) Using a=0.0346 L2⋅atm/mol2a = 0.0346\text{ L}^2\cdot\text{atm/mol}^2, b=0.0238 L/molb = 0.0238\text{ L/mol}, and R=0.08206 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K)R = 0.08206\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}), compute TBT_{\text{B}} for helium.

Answer

(a) Setting b−aRTB=0b - \frac{a}{RT_{\text{B}}} = 0 yields TB=abRT_{\text{B}} = \frac{a}{bR}. (b) TB=0.0346(0.0238)(0.08206)≈17.7 KT_{\text{B}} = \frac{0.0346}{(0.0238)(0.08206)} \approx 17.7\text{ K}. At temperatures far above 17.7 K17.7\text{ K} (such as 273.15 K273.15\text{ K}), b>aRTb > \frac{a}{RT}, so helium always exhibits Z>1Z > 1.

Loading workspace…