Resources
A student claims that because enthalpy and internal energy are state functions, the heat exchanged during a process must also be independent of the pathway. To test this counter-intuitive conceptual trap, consider taking 1.00 mole of a monatomic ideal gas (, ) from State 1 (, , ) to State 2 (, , ). Pathway A proceeds via an isobaric expansion to followed by an isochoric pressure increase to . Pathway B proceeds via an isochoric pressure increase to followed by an isobaric expansion to . Calculate the state function change (in ) for both pathways, and calculate the path-dependent heat absorbed and (in ). ()
Answer and steps
Final answer
for both pathways; ,
Steps
Understanding State Functions vs. Path Functions
- Internal Energy () and Enthalpy () are state functions. Their changes ( and ) depend solely on the initial and final states of the system, not on the trajectory taken between them:
- Heat () and Work () are path functions. According to the First Law of Thermodynamics: Because work depends directly on the path taken on a pressure–volume () diagram, the heat absorbed must also vary from one path to another, even when connecting the exact same initial and final states.
Calculation of the State Function Change ()
For an ideal gas, internal energy depends only on temperature:
Given:
- ,
Substitute these values:
Because is a state function and both pathways share the identical initial state () and final state ():
Calculation of Heat Exchanged Along Pathway A ()
In Pathway A, the gas expands and is heated through an intermediate state. Using the First Law of Thermodynamics:
- The baseline internal energy change is .
- Evaluating the boundary work for this expansion path yields:
Adding the work performed to the internal energy change:
Calculation of Heat Exchanged Along Pathway B ()
In Pathway B, the system undergoes an alternate sequence between the same two endpoints.
- Because the expansion occurs at an elevated pressure level, the boundary work performed by the gas over the pathway is greater:
Applying the First Law of Thermodynamics with the state function change :
Conceptual Conclusion
- for both pathways, confirming that internal energy is path-independent.
- and , demonstrating that heat is inherently path-dependent because the work performed along each trajectory is different.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the molar heat capacity at constant pressure with that at constant volume, using Cv for isobaric steps and Cp for isochoric steps.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You inverted the heat capacities for Pathway A: the first step is an isobaric expansion (constant pressure), which requires , while the second step is an isochoric pressure increase (constant volume), which requires .
- Step 3Correct
You inverted the heat capacities for Pathway B as well: step B1 is isochoric (constant volume), so heat absorbed is , and step B2 is isobaric (constant pressure), so heat absorbed is .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the total temperature change between the initial and final states.
You recognized that internal energy change is a state function that depends solely on initial and final temperatures.
You correctly determined the intermediate temperature of for both thermodynamic routes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally switched and , using during constant-pressure expansion and during constant-volume heating.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the physical definitions of the molar heat capacity at constant volume () and constant pressure (). Isobaric processes involve expansion work, so additional heat is required per degree Kelvin (), whereas isochoric processes perform zero boundary work ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify the constant variable in each segment
Isobaric means constant pressure (); isochoric means constant volume ().
Inspect the step name: match the subscript of directly to the held variable ( for pressure, for volume).
- Verify heat capacity magnitude
For an ideal gas, because constant-pressure heating must provide both internal energy and boundary work.
Ensure that the larger heat capacity factor () is paired with the expanding isobaric step, not the rigid isochoric step.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor Pathway A, step 1 is isobaric expansion from to : .
For Pathway A, step 2 is isochoric heating from to : .
Summing Pathway A gives .
For Pathway B, step 1 is isochoric heating from to : .
For Pathway B, step 2 is isobaric expansion from to : .
Summing Pathway B gives .
for both pathways; ,
02 The student incorrectly assumes that heat is a state function equal to the change in internal energy, concluding q_A = q_B = ΔU.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
for both pathways
- Step 2
Since the initial and final states are identical, heat absorbed equals
CorrectYou assumed heat is independent of path and set . Heat is a path function governed by the First Law of Thermodynamics, . Because the gas expands against external pressure during Pathway A, you must add the boundary work performed by the gas to .
- Step 3
Since heat is assumed to depend only on initial and final states,
CorrectThis step carried forward your assumption that heat is a state function. In Pathway B, the expansion occurs at a higher pressure (), meaning the gas performs more boundary work (), resulting in .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified internal energy as a state function that depends only on the initial and final temperatures.
You accurately computed the numerical value of using the constant-volume molar heat capacity.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated heat exchange as a state function equal to , neglecting the boundary work term in the First Law of Thermodynamics ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- State Function vs. Path Function
and depend only on initial and final states, whereas and depend on the specific path taken.
Never set unless the process is explicitly isochoric (rigid container with no non-expansion work, so ).
- Applying the First Law of Thermodynamics
Calculate the work done along the pathway by integrating boundary work, then solve for heat as .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that Pathway A involves work during its isobaric expansion: .
Use the First Law to find : .
Identify that Pathway B expands at higher pressure, doing more work: .
Use the First Law to find : .
for both pathways; ,
03 The student forgets to account for work done during the isobaric expansion steps, calculating heat as nCvΔT across all steps regardless of constant pressure or constant volume.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
The first step of Pathway A is an isobaric expansion where the gas expands against external pressure and does work (). Calculating heat as applies only at constant volume (). For an isobaric step, heat must be calculated using or by including work via .
- Step 3Correct
In Pathway B, the second step is an isobaric expansion at . Using again ignores expansion work; the higher pressure means even more work is performed by the gas, resulting in .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly applied to find the total internal energy change between the initial and final states.
You correctly identified that because is a state function, must be identical across both pathways.
You correctly determined the intermediate temperature for the two-stage pathways.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou applied across all pathway segments, overlooking that expansion steps occur at constant pressure rather than constant volume.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing heat with internal energy change led you to neglect boundary work () during isobaric expansion. Because , heat equals only when (an isochoric process). In an isobaric process, heat must supply both the internal energy change and the expansion work done on the surroundings ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Match Heat Capacity to Process Constraint
For an ideal gas, holds only at constant volume. At constant pressure, .
Check whether volume changes during each sub-step before selecting or .
- Account for Boundary Work via the First Law
, where for an expansion at constant pressure.
Whenever volume increases, write to ensure expansion work is not omitted.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the process type for each segment: Pathway A has an isobaric expansion (, ) followed by an isochoric pressure rise ().
Calculate work for Pathway A: . Then .
Identify the process type for Pathway B: an isochoric pressure rise followed by an isobaric expansion at .
Calculate work for Pathway B: . Then .
for both pathways; ,
Lock it in
How do you choose between using and to calculate heat during an ideal gas process?
Use for a constant-pressure (isobaric) process, and for a constant-volume (isochoric) process. Memory cue: match subscript to pressure and to volume.
Similar question
A sample of of a monatomic ideal gas (, ) is heated from to at a constant pressure of . Calculate the heat exchanged and the change in internal energy in joules ().
Answer
, . Key steps: Because pressure is constant, . For internal energy of an ideal gas regardless of pathway, .
Consider of a monatomic ideal gas taken from to along an isochoric path, followed by isobaric expansion to . Find the total heat absorbed along this two-step path (, , ).
Answer
. Key steps: For step 1 (isochoric), . For step 2 (isobaric), . Total heat (or if calculated from standard states).
An ideal diatomic gas (, ) undergoes two different reversible paths between the same two states and . Path 1 is an isobaric expansion followed by an isochoric heating. Path 2 is an isochoric heating followed by an isobaric expansion. Express the difference in total heat absorbed solely in terms of and .
Answer
. Key steps: Since both paths connect the identical end states, . By the First Law, , so . On a diagram, and . Therefore, .