Resources
Determine whether boron trifluoride () is a polar or nonpolar molecule. In your analysis, state the Lewis structure valence electron count, the steric number and hybridization of the central boron atom, the VSEPR molecular geometry, the polarity of the individual bonds based on electronegativity difference (, ), and explain whether the net dipole moment () is zero or nonzero based on molecular symmetry.
Answer and steps
Final answer
has valence electrons. The central atom has a steric number of (zero lone pairs) with hybridization, yielding a trigonal planar molecular geometry with bond angles. Although each bond is highly polar (), the three equal bond dipole vectors are oriented symmetrically in a single plane and sum to zero by vector addition (). Therefore, has a net dipole moment of and is classified as a nonpolar molecule.
Steps
Valence Electron Count
To determine whether boron trifluoride () is polar or nonpolar, analyze its bonding, geometry, and vector symmetry systematically:
- Boron () is in Group 13 and contributes valence electrons.
- Each fluorine () is in Group 17 and contributes valence electrons.
In the Lewis structure, the central boron atom forms three single bonds with the fluorine atoms, using electrons. The remaining electrons are placed as three lone pairs on each of the three fluorine atoms to complete their octets. Boron has an incomplete octet with six valence electrons, which is stable and typical for Group 13 elements.
Steric Number and Hybridization
- The central boron atom forms single bonds (-bonds) and has lone pairs.
- Steric number (SN):
- A steric number of corresponds to hybridization.
VSEPR Molecular Geometry
- With three bonding domains and zero lone pairs ( system), electron-electron repulsions are minimized when the bonds are oriented as far apart as possible in a single plane.
- Molecular geometry: Trigonal planar
- Bond angles: Exactly
Bond Polarity
The electronegativities are given as and .
Because , each individual bond is strongly polar covalent. Fluorine is significantly more electronegative than boron, so each bond dipole vector points from the partially positive boron atom () toward the partially negative fluorine atom ().
Molecular Symmetry and Net Dipole Moment ()
A common pitfall is to assume that a molecule with polar bonds is automatically polar. Molecular polarity depends on the vector sum of all individual bond dipole moments:
- The three bond dipoles have equal magnitudes because the surrounding atoms are identical.
- The molecule has high geometric symmetry (trigonal planar with identical angles in a single flat plane).
- When two equal dipole vectors separated by are added, their resultant vector has the exact same magnitude as each individual vector but points directly opposite the third dipole vector. Therefore, all three vectors cancel completely:
Conclusion
Because the individual bond dipoles cancel out due to trigonal planar symmetry, the net dipole moment of is , making a nonpolar molecule.
Typical errors
01 The student forces an octet on the central boron atom by adding a lone pair, leading to a trigonal pyramidal geometry and an incorrect polar conclusion.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Boron is a common exception to the octet rule and is stable with an incomplete octet of valence electrons ( bonding pairs). Adding a lone pair to boron would require electrons (), which exceeds your total pool of valence electrons.
- Step 3Correct
Because boron has single bonds and lone pairs, its steric number is , giving hybridization rather than .
- Step 4Correct
An system with zero lone pairs adopts a trigonal planar geometry with bond angles of .
- Step 5
- Step 6Correct
Because is trigonal planar, the three identical bond dipole vectors point toward the corners of an equilateral triangle at angles and cancel completely, giving a net dipole moment of zero.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the total number of valence electrons accurately as .
You correctly found the electronegativity difference between boron and fluorine and identified the bonds as polar covalent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed every non-hydrogen central atom must have an octet, adding an extra lone pair to boron without verifying that it violates the total -electron budget.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Electron Count Budget Check
The sum of all bonding and lone pair electrons in the completed Lewis structure must strictly equal the total valence electron count.
Always recount all drawn electrons: . Adding a lone pair to boron would make , which is impossible.
- Incomplete Octet Exception
Group 13 central atoms (like and ) and Group 2 atoms (like ) routinely form stable electron-deficient neutral molecules with only (or ) valence electrons.
Do not force a lone pair or double bond onto a neutral boron atom when bonded to halogens; leave boron with single bonds and lone pairs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDraw the central atom single-bonded to three atoms. Complete the octet on each atom with lone pairs (). All valence electrons are now accounted for (), leaving lone pairs on .
Determine the steric number: , which corresponds to hybridization.
Determine the molecular geometry: with an arrangement, the molecular shape is trigonal planar with bond angles of .
Sum the dipole vectors: three equal bond dipoles oriented symmetrically at in a single plane cancel out completely ().
has a net dipole moment of and is nonpolar.
02 The student incorrectly assumes any molecule containing strongly polar bonds must be polar overall, ignoring dipole cancellation by symmetry.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4
- Step 5Correct
You treated molecular polarity as a simple scalar sum of bond polarities rather than a vector sum. In a symmetric trigonal planar molecule with three identical terminal atoms, the three equal bond dipoles oriented at cancel out completely, resulting in a net dipole moment of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the 24 valence electrons and established the correct Lewis connectivity for .
You accurately found the steric number of 3 and assigned hybridization to boron.
You correctly determined that an electron geometry corresponds to a trigonal planar shape.
You correctly computed and identified that the bonds are polar.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeAssuming that the presence of polar bonds guarantees a nonzero net dipole moment for the molecule.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou evaluated molecular polarity solely from bond electronegativity differences without performing vector addition on the bond dipole moments according to molecular geometry and symmetry.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Vector Cancellation in Symmetric Geometries
A molecule with identical terminal atoms and no lone pairs on the central atom (e.g., linear , trigonal planar , tetrahedral ) has symmetric bond dipoles that sum to zero ().
Always draw the 3D geometry with dipole vectors pointing toward the more electronegative atoms, and check if vector symmetry cancels the net dipole moment before declaring the molecule polar.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationOrient the three equal bond dipole vectors in the trigonal planar geometry at angles of apart in a single plane.
Compute the vector sum of any two dipole vectors: their resultant has a magnitude equal to one bond dipole and points directly opposite the third bond dipole.
Add the third dipole vector to this resultant: .
has a net dipole moment of and is a nonpolar molecule.
03 The student confuses molecular geometry with electron geometry by misinterpreting a three-coordinate system as T-shaped, concluding the dipoles do not cancel.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
A central atom with bonding domains and lone pairs (an arrangement) adopts a trigonal planar geometry with bond angles. T-shaped geometry occurs only when there is a steric number of with bonding pairs and lone pairs (an arrangement, such as ).
- Step 4
- Step 5Correct
Because of your earlier geometry error, you evaluated vector symmetry for a T-shaped molecule. In the actual trigonal planar geometry, the three equal bond dipoles are oriented symmetrically at in a single plane, so they sum to zero and make nonpolar.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the valence electrons.
You accurately identified that boron has a steric number of with no lone pairs.
You correctly linked the steric number of to hybridization.
You properly calculated to classify the bonds as polar.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the three-coordinate geometry derived from steric number 3 (trigonal planar, ) with the three-coordinate geometry derived from steric number 5 (T-shaped, ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Steric Number vs. Molecular Geometry
For a central atom with and lone pairs (formula ), electron repulsions push the three electron domains into a single plane separated by , giving a trigonal planar geometry.
Always determine geometry by first identifying total electron pairs (steric number), then subtracting lone pairs. Reserve T-shaped only for systems with electron domains.
- Trigonal Planar Dipole Cancellation
Three identical bond dipoles oriented at in a single plane cancel completely by vector addition ().
When surrounding atoms are identical and arranged symmetrically in a trigonal planar frame, conclude that and the molecule is nonpolar.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSteric number is with lone pairs on , which corresponds to an system.
An system adopts a trigonal planar molecular geometry with bond angles of .
The three equal bond dipole vectors point toward the fluorines at in a flat plane.
Adding these three equal coplanar vectors gives a net vector sum of zero: .
has a net dipole moment of and is a nonpolar molecule.
Lock it in
How many valence electrons does a neutral boron atom typically share in stable trihalides like or ?
Six valence electrons ( single bonds, lone pairs). Boron is a Group 13 element with a stable incomplete octet.
Similar question
Determine whether beryllium difluoride (, gas phase) is polar or nonpolar. State the valence electron count, molecular geometry, and whether bond dipoles cancel.
Answer
has valence electrons. Beryllium has an incomplete octet with single bonds and lone pairs (). The molecular geometry is linear (). The two equal bond dipoles point in opposite directions and cancel completely (), making nonpolar ().
Compare and : identify the steric number, molecular geometry, and overall molecular polarity for each.
Answer
For (): ( bonds, lone pairs), trigonal planar geometry; symmetric bond dipoles cancel, so it is nonpolar (). For (): ( bonds, lone pair), trigonal pyramidal geometry; asymmetric dipole vectors do not cancel, so it is polar ().
Determine the molecular geometry and polarity of aluminum triiodide () in the monomeric vapor phase. Explain how vector addition dictates its net dipole moment.
Answer
has valence electrons. Aluminum (Group 13) forms single bonds with lone pairs (incomplete octet, ), giving a trigonal planar geometry with bond angles. Because all three bond dipole vectors have equal magnitude and point radially outward in a single flat plane, their vector sum is exactly zero (). Therefore, is nonpolar with .