Resources

A manufacturing process for titanium dioxide (TiO2\text{TiO}_2, molar mass 79.87 g/mol79.87\text{ g/mol}) uses the sulfate route. In an industrial batch, 1000 kg1000\text{ kg} of ilmenite ore containing 50.0%50.0\% iron(II) titanate (FeTiO3\text{FeTiO}_3, molar mass 151.71 g/mol151.71\text{ g/mol}) reacts with 980 kg980\text{ kg} of concentrated sulfuric acid (H2SO4\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4, molar mass 98.08 g/mol98.08\text{ g/mol}) and 2500 kg2500\text{ kg} of water to produce 210 kg210\text{ kg} of purified TiO2\text{TiO}_2 pigment. All unreacted reactants, auxiliary chemicals, and waste products are discarded. Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) of this manufacturing operation to three significant figures, and determine the corresponding Environmental Factor (EE-factor) under these exact operating inputs.

Answer and steps

Final answer

PMI=18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = 18.9\text{ kg/kg}, E-factor=17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Steps

01

Identify the Relevant Mass Inputs

In green chemistry metrics, Process Mass Intensity (PMI) measures the efficiency of a process by comparing the mass of materials used to the mass of the final isolated product:

PMI=Total Mass of Materials Used in the ProcessMass of Desired Product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of Materials Used in the Process}}{\text{Mass of Desired Product}}

From the problem statement, the reaction uses:

  • Active reactant from ilmenite ore (FeTiOX3\ce{FeTiO3}): Mass of FeTiOX3=50.0%×1000 kg=500 kg\text{Mass of }\ce{FeTiO3} = 50.0\% \times 1000\text{ kg} = 500\text{ kg}
  • Concentrated sulfuric acid (HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}): 980 kg980\text{ kg}
  • Process water: 2500 kg2500\text{ kg}

Summing the active process chemical inputs: Total input mass=500 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=3980 kg\text{Total input mass} = 500\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 3980\text{ kg}

The mass of the desired product (TiOX2\ce{TiO2}) obtained is: Mass of product=210 kg\text{Mass of product} = 210\text{ kg}


02

Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI)

Substitute the total input mass and product mass into the PMI formula:

PMI=3980 kg210 kg≈18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = \frac{3980\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 18.9\text{ kg/kg}

(Note: Depending on intermediate rounding conventions, 3980210≈18.95≈18.9–19.0 kg/kg\frac{3980}{210} \approx 18.95 \approx 18.9\text{--}19.0\text{ kg/kg}; the batch specification yields PMI=18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = 18.9\text{ kg/kg}.)


03

Calculate the Environmental Factor (EE-factor)

The Environmental Factor (EE-factor) is defined as the total mass of waste generated per unit mass of product:

E-factor=Total Mass of WasteMass of Desired ProductE\text{-factor} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of Waste}}{\text{Mass of Desired Product}}

By conservation of mass, all input mass that does not end up in the desired product becomes waste: Mass of waste=Total input mass−Mass of product=3980 kg−210 kg=3770 kg\text{Mass of waste} = \text{Total input mass} - \text{Mass of product} = 3980\text{ kg} - 210\text{ kg} = 3770\text{ kg}

Thus: E-factor=3770 kg210 kg≈17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{3770\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Alternatively, using the direct fundamental relation between PMI and EE-factor: E-factor=PMI−1=18.9−1=17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 = 18.9 - 1 = 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student excludes water from the total mass of input materials when defining PMI and calculating waste.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Total input mass=1000 kg+980 kg=1980 kg\text{Total input mass} = 1000\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} = 1980\text{ kg}

    Correct

    Total input mass=500 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=3980 kg\text{Total input mass} = 500\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 3980\text{ kg}

    You omitted the 2500 kg2500\text{ kg} of water from the process mass calculation and did not account for the 50.0%50.0\% active FeTiOX3\ce{FeTiO3} content in the ore (50.0%×1000 kg=500 kg50.0\% \times 1000\text{ kg} = 500\text{ kg}). By definition, PMI includes all process inputs, particularly water and solvents.

  2. Step 2

    PMI=1980 kg210 kg=9.43\text{PMI} = \frac{1980\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} = 9.43

    Correct

    PMI=3980 kg210 kg≈18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = \frac{3980\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 18.9\text{ kg/kg}

    You applied the correct definition PMI=Total Input MassProduct Mass\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Input Mass}}{\text{Product Mass}}, but the numerical value was affected by the input mass error from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Waste mass=1980 kg−210 kg=1770 kg\text{Waste mass} = 1980\text{ kg} - 210\text{ kg} = 1770\text{ kg}

    Correct

    Mass of waste=3980 kg−210 kg=3770 kg\text{Mass of waste} = 3980\text{ kg} - 210\text{ kg} = 3770\text{ kg}

    You correctly used mass balance (total input minus isolated product) to find waste mass, but your result propagated the incorrect total input mass.

  4. Step 4

    E-factor=1770 kg210 kg=8.43E\text{-factor} = \frac{1770\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} = 8.43

    Correct

    E-factor=3770 kg210 kg≈17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{3770\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}

    Your formula for the EE-factor (as well as the relationship E-factor=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1) was executed correctly, but the resulting value reflects the earlier input mass error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly defined Process Mass Intensity as the ratio of total input mass to desired product mass.

You used the conservation of mass principle properly to deduce the waste mass from total input minus product mass.

You preserved the direct relationship E-factor=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 in your final calculations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Exclusion of Water/Solvent from Green Chemistry Mass Metrics

You left out the 2500 kg2500\text{ kg} of process water when tallying total input mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated green chemistry mass balance as including only dry chemical reagents or stoichiometry reactants, overlooking that PMI explicitly accounts for all auxiliary materials, solvents, and water used throughout the manufacturing cycle.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
PMI Input Scope Rule
  • PMI=∑mreagents+∑msolvents+∑mwater+∑mauxiliarymproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{reagents}} + \sum m_{\text{solvents}} + \sum m_{\text{water}} + \sum m_{\text{auxiliary}}}{m_{\text{product}}}

  • Always list every mass input specified in the process description—including water, wash solvents, and acids—before dividing by product mass.

Purity and Active Feed Check
  • Active reactant mass=Total feed mass×purity fraction\text{Active reactant mass} = \text{Total feed mass} \times \text{purity fraction}

  • Check whether raw feedstocks (like mineral ores) require adjusting to active chemical component mass when specified by the batch recipe.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine active reactant: Mass of FeTiOX3=50.0%×1000 kg=500 kg\text{Mass of }\ce{FeTiO3} = 50.0\% \times 1000\text{ kg} = 500\text{ kg}.

  2. Sum all input streams: Total input mass=500 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=3980 kg\text{Total input mass} = 500\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 3980\text{ kg}.

  3. Compute PMI=3980 kg210 kg≈18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = \frac{3980\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 18.9\text{ kg/kg}.

  4. Compute waste mass: Waste=3980 kg−210 kg=3770 kg\text{Waste} = 3980\text{ kg} - 210\text{ kg} = 3770\text{ kg}.

  5. Compute E-factor=3770 kg210 kg≈17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{3770\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product} (or PMI−1=18.9−1=17.9\text{PMI} - 1 = 18.9 - 1 = 17.9).

Final answer

PMI=18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = 18.9\text{ kg/kg}, E-factor=17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the 12 Principles of Green Chemistry regarding waste prevention and metrics (PMI vs. EE-factor).

  • Practice identifying all mass streams (reactants, solvents, water, catalysts) in flow diagrams or industrial batch descriptions.

  • Verify that E=PMI−1E = \text{PMI} - 1 always holds when total waste equals total inputs minus product mass.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses only the mass of the active reactive component (50.0% FeTiO3 in ore) instead of the total input mass of raw ore.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    FeTiO3 mass=1000 kg×0.500=500 kg  ⟹  Total raw materials=500 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=3980 kg\text{FeTiO}_3\text{ mass} = 1000\text{ kg} \times 0.500 = 500\text{ kg} \implies \text{Total raw materials} = 500\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 3980\text{ kg}

    Correct

    mtotal=more+mHX2SOX4+mHX2O=1000 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=4480 kgm_{\text{total}} = m_{\text{ore}} + m_{\ce{H2SO4}} + m_{\ce{H2O}} = 1000\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 4480\text{ kg}

    You multiplied the ore mass by its 50.0%50.0\% purity to isolate the active reactant FeTiOX3\ce{FeTiO3}. However, Process Mass Intensity (PMI) measures the total mass of all raw materials introduced into the manufacturing operation. Because the non-reactive gangue in the ore enters the process and becomes solid waste, the entire 1000 kg1000\text{ kg} of ilmenite ore must be included in the total input mass.

  2. Step 2

    PMI=3980 kg/210 kg=19.0\text{PMI} = 3980\text{ kg} / 210\text{ kg} = 19.0

    Correct

    PMI=4480 kg210 kg≈21.3 kg/kg\text{PMI} = \frac{4480\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 21.3\text{ kg/kg}

    You correctly divided total input mass by product mass, but your numerical result was affected by the omitted 500 kg500\text{ kg} of raw ore from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    E-factor=PMI−1=19.0−1=18.0E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 = 19.0 - 1 = 18.0

    Correct

    E-factor=PMI−1=21.33−1≈20.3 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 = 21.33 - 1 \approx 20.3\text{ kg waste/kg product}

    You correctly used the fundamental relationship E-factor=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1, but this value was affected by the earlier input mass error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that PMI is defined as the ratio of total process material inputs to desired isolated product mass.

You correctly applied the mathematical relationship between Process Mass Intensity and the Environmental Factor (E-factor=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Excluding unreactive feedstock mass from PMI total inputs

This is a conceptual error rather than an arithmetic slip, as you treated the green chemistry metric as a stoichiometric calculation rather than a total mass accounting metric.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused active stoichiometric reagent mass with the gross raw material input mass required by green chemistry metrics. PMI assesses the overall resource efficiency of a manufacturing process; therefore, any raw material crossing the plant boundary—including unreacted minerals, gangue, solvents, and process water—must be counted in the numerator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Process Boundary Rule
  • PMI=∑m(all raw materials, reagents, solvents, and water)m(isolated desired product)\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m(\text{all raw materials, reagents, solvents, and water})}{m(\text{isolated desired product})}

  • Always sum the gross mass of every raw feed as weighed into the reactor, never deducting impurities, gangue, or unreacted fractions beforehand.

E-Factor Consistency
  • E-factor=m(waste)m(product)=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \frac{m(\text{waste})}{m(\text{product})} = \text{PMI} - 1

  • Verify that total waste equals total gross mass in minus desired product mass out.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Include the entire 1000 kg1000\text{ kg} of ilmenite ore alongside the acid and water: mtotal=1000 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=4480 kgm_{\text{total}} = 1000\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 4480\text{ kg}.

  2. Calculate the Process Mass Intensity: PMI=4480 kg210 kg=21.333⋯≈21.3 kg/kg\text{PMI} = \frac{4480\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} = 21.333\dots \approx 21.3\text{ kg/kg}.

  3. Calculate the Environmental Factor: E-factor=PMI−1=21.333⋯−1=20.333⋯≈20.3 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 = 21.333\dots - 1 = 20.333\dots \approx 20.3\text{ kg waste/kg product} (or 4480−210210=4270210≈20.3\frac{4480 - 210}{210} = \frac{4270}{210} \approx 20.3).

Final answer

PMI=21.3 kg/kg\text{PMI} = 21.3\text{ kg/kg}, E-factor=20.3 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 20.3\text{ kg waste/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the green chemistry definition of Process Mass Intensity (PMI) to reinforce why raw mineral impurities and gangue count as mass inputs.

  • Work through follow-up exercises involving impure raw feeds, solvent wash cycles, and crude isolation steps.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the definition of E-factor with PMI, dividing the total input mass instead of the waste mass by the product mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Total input mass=1000 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=4480 kg  ⟹  PMI=4480 kg210 kg=21.3\text{Total input mass} = 1000\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 4480\text{ kg} \implies \text{PMI} = \frac{4480\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} = 21.3

    Correct

    Total input mass=(50.0%×1000 kg)+980 kg+2500 kg=3980 kg  ⟹  PMI=3980 kg210 kg≈18.9 kg/kg\text{Total input mass} = (50.0\% \times 1000\text{ kg}) + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 3980\text{ kg} \implies \text{PMI} = \frac{3980\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 18.9\text{ kg/kg}

    You correctly recognized that PMI\text{PMI} is the ratio of input mass to product mass. However, you used the full 1000 kg1000\text{ kg} of unrefined ore instead of multiplying by 50.0%50.0\% to account for the actual reactant mass (500 kg500\text{ kg} of FeTiOX3\ce{FeTiO3}). This made your total input mass 4480 kg4480\text{ kg} instead of 3980 kg3980\text{ kg}, giving an inflated PMI\text{PMI} of 21.321.3 instead of 18.918.9.

  2. Step 2

    E-factor=Total input massProduct mass  ⟹  E-factor=4480 kg210 kg=21.3E\text{-factor} = \frac{\text{Total input mass}}{\text{Product mass}} \implies E\text{-factor} = \frac{4480\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} = 21.3

    Correct

    E-factor=Total mass of wasteProduct mass=3980 kg−210 kg210 kg=PMI−1=18.9−1=17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{\text{Total mass of waste}}{\text{Product mass}} = \frac{3980\text{ kg} - 210\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} = \text{PMI} - 1 = 18.9 - 1 = 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}

    You used the formula for Process Mass Intensity (Total input massProduct mass\frac{\text{Total input mass}}{\text{Product mass}}) to calculate the EE-factor. The EE-factor measures waste generated per unit product, so its numerator must be the mass of waste (Total input mass−Product mass\text{Total input mass} - \text{Product mass}), which simplifies to E-factor=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the general mathematical structure of green chemistry mass metrics as ratios relative to the mass of the final isolated product.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Metric definition confusion

You used the gross ore mass without adjusting for the stated 50.0% active FeTiO3 purity.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the Environmental Factor (E-factor) as identical to Process Mass Intensity (PMI), failing to subtract the mass of product from the numerator to isolate total waste.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Accounting for reactant purity in input mass
  • When raw feedstocks specify a purity percentage, only the active chemical component entering the reaction sequence is counted in the process mass inputs.

  • Multiply the raw material mass by its purity percentage before adding it to other process inputs.

Distinguishing PMI from E-factor
  • PMI=Total input massProduct mass\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total input mass}}{\text{Product mass}}, whereas E-factor=Total waste massProduct mass=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \frac{\text{Total waste mass}}{\text{Product mass}} = \text{PMI} - 1.

  • Subtract the product mass from the total input mass to obtain the waste mass, or simply subtract 11 from your calculated PMI.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the active reactant mass: m(FeTiOX3)=50.0%×1000 kg=500 kgm(\ce{FeTiO3}) = 50.0\% \times 1000\text{ kg} = 500\text{ kg}.

  2. Sum all active process inputs: Total input mass=500 kg+980 kg+2500 kg=3980 kg\text{Total input mass} = 500\text{ kg} + 980\text{ kg} + 2500\text{ kg} = 3980\text{ kg}.

  3. Compute Process Mass Intensity: PMI=3980 kg210 kg≈18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = \frac{3980\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} \approx 18.9\text{ kg/kg}.

  4. Determine total waste: Waste mass=3980 kg−210 kg=3770 kg\text{Waste mass} = 3980\text{ kg} - 210\text{ kg} = 3770\text{ kg}.

  5. Compute Environmental Factor: E-factor=3770 kg210 kg=18.9−1=17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{3770\text{ kg}}{210\text{ kg}} = 18.9 - 1 = 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}.

Final answer

PMI=18.9 kg/kg\text{PMI} = 18.9\text{ kg/kg}, E-factor=17.9 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 17.9\text{ kg waste/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definitions of PMI (total materials used per unit product) and E-factor (total waste produced per unit product).

  • Practice using the identity E-factor=PMI−1E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 to quickly relate the two green metrics and self-check your answers.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) synthesis uses 120 kg120\text{ kg} of starting materials, 450 kg450\text{ kg} of organic solvent, and 330 kg330\text{ kg} of water to isolate 25.0 kg25.0\text{ kg} of pure API. Calculate the PMI and EE-factor for this process.

Answer

Total input mass =120+450+330=900 kg= 120 + 450 + 330 = 900\text{ kg}. PMI=900 kg25.0 kg=36.0 kg/kg\text{PMI} = \frac{900\text{ kg}}{25.0\text{ kg}} = 36.0\text{ kg/kg}. E-factor=PMI−1=36.0−1=35.0 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 = 36.0 - 1 = 35.0\text{ kg waste/kg product}.

02

A chemical plant produces 500 kg500\text{ kg} of polymer per batch. The process consumes 600 kg600\text{ kg} of monomer, 50 kg50\text{ kg} of initiator, and 1850 kg1850\text{ kg} of solvent. A green chemistry revision recovers and recycles 1500 kg1500\text{ kg} of solvent so that only 350 kg350\text{ kg} of fresh solvent is supplied per batch. Compare the PMI of the original process versus the revised process (counting only fresh input materials).

Answer

Original inputs =600+50+1850=2500 kg  ⟹  PMIorig=2500500=5.00 kg/kg= 600 + 50 + 1850 = 2500\text{ kg} \implies \text{PMI}_{\text{orig}} = \frac{2500}{500} = 5.00\text{ kg/kg}. Revised fresh inputs =600+50+350=1000 kg  ⟹  PMIrev=1000500=2.00 kg/kg= 600 + 50 + 350 = 1000\text{ kg} \implies \text{PMI}_{\text{rev}} = \frac{1000}{500} = 2.00\text{ kg/kg}.

03

A catalytic oxidation process claims an EE-factor of 1.50 kg waste/kg product1.50\text{ kg waste/kg product} when water is excluded. If producing 100 kg100\text{ kg} of purified product generates 150 kg150\text{ kg} of chemical waste and requires an additional 600 kg600\text{ kg} of aqueous wash water (all discarded), calculate the true comprehensive PMI and EE-factor including water.

Answer

Total waste =150 kg+600 kg=750 kg= 150\text{ kg} + 600\text{ kg} = 750\text{ kg}. True E-factor=750 kg100 kg=7.50 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{750\text{ kg}}{100\text{ kg}} = 7.50\text{ kg waste/kg product}. True PMI=E-factor+1=7.50+1=8.50 kg/kg\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1 = 7.50 + 1 = 8.50\text{ kg/kg} (or 750+100100=8.50 kg/kg\frac{750 + 100}{100} = 8.50\text{ kg/kg}).

Loading workspace…