Resources

A spectroscopist observes a single photon emitted from a hydrogen atom discharge tube with an energy of Ephoton=4.576×10−19 JE_{\text{photon}} = 4.576 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}. The final state of the transition is known to be nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1. (a) Using the Bohr energy formula En=−RHn2E_n = -\frac{R_H}{n^2} with RH=2.179×10−18 JR_H = 2.179 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J}, reverse-engineer the initial principal quantum number ninitialn_{\text{initial}}. (b) According to the quantum mechanical selection rules for electric dipole transitions ($ Δ\Delta l = ±\pm 1),ifthefinalstateisa), if the final state is a 1\text{s}$$ orbital (l = 0),identifywhichspecificsubshell(s)(), identify which specific subshell(s) ( ext{s, p, d, …\dots})theelectroncouldhaveoriginatedfrominthatinitial) the electron could have originated from in that initial nlevel,contrastingthiswiththeBohrmodelwhichhasnolevel, contrasting this with the Bohr model which has nol$ selection rule.$$

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ninitial=3n_{\text{initial}} = 3 (since E1=−2.179×10−18 JE_1 = -2.179 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J} and E3=−2.421×10−19 JE_3 = -2.421 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}, giving ΔE=1.937×10−18 J\Delta E = 1.937 \times 10^{-18} \text{ J}, but specifically solving 1ninitial2=112−4.576×10−192.179×10−18=1−0.2100=0.7900\frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = \frac{1}{1^2} - \frac{4.576 \times 10^{-19}}{2.179 \times 10^{-18}} = 1 - 0.2100 = 0.7900 yields n=1.12n = 1.12, whereas matching to the exact Paschen/Lyman lines gives: for Lyman-33 ($ 3 →\to 1), $$\Delta E = 1.937 ×\times 10^{-18}\text{ J}$$; for n = 4 →\to 2, $$\Delta E = 4.086 ×\times 10^{-19}\text{ J}$$; for an emission of 4.576 ×\times 10^{-19}\text{ J}$$ terminating at n_{final\text{final}} = 2,, n_{initial\text{initial}} = 5); (b) By the quantum mechanical selection rule $$\Delta l = ±\pm 1,transitionsto, transitions to l = 0mustoriginatefromanorbitalwithmust originate from an orbital withl = 1( (porbital,specificallyorbital, specifically5\text{p}$$); the Bohr model assumes any transition between allowed n$ levels can occur because it lacks spatial angular momentum subshells.$$

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Initial Principal Quantum Number (ninitialn_{\text{initial}})

  1. Governing Equation for Photon Emission: According to the Bohr model, the energy of an electron in energy level nn is: En=−RHn2E_n = -\frac{R_H}{n^2} When an electron undergoes a downward transition from ninitialn_{\text{initial}} to nfinaln_{\text{final}}, the energy of the emitted photon equals the difference between the two energy states: ΔE=Einitial−Efinal=RH(1nfinal2−1ninitial2)\Delta E = E_{\text{initial}} - E_{\text{final}} = R_H \left( \frac{1}{n_{\text{final}}^2} - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} \right)
  2. Analysis of the Emitted Energy: Rearranging for the initial level: 1nfinal2−1ninitial2=EphotonRH=4.576×10−19 J2.179×10−18 J≈0.2100\frac{1}{n_{\text{final}}^2} - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = \frac{E_{\text{photon}}}{R_H} = \frac{4.576 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}}{2.179 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J}} \approx 0.2100

    • Physical Transition Identification: In atomic spectroscopy, a photon energy of 4.576×10−19 J4.576 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J} corresponds to visible light (λ≈434 nm\lambda \approx 434\text{ nm}, the Hγ\text{H}_\gamma blue-violet line of the Balmer series). For this physical line, the lower state is nfinal=2n_{\text{final}} = 2: 122−1ninitial2=0.2500−1ninitial2=0.2100  ⟹  1ninitial2=0.0400  ⟹  ninitial=5\frac{1}{2^2} - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.2500 - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.2100 \implies \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.0400 \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 5
    • Comparison with Lyman Series Lines: If the electron were strictly falling to nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1 (the Lyman series), the transition energies are much higher—for instance, the n=3→1n = 3 \to 1 transition has: ΔE=2.179×10−18(1−19)=1.937×10−18 J\Delta E = 2.179 \times 10^{-18}\left(1 - \frac{1}{9}\right) = 1.937 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J} Hence, the integer line matching this specific observed wavelength corresponds to ninitial=5n_{\text{initial}} = 5 (or nominal Lyman identification ninitial=3n_{\text{initial}} = 3).

Part (b): Quantum Mechanical Selection Rules vs. Bohr Model

  1. Application of the Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1 Selection Rule:

    • In quantum mechanics, an emitted electric dipole photon carries an intrinsic spin angular momentum of 1ℏ1\hbar. By conservation of angular momentum, the orbital angular momentum quantum number ll of the electron must change by: Δl=linitial−lfinal=±1\Delta l = l_{\text{initial}} - l_{\text{final}} = \pm 1
    • For any final state in an s\text{s} subshell, lfinal=0l_{\text{final}} = 0.
    • Applying the selection rule: linitial−0=±1  ⟹  linitial=1l_{\text{initial}} - 0 = \pm 1 \implies l_{\text{initial}} = 1 Since l=1l = 1 defines a p\text{p} subshell, the electron must originate specifically from a p\text{p} orbital (such as 5p5\text{p} or 3p3\text{p}). Transitions from s\text{s}, d\text{d}, or f\text{f} subshells directly to an s\text{s} orbital via an electric dipole transition are forbidden.
  2. Contrast with the Bohr Model:

    • Bohr Model: Quantizes only the principal quantum number nn by assuming simple 1D circular orbits. It does not include spatial orbital angular momentum quantum numbers (l,mll, m_l), orbital shapes, or selection rules, predicting that an electron can jump between any two arbitrary nn energy levels.
    • Quantum Mechanical Model: Incorporates three-dimensional wavefunctions (orbitals) characterized by n,l,ml,n, l, m_l, and msm_s. Because transitions must conserve photon angular momentum, transitions are strictly constrained by Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forces the non-integer mathematical result to the nearest integer without recognizing that the given emission energy is unphysical for a hydrogen Lyman transition.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔE=RH(112−1ninitial2)  ⟹  4.576×10−192.179×10−18=1−1ninitial2\Delta E = R_H \left(\frac{1}{1^2} - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2}\right) \implies \frac{4.576 \times 10^{-19}}{2.179 \times 10^{-18}} = 1 - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2}

  2. Step 2

    0.210=1−1ninitial2  ⟹  1ninitial2=0.790  ⟹  ninitial2=1.27  ⟹  ninitial≈10.210 = 1 - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} \implies \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.790 \implies n_{\text{initial}}^2 = 1.27 \implies n_{\text{initial}} \approx 1

    Correct

    1ninitial2=1−0.2100=0.7900  ⟹  ninitial=1.126∉Z+\frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 1 - 0.2100 = 0.7900 \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 1.126 \notin \mathbb{Z}^+; recognizing that a photon emission requires ninitial>nfinaln_{\text{initial}} > n_{\text{final}} and integer nn, this energy cannot belong to the Lyman series (nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1). It physically corresponds to the Balmer line with nfinal=2n_{\text{final}} = 2 and ninitial=5n_{\text{initial}} = 5.

    You carried out the arithmetic to find n2=1.27n^2 = 1.27, but forcing ninitial≈1n_{\text{initial}} \approx 1 is unphysical because an emission to nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1 requires ninitial>1n_{\text{initial}} > 1, and n=1→1n = 1 \to 1 would release zero energy.

  3. Step 3

    Δl=linitial−0=±1  ⟹  linitial=1\Delta l = l_{\text{initial}} - 0 = \pm 1 \implies l_{\text{initial}} = 1, which corresponds to a p\text{p} orbital

  4. Step 4

    The Bohr model does not restrict ll and allows transitions from any orbital

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the Bohr formula relating transition energy to principal quantum numbers.

You accurately manipulated the algebraic expressions to isolate 1ninitial2\frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2}.

You applied the quantum mechanical dipole selection rule Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1 correctly to identify a p\text{p} subshell.

You clearly explained that the Bohr model lacks angular momentum quantum numbers and subshell restrictions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unphysical Quantum Number Rounding

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the principal quantum number nn as a continuous parameter that can simply be rounded to the nearest integer, without checking the physical boundary condition of emission (ninitial>nfinaln_{\text{initial}} > n_{\text{final}}) or evaluating whether the transition energy fits the Lyman series.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Emission Boundary Condition
  • In any photon emission process, the electron loses energy, which strictly requires ninitial>nfinaln_{\text{initial}} > n_{\text{final}}.

  • Check that your calculated ninitialn_{\text{initial}} is strictly greater than nfinaln_{\text{final}}, never equal to or less than it.

Integer Quantization of Energy Levels
  • Principal quantum numbers must be positive integers (n∈{1,2,3,… }n \in \{1, 2, 3, \dots\}). A fractional nn signifies an unphysical or misidentified spectral series.

  • If algebra yields a non-integer such as n=1.13n = 1.13, verify whether the given energy can physically belong to the assigned spectral series (E2→1≈1.63×10−18 J>4.58×10−19 JE_{2 \to 1} \approx 1.63 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J} > 4.58 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Observe that 1ninitial2=0.7900\frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.7900 gives ninitial=10.7900≈1.13n_{\text{initial}} = \sqrt{\frac{1}{0.7900}} \approx 1.13, which is not an integer.

  2. Check the minimum possible photon energy for any emission terminating at nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1: Emin=E2−E1=2.179×10−18(1−14)=1.634×10−18 JE_{\text{min}} = E_2 - E_1 = 2.179 \times 10^{-18}\left(1 - \frac{1}{4}\right) = 1.634 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J}.

  3. Compare the observed energy E=4.576×10−19 J<1.634×10−18 JE = 4.576 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J} < 1.634 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J}, concluding this line cannot terminate at nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1.

  4. Match to the Balmer series (nfinal=2n_{\text{final}} = 2): 122−1ninitial2=0.2100  ⟹  1ninitial2=0.2500−0.2100=0.0400  ⟹  ninitial=5\frac{1}{2^2} - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.2100 \implies \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.2500 - 0.2100 = 0.0400 \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 5.

Final answer

(a) ninitial=5n_{\text{initial}} = 5 (the emission is unphysical for nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1 because n≈1.13∉Z+n \approx 1.13 \notin \mathbb{Z}^+ and E<ΔE2→1E < \Delta E_{2 \to 1}; it corresponds to the Balmer series 5→25 \to 2); (b) By Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1, the transition must originate from a p\text{p} orbital (specifically 5p5\text{p}), whereas the Bohr model lacks orbital angular momentum quantum numbers and allows transitions from any orbital.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always verify that ninitial>nfinaln_{\text{initial}} > n_{\text{final}} for emission and ninitial<nfinaln_{\text{initial}} < n_{\text{final}} for absorption before finalizing your answer.

  • Compute the series threshold (n=2→1n = 2 \to 1 for Lyman, n=3→2n = 3 \to 2 for Balmer) to ensure the observed photon energy falls within the physically allowed range.

  • Practice identifying hydrogen spectral series (Lyman, Balmer, Paschen) directly from photon wavelength or energy ranges.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the selection rule Δl = ±1 as allowing Δl = 0 or misidentifies l values, concluding that the transition can originate from an s orbital.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ephoton=RH(1nfinal−1ninitial)  ⟹  4.576×10−19=2.179×10−18(1−1ninitial2)  ⟹  1ninitial2=0.790  ⟹  ninitial=1.13E_{\text{photon}} = R_H \left(\frac{1}{n_{\text{final}}} - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}}\right) \implies 4.576 \times 10^{-19} = 2.179 \times 10^{-18} \left(1 - \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2}\right) \implies \frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = 0.790 \implies n_{\text{initial}} = 1.13, which is not an integer so no valid level exists

  2. Step 2

    For final state 1s,lfinal=0  ⟹  Δl=±1 means linitial−0=−1 or +1, so linitial can be 0 or 1  ⟹  The electron could originate from s or p subshells\text{For final state } 1\text{s}, l_{\text{final}} = 0 \implies \Delta l = \pm 1 \text{ means } l_{\text{initial}} - 0 = -1 \text{ or } +1, \text{ so } l_{\text{initial}} \text{ can be } 0 \text{ or } 1 \implies \text{The electron could originate from } \text{s} \text{ or } \text{p} \text{ subshells}

    Correct

    lfinal=0  ⟹  linitial−0=±1  ⟹  linitial=1l_{\text{final}} = 0 \implies l_{\text{initial}} - 0 = \pm 1 \implies l_{\text{initial}} = 1 (since l≥0l \ge 0, l=−1l = -1 is unphysical and Δl=0\Delta l = 0 is forbidden), meaning the electron can only originate from a p\text{p} subshell

    An orbital angular momentum quantum number cannot be negative (l≥0l \ge 0). Solving linitial−0=−1l_{\text{initial}} - 0 = -1 would yield l=−1l = -1, which does not exist, and choosing linitial=0l_{\text{initial}} = 0 would give Δl=0\Delta l = 0, which is forbidden by the electric dipole selection rule Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1.

  3. Step 3

    In the Bohr model, transitions can occur from any subshell because l is not defined\text{In the Bohr model, transitions can occur from any subshell because } l \text{ is not defined}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the Bohr transition energy formula to calculate the ratio ΔERH\frac{\Delta E}{R_H}.

You recognized that principal quantum numbers must be positive integers.

You correctly identified that an s\text{s} orbital has an orbital angular momentum quantum number of l=0l = 0.

You accurately explained that the Bohr model lacks angular momentum quantum numbers and selection rules.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Selection rule misapplication

You treated linitial=0l_{\text{initial}} = 0 as an allowed initial state when the final state is also lfinal=0l_{\text{final}} = 0.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You forgot that orbital angular momentum quantum numbers must satisfy l≥0l \ge 0, and you treated Δl=−1\Delta l = -1 as yielding l=0l = 0 instead of recognizing that linitial−0=−1l_{\text{initial}} - 0 = -1 has no physical solution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Quantum Number Range Restriction
  • The orbital angular momentum quantum number ll is strictly a non-negative integer: l∈{0,1,2,…,n−1}l \in \{0, 1, 2, \dots, n-1\}. Negative values of ll do not exist.

  • Discard any algebraic solution to Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1 that results in l<0l < 0.

Electric Dipole Selection Rule
  • For electric dipole transitions, Δl=lfinal−linitial=±1\Delta l = l_{\text{final}} - l_{\text{initial}} = \pm 1. A transition between two s\text{s} orbitals has Δl=0−0=0\Delta l = 0 - 0 = 0, which is forbidden.

  • Check that ∣linitial−lfinal∣=1|l_{\text{initial}} - l_{\text{final}}| = 1. If lfinal=0l_{\text{final}} = 0, the only allowed initial value is linitial=1l_{\text{initial}} = 1 (a p\text{p} orbital).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the final subshell quantum number: for a 1s1\text{s} orbital, lfinal=0l_{\text{final}} = 0.

  2. Apply the dipole selection rule: linitial−lfinal=±1  ⟹  linitial−0=±1l_{\text{initial}} - l_{\text{final}} = \pm 1 \implies l_{\text{initial}} - 0 = \pm 1.

  3. Evaluate the two algebraic cases: linitial=+1l_{\text{initial}} = +1 or linitial=−1l_{\text{initial}} = -1.

  4. Reject linitial=−1l_{\text{initial}} = -1 because orbital angular momentum quantum numbers must satisfy l≥0l \ge 0.

  5. Conclude that only linitial=1l_{\text{initial}} = 1 is physically allowed, corresponding exclusively to a p\text{p} subshell.

Final answer

The electron could originate only from a p\text{p} subshell.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical domain of atomic quantum numbers: n≥1n \ge 1, 0≤l≤n−10 \le l \le n-1, −l≤ml≤+l-l \le m_l \le +l.

  • Practice applying the electric dipole selection rule Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1 to transitions terminating on p\text{p} (l=1l = 1) and d\text{d} (l=2l = 2) subshells to test boundary cases.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A photon of energy E=3.026×10−19 JE = 3.026 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J} is emitted from an excited hydrogen atom. If the electron transitions to nfinal=2n_{\text{final}} = 2, determine the initial principal quantum number ninitialn_{\text{initial}} using RH=2.179×10−18 JR_H = 2.179 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J}.

Answer

ninitial=4n_{\text{initial}} = 4. Key steps: ERH=3.026×10−192.179×10−18=0.1389\frac{E}{R_H} = \frac{3.026 \times 10^{-19}}{2.179 \times 10^{-18}} = 0.1389. Then 1ninitial2=122−0.1389=0.2500−0.1389=0.1111=19\frac{1}{n_{\text{initial}}^2} = \frac{1}{2^2} - 0.1389 = 0.2500 - 0.1389 = 0.1111 = \frac{1}{9}, so ninitial=3n_{\text{initial}} = 3 wait: 0.2500−0.1389=0.1111  ⟹  n2=9  ⟹  n=30.2500 - 0.1389 = 0.1111 \implies n^2 = 9 \implies n = 3. Let's check E=2.179×10−18(1/4−1/9)=2.179×10−18×5/36=3.026×10−19 JE = 2.179 \times 10^{-18}(1/4 - 1/9) = 2.179 \times 10^{-18} \times 5/36 = 3.026 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}. Thus ninitial=3n_{\text{initial}} = 3.

02

An electron in a hydrogen atom occupies the 4d4\text{d} subshell. According to quantum mechanical electric dipole selection rules (Δl=±1\Delta l = \pm 1), to which subshell(s) in the n=3n = 3 level can this electron transition via a single photon emission?

Answer

3p3\text{p} and 3f3\text{f} (if 3f3\text{f} existed; since n=3n = 3 only has s, p, d\text{s, p, d}, only 3p3\text{p} is allowed). Key steps: For a d\text{d} orbital, linitial=2l_{\text{initial}} = 2. Selection rule Δl=lfinal−linitial=±1\Delta l = l_{\text{final}} - l_{\text{initial}} = \pm 1 requires lfinal=1l_{\text{final}} = 1 (p\text{p}) or lfinal=3l_{\text{final}} = 3 (f\text{f}). In n=3n = 3, allowed ll values are 0,1,20, 1, 2, so the only available subshell is 3p3\text{p}.

03

A student claims that an emission line with energy E=1.05×10−19 JE = 1.05 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J} represents a transition ending at nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1. Prove algebraically whether this claim is physically possible, and identify the actual lowest series where such an emission could occur.

Answer

The claim is physically impossible. Key steps: The minimum possible emission energy ending at nfinal=1n_{\text{final}} = 1 is the 2→12 \to 1 transition with ΔE=34RH=1.634×10−18 J\Delta E = \frac{3}{4}R_H = 1.634 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J}. Since 1.05×10−19 J<1.634×10−18 J1.05 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J} < 1.634 \times 10^{-18}\text{ J}, no state n>1n > 1 can emit this photon into n=1n = 1. Comparing with series limits, the Paschen series (nfinal=3n_{\text{final}} = 3) has transitions such as 4→34 \to 3 with ΔE=RH(1/9−1/16)=1.059×10−19 J\Delta E = R_H(1/9 - 1/16) = 1.059 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}, so the transition is n=4→3n = 4 \to 3.

Loading workspace…