Resources

A student attempts to classify four pure substances—NaCl(s)\text{NaCl}(s), SiO2(s)\text{SiO}_2(s), I2(s)\text{I}_2(s), and Fe(s)\text{Fe}(s)—based on electrical conductivity and solubility. The student hypothesizes that: 'Because SiO2\text{SiO}_2 contains polar covalent bonds (Δχ=1.54\Delta\chi = 1.54), it will dissolve in polar water and conduct electricity when molten.' (a) Critique both parts of the student's hypothesis, identifying the exact conceptual error regarding network integrity and charge carriers. (b) State the electrical conductivity of SiO2\text{SiO}_2 in both solid and molten states and its solubility in water at 298 K298\text{ K}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) The student incorrectly conflates polar bond character with discrete molecular polarity and electrolytic behavior. Although the individual Si−O\text{Si}-\text{O} bonds are polar, SiO2\text{SiO}_2 exists as an infinite three-dimensional covalent network; dissolving it would require breaking colossal numbers of covalent σ\sigma bonds, which hydration enthalpy cannot overcome (insoluble in water). Furthermore, molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 does not dissociate into free ions like an ionic solid (NaCl\text{NaCl}); its valence electrons remain localized in covalent bonds, so it lacks mobile charge carriers. (b) SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is an electrical insulator in both solid and liquid states (conductivity σ<10−10 S/m\sigma < 10^{-10}\text{ S/m}) and is insoluble in liquid water at 298 K298\text{ K}.

Steps

01

Network Integrity and Solubility in Water

Part (a): Critique of the Student's Hypothesis

The student's hypothesis confuses the properties of individual polar bonds within a discrete molecule with the bulk thermodynamic and electrical properties of a giant covalent network solid.

  • The Error: The student assumes that having polar bonds (Δχ=1.54\Delta\chi = 1.54 for Si−O\ce{Si-O}) makes the substance behave like a polar molecular substance or an ionic lattice that readily dissolves in water.
  • The Correction:
    • Silicon dioxide (SiOX2\ce{SiO2}, quartz) does not exist as discrete, independent SiOX2\ce{SiO2} molecules held by weak intermolecular forces. Instead, it forms an infinite, three-dimensional network solid where every silicon atom is tetrahedrally bonded to four oxygen atoms via strong single covalent (σ\sigma) bonds, and each oxygen atom bridges two silicon atoms.
    • For SiOX2\ce{SiO2} to dissolve in water, these strong covalent bonds throughout the entire lattice would have to be cleaved. The weak electrostatic attractions (hydrogen bonding and dipole-dipole interactions) formed between water molecules and the disrupted solid cannot release enough hydration energy to compensate for the enormous bond-dissociation enthalpy required to rupture the covalent framework (ΔHsolution≫0\Delta H_{\text{solution}} \gg 0). Consequently, the network remains intact, making SiOX2\ce{SiO2} completely insoluble in water.
02

Charge Carriers and Electrical Conductivity in the Molten State

  • The Error: The student predicts that high bond polarity will cause SiOX2\ce{SiO2} to dissociate into mobile ions upon melting, analogous to ionic solids such as NaCl(l)\ce{NaCl}(l).
  • The Correction:
    • Electrical conduction requires the presence of mobile charge carriers—either freely moving ions or delocalized valence electrons.
    • When an ionic solid like NaCl\ce{NaCl} melts, the ionic lattice collapses into mobile NaX+\ce{Na+} cations and ClX−\ce{Cl-} anions that can migrate under an applied electric field.
    • In contrast, when SiOX2\ce{SiO2} melts at extremely high temperatures (≈1986 K\approx 1986\text{ K}), it forms a highly viscous liquid composed of polymeric, covalently bridged silicate frameworks. The Si−O\ce{Si-O} bonds remain fundamentally covalent, and the valence electrons remain localized in σ\sigma-bonding orbitals and oxygen lone pairs. Because no free ions or delocalized electrons are generated, molten SiOX2\ce{SiO2} cannot conduct electricity.

Part (b): Conductivity and Solubility Properties

  • Electrical Conductivity of SiOX2\ce{SiO2}:
    • Solid state: Electrical insulator (non-conductor).
    • Molten state: Electrical insulator (non-conductor; specific conductivity σ<10−10 S/m\sigma < 10^{-10}\text{ S/m}).
  • Solubility in Water at 298 K298\text{ K}:
    • Insoluble in liquid water.

Common Pitfall

Do not assume that the phrase "like dissolves like" applies to giant covalent networks. The rule applies only to discrete substances where solute–solute intermolecular forces can be replaced by comparable solute–solvent intermolecular forces. Dissolving a network solid requires breaking chemical bonds, not merely overcoming weak intermolecular attractions.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the large electronegativity difference of polar covalent Si–O bonds with ionic bonding, concluding molten SiO₂ conducts via mobile ions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Water cannot break the strong lattice to dissolve it, so it is insoluble. ⟹\Longrightarrow Solubility in water: insoluble.

  2. Step 2

    SiO2\text{SiO}_2 has polar covalent bonds with large Δχ=1.54\Delta\chi = 1.54, so it behaves like an ionic salt upon melting. However, melting breaks the crystal into mobile Si4+\text{Si}^{4+} and O2−\text{O}^{2-} ions that conduct electricity.

    Correct

    Molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 does not form mobile Si4+\text{Si}^{4+} and O2−\text{O}^{2-} ions. It forms a viscous liquid of covalently linked polymeric silicate networks with valence electrons localized in σ\sigma-bonds, lacking mobile charge carriers.

    You assumed that a high electronegativity difference causes covalent bonds to dissociate into free ions upon melting. Covalent network solids retain localized covalent bonding in the liquid state rather than breaking down into discrete ions.

  3. Step 3

    Solid conductivity: non-conductor.

  4. Step 4

    Molten conductivity: conductor.

    Correct

    Molten conductivity: non-conductor (electrical insulator).

    Because no free ions or delocalized electrons are generated in the melt, liquid SiO2\text{SiO}_2 remains an electrical insulator (conductivity σ<10−10 S/m\sigma < 10^{-10}\text{ S/m}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly explained that water cannot overcome the strong network lattice to dissolve SiO2\text{SiO}_2.

You correctly identified solid SiO2\text{SiO}_2 as an electrical non-conductor.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Bond Polarity with Ionic Dissociation in Molten Network Solids

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that a large electronegativity difference (Δχ=1.54Δ\chi = 1.54) causes covalent bonds to behave like ionic bonds upon phase change, resulting in hypothetical mobile cations and anions in the melt rather than recognizing that liquid SiO2\text{SiO}_2 remains a covalently bonded network with localized electrons.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Structure of Molten Network Solids
  • Covalent network solids (like quartz) melt into disordered, covalently bridged polymer-like liquids without producing free ions.

  • Do not assume melting converts polar covalent bonds into mobile ions; verify whether true ionic bonds existed in the lattice.

Requirements for Electrical Conduction
  • Electrical conduction requires mobile charge carriers: either delocalized valence electrons or freely moving ions.

  • Check whether melting generates mobile ions; if bonds remain covalent with localized electrons, the melt is an insulator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that despite polar covalent bonds, SiO2\text{SiO}_2 remains a covalent network when melted at high temperature (≈1986 K\approx 1986\text{ K}).

  2. Note that the molten state consists of disordered, polymeric covalent Si−O\text{Si}-\text{O} frameworks where valence electrons remain localized in σ\sigma-bonding orbitals and oxygen lone pairs.

  3. Conclude that because there are neither mobile ions nor delocalized electrons, molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 cannot carry electric current.

Final answer

Molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is an electrical insulator (non-conductor).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental distinction between ionic lattices (which produce mobile ions upon melting) and covalent network solids (which maintain localized covalent bonds in the liquid state).

  • Practice distinguishing bond polarity from bulk ionic dissociation across intermediate electronegativity compounds such as AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3, SiO2\text{SiO}_2, and BeCl2\text{BeCl}_2.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats SiO₂ as simple discrete polar molecules like CO₂, erroneously predicting it dissolves in polar water while remaining a non-conductor.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is a simple covalent compound with polar bonds, similar to CO2\text{CO}_2.

    Correct

    SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is a giant covalent network solid (macromolecular lattice) in which each silicon atom is bonded to four oxygen atoms in an infinite three-dimensional tetrahedral framework.

    You treated SiO2\text{SiO}_2 as a discrete molecular substance analogous to CO2\text{CO}_2. While carbon forms stable pπ–pπp\pi\text{--}p\pi double bonds to oxygen to form linear O=C=O\text{O}=\text{C}=\text{O} molecules, silicon's larger atomic radius prevents effective pπ–pπp\pi\text{--}p\pi overlap. Instead, silicon maximizes single σ\sigma bonds, forming a continuous 3D network solid.

  2. Step 2

    Because like dissolves like, polar SiO2\text{SiO}_2 molecules dissolve in polar water via dipole-dipole attractions.

    Correct

    SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is insoluble in water because dissolution would require cleaving an enormous number of strong covalent Si−O\text{Si}-\text{O} bonds (bond enthalpy ≈460 kJ/mol\approx 460\text{ kJ/mol}), which hydration interactions with water cannot thermodynamically compensate for.

    Because of the earlier misclassification, you incorrectly applied the molecular 'like dissolves like' heuristic. Giant covalent networks do not dissolve in water because dissolving them requires breaking strong covalent bonds throughout the lattice, not just overcoming weak intermolecular forces.

  3. Step 3

    It does not conduct electricity when molten because it consists of neutral molecules without free ions.

    Correct

    Molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 does not conduct electricity because it remains a viscous covalent network with electrons localized in σ\sigma-bonding orbitals and oxygen lone pairs, lacking mobile ions or delocalized electrons.

    You reached the correct conclusion that molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is a non-conductor, but your reasoning incorrectly assumed the melt consists of discrete neutral molecules rather than a polymeric network of covalently bonded atoms with localized electrons.

  4. Step 4

    Solid conductivity: non-conductor.   ⟹  \implies Molten conductivity: non-conductor.   ⟹  \implies Solubility in water: soluble.

    Correct

    Solid conductivity: non-conductor.   ⟹  \implies Molten conductivity: non-conductor.   ⟹  \implies Solubility in water: insoluble.

    You correctly stated the electrical conductivity for both states, but your claim that SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is soluble in water is incorrect due to its giant covalent lattice structure.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that SiO2\text{SiO}_2 contains polar covalent bonds.

You correctly concluded that SiO2\text{SiO}_2 does not conduct electricity in either the solid or molten state.

You correctly recognized that electrical conduction in a liquid requires mobile charge carriers such as free ions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating covalent network solids with discrete molecular substances

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the macroscopic chemical formula SiO2\text{SiO}_2 with a discrete triatomic molecule like CO2\text{CO}_2, leading you to evaluate solubility and state properties using intermolecular force rules ('like dissolves like') rather than covalent network bond dissociation energetics.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Network Solids from Molecular Compounds
  • Group 14 oxides diverge down the group: CO2\text{CO}_2 forms discrete nonpolar molecules held by London dispersion forces, whereas SiO2\text{SiO}_2 forms an infinite 3D covalent network of tetrahedral SiO4\text{SiO}_4 units.

  • Always classify quartz/silica (SiO2\text{SiO}_2), diamond, graphite, and SiC\text{SiC} as covalent network solids rather than molecular substances.

Thermodynamics of Network Dissolution
  • The 'like dissolves like' rule applies only when solute–solute intermolecular forces can be replaced by comparable solute–solvent intermolecular forces; it never applies to covalent networks.

  • Recognize that dissolving a network solid requires cleaving covalent bonds (high ΔHlattice/bond\Delta H_{\text{lattice/bond}}), which solvation enthalpy cannot overcome, making network solids insoluble in all common solvents.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that SiO2\text{SiO}_2 forms an infinite 3D lattice where each Si\text{Si} atom is covalently bonded to four O\text{O} atoms, and each O\text{O} bridges two Si\text{Si} atoms.

  2. Critique solubility: dissolving SiO2\text{SiO}_2 would require breaking strong Si−O\text{Si}-\text{O} covalent bonds throughout the network. Hydration of surface sites releases far too little energy to cleave these bonds, so the network remains intact and insoluble.

  3. Critique molten conductivity: melting breaks some bonds to form a viscous liquid of linked silicate fragments, but the bonding remains fundamentally covalent with localized valence electrons and no mobile ions; hence, it cannot conduct electricity.

  4. State properties: solid SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is a non-conductor (insulator), molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is a non-conductor (insulator), and SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is insoluble in liquid water at 298 K298\text{ K}.

Final answer

(a) The student confuses bond polarity with molecular polarity and network behavior. SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is an infinite 3D covalent network; dissolving it requires breaking colossal numbers of strong covalent bonds, which hydration cannot overcome (insoluble). In the molten state, bonding remains covalent with localized electrons, producing no mobile ions or delocalized charge carriers. (b) Solid conductivity: insulator; molten conductivity: insulator; solubility in water at 298 K298\text{ K}: insoluble.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the structural differences between second-period oxides (CO2\text{CO}_2, discrete molecular) and third-period oxides (SiO2\text{SiO}_2, giant covalent network).

  • Practice identifying the required energy barrier for dissolving different solid types (molecular vs. ionic vs. covalent network).

  • Work through the follow-up flashcards and practice problems below to master network solid properties.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Silicon carbide, SiC(s)\text{SiC}(s), has polar covalent bonds with Δχ=0.65Δ\chi = 0.65 and forms a network lattice analogous to diamond. Predict its electrical conductivity in the solid and liquid states, and state whether it dissolves in water.

Answer

Non-conductor in both solid and liquid states; insoluble in water. SiC\text{SiC} is a covalent network solid without delocalized electrons or ions, and water cannot overcome its strong covalent lattice.

02

Compare the electrical conductivity of molten Al2O3\text{Al}_2\text{O}_3 and molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2. Explain the difference based on their bonding and mobile charge carriers.

Answer

Molten Al2O3\text{Al}_2\text{O}_3 conducts electricity, while molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 is an insulator. Al2O3\text{Al}_2\text{O}_3 has predominant ionic character and dissociates into mobile Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} and O2−\text{O}^{2-} ions upon melting. In contrast, molten SiO2\text{SiO}_2 retains localized covalent Si−O\text{Si}-\text{O} frameworks with no free ions.

03

A substance XX melts at 1200∘C1200^\circ\text{C} to give a non-conducting liquid, while substance YY melts at 801∘C801^\circ\text{C} to give a highly conducting liquid. Both are insulators as solids. Classify the bonding type and crystal structure of XX and YY.

Answer

XX is a covalent network solid; YY is an ionic solid. Covalent network solids retain localized covalent bonds without ions in the melt, whereas ionic lattices dissociate into freely migrating ions when molten.

Loading workspace…