Resources

A green pesticide manufacturer evaluates a catalytic hydrogenation step carried out in an ethanol solvent. In a pilot test, 45.0 mmol45.0\text{ mmol} of an alkene substrate (molar mass 154.2 g/mol154.2\text{ g/mol}) is dissolved in 250 mL250\text{ mL} of ethanol (density 0.789 g/mL0.789\text{ g/mL}) along with 150 mg150\text{ mg} of a recyclable heterogeneous palladium catalyst. Hydrogen gas is charged at 5.00 bar5.00\text{ bar} into the reactor headspace. After reaction completion, 41.8 mmol41.8\text{ mmol} of the saturated alkane product (molar mass 156.2 g/mol156.2\text{ g/mol}) is isolated. Assuming the heterogeneous catalyst and 92.0%92.0\% of the ethanol solvent are recovered and recycled for the next cycle, calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) of this pilot operation (defined as total mass of non-recycled inputs per mass of isolated product) to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

PMI=3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

Steps

01

Definition of Process Mass Intensity (PMI)

Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) is a key metric in green chemistry that quantifies the material efficiency of a chemical process. It is defined as:

PMI=Total mass of non-recycled raw materials and inputsMass of isolated final product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total mass of non-recycled raw materials and inputs}}{\text{Mass of isolated final product}}

Because PMI\text{PMI} is a mass-to-mass ratio, it can be expressed equivalently in g input/g product\text{g input/g product} or kg input/kg product\text{kg input/kg product}.


02

Calculate the Mass of Isolated Product

The reaction yields 41.8 mmol41.8\text{ mmol} of the saturated alkane product (M=156.2 g/molM = 156.2\text{ g/mol}):

mproduct=41.8 mmol×10−3 mol/mmol×156.2 g/mol=6.529 gm_{\text{product}} = 41.8\text{ mmol} \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol/mmol} \times 156.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.529\text{ g}


03

Determine the Mass of Non-Recycled Inputs

  1. Alkene Substrate:
    The entire initial charge of alkene is introduced into the process: malkene=45.0 mmol×10−3 mol/mmol×154.2 g/mol=6.939 gm_{\text{alkene}} = 45.0\text{ mmol} \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol/mmol} \times 154.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.939\text{ g}
  2. Ethanol Solvent (Non-recycled portion):
    The total mass of ethanol charged is: mEtOH, total=250 mL×0.789 g/mL=197.25 gm_{\text{EtOH, total}} = 250\text{ mL} \times 0.789\text{ g/mL} = 197.25\text{ g} Since 92.0%92.0\% of the ethanol is recovered and recycled, the non-recycled (lost) solvent that must be made up per cycle is 100%−92.0%=8.0%100\% - 92.0\% = 8.0\%: mEtOH, lost=197.25 g×0.080=15.78 gm_{\text{EtOH, lost}} = 197.25\text{ g} \times 0.080 = 15.78\text{ g}
  3. Catalyst and Hydrogen Gas:

    • The pilot batch utilizes 150 mg=0.150 g150\text{ mg} = 0.150\text{ g} of catalyst.
    • The hydrogen gas (HX2\ce{H2}) stoichiometrically consumed to form 41.8 mmol41.8\text{ mmol} of alkane has a mass of: mHX2=41.8 mmol×10−3 mol/mmol×2.016 g/mol≈0.084 gm_{\ce{H2}} = 41.8\text{ mmol} \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol/mmol} \times 2.016\text{ g/mol} \approx 0.084\text{ g}

Summing the non-recycled mass contributions: minputs, net=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g+0.084 g≈22.95 gm_{\text{inputs, net}} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} + 0.084\text{ g} \approx 22.95\text{ g}

(Using rounded values to three significant figures: 6.94 g+15.8 g+0.15 g=22.89 g≈22.9 g6.94\text{ g} + 15.8\text{ g} + 0.15\text{ g} = 22.89\text{ g} \approx 22.9\text{ g}.)


04

Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI)

Substitute the net input mass and product mass into the PMI\text{PMI} equation:

PMI=22.95 g6.529 g≈3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = \frac{22.95\text{ g}}{6.529\text{ g}} \approx 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

Rounding to three significant figures gives PMI=3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student includes the total mass of the solvent instead of only the non-recycled portion, vastly overestimating the PMI.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mass of substrate=0.0450 mol×154.2 g/mol=6.939 g\text{mass of substrate} = 0.0450\text{ mol} \times 154.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.939\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    mass of ethanol=250 mL×0.789 g/mL=197.25 g\text{mass of ethanol} = 250\text{ mL} \times 0.789\text{ g/mL} = 197.25\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    total non-recycled inputs=6.939 g+197.25 g=204.19 g\text{total non-recycled inputs} = 6.939\text{ g} + 197.25\text{ g} = 204.19\text{ g}

    Correct

    mEtOH, lost=197.25 g×(1−0.920)=15.78 g  ⟹  minputs, net=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g+0.084 g=22.95 gm_{\text{EtOH, lost}} = 197.25\text{ g} \times (1 - 0.920) = 15.78\text{ g} \implies m_{\text{inputs, net}} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} + 0.084\text{ g} = 22.95\text{ g}

    You treated the entire solvent charge (197.25 g197.25\text{ g}) as consumed input. Because 92.0%92.0\% of the ethanol is recovered and reused, only the lost portion (100%−92.0%=8.0%100\% - 92.0\% = 8.0\%, or 15.78 g15.78\text{ g}) counts as a non-recycled mass input per cycle, alongside the catalyst and consumed HX2\ce{H2}.

  4. Step 4

    mass of product=0.0418 mol×156.2 g/mol=6.529 g\text{mass of product} = 0.0418\text{ mol} \times 156.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.529\text{ g}

  5. Step 5

    PMI=204.19 g/6.529 g=31.3\text{PMI} = 204.19\text{ g} / 6.529\text{ g} = 31.3

    Correct

    PMI=22.95 g6.529 g=3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = \frac{22.95\text{ g}}{6.529\text{ g}} = 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

    Your division followed the correct formula for Process Mass Intensity, but the numerical result was inflated because of the unadjusted solvent mass in Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the masses of both the starting substrate and the isolated product using their molar quantities.

You correctly converted the volume of liquid solvent to total mass using the given density.

You set up the ratio for Process Mass Intensity as total input mass divided by isolated product mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Failure to deduct recycled solvent in PMI calculation

You used the total charged solvent mass instead of multiplying by the make-up fraction (1−recovery rate)(1 - \text{recovery rate}) for the recycled solvent.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the definition of non-recycled inputs in green chemistry metrics. Solvents and catalysts that are recovered and reused in subsequent batches do not count as net consumable mass inputs in steady-state PMI calculations.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for Solvent Recycling
  • When a percentage RR of solvent is recycled, the net input required per batch is only the make-up solvent: msolvent, net=msolvent, total×(1−R)m_{\text{solvent, net}} = m_{\text{solvent, total}} \times (1 - R).

  • Always multiply total solvent mass by (1−fraction recovered)(1 - \text{fraction recovered}) before summing the input materials.

Include All Consumed Reagents
  • Every stoichiometric reactant entering the isolated product (such as gaseous HX2\ce{H2}) and any non-recovered catalyst mass must be included in the total input mass.

  • Check the chemical equation to ensure stoichiometric gases and catalysts are factored into the input total.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the non-recycled solvent loss: mEtOH, lost=197.25 g×0.080=15.78 gm_{\text{EtOH, lost}} = 197.25\text{ g} \times 0.080 = 15.78\text{ g}.

  2. Add the mass of stoichiometric hydrogen consumed: mHX2=0.0418 mol×2.016 g/mol=0.084 gm_{\ce{H2}} = 0.0418\text{ mol} \times 2.016\text{ g/mol} = 0.084\text{ g}, plus the catalyst charge (0.150 g0.150\text{ g}).

  3. Sum all net inputs: minputs, net=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g+0.084 g=22.95 gm_{\text{inputs, net}} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} + 0.084\text{ g} = 22.95\text{ g}.

  4. Compute PMI: PMI=22.95 g6.529 g=3.51\text{PMI} = \frac{22.95\text{ g}}{6.529\text{ g}} = 3.51.

Final answer

PMI=3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between simple batch PMI and steady-state recycled PMI.

  • Practice identifying all chemical inputs, including stoichiometric gases and make-up solvents, in green process metrics.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly takes 92.0% of the ethanol mass as the input rather than the 8.0% that was consumed and not recycled.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mass of substrate=0.0450 mol×154.2 g/mol=6.939 g\text{mass of substrate} = 0.0450\text{ mol} \times 154.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.939\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    mass of ethanol=250 mL×0.789 g/mL=197.25 g\text{mass of ethanol} = 250\text{ mL} \times 0.789\text{ g/mL} = 197.25\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    non-recycled ethanol=197.25 g×0.920=181.47 g\text{non-recycled ethanol} = 197.25\text{ g} \times 0.920 = 181.47\text{ g}

    Correct

    mEtOH, lost=197.25 g×(1−0.920)=197.25 g×0.080=15.78 gm_{\text{EtOH, lost}} = 197.25\text{ g} \times (1 - 0.920) = 197.25\text{ g} \times 0.080 = 15.78\text{ g}

    Because 92.0%92.0\% of the ethanol is recovered and recycled, only the remaining 100%−92.0%=8.0%100\% - 92.0\% = 8.0\% represents the non-recycled solvent input for the cycle. Multiplying by 0.9200.920 gave the recycled mass rather than the waste/make-up mass.

  4. Step 4

    total non-recycled inputs=6.939 g+181.47 g=188.41 g\text{total non-recycled inputs} = 6.939\text{ g} + 181.47\text{ g} = 188.41\text{ g}

    Correct

    minputs, net=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g+0.084 g≈22.95 gm_{\text{inputs, net}} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} + 0.084\text{ g} \approx 22.95\text{ g}

    This sum was carried forward using your incorrect non-recycled ethanol value. Additionally, note that the initial catalyst charge and consumed hydrogen gas also contribute to the inputs.

  5. Step 5

    mass of product=0.0418 mol×156.2 g/mol=6.529 g\text{mass of product} = 0.0418\text{ mol} \times 156.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.529\text{ g}

  6. Step 6

    PMI=188.41 g/6.529 g=28.9\text{PMI} = 188.41\text{ g} / 6.529\text{ g} = 28.9

    Correct

    PMI=22.95 g6.529 g≈3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = \frac{22.95\text{ g}}{6.529\text{ g}} \approx 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

    Your division setup matches the definition of PMI, but the final value was inflated due to the error in step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the mass of the starting substrate from its molar mass and amount.

You used the density of ethanol properly to determine the total mass of solvent charged.

You accurately found the mass of isolated alkane product.

You correctly set up the ratio of input mass to product mass according to the PMI definition.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Recycle vs. Loss Fraction Confusion

You multiplied the total solvent mass by the recovery percentage (92.0%92.0\%) instead of the loss/make-up percentage (8.0%8.0\%).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the recycled/recovered fraction (RR) with the non-recycled or lost fraction (1−R1 - R) when calculating net material inputs for green chemistry metrics.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recycled vs. Non-Recycled Fraction
  • If a solvent or reagent has a recovery rate of RR, the fraction that must be replaced (non-recycled) is 1−R1 - R.

  • Always check whether a percentage represents the recovered material or the unrecovered waste before multiplying.

Accounting for All Inputs in PMI
  • PMI=∑mnon-recycled inputsmisolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{non-recycled inputs}}}{m_{\text{isolated product}}}.

  • Ensure all non-recycled chemical inputs (substrate, unrecovered solvent, reagent gases, and any net catalyst make-up) are summed in the numerator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the non-recycled fraction of ethanol: 100%−92.0%=8.0%=0.080100\% - 92.0\% = 8.0\% = 0.080.

  2. Calculate non-recycled ethanol mass: mEtOH, lost=197.25 g×0.080=15.78 gm_{\text{EtOH, lost}} = 197.25\text{ g} \times 0.080 = 15.78\text{ g}.

  3. Include the stoichiometric hydrogen consumed: mHX2=0.0418 mol×2.016 g/mol≈0.084 gm_{\ce{H2}} = 0.0418\text{ mol} \times 2.016\text{ g/mol} \approx 0.084\text{ g} and catalyst (0.150 g0.150\text{ g}).

  4. Sum all non-recycled input masses: minputs, net=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g+0.084 g=22.95 gm_{\text{inputs, net}} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} + 0.084\text{ g} = 22.95\text{ g}.

  5. Compute PMI: PMI=22.95 g6.529 g≈3.51\text{PMI} = \frac{22.95\text{ g}}{6.529\text{ g}} \approx 3.51.

Final answer

PMI=3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between 'percent recovered' and 'percent lost' in process flow problems.

  • Solve the targeted flashcards on recycling fractions and PMI calculations below.

  • Work through the progressive practice problems to solidify accounting for solvent recovery.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student includes the recyclable catalyst mass in the non-recycled input total despite it being completely recovered and recycled.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mass of substrate=0.0450 mol×154.2 g/mol=6.939 g\text{mass of substrate} = 0.0450\text{ mol} \times 154.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.939\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    mass of ethanol=250 mL×0.789 g/mL=197.25 g  ⟹  non-recycled ethanol=197.25 g×0.080=15.78 g\text{mass of ethanol} = 250\text{ mL} \times 0.789\text{ g/mL} = 197.25\text{ g} \implies \text{non-recycled ethanol} = 197.25\text{ g} \times 0.080 = 15.78\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    catalyst mass=0.150 g  ⟹  total non-recycled inputs=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g=22.87 g\text{catalyst mass} = 0.150\text{ g} \implies \text{total non-recycled inputs} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} = 22.87\text{ g}

    Correct

    minputs, net=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g+0.084 g=22.95 gm_{\text{inputs, net}} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} + 0.084\text{ g} = 22.95\text{ g}

    You omitted the mass of hydrogen gas (HX2\ce{H2}) consumed during the hydrogenation. Forming 41.8 mmol41.8\text{ mmol} of alkane requires at least 41.8 mmol41.8\text{ mmol} of HX2\ce{H2}, which contributes 0.0418 mol×2.016 g/mol≈0.084 g0.0418\text{ mol} \times 2.016\text{ g/mol} \approx 0.084\text{ g} of consumed mass input.

  4. Step 4

    mass of product=0.0418 mol×156.2 g/mol=6.529 g\text{mass of product} = 0.0418\text{ mol} \times 156.2\text{ g/mol} = 6.529\text{ g}

  5. Step 5

    PMI=22.87 g/6.529 g=3.50\text{PMI} = 22.87\text{ g} / 6.529\text{ g} = 3.50

    Correct

    PMI=22.95 g6.529 g≈3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = \frac{22.95\text{ g}}{6.529\text{ g}} \approx 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

    You set up the PMI ratio correctly, but your numerical value was slightly off due to the missing hydrogen gas mass in Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted millimoles of organic substrate and product into grams using their molar masses.

You properly accounted for the 92.0%92.0\% solvent recovery rate to find the net non-recycled ethanol mass.

You set up the PMI definition correctly as the ratio of total input mass to isolated product mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Gaseous Reagent Mass in PMI

No, this is a conceptual oversight where gaseous reactants in the headspace were excluded from material mass accounting.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When calculating green chemistry mass metrics such as Process Mass Intensity (PMI), all raw materials consumed in the transformation must be included. Because gaseous reactants like HX2\ce{H2} are supplied by pressure rather than weighed on a benchtop balance, they are frequently forgotten in mass balance accounting.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Include All Chemical Reactants
  • PMI=∑mraw materialsmass of isolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{raw materials}}}{\text{mass of isolated product}}

  • List every stoichiometric reagent consumed in the reaction—including gases like HX2\ce{H2}, OX2\ce{O2}, or CO\ce{CO}—and add their masses to the input total.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the stoichiometric mass of consumed hydrogen gas: mHX2=0.0418 mol×2.016 g/mol=0.0843 gm_{\ce{H2}} = 0.0418\text{ mol} \times 2.016\text{ g/mol} = 0.0843\text{ g}.

  2. Recalculate total non-recycled inputs: minputs, net=6.939 g+15.78 g+0.150 g+0.0843 g=22.953 gm_{\text{inputs, net}} = 6.939\text{ g} + 15.78\text{ g} + 0.150\text{ g} + 0.0843\text{ g} = 22.953\text{ g}.

  3. Compute PMI: PMI=22.953 g6.529 g=3.515...≈3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = \frac{22.953\text{ g}}{6.529\text{ g}} = 3.515... \approx 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}.

Final answer

PMI=3.51 kg input/kg product\text{PMI} = 3.51\text{ kg input/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the balanced chemical equation to identify every consumed reactant, especially headspace gases.

  • Double-check each component in your material inventory before summing the total input mass.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A synthesis uses 10.0 g10.0\text{ g} of reactant and 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} of acetone solvent to yield 8.0 g8.0\text{ g} of product. If 95.0%95.0\% of the acetone is recovered and recycled, what is the PMI of the process?

Answer

PMI=1.88\text{PMI} = 1.88. Non-recycled acetone is 100.0 g×(1−0.950)=5.0 g100.0\text{ g} \times (1 - 0.950) = 5.0\text{ g}. Total non-recycled inputs =10.0 g+5.0 g=15.0 g= 10.0\text{ g} + 5.0\text{ g} = 15.0\text{ g}. Then PMI=15.0 g8.0 g=1.88\text{PMI} = \frac{15.0\text{ g}}{8.0\text{ g}} = 1.88.

02

An esterification consumes 60.0 g60.0\text{ g} of acetic acid and 46.0 g46.0\text{ g} of ethanol in the presence of 2.0 g2.0\text{ g} of a solid acid catalyst, isolating 70.4 g70.4\text{ g} of ethyl acetate. The catalyst is 100%100\% recovered and reused. Calculate the PMI of this single-batch operation.

Answer

PMI=1.51\text{PMI} = 1.51. Because the catalyst is completely recovered, non-recycled inputs include only the stoichiometric reactants: 60.0 g+46.0 g=106.0 g60.0\text{ g} + 46.0\text{ g} = 106.0\text{ g}. Thus, PMI=106.0 g70.4 g=1.51\text{PMI} = \frac{106.0\text{ g}}{70.4\text{ g}} = 1.51.

03

A batch reduction uses 25.0 mmol25.0\text{ mmol} of ketone (M=120.0 g/molM = 120.0\text{ g/mol}) in 80 mL80\text{ mL} of isopropanol (density=0.786 g/mL\text{density} = 0.786\text{ g/mL}) with 0.50 g0.50\text{ g} of recyclable Raney nickel. Stoichiometric HX2\ce{H2} (M=2.02 g/molM = 2.02\text{ g/mol}) is consumed with an 88.0%88.0\% chemical yield to alcohol (M=122.0 g/molM = 122.0\text{ g/mol}). If 94.0%94.0\% of the isopropanol and all catalyst are recycled, calculate the PMI to three significant figures.

Answer

PMI=2.95\text{PMI} = 2.95. Mass of ketone =0.0250 mol×120.0 g/mol=3.00 g= 0.0250\text{ mol} \times 120.0\text{ g/mol} = 3.00\text{ g}. Product formed =0.0250×0.880=0.0220 mol= 0.0250 \times 0.880 = 0.0220\text{ mol}, so mass of product =0.0220 mol×122.0 g/mol=2.684 g= 0.0220\text{ mol} \times 122.0\text{ g/mol} = 2.684\text{ g}. Hydrogen consumed =0.0220 mol×2.02 g/mol=0.0444 g= 0.0220\text{ mol} \times 2.02\text{ g/mol} = 0.0444\text{ g}. Total solvent mass =80 mL×0.786 g/mL=62.88 g= 80\text{ mL} \times 0.786\text{ g/mL} = 62.88\text{ g}. Make-up solvent lost =62.88 g×0.060=3.773 g= 62.88\text{ g} \times 0.060 = 3.773\text{ g}. Catalyst loss =0 g= 0\text{ g}. Total inputs =3.00 g+0.0444 g+3.773 g=6.817 g= 3.00\text{ g} + 0.0444\text{ g} + 3.773\text{ g} = 6.817\text{ g}. Therefore, PMI=6.817 g2.684 g=2.95\text{PMI} = \frac{6.817\text{ g}}{2.684\text{ g}} = 2.95.

Loading workspace…