Resources
An introductory chemistry student writes the following orbital diagram representation for the ground-state valence shell of a neutral nitrogen atom (): contains and the three degenerate orbitals are written as . Explain whether this proposed arrangement violates the Pauli exclusion principle, the Aufbau principle, or Hund's rule. What is the correct spin convention required by Hund's rule for degenerate singly occupied orbitals, and what is the consequence of this rule on the atom's exchange energy?
Answer and steps
Final answer
The arrangement violates Hund's rule; it violates neither the Pauli exclusion principle (since no orbital contains two electrons with identical spins) nor the Aufbau principle (since the lowest-energy available subshell is occupied). Hund's rule requires that electrons singly occupying degenerate orbitals must have parallel spins (all or all , represented as ). The parallel-spin alignment maximizes electron exchange energy and keeps electrons spatially separated, thereby minimizing electron-electron Coulombic repulsion and achieving the lowest potential energy state.
Steps
Evaluating the Three Governing Principles
To determine whether the proposed configuration for the valence shell of nitrogen () is valid, examine each electronic rule individually:
- Aufbau Principle:
Electrons fill orbitals in order of increasing energy (). Nitrogen () has 7 electrons: the inner subshell is fully occupied, the lower-energy subshell is filled (), and the remaining three electrons occupy the next available subshell. Because no higher-energy subshell (such as ) is occupied before , the Aufbau principle is not violated. - Pauli Exclusion Principle:
No two electrons in the same atom can possess identical sets of all four quantum numbers (). This requires that each individual spatial orbital can hold a maximum of two electrons, and if two electrons share an orbital, they must have opposite (antiparallel) spins. In the given configuration, the orbital has paired electrons ( and ), and each of the three orbitals holds only a single electron with a distinct magnetic quantum number . Because no single orbital contains electrons with identical spins, the Pauli exclusion principle is not violated. - Hund's Rule of Maximum Multiplicity:
When degenerate orbitals (orbitals of equal energy, such as the three orbitals) are being populated, electrons must occupy them singly with parallel spins before any pairing occurs. In the student's diagram, the three degenerate orbitals contain two spin-up electrons and one spin-down electron (). Because the spins of these singly occupying electrons are not all parallel, the proposed arrangement violates Hund's rule. It represents an excited state rather than the ground state.
Correct Spin Convention Under Hund's Rule
For degenerate, singly occupied orbitals, all unpaired electrons must share the same spin magnetic quantum number: By convention, arrows pointing upward () are standard for the first electron placed in each orbital.
Consequence on Exchange Energy and Stability
Hund's rule is grounded in quantum mechanics and electrostatic repulsion:
-
Exchange Energy: Electrons with identical spins (parallel spins) are indistinguishable and undergo a quantum mechanical phenomenon known as electron exchange. Each pair of parallel-spin electrons lowers the total energy of the atom by an exchange energy term (, where ).
- In the correct parallel configuration (), there are electrons with identical spin, yielding:
- In the student's configuration (), only the two spin-up electrons can exchange, yielding only pair ().
- Maximizing parallel spins maximizes the magnitude of the stabilizing exchange energy.
- Coulombic Repulsion: Because the Pauli principle requires the total electronic wavefunction to be antisymmetric, electrons with parallel spins have a zero probability of occupying the same point in space (known as a Fermi hole). This forces them to remain spatially separated on average, thereby minimizing inter-electronic Coulombic repulsion and achieving the lowest potential energy (ground state).
Typical errors
01 The student confuses Hund's rule with the Pauli exclusion principle, believing any opposite spin alignment in the same subshell violates Pauli's principle.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The configuration violates the Pauli exclusion principle because electrons must have the same spin across the subshell. Aufbau and Hund's rule are satisfied since is filled after with one electron per box.
CorrectThe configuration violates Hund's rule because electrons in degenerate orbitals do not have parallel spins. It satisfies the Pauli exclusion principle (no two electrons share all four quantum numbers) and the Aufbau principle (orbitals are filled in order of increasing energy: ).
You misidentified which rule governs parallel spins across degenerate orbitals. The Pauli exclusion principle only restricts electrons sharing the exact same orbital from having identical spins. Hund's rule of maximum multiplicity governs the requirement that electrons in degenerate orbitals must align with parallel spins.
- Step 2
Hund's rule requires that degenerate orbitals are singly occupied before pairing.
CorrectHund's rule requires that degenerate orbitals are singly occupied by electrons with parallel spins (all , represented as , or all ).
You correctly remembered that orbitals must be singly occupied before pairing, but you missed the essential spin requirement: all unpaired electrons in degenerate orbitals must have parallel spins.
- Step 3
It maximizes exchange energy to achieve the lowest energy state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that ground-state stability in degenerate subshells is driven by maximizing exchange energy.
You correctly identified that the Aufbau principle is satisfied because the orbital is filled before electrons enter the subshell.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the scope of the Pauli exclusion principle with Hund's rule, assuming Pauli requires uniform spin across different orbitals in a subshell rather than opposite spins within a single orbital.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Pauli Exclusion Principle Scope
No two electrons in the same atom can have the same four quantum numbers . Within a single spatial orbital (), electrons must have opposite spins ().
Apply Pauli's principle only to electrons sharing the same individual orbital box, not across separate degenerate boxes.
- Hund's Rule Scope
In degenerate orbitals (same and , differing ), electrons must singly occupy each orbital with parallel spins before pairing begins.
Check for both single occupancy and parallel spin alignment () whenever filling degenerate subshells like , , or .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the Pauli exclusion principle: each orbital contains only one electron, so no two electrons share identical sets of four quantum numbers . Pauli is satisfied.
Evaluate Hund's rule: the three degenerate orbitals are singly occupied, but one electron has spin-down while two have spin-up (). Because spins are not parallel, Hund's rule is violated.
State the required convention: all three singly occupied orbitals must have parallel spins, conventionally written as (all ).
The configuration violates Hund's rule because the singly occupied degenerate orbitals do not have parallel spins. It violates neither the Pauli exclusion principle nor the Aufbau principle. The correct convention requires all unpaired spins to be parallel (), which maximizes stabilizing exchange energy.
02 The student believes Hund's rule only dictates single occupancy of degenerate orbitals regardless of spin direction, thus claiming no rule is violated.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
No principle is violated because 2s is filled first, no single orbital has two identical spins, and each 2p orbital has one electron.
CorrectThe arrangement violates Hund's rule. It does not violate the Aufbau principle because the lower-energy subshell is filled first, nor does it violate the Pauli exclusion principle because no individual orbital contains two electrons with identical spins.
You correctly recognized that the Aufbau principle and Pauli exclusion principle are satisfied, but the arrangement violates Hund's rule because the singly occupied orbitals do not contain parallel spins.
- Step 2
Hund's rule only requires that electrons enter separate degenerate orbitals singly before any orbital is doubly occupied, regardless of whether spins are up or down.
CorrectHund's rule (rule of maximum multiplicity) requires that electrons entering degenerate orbitals singly must have parallel spins, conventionally all spin-up (, represented as ) or all spin-down ().
Hund's rule governs both orbital occupancy and spin orientation; unpaired electrons in degenerate orbitals must have parallel spins to achieve maximum spin multiplicity.
- Step 3
Exchange energy is unaffected because the electrons are in separate orbitals.
CorrectExchange energy is directly dependent on spin alignment. A configuration with parallel spins () produces stabilizing exchange pairs, whereas having antiparallel spins () reduces this to only exchange pair, significantly raising the atom's potential energy.
Exchange energy arises exclusively between indistinguishable electrons of parallel spin; having an antiparallel spin reduces the number of exchange interactions, making the configuration higher in energy than the ground state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly verified that the Aufbau principle was followed by fully filling the lower-energy orbital before the subshell.
You correctly verified that the Pauli exclusion principle was not violated because no single orbital contains two electrons with identical quantum numbers.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeWHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted Hund's rule as only governing spatial single occupancy across degenerate orbitals, overlooking the requirement that unpaired electrons must maintain parallel spins to maximize spin multiplicity and quantum mechanical exchange stabilization.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hund's Rule of Maximum Multiplicity
For degenerate orbitals, the ground state achieves maximum total spin (), requiring all singly occupied orbitals to have parallel spins ().
Always check both the spatial distribution (single occupancy) and the spin directions (all parallel) before concluding Hund's rule is satisfied.
- Exchange Energy Calculation
The number of stabilizing exchange interactions equals , where is the number of electrons with identical parallel spins.
Count electrons with spin and spin separately when determining the number of stabilizing exchange pairs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCheck the spin magnetic quantum number of each electron across the three degenerate orbitals: two have and one has .
Identify that Hund's rule requires parallel spins for all singly occupying electrons ( or ), meaning the given configuration represents an excited state that violates Hund's rule.
Compute the stabilizing exchange pairs: parallel spins yield pairs, whereas the student's configuration yields only pair, proving that exchange stabilization is significantly lowered.
The proposed arrangement violates Hund's rule (while obeying the Aufbau and Pauli principles). Hund's rule requires all unpaired electrons in degenerate orbitals to possess parallel spins (). This alignment maximizes stabilizing electron exchange energy and keeps electrons spatially separated, minimizing inter-electronic Coulombic repulsion.
03 The student misinterprets the effect on exchange energy, thinking parallel spins increase electron repulsion and destabilize exchange energy.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The arrangement violates Hund's rule because the singly occupied 2p electrons have opposing spins instead of parallel spins. Pauli and Aufbau principles are obeyed.
- Step 2
Hund's rule requires all singly occupied degenerate orbitals to contain electrons with parallel spins.
- Step 3
Having parallel spins minimizes exchange energy because like spins repel each other and destabilize the atom.
CorrectHaving parallel spins maximizes the number of exchange pairs (), which maximizes stabilizing exchange energy (lowering the atom's total energy) and creates Fermi holes that minimize inter-electronic Coulombic repulsion.
Exchange energy is a quantum-mechanical stabilizing effect (with a negative energy contribution, ), not a destabilizing one. Parallel spins maximize this stabilizing exchange energy and reduce Coulombic repulsion by keeping electrons farther apart.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that Hund's rule is the only governing principle violated by the configuration.
You accurately recognized that degenerate orbitals must be singly populated with parallel spins under Hund's rule.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou viewed electron spin alignment purely as classical like-charge repulsion that destabilizes the atom, overlooking that exchange energy is an attractive/stabilizing quantum effect and that parallel spins actually reduce average Coulombic repulsion via Fermi holes.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Nature of Exchange Energy
Exchange energy is an inherently stabilizing quantum-mechanical interaction (, where ) between indistinguishable electrons with parallel spins.
Treat exchange energy as a stabilizing energy drop, where having more parallel-spin pairs leads to greater stability.
- Parallel Spins and Spatial Separation
Due to wavefunction antisymmetry, electrons with identical spins cannot occupy the same point in space (Fermi hole), which keeps them separated and lowers Coulombic repulsion.
Remember that parallel spins minimize electron-electron repulsion rather than creating additional destabilization.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount the number of indistinguishable electron pairs with parallel spins: for parallel electrons, there are exchange pairs.
Each pair contributes a stabilizing exchange energy term , so maximizing parallel spins maximizes the stabilizing exchange energy.
Because parallel spins cannot occupy the same spatial coordinates (Fermi hole), they stay farther apart on average, minimizing mutual Coulombic repulsion and achieving the lowest potential energy ground state.
Maximizing parallel spins maximizes the stabilizing exchange energy (more negative potential energy) and minimizes electron-electron Coulombic repulsion, yielding the ground-state stability.
Lock it in
What specific condition does the Pauli exclusion principle impose on an orbital diagram?
Each individual orbital can hold at most two electrons, and they must have opposite (antiparallel) spins: .
Similar question
A student writes the valence configuration of carbon () as with represented as . Which rule is violated, and what is the ground-state diagram?
Answer
Hund's rule is violated because electrons must occupy degenerate orbitals singly with parallel spins before pairing. The correct ground-state diagram is .
Consider an excited state of helium with the orbital diagram . Does this arrangement violate the Pauli exclusion principle or the Aufbau principle? Explain.
Answer
It violates the Aufbau principle because the lower-energy orbital is not fully filled before occupying . It does not violate Pauli because the two electrons are in different spatial orbitals with different principal quantum numbers ( vs. ).
Determine whether the subshell configuration for a species violates the Pauli exclusion principle, Hund's rule, or both.
Answer
It violates both: the second orbital contains two electrons with parallel spins (violating the Pauli exclusion principle), and the third degenerate orbital was left unoccupied while pairing occurred prematurely (violating Hund's rule).