Resources
A saturated solution of lead(II) chloride is maintained at in a beaker: . The equilibrium concentration of lead ions is reported as by mass (assuming solution density , where ). (a) Convert to and calculate the equilibrium concentration of chloride ions in and (). (b) If radioactive tracer is introduced at as of dissolved salt, calculate the expected concentration of tracer in that will incorporate into the solid phase over time, demonstrating dynamic exchange.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; . (b) Because of continuous dissolution and crystallization at equal rates, tracer ions dynamically exchange between phases until the specific activity is uniform; a static state would incorporate zero tracer into the solid crystal lattice.
Steps
Part (a): Determining Equilibrium Concentrations
-
Convert the Concentration of from to For an aqueous solution with density , a concentration of corresponds to . Therefore:
Using the molar mass of lead, :
Converting to molarity ():
-
Calculate the Equilibrium Concentration of The dissolution equilibrium of lead(II) chloride is:
From the stoichiometric coefficients, the dissolution produces moles of chloride ions for every mole of lead(II) ions:
In :
Common Pitfall: Remember to multiply the concentration by for . Students often confuse the stoichiometric factor in the equilibrium expression (K_{\text{sp}} = [\ce{Pb^{2+}][\ce{Cl^-}]^2) with the mole ratio relating ion concentrations directly in stoichiometric dissolution.
Part (b): Dynamic Equilibrium vs. a Static State
- Macroscopic vs. Microscopic Behavior At macroscopic equilibrium, the visible amounts of precipitate and the measured concentrations of dissolved ions remain constant over time. This can appear static from the outside.
-
The Radioactive Tracer Experiment When a radioactive tracer (such as ) is added exclusively to the liquid phase:
- In a hypothetical static state: The forward reaction (dissolution) and reverse reaction (precipitation) would have completely ceased (). In that scenario, all radioactive ions would remain permanently in the aqueous solution, and zero tracer would ever enter the solid precipitate.
- In a true dynamic equilibrium: Dissolution and precipitation occur continuously at equal rates (). Dissolved ions continually precipitate into the crystal lattice of while non-radioactive ions from the solid dissolve into the solution.
- Conclusion Over time, the tracer distributes between both phases until a uniform isotopic ratio is established throughout the system. The observation that tracer atoms incorporate into the solid phase directly proves that chemical equilibrium is dynamic, characterized by ongoing, balanced microscopic exchange rather than an inactive halt of reactions.
Typical errors
01 The student forgets the 1:2 stoichiometry between lead and chloride ions, setting [Cl⁻] equal to [Pb²⁺].
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
From the dissolution equation , each mole of dissolved yields two moles of chloride ions, requiring .
- Step 3
The amount of solid present is not specified, so the tracer distribution into the solid phase cannot be determined.
CorrectBecause continuous dissolution and precipitation occur at equal non-zero rates (), dissolved tracer ions dynamically incorporate into the solid crystal lattice over time, directly demonstrating dynamic equilibrium rather than a static halt.
The problem asks for the conceptual significance of tracer uptake: in a static state, zero tracer would enter the precipitate because all microscopic reaction rates would be zero; in dynamic equilibrium, ongoing forward and reverse exchange incorporates tracer into the solid phase.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou successfully converted the lead ion concentration from parts per million to millimoles per liter using the molar mass of lead.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeSetting by assuming a 1:1 ion ratio instead of applying the 1:2 stoichiometric coefficient from the chemical formula .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the dissolution stoichiometry connecting cation and anion concentrations, and you treated the tracer experiment purely as an indeterminate numerical calculation rather than a foundational test demonstrating that microscopic dissolution and precipitation continue at equilibrium.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Stoichiometric Ion Balance in Saturated Solution
For a salt dissolving in pure water, the ion ratio is .
Always write the balanced dissolution equation and multiply the cation concentration by the mole ratio before reporting the anion concentration.
- Dynamic Nature of Equilibrium via Isotopic Tracers
Macroscopic equilibrium is dynamic (). An isotopic tracer introduced to one phase will always exchange into the other phase over time.
Interpret tracer incorporation into a solid precipitate as physical proof of ongoing microscopic exchange, contrasting it with a static state where microscopic exchange is completely absent.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the balanced dissolution equilibrium: .
Relate the ion concentrations using the reaction stoichiometry: .
Explain the tracer behavior conceptually: because dissolution and crystallization occur simultaneously at equal rates, ions constantly precipitate into the lattice while unlabeled lead ions dissolve, demonstrating a dynamic microscopic balance rather than a static halt.
(a) ; . (b) The tracer continuously exchanges into the solid phase because forward and reverse rates are equal and non-zero (), proving the equilibrium is dynamic rather than static.
02 The student divides by 2 instead of multiplying by 2 when relating [Cl⁻] to [Pb²⁺] from the dissolution equation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Each formula unit of releases two ions for every one ion, so must be double , not half.
- Step 3
The quantity of solid in the beaker is not given, so the equilibrium fraction of tracer entering the solid cannot be calculated.
CorrectIn a dynamic equilibrium, forward dissolution and reverse crystallization occur continuously at equal rates (), so dissolved exchanges into the solid phase until the isotopic ratio is uniform. In contrast, a static state would incorporate zero tracer.
While finding an exact quantitative mass balance requires knowing the solid mass, the key point is conceptual: dynamic equilibrium features continuous microscopic exchange () that incorporates tracer into the solid lattice, whereas a static state would show no exchange at all.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that for dilute aqueous solutions.
You accurately converted mass concentration to molar concentration using the atomic weight of lead.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou inverted the stoichiometric mole ratio between and , dividing by the coefficient of 2 instead of multiplying.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the ratio of ions produced per formula unit with an inverse algebraic proportion, leading to dividing the majority ion concentration by 2 instead of multiplying by 2.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Stoichiometric Ion Relation
For a salt , the mole ratio is , which gives .
Always write out the dissolution mole ratio explicitly: since each yields per , multiply by 2.
- Dynamic Nature of Equilibrium
Macroscopic constancy does not imply microscopic cessation; forward and reverse processes continue at identical rates.
When asked how isotopic tracers demonstrate dynamic equilibrium, state that ongoing microscopic forward and reverse reactions cause tracer exchange between phases, proving the state is dynamic rather than static.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the stoichiometric relationship: .
Substitute : .
Convert to molarity: .
(a) ; . (b) Ongoing dynamic dissolution and crystallization exchange into the solid phase until specific activity is uniform, whereas a static state would incorporate zero tracer.
Lock it in
For a sparingly soluble salt dissolving in pure water, how does relate to ?
. Each mole of that dissolves releases twice as many ions as ions into solution.
Similar question
A saturated solution of calcium fluoride is prepared in pure water: . If , find in .
Answer
. Stoichiometry dictates .
A saturated solution of silver chromate has a measured of . Calculate and explain what happens to the specific radioactivity of the solid precipitate if radioactive is added to the solution at equilibrium.
Answer
; the solid's specific radioactivity increases from zero until the isotopic ratio is uniform between solid and liquid. Dissolution releases two ions per , so . Continuous microscopic precipitation and dissolution dynamically exchange silver ions across phases.
Solid bismuth(III) sulfide dissolves according to . In a saturated solution formed from pure water, the sulfide concentration is . (a) Calculate . (b) Explain why adding tracer leads to radioactivity appearing in the solid precipitate even though the net mass of solid precipitate remains strictly constant.
Answer
(a) . From stoichiometry, . (b) Macroscopic mass is invariant because dissolution rate equals precipitation rate, but individual sulfur atoms continuously exchange across the phase boundary, incorporating radioactive tracer into the lattice.