Resources

A chemical manufacturing unit is transitioning an oxidation reaction from stoichiometric potassium permanganate (KMnO4\text{KMnO}_4, molar mass 158.03 g/mol158.03\text{ g/mol}) to catalytic molecular oxygen (O2\text{O}_2, molar mass 32.00 g/mol32.00\text{ g/mol}). The target oxidation converts reactant RR (molar mass 120.00 g/mol120.00\text{ g/mol}) to product PP (molar mass 136.00 g/mol136.00\text{ g/mol}). The stoichiometric permanganate process has an atom economy of AEperm=27.60%\text{AE}_{\text{perm}} = 27.60\%. In the green catalytic route using O2\text{O}_2, air is supplied alongside an auxiliary ligand/stabilizer additive that cannot be recovered and is disposed of as waste. Let maddm_{\text{add}} represent the mass of non-recoverable additive required per mole of reactant RR. Determine the critical threshold value of maddm_{\text{add}} (in g/mol\text{g/mol} of reactant) above which the generalized mass efficiency of reactants and unrecovered additives in the catalytic route drops below the atom economy of the traditional permanganate route.

Answer and steps

Final answer

madd=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

Steps

01

Determine the Stoichiometry of the Catalytic Oxidation

The target reaction converts reactant RR into oxidized product PP:

  • Molar mass of reactant RR: MR=120.00 g/molM_R = 120.00\text{ g/mol}
  • Molar mass of product PP: MP=136.00 g/molM_P = 136.00\text{ g/mol}

The increase in molar mass is: ΔM=136.00 g/mol−120.00 g/mol=16.00 g/mol\Delta M = 136.00\text{ g/mol} - 120.00\text{ g/mol} = 16.00\text{ g/mol}

Because molecular oxygen (OX2\ce{O2}) has a molar mass of 32.00 g/mol32.00\text{ g/mol}, an addition of 16.00 g/mol16.00\text{ g/mol} corresponds to half a mole of OX2\ce{O2} per mole of RR: R+12 OX2→P\ce{R + \frac{1}{2} O2 -> P}

Thus, the mass of stoichiometric reactants consumed per mole of RR is: mreactants=MR+12MOX2=120.00 g+16.00 g=136.00 gm_{\text{reactants}} = M_R + \frac{1}{2}M_{\ce{O2}} = 120.00\text{ g} + 16.00\text{ g} = 136.00\text{ g}

Without any unrecovered additives, the theoretical atom economy of this ideal catalytic step would be 100%100\%, since all atoms of RR and 12OX2\frac{1}{2}\ce{O2} are incorporated into PP.


02

Express Generalized Mass Efficiency with the Additive

When an unrecovered additive is introduced into the process at a loading of maddm_{\text{add}} grams per mole of RR, the total input mass of stoichiometric reactants and non-recovered materials becomes: mtotal input=MR+12MOX2+madd=136.00 g+maddm_{\text{total input}} = M_R + \frac{1}{2}M_{\ce{O2}} + m_{\text{add}} = 136.00\text{ g} + m_{\text{add}}

The generalized mass efficiency (ME\text{ME}) of the catalytic route is defined as the mass of the desired product divided by the total mass of reactants and non-recovered auxiliary materials: ME=MPMR+12MOX2+madd=136.00136.00+madd\text{ME} = \frac{M_P}{M_R + \frac{1}{2}M_{\ce{O2}} + m_{\text{add}}} = \frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}}


03

Calculate the Critical Threshold Value

To find the threshold where the catalytic route loses its mass advantage over the traditional stoichiometric permanganate route, set ME\text{ME} equal to AEperm=27.60%=0.2760\text{AE}_{\text{perm}} = 27.60\% = 0.2760: 136.00136.00+madd=0.2760\frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760

Rearranging to solve for maddm_{\text{add}}: 136.00=0.2760⋅(136.00+madd)136.00 = 0.2760 \cdot (136.00 + m_{\text{add}})

136.00+madd=136.000.2760≈492.75 g/mol136.00 + m_{\text{add}} = \frac{136.00}{0.2760} \approx 492.75\text{ g/mol}

madd=492.75−136.00=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 492.75 - 136.00 = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

If the mass of the unrecovered additive exceeds 356.7 g356.7\text{ g} per mole of reactant, the mass efficiency of the "green" catalytic route becomes inferior to the atom economy of the stoichiometric KMnOX4\ce{KMnO4} route.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes a full mole of O2 (32.00 g) is consumed per mole of R instead of 0.5 mol (16.00 g), leading to an overestimation of the stoichiometric oxygen mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Mass of OX2 consumed per mole of R=32.00 g\text{Mass of } \ce{O2} \text{ consumed per mole of } R = 32.00\text{ g}

    Correct

    ΔM=136.00 g/mol−120.00 g/mol=16.00 g/mol  ⟹  mOX2=16.00 g\Delta M = 136.00\text{ g/mol} - 120.00\text{ g/mol} = 16.00\text{ g/mol} \implies m_{\ce{O2}} = 16.00\text{ g}

    You determined the consumed oxygen mass without checking the stoichiometric mass difference between RR and PP. Because product PP (136.00 g/mol136.00\text{ g/mol}) is 16.00 g/mol16.00\text{ g/mol} heavier than reactant RR (120.00 g/mol120.00\text{ g/mol}), only one oxygen atom (12 mol of OX2\frac{1}{2}\text{ mol of } \ce{O2}, or 16.00 g16.00\text{ g}) is incorporated per mole of RR.

  2. Step 2

    Total input mass=120.00+32.00+madd=152.00+madd  ⟹  Efficiency=136.00/(152.00+madd)=0.2760\text{Total input mass} = 120.00 + 32.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 152.00 + m_{\text{add}} \implies \text{Efficiency} = 136.00 / (152.00 + m_{\text{add}}) = 0.2760

    Correct

    Total input mass=120.00+16.00+madd=136.00+madd  ⟹  136.00136.00+madd=0.2760\text{Total input mass} = 120.00 + 16.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 136.00 + m_{\text{add}} \implies \frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760

    Your formulation for mass efficiency correctly places desired product over total stoichiometric reactants plus additive, but it carries forward the overestimated oxygen mass (32.00 g32.00\text{ g} instead of 16.00 g16.00\text{ g}).

  3. Step 3

    madd=492.75−152.00=340.75 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 492.75 - 152.00 = 340.75\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    madd=136.000.2760−136.00=492.75−136.00=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = \frac{136.00}{0.2760} - 136.00 = 492.75 - 136.00 = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

    Your arithmetic evaluation of 136.000.2760≈492.75\frac{136.00}{0.2760} \approx 492.75 and subtraction step were executed properly, but subtracting 152.00152.00 instead of 136.00136.00 yielded an understated critical additive threshold.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly defined generalized mass efficiency as the product mass divided by total input mass.

You equated the catalytic route's mass efficiency directly to the target atom economy of 27.60%27.60\%.

You solved the linear algebraic equation with sound arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric coefficient oversight in oxidation

You took the full molar mass of OX2\ce{O2} (32.00 g/mol32.00\text{ g/mol}) as the reactant mass per mole of RR rather than checking how many moles of OX2\ce{O2} are stoichiometrically required to form PP.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the stoichiometric mass balance between reactant and product leads to equating 1 mol of target reactant with 1 mol of diatomic oxidant by default, rather than deriving the required oxidant coefficient from ΔM=MP−MR\Delta M = M_P - M_R.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the stoichiometric oxygen demand
  • For an oxidation reaction R+νOX2OX2→P\ce{R + }\nu_{\ce{O2}}\ce{O2 -> P}, the stoichiometric coefficient is νOX2=MP−MRMOX2\nu_{\ce{O2}} = \frac{M_P - M_R}{M_{\ce{O2}}}.

  • Always subtract the reactant molar mass from the product molar mass to find the exact grams of oxygen incorporated before assigning an oxidant mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate oxygen incorporated: ΔM=136.00 g/mol−120.00 g/mol=16.00 g/mol\Delta M = 136.00\text{ g/mol} - 120.00\text{ g/mol} = 16.00\text{ g/mol}.

  2. Find moles of OX2\ce{O2} required: 16.00 g32.00 g/mol=0.50 mol OX2\frac{16.00\text{ g}}{32.00\text{ g/mol}} = 0.50\text{ mol } \ce{O2}, corresponding to 16.00 g of OX216.00\text{ g of } \ce{O2}.

  3. Formulate total input mass: mtotal=120.00+16.00+madd=136.00+maddm_{\text{total}} = 120.00 + 16.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 136.00 + m_{\text{add}}.

  4. Solve 136.00136.00+madd=0.2760  ⟹  136.00+madd≈492.75\frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760 \implies 136.00 + m_{\text{add}} \approx 492.75.

Final answer

madd=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the balanced chemical equation relating reactant and product before computing mass metrics.

  • Verify that the sum of stoichiometric reactant masses matches the theoretical product mass in an addition/oxidation step.

  • Practice calculating green chemistry mass metrics (such as Mass Efficiency and Process Mass Intensity) with auxiliary non-recovered reagents.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student defines the denominator of the mass efficiency as only the reactant R and the additive, omitting the mass of oxygen consumed in the reaction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Total input mass=120.00+madd  ⟹  Efficiency=136.00120.00+madd=0.2760\text{Total input mass} = 120.00 + m_{\text{add}} \implies \text{Efficiency} = \frac{136.00}{120.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760

    Correct

    Total input mass=MR+12MOX2+madd=120.00+16.00+madd=136.00+madd  ⟹  Efficiency=136.00136.00+madd=0.2760\text{Total input mass} = M_R + \frac{1}{2}M_{\ce{O2}} + m_{\text{add}} = 120.00 + 16.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 136.00 + m_{\text{add}} \implies \text{Efficiency} = \frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760

    You defined the reaction mass as only the organic substrate RR (120.00 g/mol120.00\text{ g/mol}), leaving out the 12 mol\frac{1}{2}\text{ mol} of OX2\ce{O2} (16.00 g/mol16.00\text{ g/mol}) chemically consumed to oxidize RR to PP (136.00 g/mol136.00\text{ g/mol}).

  2. Step 2

    120.00+madd=492.75  ⟹  madd=492.75−120.00=372.75 g/mol120.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 492.75 \implies m_{\text{add}} = 492.75 - 120.00 = 372.75\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    136.00+madd=492.75  ⟹  madd=492.75−136.00=356.7 g/mol136.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 492.75 \implies m_{\text{add}} = 492.75 - 136.00 = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

    You performed the division and subtraction steps correctly, but your final threshold carries over the omission of the oxygen mass from the first step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated the catalytic mass efficiency to the benchmark permanganate atom economy of 0.27600.2760.

You accurately solved the linear fractional equation for the unknown denominator.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of stoichiometric gaseous co-reactant

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the organic substrate as the only stoichiometric input in the denominator of mass efficiency, overlooking the fact that stoichiometric reagents supplied as gases (like OX2\ce{O2}) also count toward the total input mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for all stoichiometric reactants
  • Every stoichiometric reactant consumed to form the product—including gases like OX2\ce{O2} or HX2\ce{H2}—must be included in the total input mass: ∑mreactants=MR+νOX2MOX2\sum m_{\text{reactants}} = M_R + \nu_{\ce{O2}} M_{\ce{O2}}.

  • Always write out the balanced chemical equation first to ensure all consumed co-reactants are accounted for before setting up mass efficiency or atom economy expressions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the balanced reaction: R+12 OX2→P\ce{R + 1/2 O2 -> P}, giving reactant input masses of 120.00 g120.00\text{ g} of RR and 16.00 g16.00\text{ g} of OX2\ce{O2} per mole of PP.

  2. Write the complete mass efficiency expression: ME=136.00120.00+16.00+madd=136.00136.00+madd\text{ME} = \frac{136.00}{120.00 + 16.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = \frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}}.

  3. Set the expression equal to 0.27600.2760: 136.00136.00+madd=0.2760  ⟹  136.00+madd=492.75\frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760 \implies 136.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 492.75.

  4. Subtract the full reactant mass to solve for the critical additive threshold: madd=492.75−136.00=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 492.75 - 136.00 = 356.7\text{ g/mol}.

Final answer

madd=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the balanced stoichiometric reaction first whenever an oxidation or reduction is converted to a catalytic route.

  • Verify that the sum of masses of all stoichiometric reactants matches or exceeds the product mass via mass balance before adding non-recoverable auxiliary terms.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses the mass of the starting reactant R (120.00 g) in the numerator of the efficiency ratio rather than the mass of the desired product P (136.00 g).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Oxygen required=136.00−120.00=16.00 g  ⟹  Total input mass=120.00+16.00+madd=136.00+madd\text{Oxygen required} = 136.00 - 120.00 = 16.00\text{ g} \implies \text{Total input mass} = 120.00 + 16.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 136.00 + m_{\text{add}}

  2. Step 2

    Efficiency=120.00136.00+madd=0.2760\text{Efficiency} = \frac{120.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760

    Correct

    Efficiency=MPmtotal input=136.00136.00+madd=0.2760\text{Efficiency} = \frac{M_P}{m_{\text{total input}}} = \frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760

    Mass efficiency metrics measure how much mass of the desired product is formed relative to total inputs. You placed the molar mass of the starting reactant RR (120.00 g/mol120.00\text{ g/mol}) in the numerator instead of the molar mass of the desired product PP (136.00 g/mol136.00\text{ g/mol}).

  3. Step 3

    136.00+madd=120.000.2760=434.78  ⟹  madd=434.78−136.00=298.78 g/mol136.00 + m_{\text{add}} = \frac{120.00}{0.2760} = 434.78 \implies m_{\text{add}} = 434.78 - 136.00 = 298.78\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    136.00+madd=136.000.2760≈492.75  ⟹  madd=492.75−136.00=356.7 g/mol136.00 + m_{\text{add}} = \frac{136.00}{0.2760} \approx 492.75 \implies m_{\text{add}} = 492.75 - 136.00 = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

    Your algebraic rearrangement was executed properly, but the numerical result was affected by using 120.00120.00 in the numerator in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the mass difference to find the stoichiometric oxygen needed per mole of reactant.

You accurately formulated the total input mass including the unrecovered additive.

You demonstrated sound algebraic technique in isolating the variable.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula numerator confusion (reactant vs. product)

You substituted the starting reactant's mass (120.00 g/mol120.00\text{ g/mol}) into the numerator of the mass efficiency equation instead of the desired product's mass (136.00 g/mol136.00\text{ g/mol}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing green chemistry mass metrics (which evaluate output of target product relative to input mass) with conversion or yield ratios that reference starting material.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Mass Efficiency (ME)
  • Mass Efficiency=Mass of Desired ProductTotal Mass of Inputs\text{Mass Efficiency} = \frac{\text{Mass of Desired Product}}{\text{Total Mass of Inputs}}

  • Always verify that the numerator represents the target product formed, not the starting reactant consumed.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the mass of desired product PP (136.00 g136.00\text{ g}) in the numerator: 136.00136.00+madd=0.2760\frac{136.00}{136.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.2760.

  2. Solve for the total input mass: 136.00+madd=136.000.2760≈492.75 g/mol136.00 + m_{\text{add}} = \frac{136.00}{0.2760} \approx 492.75\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Subtract the reactant mass to isolate maddm_{\text{add}}: madd=492.75−136.00=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 492.75 - 136.00 = 356.7\text{ g/mol}.

Final answer

madd=356.7 g/molm_{\text{add}} = 356.7\text{ g/mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check every green chemistry metric definition before plugging in numbers: the numerator is always the mass of the desired product.

  • Review related metrics such as Reaction Mass Efficiency (RME), Process Mass Intensity (PMI), and E-factor to reinforce how product and waste relate.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A catalytic epoxidation converts an alkene (M=84.00 g/molM = 84.00\text{ g/mol}) into an epoxide (M=100.00 g/molM = 100.00\text{ g/mol}) using OX2\ce{O2}. If an unrecoverable homogeneous catalyst additive is used at a loading of 25.00 g25.00\text{ g} per mole of alkene, calculate the generalized mass efficiency of the process.

Answer

Mass of OX2\ce{O2} consumed is 100.00−84.00=16.00 g/mol100.00 - 84.00 = 16.00\text{ g/mol} (0.5 mol0.5\text{ mol}). Total input mass per mole of alkene is 84.00+16.00+25.00=125.00 g84.00 + 16.00 + 25.00 = 125.00\text{ g}. Mass efficiency is 100.00 g125.00 g=80.00%\frac{100.00\text{ g}}{125.00\text{ g}} = 80.00\%, or 0.8000.800.

02

A secondary alcohol (M=74.00 g/molM = 74.00\text{ g/mol}) is oxidized to a ketone (M=72.00 g/molM = 72.00\text{ g/mol}) using catalytic OX2\ce{O2}, producing HX2O\ce{H2O} (18.00 g/mol18.00\text{ g/mol}) as the sole by-product: R−HX2+0.5 OX2→R+HX2O\ce{R-H2 + 0.5 O2 -> R + H2O}. Calculate the maximum non-recoverable additive mass maddm_{\text{add}} (in g/mol\text{g/mol} alcohol) allowable if the mass efficiency must remain at least 40.0%40.0\%.

Answer

Input of OX2\ce{O2} per mole of alcohol is 0.5×32.00=16.00 g0.5 \times 32.00 = 16.00\text{ g}. Total input mass is 74.00+16.00+madd=90.00+madd74.00 + 16.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 90.00 + m_{\text{add}}. Desired product mass is 72.00 g72.00\text{ g}. Set 72.0090.00+madd=0.400  ⟹  90.00+madd=180.00  ⟹  madd=90.0 g/mol\frac{72.00}{90.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.400 \implies 90.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 180.00 \implies m_{\text{add}} = 90.0\text{ g/mol}.

03

A dihydroxylation process converts an alkene (M=100.00 g/molM = 100.00\text{ g/mol}) to a diol (M=134.00 g/molM = 134.00\text{ g/mol}) using molecular oxygen and water: Alkene+0.5 OX2+HX2O→Diol\ce{Alkene + 0.5 O2 + H2O -> Diol}. The competing stoichiometric OsOX4/NMO\ce{OsO4}/\ce{NMO} protocol has an atom economy of 35.0%35.0\%. Determine the threshold mass of sacrificial co-reagent maddm_{\text{add}} (in g/mol\text{g/mol} alkene) where the catalytic route matches the stoichiometric atom economy.

Answer

Mass balance: alkene (100.00 g100.00\text{ g}) + 0.5OX20.5\ce{O2} (16.00 g16.00\text{ g}) + HX2O\ce{H2O} (18.00 g18.00\text{ g}) = 134.00 g134.00\text{ g} of diol. Total input is 134.00+madd134.00 + m_{\text{add}}. Equating mass efficiency to atom economy: 134.00134.00+madd=0.350  ⟹  134.00+madd=382.86  ⟹  madd=248.9 g/mol\frac{134.00}{134.00 + m_{\text{add}}} = 0.350 \implies 134.00 + m_{\text{add}} = 382.86 \implies m_{\text{add}} = 248.9\text{ g/mol}.

Loading workspace…