Resources
Consider the isoelectronic series consisting of five chemical species containing electrons each: , , , , and . (a) List the nuclear charge () and write the common ground-state electron configuration for all five species. (b) Using Slater's rules or effective nuclear charge principles (, where shielding constant for valence electrons in a core), calculate experienced by a valence electron in the extreme anion limit () versus the extreme cation limit (). (c) Arrange all five species in order of strictly decreasing ionic/atomic radius, and explain why the ionic radius contracts dramatically as nuclear charge increases across this series despite electron count remaining identical.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Common electron configuration: . Nuclear charges: (), (), (), (), (). (b) For : . For : . (c) Order of decreasing radius: . Although the number of electrons (and mutual electron-electron repulsion) remains constant at , the increasing number of protons from to creates a progressively larger effective nuclear charge, pulling the valence shell electrons inward toward the nucleus.
Steps
Part (a): Ground-State Electron Configuration and Nuclear Charges
An isoelectronic series consists of atoms and ions that share the same total number of electrons and identical ground-state electron configurations.
- Common Electron Configuration: Each of the five species possesses electrons:
-
Nuclear Charge (): The nuclear charge equals the atomic number (the number of protons, ), which remains constant for each element regardless of its ionization state:
- For :
- For :
- For :
- For :
- For :
Part (b): Calculating Effective Nuclear Charge ()
The effective nuclear charge is given by: where is the shielding constant caused by inner-shell and fellow valence electrons. For a valence electron in the shell of a -electron neon-like core, the shielding constant is identical across all species: .
- Extreme Anion Limit ():
- Extreme Cation Limit ():
The effective nuclear charge experienced by a valence electron more than doubles from to , indicating a substantially stronger electrostatic pull toward the nucleus in the magnesium cation.
Part (c): Radius Trend and Physical Explanation
- Order of Strictly Decreasing Radius:
-
Explanation:
- Constant Electron Repulsion: Across an isoelectronic series, all species maintain the exact same number of electrons () arranged in identical principal quantum levels ( and ). Consequently, the screening constant and mutual electron-electron repulsions remain essentially constant.
- Increasing Inward Pull: As the atomic number increases from to , the positive charge in the nucleus steadily increases.
- Shell Contraction: According to Coulomb's law, a higher positive nuclear charge exerting force on the same electron cloud results in a significantly greater net inward electrostatic force ( increases from to ). This increasingly powerful attraction pulls the valence electron cloud closer to the nucleus, causing the ionic radius to contract progressively from down to .
Common Pitfall: Do not assume that having the same number of electrons means species have the same size; the balance between positive nuclear pull and negative electron repulsion determines the size, making nuclear charge the decisive factor in an isoelectronic series.
Typical errors
01 The student reverses the trend of ionic radii by incorrectly believing that cations are larger due to having a higher atomic number and more protons.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
\n Higher nuclear charge means more particles in the nucleus which pushes the radius to be larger.
Correct. With a constant electron count () and constant shielding, increasing increases , exerting a stronger electrostatic pull that draws the valence shell closer to the nucleus.
You reversed the order of ionic radii. Protons in the nucleus do not push valence electrons outward; instead, they exert an attractive electrostatic force (Coulombic attraction). A higher pulls the same electrons tighter toward the center, making the cation significantly smaller.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the nuclear charge for each ion and neutral atom.
You wrote the correct ground-state electron configuration for a -electron species.
You accurately computed the effective nuclear charges for and .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the nucleus as occupying physical space that expands the entire atom rather than acting as a positive electrostatic center that attracts negative electrons.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing nuclear size with atomic/ionic radius. Atomic radius is governed by the boundary of the electron cloud, which contracts when positive nuclear charge increases on a fixed number of electrons.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Coulombic Attraction vs. Physical Size
The nucleus is tiny compared to the atom, and its positive charge () attracts the surrounding electron cloud via Coulomb's law ().
Always interpret an increase in as a stronger inward pull on electrons, which contracts the atomic/ionic radius.
- Isoelectronic Series Radius Rule
In an isoelectronic series (identical electron count and shielding), radius is inversely related to nuclear charge ().
Order isoelectronic species from lowest (largest radius, most negative anion) to highest (smallest radius, most positive cation).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the calculated values: has , while has .
Recognize that a higher creates a stronger inward pull on the valence shell.
Conclude that greater inward attraction contracts the electron cloud, meaning higher corresponds to smaller radius.
02 The student confuses nuclear charge with net ionic charge when calculating effective nuclear charge, substituting the net charge into Z.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
, , , ,
- Step 2Correct
,
In the formula , the variable represents the nuclear charge (the number of protons, which you found in part a as for oxygen and for magnesium), not the net ionic charge ( and ). Effective nuclear charge cannot be negative here because the nucleus still has a net positive attraction.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly listed the atomic numbers and shared ground-state electron configuration for all five members of the isoelectronic series.
You correctly arranged the species in order of decreasing ionic/atomic radius.
You explained the radius contraction using the correct physical relationship between effective nuclear charge and electron cloud size.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the ion's net formal charge ( and ) for instead of the nuclear charge ( and ).
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflation between the symbol (atomic number / number of protons in the nucleus) and the overall oxidation state or net ionic charge of a chemical species. In , always measures the total positive charge residing in the nucleus.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify What Z Represents
In effective nuclear charge formulas, is the atomic number (total proton count), never the ion charge.
Check your periodic table for the element's atomic number and substitute that positive integer for .
- Sanity Check for Z_eff
For stable ground-state core and valence electrons, is always a positive quantity.
If your calculated is zero or negative, verify whether you accidentally used the ion charge instead of the atomic number.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor :
For :
and
03 The student confuses the number of protons with total electrons and assigns Z = 10 to all species because the series is isoelectronic.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
All species have electrons, so for all species ⟹ Configuration:
CorrectConfiguration: ; Nuclear charges: , , , ,
You correctly wrote the ground-state electron configuration . However, nuclear charge is the number of protons in the nucleus (the atomic number of the element), not the number of electrons. Each element retains its distinct atomic number regardless of ion formation.
- Step 2
For : ⟹ For :
CorrectFor : ; For :
You correctly applied the formula , but substituting instead of the true atomic numbers ( for and for ) produced identical, incorrect values.
- Step 3
⟹ All species have identical nuclear charges and identical electron counts, so their sizes are the same.
Correct; radius decreases because increasing nuclear charge ( to ) pulls the identical -electron cloud closer to the nucleus.
Because your previous steps assumed identical nuclear charges, you concluded the species have identical sizes. In reality, greater positive charge pulls the same electrons inward more strongly, making the largest and the smallest.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the ground-state electron configuration of the -electron species as .
You correctly applied the effective nuclear charge formula using the provided shielding constant.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated nuclear charge as variable with ionization and equal to the number of electrons (), rather than the fixed atomic number (number of protons) of each chemical element.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Nuclear Charge Definition
Nuclear charge is defined strictly by the number of protons (atomic number) in the nucleus and does not change when an atom gains or loses electrons.
Always find directly from the element's position on the periodic table, regardless of its net ionic charge.
- Isoelectronic Radius Trend
In an isoelectronic series, shielding () and electron count are constant, so increases directly with atomic number .
Rank isoelectronic species by atomic number: the species with the fewest protons has the lowest and the largest radius, while the species with the most protons has the highest and the smallest radius.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the atomic number for each element: has , has , has , has , and has .
Calculate : for , ; for , .
Order by radius: higher pulls the electron cloud inward, so radius decreases in the order .
Decreasing radius: .
Lock it in
How does increasing nuclear charge () affect the ionic radius across an isoelectronic series?
The radius decreases. With constant electron shielding, higher creates a stronger inward electrostatic pull on the electron cloud.
Similar question
Arrange the following -electron isoelectronic species in order of strictly decreasing radius: , , , , .
Answer
. Key step: Identify nuclear charges (). With equal electron count (), radius decreases monotonically as increases.
For the isoelectronic pair () and (), calculate using and explain which ion has the larger radius.
Answer
; . has the larger radius because its lower effective nuclear charge exerts a weaker inward electrostatic pull on the electrons.
Explain why the radius of () is significantly smaller than the radius of neutral (), even though both have identical electron configurations.
Answer
Neutral has , while has . The extra proton in the sodium nucleus increases from to , pulling the valence shell closer to the nucleus and causing radius contraction.