Resources
In an organic qualitative analysis laboratory, a student tests three unlabelled bottles (Labeled X, Y, and Z), each containing a pure, liquid unbranched 6-carbon aliphatic hydrocarbon. The student performs two standardized chemical tests: Test 1 involves adding drops of a solution in the absence of light; Test 2 involves adding cold, neutral aqueous potassium permanganate (, Baeyer's reagent). Sample X shows no color change in either test. Sample Y rapidly discharges the red-brown color of without evolution of gas, and turns from purple to a brown precipitate (). Quantitative titration of of Sample Z consumes exactly of before the reddish color persists. (a) Classify samples X, Y, and Z as an alkane, an alkene, or an alkyne. (b) Write the molecular formula for each sample. (c) Provide the structural feature in Sample Z responsible for the stoichiometric consumption of .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Sample X is an alkane; Sample Y is an alkene; Sample Z is an alkyne; (b) Sample X is ; Sample Y is ; Sample Z is ; (c) The presence of a carbon-carbon triple bond (), which consists of two mutually perpendicular bonds, allowing two successive electrophilic halogen addition reactions to form a 1,1,2,2-tetrabromoalkane.
Steps
Part (a): Classification of Samples X, Y, and Z
-
Analyzing Sample X:
- Bromine test ( in the dark): Alkanes only undergo free-radical halogen substitution in the presence of ultraviolet light or heat; in the dark, they do not react with molecular bromine.
- Baeyer's test (cold, neutral aqueous ): Saturated hydrocarbons lack electron-rich bonds and do not reduce permanganate ions.
- Because Sample X shows no reaction in either test, it is saturated and is therefore classified as an alkane.
-
Analyzing Sample Y:
- The rapid decolourization of the reddish-brown bromine solution in the dark without the evolution of acidic gas indicates an electrophilic addition across an unsaturated carbon-carbon multiple bond rather than a substitution reaction.
- The oxidation by cold neutral to form a brown precipitate of manganese(IV) oxide () and a vicinal diol confirms unsaturation.
- Because Sample Z is definitively shown by quantitative titration to possess two degrees of unsaturation from a triple bond (see below), Sample Y represents the mono-unsaturated species and is classified as an alkene.
-
Analyzing Sample Z:
- The quantitative reaction of of Sample Z consumes exactly of :
- A stoichiometric ratio of hydrocarbon to halogen demonstrates that two molecules of add to each hydrocarbon molecule. This is characteristic of an alkyne.
Part (b): Molecular Formulae
Each sample is an unbranched, acyclic aliphatic hydrocarbon containing carbon atoms:
- Sample X (alkane): Follows the general formula .
- Sample Y (alkene): Contains one double bond and follows the general formula .
- Sample Z (alkyne): Contains one triple bond and follows the general formula .
Part (c): Structural Feature of Sample Z Responsible for the Ratio
The stoichiometric consumption of two molar equivalents of per mole of hydrocarbon is due to the presence of a carbon-carbon triple bond ().
- A carbon-carbon triple bond consists of one strong bond and two mutually perpendicular bonds.
- Each bond has high electron density and undergoes electrophilic addition:
- The first bond reacts with of to yield a 1,2-dibromoalkene intermediate.
- The remaining bond reacts with a second of to yield a 1,1,2,2-tetrabromoalkane.
- Thus, the two reactive bonds enable the addition of two moles of per mole of alkyne.
Typical errors
01 The student misinterprets the 1:2 hydrocarbon to bromine stoichiometric ratio as meaning each mole of hydrocarbon contains half a mole of bromine-reactive double bonds, classifying Z as an alkene with fewer reactive sites instead of an alkyne with two pi bonds.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
X does not react with or , so X is an alkane.
- Step 2
Y decolorizes and forms , so Y is an alkyne. ⟹ Z reacts in a 1:2 ratio with , meaning it consumes less reagent per unsaturation, so Z is an alkene.
CorrectA mole ratio of hydrocarbon to () means each mole of Sample Z adds two moles of , which is characteristic of an alkyne (). Therefore, Sample Z is an alkyne and Sample Y is an alkene.
Consuming two moles of per mole of hydrocarbon means the molecule possesses two reactive bonds capable of successive electrophilic halogen addition. Thus, Sample Z is the alkyne and Sample Y is the alkene.
- Step 3
X: ⟹ Y: ⟹ Z:
CorrectX: (alkane, ) ⟹ Y: (alkene, ) ⟹ Z: (alkyne, )
You applied the correct homologous series formulas to your chosen classifications, but because Y and Z were swapped in part (a), their formulas are swapped here as well.
- Step 4
Sample Z contains one carbon-carbon double bond ().
CorrectSample Z contains a carbon-carbon triple bond (), composed of one bond and two mutually perpendicular bonds.
Because Sample Z is an alkyne rather than an alkene, the structural feature responsible for adding two equivalents of is a carbon-carbon triple bond containing two bonds.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified Sample X as an alkane based on its negative reaction with bromine and Baeyer's reagent.
You correctly applied the general molecular formulas , , and to 6-carbon chains.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted the hydrocarbon-to-halogen mole ratio as meaning Sample Z consumed less reagent per site of unsaturation, rather than recognizing that one mole of hydrocarbon consumed two moles of halogen because it possesses two reactive bonds.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Interpreting halogen titration ratios
An alkene possesses one bond and adds in a molar ratio (). An alkyne possesses two bonds and adds in a molar ratio ().
Always set up the ratio as . A value of directly indicates two addition steps across two bonds.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompute the titration stoichiometry: .
Deduce that Sample Z undergoes two additions of , establishing it as an alkyne with a group.
Classify Sample Y as the alkene since it reacts positively with and but does not take up two equivalents.
Assign molecular formulas using : Sample X is , Sample Y is , and Sample Z is .
(a) X is an alkane, Y is an alkene, Z is an alkyne; (b) X: , Y: , Z: ; (c) A carbon-carbon triple bond () containing two bonds.
02 The student applies the general formula of an alkene to an alkyne by confusing the degree of unsaturation of a triple bond with that of a double bond, resulting in an incorrect molecular formula for Z.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
X: alkane, Y: alkene, Z: alkyne
- Step 2
X: ⟹ Y: ⟹ Z:
CorrectX: ; Y: ; Z:
You used the correct general formulas for the alkane and alkene, but for the alkyne (Sample Z), you reused the alkene formula instead of , yielding instead of .
- Step 3
A carbon-carbon triple bond () containing two pi bonds that each add one molecule.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified all three hydrocarbons based on their reaction observations and titration stoichiometry.
You accurately determined the molecular formulas for the alkane and the alkene.
You clearly explained how the two bonds of the triple bond account for the molar consumption of bromine.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated the degree of unsaturation of an alkyne with a single double bond, incorrectly reusing instead of subtracting four hydrogen atoms from the saturated parent formula () for the two bonds.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Acyclic Hydrocarbon General Formulas
For an acyclic aliphatic hydrocarbon with carbons: an alkane has formula , a mono-alkene has , and a mono-alkyne has .
Each additional bond removes two hydrogen atoms from the formula; since a triple bond has two bonds, subtract four hydrogens from to get .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify Sample Z as an unbranched acyclic alkyne with carbons.
Apply the general formula for an acyclic mono-alkyne: .
Calculate the number of hydrogen atoms: .
Sample Z is .
03 The student attributes the 1:2 stoichiometry to two separate, isolated carbon-carbon double bonds in a diene rather than recognizing the classification requirement of an alkane, alkene, or alkyne.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
X is an alkane Y is an alkene Z is an alkyne
- Step 2
- Step 3
Two separated carbon-carbon double bonds () that each react with one equivalent of .
CorrectA carbon-carbon triple bond () containing two mutually perpendicular bonds, allowing two successive electrophilic additions of .
Because you classified Sample Z as an alkyne, its structural feature is a carbon-carbon triple bond (), not two isolated double bonds (a diene). The triple bond contains one bond and two bonds, enabling it to add two molar equivalents of to form a 1,1,2,2-tetrabromoalkane.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly matched the chemical test results to the saturated, mono-unsaturated, and di-unsaturated classes of hydrocarbons.
You correctly determined the molecular formulas for 6-carbon unbranched alkane, alkene, and alkyne molecules.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou understood that consuming two molar equivalents of requires two bonds, but you visualized them as two separate double bonds rather than recognizing that a single triple bond in an alkyne already supplies the two bonds.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Bonding in alkynes
A carbon-carbon triple bond () consists of one bond and two mutually perpendicular bonds.
When a compound is classified as an alkyne, attribute multiple halogen additions directly to its single triple bond rather than proposing multiple separate double bonds.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that Sample Z is an alkyne, meaning it contains a carbon-carbon triple bond ().
Note that a triple bond possesses two orthogonal bonds, each capable of undergoing electrophilic addition with one equivalent of .
Conclude that addition of the first mole gives a 1,2-dibromoalkene, and addition of the second mole gives a 1,1,2,2-tetrabromoalkane.
The structural feature in Sample Z is a carbon-carbon triple bond () consisting of two reactive bonds.
Lock it in
How many moles of does of an alkene consume upon complete electrophilic addition, and how many does of an alkyne consume?
An alkene consumes of (one bond); an alkyne consumes of (two bonds).
Similar question
A sample of an unbranched 5-carbon hydrocarbon reacts completely with exactly of in without light. Identify the family of this hydrocarbon and state its molecular formula.
Answer
Alkene; . The molar ratio , which corresponds to one double bond. For an acyclic alkene with , the formula is .
Hydrocarbon A and Hydrocarbon B are both unbranched 4-carbon hydrocarbons. In an analytical titration, of Hydrocarbon A consumes of , whereas of Hydrocarbon B consumes of . Identify both hydrocarbons as an alkane, alkene, or alkyne, and write their molecular formulas.
Answer
Hydrocarbon A is an alkyne (); Hydrocarbon B is an alkene (). Key steps: , so ; ratio (alkyne). , so ; ratio (alkene).
An open-chain hydrocarbon with molecular formula is treated with excess bromine liquid in the absence of light. Write the molecular formula of the fully brominated product and determine the mass of () consumed by of this hydrocarbon.
Answer
Product formula: ; Mass of consumed: . Key steps: fits , having two degrees of unsaturation (an alkyne or diene), thus consuming per mole of hydrocarbon. ; ; .