Resources
Consider the thermodynamic definition of electron affinity (): with . (a) State whether the first electron affinity () of fluorine is positive or negative under the convention where energy released corresponds to . (b) Nitrogen has while carbon has . Write the ground-state electron configuration of the gaseous negative ions and and explain the sign difference based on Hund's rule and exchange energy.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Positive (, corresponding to an exothermic process ); (b) (adds electron into empty orbital, achieving a stable half-filled subshell with maximum exchange stabilization); (requires pairing an electron into an already half-filled subshell, where strong inter-electronic pairing repulsion outweighs additional nuclear attraction, resulting in an endothermic/unfavorable process).
Steps
Part (a): Sign of the First Electron Affinity of Fluorine
- Thermodynamic Convention: The reaction for the first electron affinity is: Under the stated convention, electron affinity () is defined such that . Therefore, an exothermic process (where energy is released and ) yields a positive value for ().
- Application to Fluorine: Fluorine has a high effective nuclear charge () and needs only one electron to complete its valence shell and attain a stable noble gas configuration (). Gaining an electron releases a substantial amount of energy (). Consequently, under this sign convention:
Part (b): Electron Configurations and Anion Stability of Carbon vs. Nitrogen
-
Ground-State Electron Configurations:
- Neutral atoms:
- Gaseous anions:
- Adding an electron to carbon populates the remaining vacant orbital:
- Adding an electron to nitrogen forces the incoming electron into an already singly occupied orbital:
-
Exchange Energy and Hund's Rule Analysis:
- Exchange stabilization: According to Hund's rule, electrons with parallel spins in degenerate orbitals undergo quantum-mechanical exchange, which lowers the energy of the system. The number of exchange pairs among electrons with parallel spins is given by:
-
For Carbon ():
- In neutral (), there are parallel electrons, yielding exchange interaction.
- In (), there are parallel electrons with each occupying a separate degenerate orbital (), giving exchange interactions.
- The added electron experiences no pairing repulsion (occupies an empty orbital) and gains an extra exchange interactions, creating a particularly stable half-filled subshell. Thus, energy is released ().
-
For Nitrogen ():
- Neutral nitrogen already possesses a stable, half-filled subshell with maximal exchange energy ( parallel electrons, ).
- Forming () forces the incoming electron to pair with an electron already present in one of the orbitals. Because the orbitals are relatively compact, this introduces significant electron-electron Coulombic repulsion (pairing energy).
- The destabilizing electron-electron repulsion outweighs the attraction from the nitrogen nucleus and any marginal exchange stabilization, making electron attachment energetically unfavorable/non-spontaneous (, so ).
Typical errors
01 A student confuses the convention where exothermic processes have ΔH < 0 with EA, incorrectly concluding that fluorine has a negative electron affinity.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You correctly recognized that electron gain by fluorine releases energy (exothermic, so ). However, the problem explicitly defines , meaning that when energy is released, is positive ().
- Step 2
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that adding an electron to gaseous fluorine is an exothermic process where energy is released.
You accurately wrote the ground-state electron configurations for and .
You clearly articulated how exchange energy and pairing repulsion explain the sign difference between the electron affinities of carbon and nitrogen.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the sign of electron affinity () directly with , overlooking the negative sign in the relationship .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the thermodynamic convention where system heat release is negative () with the atomic physics/chemistry definition of electron affinity where energy released is reported as a positive affinity value ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Thermodynamic Enthalpy vs. Electron Affinity
By convention, . An exothermic process has , which corresponds to .
Whenever an electron-gain process releases energy, set as negative and as positive under the positive-release convention.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor fluorine, electron attachment is exothermic because energy is released: .
Substitute into the definition: .
(a) Positive (); (b) ,
02 A student removes electrons instead of adding them when writing the negative ion configurations, leading to the incorrect configurations of cations.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You removed an electron from neutral carbon () and nitrogen () to produce cation configurations ( and ) instead of adding an electron to form the gaseous anions and .
- Step 3Correct
Adding an electron to populates the empty orbital to yield a stable half-filled configuration with maximum exchange stabilization (), releasing energy (). Adding an electron to forces pairing into an already singly occupied orbital (), introducing strong inter-electronic pairing repulsion that outweighs nuclear attraction, resulting in an unfavorable process ().
Because your configurations were based on removing electrons, your explanation evaluated ionization stability rather than the energetics of gaining an electron.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the first electron affinity of fluorine is positive under the energy-released convention.
You correctly recalled the concept of exchange energy in relation to the stability of the half-filled subshell.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused electron affinity (adding an electron to form an anion ) with ionization energy (removing an electron to form a cation ), which caused you to subtract valence electrons instead of adding them.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Anion vs. Cation Formation
Anions () are formed by adding an electron (), increasing the electron count by . Cations () are formed by removing an electron ().
Always verify the charge of the target species before writing configurations: negative charge means electron; positive charge means electron.
- Electron Affinity and Subshell Energetics
Electron affinity measures the energy change when adding an electron. Half-filled subshells (, ) maximize exchange energy; adding an electron to an already half-filled subshell introduces pairing repulsion.
Analyze whether the incoming electron occupies an empty orbital (gaining exchange energy) or pairs with an existing electron (incurring pairing repulsion).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the ground-state electron configurations of neutral () and neutral ().
Add one electron to form each anion: becomes and becomes .
Evaluate Hund's rule: places the extra electron in an empty orbital with parallel spin, increasing exchange interactions from to () without pairing repulsion, making .
Evaluate : the extra electron must pair in an already occupied orbital, introducing strong inter-electronic repulsion that makes electron attachment unfavorable, so .
(a) Positive; (b) , . Adding an electron to creates a stable half-filled subshell with increased exchange stabilization (), whereas adding an electron to introduces substantial electron-electron pairing repulsion into the compact subshell ().
03 A student incorrectly believes pairing an electron increases exchange energy because it creates a pair, reversing the exchange energy argument.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
In forming (), the added electron enters an empty degenerate orbital with parallel spin. This increases the number of parallel-spin exchange pairs from in neutral () to in , releasing substantial exchange stabilization energy without any pairing repulsion.
You stated that unpaired parallel electrons cannot exchange. In quantum mechanics, exchange energy arises specifically between electrons with parallel spins in degenerate orbitals. Moving from to increases the number of exchange pairs from to , providing extra stabilization.
- Step 4Correct
In neutral (), there are already parallel electrons with maximal exchange stabilization (). In (), the parallel spin-up electrons still exchange (), so exchange energy is not lost; rather, forcing an electron into an already occupied orbital introduces severe Coulombic pairing repulsion, which outweighs the nuclear attraction and makes .
You stated that pairing electrons decreases exchange stabilization. The parallel electrons in still retain their exchange interactions. The unfavorable sign of for nitrogen is caused by inter-electronic Coulombic pairing repulsion in the compact orbital, not by a decrease in exchange energy.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the first electron affinity of fluorine is positive.
You correctly wrote the ground-state electron configurations of and .
You recognized that exchange energy involves electrons with parallel spins.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that unpaired electrons with parallel spins cannot undergo exchange and that pairing an electron destroys existing parallel exchange interactions, rather than recognizing that exchange stabilization is maximized among parallel spins () and that pairing introduces destabilizing Coulombic repulsion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Exchange Energy Condition
Exchange energy is a stabilizing quantum-mechanical phenomenon that occurs exclusively between electrons with identical (parallel) spins occupying degenerate orbitals, with the number of interactions given by .
Count the number of parallel-spin pairs in degenerate orbitals before and after electron attachment; a higher means greater exchange stabilization.
- Origin of Anion Destabilization in Nitrogen
Adding a fourth electron to a half-filled subshell does not reduce existing parallel-spin exchange interactions; instead, it introduces inter-electron Coulombic pairing energy in a single orbital.
Attribute the endothermic nature of electron addition to half-filled subshells to orbital pairing repulsion exceeding effective nuclear attraction.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that for neutral (), the number of exchange interactions between parallel spins is .
Adding an electron into the empty orbital produces (), where all electrons have parallel spins, yielding exchange interactions. This gain of exchange interactions provides significant stabilization ().
For neutral (), the subshell already has maximum exchange stabilization ().
Adding an electron to form () preserves those spin-up exchange interactions but forces two electrons to occupy the same compact orbital. The resulting Coulombic pairing repulsion exceeds the nuclear attraction, resulting in an unfavorable process ().
(a) Positive; (b) achieves a half-filled subshell with maximum exchange stabilization ( exchange pairs vs. in ) and no pairing repulsion, making ; forces electron pairing into a compact orbital, introducing strong Coulombic pairing repulsion that outweighs nuclear attraction, making .
Lock it in
How are the enthalpy of electron attachment () and electron affinity () related under the standard convention where energy released means ?
. Therefore, an exothermic process (energy released, ) has a positive electron affinity ().
Similar question
Chlorine has an electron attachment enthalpy of . Under the convention , state whether is positive or negative, and give its numerical value.
Answer
is positive, with a value of because .
Oxygen has and . Write the chemical equation for the process corresponding to and state whether this second step is exothermic or endothermic.
Answer
Equation: . Because , , making the process endothermic due to electron-ion Coulombic repulsion.
Phosphorus has while silicon has . Using ground-state valence configurations and exchange energy considerations, explain why silicon has a larger positive electron affinity than phosphorus.
Answer
Valence configurations: is and forms (), gaining a stable half-filled subshell with an increase from to exchange pairs without pairing repulsion. In contrast, () already has maximum exchange stabilization ( pairs); forming () forces electron pairing into a compact orbital, introducing inter-electronic repulsion that reduces net energy release.