Resources

A standard organic bromination of benzene requires coupling a Brønsted-Lowry/Lewis halogenation mechanism: molecular bromine, Br2\text{Br}_2, reacts with iron(III) bromide, FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3, to generate the reactive electrophile complex [FeBr4]−−Br+[\text{FeBr}_4]^- - \text{Br}^+. (a) Identify the Lewis acid and Lewis base in this initial catalyst activation step. (b) Explain how this initial Lewis acid-base coupling alters the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} bond polarization to permit benzene (acting as a π\pi-electron Lewis base) to attack the terminal electrophilic bromine atom.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Lewis acid: FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 (empty dd/hybrid orbital on iron accepting an electron pair); Lewis base: Br2\text{Br}_2 (lone pair donor from bromine); (b) Coordination of a bromine lone pair into the vacant orbital of FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 polarizes the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} bond, creating a significant partial positive charge (electrophilic character, δ+\delta^+) on the terminal bromine atom, lowering the activation barrier for attack by the π\pi-electron pair of the benzene ring.

Steps

Part (a): Identifying the Lewis Acid and Lewis Base

By the Lewis definition:

  • A Lewis base is an electron-pair donor.
  • A Lewis acid is an electron-pair acceptor.
  1. Iron(III) bromide (FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3}): The central iron atom in FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3} has accessible empty orbitals capable of accepting an incoming electron pair. Therefore, FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3} acts as the Lewis acid.
  2. Molecular bromine (BrX2\ce{Br2}): Each neutral bromine atom in :Br−Br:\ce{:Br-Br:} possesses three non-bonding valence electron pairs (lone pairs). One of these lone pairs is donated to the vacant orbital of the iron center. Therefore, BrX2\ce{Br2} acts as the Lewis base.

Part (b): Mechanism of Br−Br\ce{Br-Br} Bond Polarization

  1. Unactivated BrX2\ce{Br2} is a weak electrophile: In isolated BrX2\ce{Br2}, the bonding electron pair is shared equally between the two identical halogen atoms, resulting in a nonpolar covalent bond. Benzene possesses a stable, aromatic conjugated π\pi-system; neutral BrX2\ce{Br2} alone is not electrophilic enough to disrupt this aromatic stabilization.
  2. Induction of polarization via coordination: When one bromine atom donates a lone pair into the vacant orbital of FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3}, a coordinate covalent bond forms: Br−Br+FeBrX3→BrXδ+−BrXδ+−[FeBrX3]Xδ−\ce{Br-Br + FeBr3 -> Br^{\delta+} - Br^{\delta+} - [FeBr3]^{\delta-}} The bromine directly bonded to iron takes on positive character as it shares its electron density with the metal center. To compensate, this coordinated bromine pulls electron density away from the adjacent Br−Br\ce{Br-Br} σ\sigma-bond.
  3. Enhancing electrophilicity for aromatic attack: This electron withdrawal polarizes the Br−Br\ce{Br-Br} bond heavily, generating a strong partial positive charge (δ+\delta^+) on the outer, terminal bromine atom. This dramatically lowers the activation energy required for the electron-rich π\pi-cloud of the benzene ring (functioning as a nucleophile/Lewis base) to attack the terminal bromine, displacing [FeBrX4]−[\ce{FeBr4}]^-.

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse Brønsted-Lowry definitions (which involve proton transfer, HX+\ce{H^+}) with Lewis definitions (which involve electron-pair donation and acceptance). Here, no protons are transferred in this activation step; the reaction proceeds strictly via coordinate electron-pair donation.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the definitions of Lewis acid and Lewis base, misidentifying the electron pair donor as the acid and the electron pair acceptor as the base.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    FeBr3 has an incomplete octet and donates electron density.  ⟹  Lewis acid: BrX2,  Lewis base: FeBrX3\text{FeBr}_3\text{ has an incomplete octet and donates electron density.} \implies \text{Lewis acid: }\ce{Br2},\;\text{Lewis base: }\ce{FeBr3}

    Correct

    Lewis acid: FeBrX3,  Lewis base: BrX2\text{Lewis acid: }\ce{FeBr3},\;\text{Lewis base: }\ce{Br2}

    A species with an incomplete octet or vacant orbital accepts an electron pair rather than donating one. Therefore, FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3} acts as the Lewis acid (electron-pair acceptor), while BrX2\ce{Br2} acts as the Lewis base (electron-pair donor via its lone pairs).

  2. Step 2

    Coordination of BrX2 to FeBrX3 polarizes the Br−Br bond.  ⟹  Electron density shifts toward the complexed bromine.  ⟹  The terminal bromine becomes electron-deficient (delta+) and is attacked by the pi electrons of benzene.\text{Coordination of }\ce{Br2}\text{ to }\ce{FeBr3}\text{ polarizes the }\ce{Br-Br}\text{ bond.} \implies \text{Electron density shifts toward the complexed bromine.} \implies \text{The terminal bromine becomes electron-deficient (delta+) and is attacked by the pi electrons of benzene.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly described how coordination shifts electron density and polarizes the bromine-bromine bond.

You accurately identified that the terminal bromine develops electrophilic character (δ+\delta^+) that enables benzene's π\pi-system to attack it.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Lewis Acid-Base Definitions

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated an incomplete octet with donating electron density rather than accepting it, which led you to swap the definitions of a Lewis acid and a Lewis base.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Lewis Acid vs. Lewis Base
  • A Lewis acid is an electron-pair acceptor (often possessing vacant orbitals or an incomplete octet), whereas a Lewis base is an electron-pair donor (possessing lone pairs or π\pi-bonds).

  • Check which species has accessible non-bonding lone pairs to donate and which species has an empty orbital capable of receiving them.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the electron donor: BrX2\ce{Br2} has non-bonding lone pairs on each bromine atom available for donation, making it the Lewis base.

  2. Identify the electron acceptor: FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3} has accessible empty orbitals on the iron center ready to accept an incoming pair, making it the Lewis acid.

Final answer

(a) Lewis acid: FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3}; Lewis base: BrX2\ce{Br2}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the memory cue 'Acid Accepts' (both start with the letter A) to firmly lock in the Lewis acid definition.

  • Practice classifying classic Group 13 and transition metal halides (such as AlClX3\ce{AlCl3}, BFX3\ce{BF3}, and FeClX3\ce{FeCl3}) as Lewis acids.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies which bromine atom becomes electrophilic, incorrectly claiming that coordination directs electron density toward the terminal bromine and leaves the internal bromine electrophilic.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Lewis acid: FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3   ⟹  \implies Lewis base: Br2\text{Br}_2

  2. Step 2

    FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 coordinates with one bromine atom of Br2\text{Br}_2.

  3. Step 3

    Electron density is pushed onto the terminal bromine atom, giving it a partial negative charge.   ⟹  \implies The internal bromine becomes delta+ and benzene attacks the terminal bromine instead because of steric hindrance.

    Correct

    The coordinated internal bromine draws electron density away from the terminal bromine through the σ\sigma-bond, making the terminal bromine electrophilic (δ+\delta^+) so it can accept electrons from the benzene π\pi-system.

    When the internal bromine shares its lone pair with FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3, it becomes electron-deficient and pulls electrons through the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} σ\sigma-bond toward itself. This leaves the terminal bromine atom with a strong partial positive charge (δ+\delta^+), which is why the nucleophilic π\pi-electrons of benzene attack it.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 as the Lewis acid and Br2\text{Br}_2 as the Lewis base.

You recognized that catalyst activation begins with the coordination of FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 to one bromine atom.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Electrophilic polarization inversion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated coordination as though it transfers electron density onto the uncoordinated halogen atom rather than realizing that coordinate covalent bonding pulls σ\sigma-bonding electrons toward the electron-deficient coordination site.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Lewis Acid Coordination and Induction
  • When an atom donates an electron pair to a Lewis acid, it develops positive character and strongly withdraws σ\sigma-electron density from adjacent bonded atoms.

  • Trace the movement of electron density toward the Lewis acid center to determine which adjacent atom is depleted of electrons and becomes electrophilic.

Nucleophile-Electrophile Matching
  • Benzene acts as an electron-rich nucleophile (Lewis base) and must attack an electron-poor electrophilic center (δ+\delta^+).

  • Check that the atom attacked by the benzene π\pi-cloud carries a partial positive charge rather than a partial negative charge.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Coordination places formal positive character on the internal bromine atom directly bonded to iron: BrXδ+−BrXδ+−[FeBrX3]Xδ−\ce{Br^{\delta+} - Br^{\delta+} - [FeBr3]^{\delta-}}.

  2. To stabilize its positive character, this internal bromine pulls the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} σ\sigma-bonding electrons toward itself.

  3. This inductive withdrawal leaves the terminal bromine significantly electron-deficient (δ+\delta^+), transforming it into a reactive electrophile.

  4. The nucleophilic π\pi-electron pair of benzene attacks this terminal δ+\delta^+ bromine atom, displacing [extFeBr4]−[ ext{FeBr}_4]^- as the leaving group.

Final answer

(a) Lewis acid: FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3; Lewis base: Br2\text{Br}_2. (b) Coordination of a bromine lone pair to FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 pulls electron density through the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} bond toward the coordinated internal bromine, generating a strong partial positive charge (δ+\delta^+) on the terminal bromine atom that enables attack by the nucleophilic benzene π\pi-cloud.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how Lewis acid coordination activates diatomic halogens by drawing inductive dipoles along the bond.

  • Practice drawing electron-pushing arrows from the Lewis base lone pair to the metal center to trace the resulting partial charges.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly assumes homolytic cleavage occurs, claiming that FeBr3 generates neutral bromine free radicals rather than polarising the bond for electrophilic attack.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Lewis acid: FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 ⟹\Longrightarrow Lewis base: Br2\text{Br}_2

  2. Step 2

    FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 initiates homolytic cleavage of the nonpolar Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} bond ⟹\Longrightarrow This produces two neutral Br\text{Br} radicals instead of a polarized bond ⟹\Longrightarrow Benzene attacks the neutral bromine radical via a radical substitution pathway.

    Correct

    A lone pair on one bromine atom of Br2\text{Br}_2 coordinates into an empty orbital of FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3, forming a coordinate complex Br−Br−FeBr3\text{Br}-\text{Br}-\text{FeBr}_3. This coordination pulls electron density toward the iron center, heavily polarizes the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} bond, and induces a strong partial positive charge (δ+\delta^+) on the terminal bromine atom, allowing attack by the π\pi-electron cloud of benzene.

    Lewis acid-base activation is a two-electron (heterolytic) coordination process rather than a single-electron homolytic cleavage. Coordinating Br2\text{Br}_2 to the iron center polarizes the bond to generate an electrophilic bromine atom (Brδ+\text{Br}^{\delta+}), rather than generating neutral free radicals.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 as the Lewis acid and Br2\text{Br}_2 as the Lewis base.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Homolytic Cleavage Misconception

You described the activation as homolytic cleavage producing neutral radicals rather than coordinate complex formation that polarizes the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} bond.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing heterolytic two-electron Lewis acid coordination with photochemical or thermal homolytic cleavage, resulting in an incorrect radical substitution mechanism for electrophilic aromatic substitution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Lewis Coordination is a Two-Electron Process
  • A Lewis acid accepts an electron pair from a Lewis base to form a coordinate covalent bond without breaking bonds homolytically.

  • Track electron pairs moving into vacant orbitals using full curved arrows rather than single-electron fishhook arrows.

Polarization Creates Electrophiles
  • Coordination of a halogen lone pair to an electron-deficient metal center draws electron density away from the halogen-halogen bond, inducing strong electrophilic (δ+\delta^+) character at the distal halogen.

  • Represent the complex as polarized Brδ+−Brδ−−FeBr3\text{Br}^{\delta+}-\text{Br}^{\delta-}-\text{FeBr}_3 rather than neutral radicals.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that a lone pair from Br2\text{Br}_2 donates into the vacant orbital of FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3, forming a coordinate adduct: Br−Br−FeBr3\text{Br}-\text{Br}-\text{FeBr}_3.

  2. Show that the coordinated bromine becomes electron-deficient and withdraws electron density from the adjacent Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} σ\sigma-bond.

  3. Conclude that this induces a strong partial positive charge (δ+\delta^+) on the terminal bromine atom, activating it for nucleophilic attack by the π\pi-electrons of the benzene ring.

Final answer

(a) Lewis acid: FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3; Lewis base: Br2\text{Br}_2. (b) Coordination of a bromine lone pair into the vacant orbital of FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3 polarizes the Br−Br\text{Br}-\text{Br} bond, creating a significant partial positive charge (δ+\delta^+) on the terminal bromine atom and lowering the activation barrier for attack by the π\pi-electron pair of benzene.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental difference between two-electron heterolytic polar mechanisms (Lewis acid-base catalysis) and one-electron homolytic radical mechanisms.

  • Practice drawing curved-arrow mechanisms for the coordination of halogens to metal halides (such as AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 and FeBr3\text{FeBr}_3) to track formal and partial charges.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In the Friedel-Crafts alkylation reaction step CHX3Cl+AlClX3→CHX3−ClX+−AlX−ClX3\ce{CH3Cl + AlCl3 -> CH3-Cl^{+}-Al^{-}Cl3}, identify the Lewis acid and the Lewis base.

Answer

Lewis acid: AlClX3\ce{AlCl3}; Lewis base: CHX3Cl\ce{CH3Cl}. Key step: The chlorine atom of chloromethane donates a lone pair into the vacant 3p3p orbital of aluminum.

02

In the formation of the complex ion [Cu(HX2O)X6]2+[\ce{Cu(H2O)6}]^{2+} from CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}} and water, identify the Lewis acid and Lewis base, and explain your choice using valence electron configurations.

Answer

Lewis acid: CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}}; Lewis base: HX2O\ce{H2O}. Key step: CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}} has empty valence dd/hybrid orbitals that accept electron pairs, while neutral oxygen in HX2O\ce{H2O} possesses two lone pairs available for coordinate covalent donation.

03

Titanium(IV) chloride, TiClX4\ce{TiCl4}, reacts with diethyl ether, (CX2HX5)X2O\ce{(C2H5)2O}, to form the adduct TiClX4 ⋅2 O(CX2HX5)X2\ce{TiCl4 \cdot 2O(C2H5)2}. Identify the Lewis acid and Lewis base, state the coordinate coordination number change of titanium, and predict the direction of electron flow.

Answer

Lewis acid: TiClX4\ce{TiCl4}; Lewis base: (CX2HX5)X2O\ce{(C2H5)2O}. Key steps: (1) Diethyl ether donates ether oxygen lone pairs to vacant dd-orbitals on titanium; (2) Electron flow proceeds from oxygen toward titanium; (3) Titanium's coordination number increases from 4 to 6 (tetrahedral to octahedral geometry).

Loading workspace…