Resources

A sealed, evacuated 5.00 L5.00\text{ L} flask is charged at 250∘C250^\circ\text{C} with 0.150 mol0.150\text{ mol} of PCl5(g)\text{PCl}_5(g), 0.300 mol0.300\text{ mol} of PCl3(g)\text{PCl}_3(g), and 0.200 mol0.200\text{ mol} of Cl2(g)\text{Cl}_2(g) according to the reversible equilibrium: PCl5(g)⇌PCl3(g)+Cl2(g)\text{PCl}_5(g) \rightleftharpoons \text{PCl}_3(g) + \text{Cl}_2(g), which has Kc=0.0420 MK_c = 0.0420\text{ M}. (a) Calculate the reaction quotient QcQ_c for the initial mixture. (b) State whether the net reaction proceeds in the forward direction, reverse direction, or is already at dynamic equilibrium, explaining the sign convention for the change in extent Δx\Delta x.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Qc=0.0800 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M}; (b) Since Qc>KcQ_c > K_c, the system shifts in the reverse direction toward reactants (Deltax<0\\Delta x < 0 for products, Deltax>0\\Delta x > 0 for reactants) until rf=rrr_f = r_r.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Initial Reaction Quotient QcQ_c

  1. Calculate the initial molar concentrations: The flask has a volume of V=5.00 LV = 5.00\text{ L}. Use the definition of molarity, [X]0=n0V[\text{X}]_0 = \frac{n_0}{V}:

    [PClX5]0=0.150 mol5.00 L=0.0300 M[\ce{PCl5}]_0 = \frac{0.150\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0300\text{ M}

    [PClX3]0=0.300 mol5.00 L=0.0600 M[\ce{PCl3}]_0 = \frac{0.300\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0600\text{ M}

    [ClX2]0=0.200 mol5.00 L=0.0400 M[\ce{Cl2}]_0 = \frac{0.200\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0400\text{ M}

  2. Write the expression for the reaction quotient QcQ_c: For the reversible gas-phase dissociation: PClX5(g)⇌PClX3(g)+ClX2(g)\ce{PCl5(g) <=> PCl3(g) + Cl2(g)}

    the reaction quotient takes the same mathematical form as the equilibrium constant expression evaluated at non-equilibrium conditions:

    Qc=[PClX3]0[ClX2]0[PClX5]0Q_c = \frac{[\ce{PCl3}]_0 [\ce{Cl2}]_0}{[\ce{PCl5}]_0}

  3. Substitute the initial concentrations into QcQ_c:

    Qc=(0.0600 M)⋅(0.0400 M)0.0300 M=0.0800 MQ_c = \frac{(0.0600\text{ M}) \cdot (0.0400\text{ M})}{0.0300\text{ M}} = 0.0800\text{ M}


Part (b): Predicting the Direction of Net Reaction

  1. Compare QcQ_c with KcK_c:

    • Qc=0.0800 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M}
    • Kc=0.0420 MK_c = 0.0420\text{ M}

    Since Qc>KcQ_c > K_c, the ratio of product concentrations to reactant concentrations is greater than the ratio required at equilibrium.

  2. Determine the net shift: To reduce the value of the quotient from 0.0800 M0.0800\text{ M} down to 0.0420 M0.0420\text{ M}, products must be consumed and reactants must be formed. Therefore, the system proceeds with a net shift in the reverse direction (toward the reactants, to the left).
  3. Sign convention for extent of reaction (Δx\Delta x):

    • By standard convention, defining the forward progress as +Δx+\Delta x means products change by +Δx+\Delta x and reactants change by −Δx-\Delta x.
    • Because the reaction shifts in the reverse direction, the change in forward reaction extent is negative (Δx<0\Delta x < 0). Consequently, the concentration of products decreases (Δ[PClX3]<0\Delta[\ce{PCl3}] < 0, Δ[ClX2]<0\Delta[\ce{Cl2}] < 0) while the concentration of reactant increases (Δ[PClX5]>0\Delta[\ce{PCl5}] > 0).
    • The net shift continues until the rate of the forward reaction equals the rate of the reverse reaction (rf=rrr_f = r_r), establishing dynamic chemical equilibrium.

Common Pitfall: Be careful not to substitute mole values directly into QcQ_c unless the total stoichiometric coefficients of gaseous products and gaseous reactants are equal (Δng=0\Delta n_g = 0). Here, Δng=(1+1)−1=+1\Delta n_g = (1 + 1) - 1 = +1, so dividing each mole quantity by the volume V=5.00 LV = 5.00\text{ L} is essential.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates Qc using moles directly instead of molar concentrations, yielding an incorrect quotient of 0.400.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Qc=n(PCl3)∗n(Cl2)n(PCl5)  ⟹  Qc=(0.300∗0.200)0.150=0.400Q_c = \frac{n(\text{PCl}_3) * n(\text{Cl}_2)}{n(\text{PCl}_5)} \implies Q_c = \frac{(0.300 * 0.200)}{0.150} = 0.400

    Correct

    [PCl5]0=0.150 mol5.00 L=0.0300 M,  [PCl3]0=0.300 mol5.00 L=0.0600 M,  [Cl2]0=0.200 mol5.00 L=0.0400 M  ⟹  Qc=[PCl3]0[Cl2]0[PCl5]0=(0.0600 M)(0.0400 M)0.0300 M=0.0800 M[\text{PCl}_5]_0 = \frac{0.150\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0300\text{ M},\; [\text{PCl}_3]_0 = \frac{0.300\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0600\text{ M},\; [\text{Cl}_2]_0 = \frac{0.200\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0400\text{ M} \implies Q_c = \frac{[\text{PCl}_3]_0[\text{Cl}_2]_0}{[\text{PCl}_5]_0} = \frac{(0.0600\text{ M})(0.0400\text{ M})}{0.0300\text{ M}} = 0.0800\text{ M}

    You substituted mole numbers directly into the expression for QcQ_c instead of dividing each quantity by the container volume (V=5.00 LV = 5.00\text{ L}) to obtain molar concentrations. Because the total moles of gas change during the reaction (Δng=1+1−1=+1\Delta n_g = 1 + 1 - 1 = +1), the volume terms do not cancel out.

  2. Step 2

    Qc=0.400>Kc=0.0420Q_c = 0.400 > K_c = 0.0420, so the reaction proceeds in the reverse direction.

    Correct

    Qc=0.0800 M>Kc=0.0420 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M} > K_c = 0.0420\text{ M}, so the reaction proceeds in the reverse direction.

    Your comparison rule is conceptually sound: whenever Qc>KcQ_c > K_c, the system shifts in reverse toward reactants. Although this step relied on your incorrect QcQ_c value from step 1, the true quotient (0.0800 M0.0800\text{ M}) still exceeds KcK_c, leading to the same conclusion.

  3. Step 3

    Since the reaction shifts in reverse, Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly formulated the ratio of products over reactants according to the balanced chemical equation.

You correctly applied the criterion that Qc>KcQ_c > K_c indicates a net shift in the reverse direction.

You correctly related the reverse reaction shift to a negative change in extent (Δx<0\Delta x < 0).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Container Volume in Concentration Quotient

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the reaction quotient QcQ_c as a ratio of mole quantities rather than molar concentrations, overlooking that the volume terms do not cancel when Δng≠0\Delta n_g \neq 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Concentration Units for $Q_c$
  • Qc=∏[products]ν/∏[reactants]νQ_c = \prod [\text{products}]^{\nu} / \prod [\text{reactants}]^{\nu}, where [X]=nXV[\text{X}] = \frac{n_{\text{X}}}{V}. Mole quantities can substitute for concentrations only if Δng=0\Delta n_g = 0.

  • Always calculate [X]=nV[\text{X}] = \frac{n}{V} for every gaseous or aqueous species before inserting numbers into QcQ_c or KcK_c.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert initial moles to initial molarity: [PCl5]0=0.150 mol5.00 L=0.0300 M[\text{PCl}_5]_0 = \frac{0.150\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0300\text{ M}, [PCl3]0=0.300 mol5.00 L=0.0600 M[\text{PCl}_3]_0 = \frac{0.300\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0600\text{ M}, and [Cl2]0=0.200 mol5.00 L=0.0400 M[\text{Cl}_2]_0 = \frac{0.200\text{ mol}}{5.00\text{ L}} = 0.0400\text{ M}.

  2. Substitute molarities into QcQ_c: Qc=(0.0600 M)(0.0400 M)0.0300 M=0.0800 MQ_c = \frac{(0.0600\text{ M})(0.0400\text{ M})}{0.0300\text{ M}} = 0.0800\text{ M}.

  3. Compare with KcK_c: since Qc=0.0800 M>0.0420 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M} > 0.0420\text{ M}, the net reaction shifts in reverse (left), meaning Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

Final answer

(a) Qc=0.0800 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M}; (b) Since Qc>KcQ_c > K_c, the net reaction proceeds in the reverse direction toward reactants (Δx<0\Delta x < 0).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Calculate molar concentrations [X]=n/V[\text{X}] = n/V explicitly as your first written step for any equilibrium or quotient problem.

  • Check Δng=∑nproducts−∑nreactants\Delta n_g = \sum n_{\text{products}} - \sum n_{\text{reactants}} to determine whether volume affects the equilibrium quotient.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the reaction quotient expression as reactants over products, leading to Qc = 12.5.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    [PClX5]=0.1505.00=0.0300 M  ⟹  [PClX3]=0.3005.00=0.0600 M  ⟹  [ClX2]=0.2005.00=0.0400 M[\ce{PCl5}] = \frac{0.150}{5.00} = 0.0300\text{ M} \implies [\ce{PCl3}] = \frac{0.300}{5.00} = 0.0600\text{ M} \implies [\ce{Cl2}] = \frac{0.200}{5.00} = 0.0400\text{ M}

  2. Step 2

    Qc=[PClX5][PClX3][ClX2]=0.03000.0600×0.0400=12.5Q_c = \frac{[\ce{PCl5}]}{[\ce{PCl3}][\ce{Cl2}]} = \frac{0.0300}{0.0600 \times 0.0400} = 12.5

    Correct

    Qc=[PClX3]0[ClX2]0[PClX5]0=(0.0600 M)(0.0400 M)0.0300 M=0.0800 MQ_c = \frac{[\ce{PCl3}]_0 [\ce{Cl2}]_0}{[\ce{PCl5}]_0} = \frac{(0.0600\text{ M})(0.0400\text{ M})}{0.0300\text{ M}} = 0.0800\text{ M}

    You inverted the reaction quotient formula. By definition, reaction quotient and equilibrium constant expressions place product concentrations in the numerator and reactant concentrations in the denominator, each raised to their stoichiometric coefficients.

  3. Step 3

    Qc=12.5>Kc=0.0420Q_c = 12.5 > K_c = 0.0420, so the reaction proceeds in the reverse direction.   ⟹  \implies Because the shift is in the reverse direction, Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

    Correct

    Since Qc=0.0800 M>Kc=0.0420 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M} > K_c = 0.0420\text{ M}, the net reaction shifts in the reverse direction to consume products and form reactants, meaning Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

    Your reasoning that Q>KQ > K leads to a reverse shift with Δx<0\Delta x < 0 is logically correct, but it relies on your erroneous QcQ_c value from the previous step. Coincidentally, the correct QcQ_c is also greater than KcK_c (0.0800>0.04200.0800 > 0.0420), so the qualitative conclusion happens to match.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly divided the initial mole amounts by the flask volume to find molarities.

You correctly applied the relationship that Q>KQ > K leads to a net shift in the reverse direction.

You correctly identified that a reverse shift corresponds to a negative forward reaction extent, Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Equilibrium Expression

You accidentally placed the reactant in the numerator and the products in the denominator when setting up the reaction quotient expression.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the conventional numerator/denominator placement in equilibrium law expressions (Qc=[products][reactants]Q_c = \frac{\text{[products]}}{\text{[reactants]}} vs. [reactants][products]\frac{\text{[reactants]}}{\text{[products]}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equilibrium Law Definition
  • For a general reaction aA+bB⇌cC+dDa\ce{A} + b\ce{B} \rightleftharpoons c\ce{C} + d\ce{D}, the reaction quotient is Qc=[C]c[D]d[A]a[B]bQ_c = \frac{[\ce{C}]^c [\ce{D}]^d}{[\ce{A}]^a [\ce{B}]^b}.

  • Always write 'Products over Reactants' at the top of your paper before plugging in concentration values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard expression with products in the numerator: Qc=[PClX3][ClX2][PClX5]Q_c = \frac{[\ce{PCl3}][\ce{Cl2}]}{[\ce{PCl5}]}.

  2. Substitute the initial concentrations: Qc=(0.0600)(0.0400)0.0300=0.0800 MQ_c = \frac{(0.0600)(0.0400)}{0.0300} = 0.0800\text{ M}.

  3. Compare with the equilibrium constant: Qc=0.0800 M>Kc=0.0420 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M} > K_c = 0.0420\text{ M}.

  4. Conclude that the system must consume products to reach equilibrium, shifting in the reverse direction with Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

Final answer

(a) Qc=0.0800 MQ_c = 0.0800\text{ M}; (b) The net reaction proceeds in the reverse direction toward reactants, so Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check every equilibrium fraction by whispering the mnemonic 'Products over Reactants' before writing concentrations.

  • Practice writing QcQ_c expressions for reactions with varying stoichiometric coefficients to build automatic recall.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets Qc > Kc as having excess reactants rather than excess products, incorrectly concluding the reaction shifts forward with Δx > 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    [PCl5]=0.150/5.00=0.0300 M  ⟹  [PCl3]=0.300/5.00=0.0600 M  ⟹  [Cl2]=0.200/5.00=0.0400 M[\text{PCl}_5] = 0.150 / 5.00 = 0.0300\text{ M} \implies [\text{PCl}_3] = 0.300 / 5.00 = 0.0600\text{ M} \implies [\text{Cl}_2] = 0.200 / 5.00 = 0.0400\text{ M}

  2. Step 2

    Qc=(0.0600∗0.0400)/0.0300=0.0800Q_c = (0.0600 * 0.0400) / 0.0300 = 0.0800

  3. Step 3

    Qc=0.0800>Kc=0.0420Q_c = 0.0800 > K_c = 0.0420, so the system shifts forward to reach equilibrium.

    Correct

    Qc=0.0800>Kc=0.0420Q_c = 0.0800 > K_c = 0.0420, so the system shifts in the reverse direction (to the left) toward reactants.

    Because Qc>KcQ_c > K_c, there is an excess of products relative to reactants. To reach equilibrium, the quotient must decrease toward KcK_c, meaning products must be consumed and reactants formed through a net reverse reaction.

  4. Step 4

    Because the reaction proceeds forward, the change in extent is positive, Δx>0\Delta x > 0.

    Correct

    Because the reaction proceeds in the reverse direction, the net change in forward extent is negative (Δx<0\Delta x < 0).

    Your reasoning about the sign of Δx\Delta x matches your direction in Step 3, but because the actual net reaction proceeds in reverse, the correct change in forward extent is Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly divided the initial mole amounts by the flask volume to find the initial concentrations.

You set up and evaluated the reaction quotient expression accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equilibrium shift misinterpretation ($Q_c > K_c$)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You interpreted Qc>KcQ_c > K_c as driving the reaction forward rather than recognizing that Qc>KcQ_c > K_c means the product-to-reactant ratio is already too large, requiring a reverse shift to reduce QcQ_c to KcK_c.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Interpreting $Q$ versus $K$
  • Remember that Q=[products][reactants]Q = \frac{[\text{products}]}{[\text{reactants}]}. If Q>KQ > K, the numerator (products) is too large, so the system must shift left (reverse) to decrease QQ until Q=KQ = K.

  • Always draw a number line with QQ and KK; the system shifts from QQ toward KK.

Extent of Reaction Sign
  • By convention, forward reaction corresponds to Δx>0\Delta x > 0. A net shift in the reverse direction consumes products and yields Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

  • Check whether the required shift is forward (+Δx+\Delta x) or reverse (−Δx-\Delta x) after establishing the direction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the quotients: Qc=0.0800>Kc=0.0420Q_c = 0.0800 > K_c = 0.0420.

  2. Because QcQ_c is greater than KcK_c, the product concentrations are too high relative to the reactant concentrations.

  3. To reach equilibrium, the numerator must decrease and the denominator must increase, so the system shifts in the reverse direction (left, toward reactants).

  4. Under the standard convention where the forward reaction is defined as +Δx+\Delta x, a reverse shift requires Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

Final answer

(a) Qc=0.0800Q_c = 0.0800; (b) Since Qc>KcQ_c > K_c, the system shifts in the reverse direction toward reactants, so Δx<0\Delta x < 0.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice visualizing QQ and KK on a horizontal number line where the arrow always points from QQ to KK to indicate the direction of shift.

  • Review how ICE tables link the direction of shift to the signs of +Δx+\Delta x and −Δx-\Delta x.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 2.00 L2.00\text{ L} vessel contains 0.400 mol0.400\text{ mol} of NX2OX4(g)\ce{N2O4(g)} and 0.800 mol0.800\text{ mol} of NOX2(g)\ce{NO2(g)} at 100∘C100^\circ\text{C} for the reaction NX2OX4(g)⇌2 NOX2(g)\ce{N2O4(g) <=> 2 NO2(g)} with Kc=0.360 MK_c = 0.360\text{ M}. Calculate QcQ_c and predict the direction of net reaction.

Answer

Qc=0.800 MQ_c = 0.800\text{ M}; since Qc>KcQ_c > K_c, the reaction shifts in the reverse direction toward NX2OX4\ce{N2O4}. Key steps: [NX2OX4]0=0.400 mol2.00 L=0.200 M[\ce{N2O4}]_0 = \frac{0.400\text{ mol}}{2.00\text{ L}} = 0.200\text{ M}, [NOX2]0=0.800 mol2.00 L=0.400 M[\ce{NO2}]_0 = \frac{0.800\text{ mol}}{2.00\text{ L}} = 0.400\text{ M}. Qc=[NOX2]02[NX2OX4]0=(0.400)20.200=0.800 MQ_c = \frac{[\ce{NO2}]_0^2}{[\ce{N2O4}]_0} = \frac{(0.400)^2}{0.200} = 0.800\text{ M}. Because 0.800>0.3600.800 > 0.360, the system proceeds in reverse.

02

In a 10.0 L10.0\text{ L} rigid container at 450∘C450^\circ\text{C}, a mixture has 2.00 mol HX22.00\text{ mol }\ce{H2}, 1.00 mol IX21.00\text{ mol }\ce{I2}, and 3.00 mol HI3.00\text{ mol }\ce{HI} for HX2(g)+IX2(g)⇌2 HI(g)\ce{H2(g) + I2(g) <=> 2 HI(g)} (Kc=50.0K_c = 50.0). (a) Calculate QcQ_c. (b) Explain why using mole quantities directly yields the exact same QcQ_c in this specific reaction.

Answer

(a) Qc=4.50Q_c = 4.50; the reaction proceeds forward since Qc<KcQ_c < K_c. (b) Since Δng=2−(1+1)=0\Delta n_g = 2 - (1 + 1) = 0, VV appears as V2V^2 in both numerator and denominator, canceling out completely: Qc=(nHI/V)2(nHX2/V)(nIX2/V)=nHI2nHX2nIX2=3.002(2.00)(1.00)=4.50Q_c = \frac{(n_{\ce{HI}}/V)^2}{(n_{\ce{H2}}/V)(n_{\ce{I2}}/V)} = \frac{n_{\ce{HI}}^2}{n_{\ce{H2}}n_{\ce{I2}}} = \frac{3.00^2}{(2.00)(1.00)} = 4.50.

03

Consider the synthesis NX2(g)+3 HX2(g)⇌2 NHX3(g)\ce{N2(g) + 3 H2(g) <=> 2 NH3(g)} with Kc=1.20 M−2K_c = 1.20\text{ M}^{-2}. An equilibrium mixture in a 4.00 L4.00\text{ L} vessel contains 0.800 mol NX20.800\text{ mol }\ce{N2} and 1.60 mol HX21.60\text{ mol }\ce{H2}. If the volume is suddenly halved to 2.00 L2.00\text{ L} at constant temperature, write the new QcQ_c in terms of the original KcK_c and state the direction of net shift.

Answer

Qc=14Kc=0.300 M−2Q_c = \frac{1}{4} K_c = 0.300\text{ M}^{-2}; the system shifts forward (to the right). Key steps: Qc=nNHX32/V2(nNX2/V)(nHX23/V3)=nNHX32nNX2nHX23⋅V2Q_c = \frac{n_{\ce{NH3}}^2 / V^2}{(n_{\ce{N2}}/V)(n_{\ce{H2}}^3/V^3)} = \frac{n_{\ce{NH3}}^2}{n_{\ce{N2}}n_{\ce{H2}}^3} \cdot V^2. Halving volume from VV to V/2V/2 multiplies QcQ_c by (1/2)2=1/4(1/2)^2 = 1/4. Since Qc=14Kc<KcQ_c = \frac{1}{4}K_c < K_c, the net reaction shifts toward fewer gas molecules (forward).

Loading workspace…