Resources

In an analytical inorganic chemistry laboratory, a volatile interhalogen compound containing iodine and chlorine is synthesized and standardized. Combustion and gravimetric precipitation with silver nitrate of a 0.467 g0.467\text{ g} sample yields 0.287 g0.287\text{ g} of AgCl\text{AgCl} (molar mass =143.32 g/mol= 143.32\text{ g/mol}). The remaining mass is confirmed to be iodine (molar mass =126.90 g/mol= 126.90\text{ g/mol}). (a) Calculate the empirical formula of the compound. (b) Under cryogenic crystallization, the compound exists as a planar dimer I2Cl6\text{I}_2\text{Cl}_6, but in the gas phase at 120∘C120^\circ\text{C} it dissociates completely into monomeric IClx\text{ICl}_x. For this monomer, determine the total number of valence electrons, sketch the VSEPR electron-domain and molecular geometries, and state the approximate bond angles.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Moles of Cl=moles of AgCl=0.287 g143.32 g/mol=2.00×10−3 mol\text{Cl} = \text{moles of }\text{AgCl} = \frac{0.287\text{ g}}{143.32\text{ g/mol}} = 2.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}; mass of Cl=2.00×10−3 mol×35.45 g/mol=0.0709 g\text{Cl} = 2.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol} \times 35.45\text{ g/mol} = 0.0709\text{ g}. Mass of I=0.467 g−0.0709 g=0.3961 g\text{I} = 0.467\text{ g} - 0.0709\text{ g} = 0.3961\text{ g}; moles of I=0.3961 g126.90 g/mol=3.12×10−3 mol\text{I} = \frac{0.3961\text{ g}}{126.90\text{ g/mol}} = 3.12 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}. Ratio of Cl:I≈1:1.5\text{Cl} : \text{I} \approx 1 : 1.5, yielding the empirical formula I2Cl3\text{I}_2\text{Cl}_3 or monomeric fraction ICl3\text{ICl}_3 upon thermal balance (gas-phase monomer: ICl3\text{ICl}_3, 2828 valence electrons). (b) Monomer ICl3\text{ICl}_3 has 33 single bonds and 22 lone pairs on iodine (steric number 55, AX3E2\text{AX}_3\text{E}_2); electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal; molecular geometry: T-shaped; ∠Clax−I−Cleq<90∘\angle\text{Cl}_\text{ax}-\text{I}-\text{Cl}_\text{eq} < 90^\circ (approximately 86∘86^\circ to 88∘88^\circ) and ∠Clax−I−Clax≈175∘\angle\text{Cl}_\text{ax}-\text{I}-\text{Cl}_\text{ax} \approx 175^\circ.

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Empirical Formula

  1. Calculate the moles and mass of chlorine (Cl\ce{Cl}): All chlorine in the compound precipitates as silver chloride, AgCl\ce{AgCl}. Moles of Cl=moles of AgCl=0.287 g143.32 g/mol≈2.003×10−3 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{Cl} = \text{moles of } \ce{AgCl} = \frac{0.287\text{ g}}{143.32\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.003 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol} Mass of Cl=2.003×10−3 mol×35.45 g/mol≈0.0710 g\text{Mass of } \ce{Cl} = 2.003 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol} \times 35.45\text{ g/mol} \approx 0.0710\text{ g}
  2. Calculate the mass and moles of iodine (I\ce{I}): By conservation of mass, the remainder of the 0.467 g0.467\text{ g} sample consists entirely of iodine: Mass of I=0.467 g−0.0710 g=0.3960 g\text{Mass of } \ce{I} = 0.467\text{ g} - 0.0710\text{ g} = 0.3960\text{ g} Moles of I=0.3960 g126.90 g/mol≈3.121×10−3 mol\text{Moles of } \ce{I} = \frac{0.3960\text{ g}}{126.90\text{ g/mol}} \approx 3.121 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}
  3. Determine the empirical formula and monomer composition: Taking the molar ratio gives: Moles of ClMoles of I=2.00×10−33.12×10−3≈23\frac{\text{Moles of } \ce{Cl}}{\text{Moles of } \ce{I}} = \frac{2.00 \times 10^{-3}}{3.12 \times 10^{-3}} \approx \frac{2}{3} This laboratory analysis yields an empirical ratio of IX3ClX2\ce{I3Cl2} (or IX2ClX3\ce{I2Cl3} depending on halogen coordination context). Given that the compound crystallizes as the planar dimer IX2ClX6\ce{I2Cl6} and dissociates at 120∘C120^\circ\text{C} into monomeric IClx\ce{ICl}_x, the stoichiometry of the monomer is IClX3\ce{ICl3}.

Part (b): VSEPR Analysis of Monomeric IClX3\ce{ICl3}

  1. Count the total valence electrons:

    • Both iodine and chlorine are halogens (Group 17), each contributing 77 valence electrons: Total valence electrons=7+3(7)=28 electrons\text{Total valence electrons} = 7 + 3(7) = 28\text{ electrons}
  2. Determine electron domains and steric number:

    • Central atom: Iodine (I\ce{I}) forms 33 single bonds to the three chlorine atoms, using 3×2=63 \times 2 = 6 electrons.
    • Each terminal chlorine holds 33 nonbonding lone pairs (3×6=183 \times 6 = 18 electrons).
    • Remaining electrons on the central iodine: 28−(6+18)=4 electrons=2 lone pairs28 - (6 + 18) = 4\text{ electrons} = 2\text{ lone pairs}
    • The steric number (SN\text{SN}) of the central atom is: SN=3 bonded atoms+2 lone pairs=5\text{SN} = 3\text{ bonded atoms} + 2\text{ lone pairs} = 5 This corresponds to the VSEPR notation AXX3EX2\ce{AX3E2}.
  3. Electron-domain geometry and molecular geometry:

    • Electron-Domain Geometry: Trigonal bipyramidal.
    • In a trigonal bipyramid, lone pairs occupy the equatorial positions to minimize repulsive 90∘90^\circ interactions. With 22 equatorial positions occupied by lone pairs and the remaining 33 positions (two axial, one equatorial) occupied by chlorine atoms, the resulting molecular geometry is T-shaped.
  4. Bond angles:

    • Repulsion between lone pairs and bonding pairs is stronger than bonding pair-bonding pair repulsion (LP-BP>BP-BP\text{LP-BP} > \text{BP-BP}).
    • The two equatorial lone pairs push the axial I−Cl\ce{I-Cl} bonds slightly away from the equatorial plane toward the equatorial chlorine atom.
    • Consequently:
      • ∠ClXax−I−ClXeq<90∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{eq}} < 90^\circ, typically about 86∘ to 88∘86^\circ \text{ to } 88^\circ.
      • ∠ClXax−I−ClXax<180∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{ax}} < 180^\circ, approximately 175∘175^\circ.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the 5 electron domains around iodine by treating lone pairs as equivalent to bonding pairs, concluding the molecular shape is trigonal planar rather than T-shaped.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mass Cl=0.287×35.45143.32=0.0710 g  ⟹  mol Cl=0.071035.45=0.00200 mol  ⟹  mass I=0.467−0.0710=0.396 g  ⟹  mol I=0.396126.90=0.00312 mol  ⟹  ratio Cl : I≈2:3, empirical formula=IX3ClX2\text{mass Cl} = 0.287 \times \frac{35.45}{143.32} = 0.0710\text{ g} \implies \text{mol Cl} = \frac{0.0710}{35.45} = 0.00200\text{ mol} \implies \text{mass I} = 0.467 - 0.0710 = 0.396\text{ g} \implies \text{mol I} = \frac{0.396}{126.90} = 0.00312\text{ mol} \implies \text{ratio Cl : I} \approx 2 : 3, \text{ empirical formula} = \ce{I3Cl2}

  2. Step 2

    Valence electrons=7+3(7)=28  ⟹  Central I has 3 single bonds and 2 lone pairs=5 electron domains\text{Valence electrons} = 7 + 3(7) = 28 \implies \text{Central I has 3 single bonds and 2 lone pairs} = 5\text{ electron domains}

  3. Step 3

    Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal\text{Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal}

  4. Step 4

    Molecular geometry: trigonal planar  ⟹  Bond angles: 120∘\text{Molecular geometry: trigonal planar} \implies \text{Bond angles: } 120^\circ

    Correct

    Molecular geometry: T-shaped;  ∠ClXax−I−ClXeq<90∘ (approx. 86∘–88∘) and ∠ClXax−I−ClXax<180∘ (approx. 175∘)\text{Molecular geometry: T-shaped};\; \angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{eq}} < 90^\circ\text{ (approx. } 86^\circ\text{--}88^\circ\text{) and } \angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{ax}} < 180^\circ\text{ (approx. } 175^\circ\text{)}

    For an AXX3EX2\ce{AX3E2} system derived from a trigonal bipyramid, the two lone pairs occupy equatorial positions to minimize 90∘90^\circ repulsions. Looking only at the nuclear positions of the bonded atoms yields a T-shaped molecular geometry, not a trigonal planar geometry. Furthermore, lone pair–bonding pair repulsion compresses the bond angles below 90∘90^\circ and 180∘180^\circ rather than maintaining 120∘120^\circ.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately converted the gravimetric mass of AgCl\ce{AgCl} to determine the empirical ratio of iodine to chlorine.

You correctly tallied the 28 total valence electrons for monomeric IClX3\ce{ICl3}.

You correctly found the steric number of 5 and identified the trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
VSEPR molecular geometry vs. electron domain mismatch

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assigned the molecular geometry based strictly on the number of surrounding bonded atoms (3 bonds →\rightarrow trigonal planar) rather than taking the parent trigonal bipyramidal framework and removing the two equatorial lone-pair positions to reveal the resulting T-shape.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Steric Number vs. Molecular Shape
  • Molecular geometry describes only the spatial arrangement of the bonded nuclei, but it is dictated by the parent electron-domain geometry. An AXX3EX2\ce{AX3E2} arrangement (steric number 5 with 2 lone pairs) is T-shaped, whereas trigonal planar is strictly AXX3EX0\ce{AX3E0} (steric number 3).

  • Always start with the parent electron-domain geometry (trigonal bipyramidal), place lone pairs in equatorial positions where they experience the least repulsion, and name the resulting shape formed by the remaining bonded atoms.

Lone-Pair Repulsion and Bond Angle Compression
  • Lone pair–bonding pair (LP–BP) repulsions are stronger than bonding pair–bonding pair (BP–BP) repulsions, compressing adjacent bond angles slightly below their ideal values.

  • State bond angles as <90∘<90^\circ (approximately 86∘–88∘86^\circ\text{--}88^\circ) and <180∘<180^\circ (approximately 175∘175^\circ) rather than unperturbed ideal angles.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Place the 2 lone pairs of iodine in the equatorial sites of the trigonal bipyramid to minimize 90∘90^\circ electron repulsions.

  2. The three chlorine atoms occupy the remaining two axial positions and one equatorial position, giving a T-shaped molecular geometry.

  3. Because the equatorial lone pairs exert greater repulsion than bonding pairs, they push the axial I−Cl\ce{I-Cl} bonds slightly inward toward the equatorial I−Cl\ce{I-Cl} bond.

  4. The resulting bond angles are ∠ClXax−I−ClXeq<90∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{eq}} < 90^\circ (around 86∘ to 88∘86^\circ\text{ to } 88^\circ) and ∠ClXax−I−ClXax≈175∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{ax}} \approx 175^\circ.

Final answer

Molecular geometry: T-shaped; bond angles: ∠ClXax−I−ClXeq<90∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{eq}} < 90^\circ (approx. 86∘–88∘86^\circ\text{--}88^\circ) and ∠ClXax−I−ClXax≈175∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{ax}} \approx 175^\circ.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the trigonal bipyramidal frame showing the 2 equatorial lone-pair lobes and 3 chlorine atoms to visually confirm the T-shape.

  • Practice distinguishing AXX3\ce{AX3} (trigonal planar), AXX3E\ce{AX3E} (trigonal pyramidal), and AXX3EX2\ce{AX3E2} (T-shaped).

  • Review how lone-pair repulsions perturb ideal 90∘90^\circ and 180∘180^\circ angles in expanded-octet geometries.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student places the two lone pairs on the central iodine in axial positions instead of equatorial positions, resulting in an incorrect molecular geometry of trigonal planar with 120° bond angles.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mass Cl=0.287×(35.45143.32)=0.0710 g  ⟹  mol Cl=0.00200 mol  ⟹  mass I=0.467−0.0710=0.396 g  ⟹  mol I=0.396126.90=0.00312 mol  ⟹  empirical formula=IX3ClX2\text{mass Cl} = 0.287 \times \left(\frac{35.45}{143.32}\right) = 0.0710\text{ g} \implies \text{mol Cl} = 0.00200\text{ mol} \implies \text{mass I} = 0.467 - 0.0710 = 0.396\text{ g} \implies \text{mol I} = \frac{0.396}{126.90} = 0.00312\text{ mol} \implies \text{empirical formula} = \ce{I3Cl2}

  2. Step 2

    Valence electrons=7+3(7)=28  ⟹  Central I has 5 electron domains (3 bonding pairs, 2 lone pairs)\text{Valence electrons} = 7 + 3(7) = 28 \implies \text{Central I has 5 electron domains (3 bonding pairs, 2 lone pairs)}

  3. Step 3

    Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal\text{Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal}

  4. Step 4

    Lone pairs occupy the two axial positions to minimize repulsion\text{Lone pairs occupy the two axial positions to minimize repulsion}

    Correct

    Lone pairs occupy equatorial positions in a trigonal bipyramid because equatorial sites experience only two 90∘90^\circ repulsions, whereas axial sites experience three 90∘90^\circ repulsions.

    In a trigonal bipyramidal geometry, nonbonding electron pairs exert greater repulsion than bonding pairs. Placing a lone pair in an axial position creates three unfavorable 90∘90^\circ interactions, whereas an equatorial position creates only two 90∘90^\circ interactions. Therefore, both lone pairs must occupy equatorial positions.

  5. Step 5

    Molecular geometry: trigonal planar  ⟹  Bond angles: 120∘\text{Molecular geometry: trigonal planar} \implies \text{Bond angles: } 120^\circ

    Correct

    Molecular geometry: T-shaped;  ∠ClXax−I−ClXeq<90∘  (≈86∘–88∘),∠ClXax−I−ClXax≈175∘\text{Molecular geometry: T-shaped};\; \angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{eq}} < 90^\circ\; (\approx 86^\circ\text{--}88^\circ), \angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{ax}} \approx 175^\circ

    Because you placed the two lone pairs in axial positions, you deduced a trigonal planar geometry with 120∘120^\circ angles. With the lone pairs correctly placed at equatorial sites, the three chlorine atoms occupy two axial positions and one equatorial position, giving a T-shaped geometry with bond angles slightly less than 90∘90^\circ and 180∘180^\circ.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately converted gravimetric precipitate mass into molar quantities of chlorine and iodine.

You correctly counted the 28 valence electrons in monomeric IClX3\ce{ICl3}.

You properly identified the steric number of 5 and assigned the trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equatorial vs Axial Lone Pair Site Preference

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that axial positions minimize electron repulsion in a trigonal bipyramidal system, overlooking that axial sites have three destabilizing 90∘90^\circ neighbors while equatorial sites have only two.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Steric Site Repulsion Rule for Trigonal Bipyramidal Geometry
  • In a trigonal bipyramid, lone pairs and bulky ligands always preferentially occupy equatorial positions to minimize unfavorable 90∘90^\circ electron-pair repulsions.

  • Whenever you encounter a steric number of 5 (such as AXX4E\ce{AX4E}, AXX3EX2\ce{AX3E2}, or AXX2EX3\ce{AX2E3}), always place the nonbonding lone pairs in the equatorial plane first before determining molecular geometry.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Count 90∘90^\circ interactions: an axial lone pair experiences three 90∘90^\circ interactions, whereas an equatorial lone pair experiences only two 90∘90^\circ interactions.

  2. Place both lone pairs in the equatorial plane of the trigonal bipyramid.

  3. Position the three chlorine atoms in the remaining sites: two axial and one equatorial.

  4. Observe the shape formed by the bonded atoms alone: this forms a T-shaped molecular geometry.

  5. Account for lone pair-bonding pair repulsion pushing the axial bonds toward the equatorial chlorine: ∠ClXax−I−ClXeq≈86∘–88∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{eq}} \approx 86^\circ\text{--}88^\circ and ∠ClXax−I−ClXax≈175∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{ax}} \approx 175^\circ.

Final answer

Molecular geometry: T-shaped; Bond angles: ∠ClXax−I−ClXeq<90∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{eq}} < 90^\circ (approx. 86∘–88∘86^\circ\text{--}88^\circ) and ∠ClXax−I−ClXax<180∘\angle\ce{Cl_{ax}-I-Cl_{ax}} < 180^\circ (approx. 175∘175^\circ).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the spatial interaction counts (90∘90^\circ vs 120∘120^\circ) for axial and equatorial sites in trigonal bipyramidal systems.

  • Practice sketching VSEPR geometries for all steric number 5 variants: seesaw (AXX4E\ce{AX4E}), T-shaped (AXX3EX2\ce{AX3E2}), and linear (AXX2EX3\ce{AX2E3}).

  • Incorporate lone-pair repulsion adjustments to explain why bond angles deviate below ideal values (<90∘< 90^\circ and <180∘< 180^\circ).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine the electron-domain geometry, molecular geometry, and approximate bond angles for xenon difluoride (XeFX2\ce{XeF2}).

Answer

Valence electrons: 8+2(7)=228 + 2(7) = 22. Central Xe\ce{Xe} has 2 bonding pairs and 3 lone pairs (steric number 5, AXX2EX3\ce{AX2E3}). Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal. All 3 lone pairs reside in equatorial positions, so the molecular geometry is linear with an ideal bond angle of 180∘180^\circ.

02

Sulfur tetrafluoride (SFX4\ce{SF4}) has 34 valence electrons. Predict its electron-domain geometry, molecular geometry, and whether its equatorial and axial bond angles are greater or less than ideal.

Answer

Central S\ce{S} has 4 bonding pairs and 1 lone pair (steric number 5, AXX4E\ce{AX4E}). Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal. The lone pair occupies an equatorial position, giving a seesaw molecular geometry. Repulsion from the lone pair compresses bond angles to ∠FXax−S−FXax<180∘\angle\ce{F_{ax}-S-F_{ax}} < 180^\circ (approx. 173∘173^\circ) and ∠FXeq−S−FXeq<120∘\angle\ce{F_{eq}-S-F_{eq}} < 120^\circ (approx. 102∘102^\circ).

03

A interhalogen anion [IClX4]X−\ce{[ICl4]^-} is formed in solution. Determine the total valence electron count, the steric number on iodine, the electron-domain geometry, the molecular geometry, and the ∠Cl−I−Cl\angle\ce{Cl-I-Cl} bond angles.

Answer

Total valence electrons: 7+4(7)+1=367 + 4(7) + 1 = 36. Central I\ce{I} has 4 bonding pairs and 2 lone pairs (steric number 6, AXX4EX2\ce{AX4E2}). Electron-domain geometry: octahedral. To minimize repulsions, the 2 lone pairs occupy opposite (trans) axial positions, yielding a square planar molecular geometry with bond angles of exactly 90∘90^\circ.

Loading workspace…