Resources
A standard laboratory titration is conducted to determine the concentration of an unlabelled sulfurous acid solution (). In the experiment, a aliquot of is titrated to its second equivalence point with , requiring exactly of titrant to convert all acid to the sulfite ion, . (a) Calculate the analytical molarity of the original solution. (b) For the generated analyte ion at the endpoint, , draw the most stable Lewis structure that satisfies the octet rule for oxygen while minimizing formal charges on the central sulfur via an expanded octet. (c) In this minimized formal charge Lewis structure, state: (1) the number of double bonds, (2) the number of single bonds, (3) the number of lone pairs on the central sulfur atom, and (4) the formal charge of the central sulfur atom.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Moles of . From stoichiometry , moles of . Molarity of ; (b) Total valence electrons in ; (c) In the formal-charge-minimized structure: (1) Number of double bonds = ; (2) Number of single bonds = ; (3) Lone pairs on central ; (4) Formal charge on central (the two single-bonded oxygens carry formal charges of each, and the double-bonded oxygen has a formal charge of ).
Steps
Part (a): Analytical Molarity of
- Write the balanced neutralization equation: Sulfurous acid () is a diprotic acid. At the second equivalence point, both protons are neutralized by hydroxide ions:
- Calculate the moles of consumed:
- Determine the moles of present in the aliquot: Using the stoichiometric mole ratio ():
- Calculate the molarity of the acid solution:
Part (b): Lewis Structure for
-
Count total valence electrons:
- Sulfur ():
- Three oxygen atoms ():
- Ionic charge of :
-
Form the skeletal frame and satisfy outer octets:
- Place the less electronegative sulfur atom in the center and connect each oxygen with a single bond ().
- Distribute lone pairs ( electrons) to each oxygen to complete their octets ().
- Electrons used so far: . Place the remaining electrons as a lone pair on the central sulfur atom.
-
Minimize formal charges via an expanded octet:
- With three single bonds, the formal charges are:
- Because sulfur is in Period 3, it has accessible orbitals and can expand its octet beyond electrons. Converting one lone pair from an oxygen atom into an double bond reduces the formal charge of that oxygen from to , and reduces the formal charge on sulfur from to .
Part (c): Structure Characteristics
From the formal-charge-minimized Lewis structure:
- Number of double bonds:
- Number of single bonds:
- Number of lone pairs on the central sulfur atom:
- Formal charge on the central sulfur atom: (The two single-bonded oxygens each retain a formal charge of , matching the overall net charge of .)
Typical errors
01 The student assumes a 1:1 stoichiometric mole ratio between diprotic sulfurous acid and sodium hydroxide instead of 1:2, doubling the calculated acid concentration.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Sulfurous acid () is diprotic. Reaching the second equivalence point requires of per of , which makes the true concentration half of your result.
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
with all oxygen octets filled (three lone pairs on each single-bonded , two lone pairs on the double-bonded , and one lone pair on )
In the base octet structure of with three single bonds, sulfur has a formal charge of . Converting just one single bond into an double bond reduces sulfur's formal charge to . Adding a second double bond unnecessarily gives sulfur a formal charge of and leaves out the required lone pairs on oxygen.
- Step 5Correct
, , ,
The minimized structure contains double bond and single bonds. Furthermore, evaluating yields , not .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the moles of from its concentration and volume.
You correctly determined the total count of valence electrons for the ion.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeIn your formal charge arithmetic on sulfur, you wrote instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated diprotic acid titration at the second equivalence point as a neutralization, and when expanding the octet of sulfur, you added double bonds until sulfur had five bonding pairs rather than stopping as soon as sulfur's formal charge reached zero.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Equivalence Point Equivalence Ratio
For an -protic acid titrated to its -th equivalence point, .
Always write the balanced neutralization equation first and identify whether the titration stops at the first or second equivalence point.
- Minimizing Formal Charges
. Stop converting lone pairs into double bonds as soon as the central atom's formal charge reaches zero (or cannot be reduced further without placing unfavorable charges on more electronegative atoms).
Calculate the formal charge after each newly formed double bond: starting from with three single bonds, exactly one double bond brings to .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the balanced reaction for the second equivalence point: .
Calculate moles of acid: .
Determine analytical molarity: .
Construct the base octet structure for ( electrons): central with lone pair and single bonds to gives .
Form one double bond using an oxygen lone pair: , achieving minimal formal charge.
(a) ; (b) with octets completed on all oxygens; (c) (1) double bond, (2) single bonds, (3) lone pair on , (4) .
02 The student strictly obeys the octet rule for the central sulfur atom without expanding its octet to minimize formal charges, resulting in three single bonds and a +1 formal charge on sulfur.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
Central atom bonded to three atoms by single bonds with one lone pair on , giving each atom an octet, with overall charge
CorrectForm one double bond and two single bonds around central (retaining 1 lone pair on ), expanding the octet of sulfur to 10 electrons to minimize formal charges.
While your structure satisfies the octet rule for all atoms, sulfur is a Period 3 element with accessible orbitals. The prompt specifically asked to minimize formal charges via an expanded octet. Converting one lone pair from an oxygen atom into an double bond reduces the formal charge of from to and that oxygen from to .
- Step 4
Number of double bonds = ; Number of single bonds = ; Lone pairs on ; Formal charge on
Correct(1) Number of double bonds = ; (2) Number of single bonds = ; (3) Lone pairs on ; (4) Formal charge on
These counts follow logically from your octet structure, but because the structure did not minimize formal charges, the bond counts and sulfur's formal charge differ from the required structure.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou executed the titration stoichiometry and molarity calculation flawlessly.
You accurately counted the 26 total valence electrons for the sulfite ion.
You calculated formal charges systematically using the correct valence formula.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou built an octet-compliant structure rather than expanding sulfur's valence shell to reduce its formal charge to zero.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the octet rule as an absolute constraint rather than recognizing that elements in Period 3 and beyond can use accessible subshells to form additional bonds when doing so minimizes formal charge.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Central Atom Period
Elements in Period 2 (C, N, O, F) never exceed an octet; elements in Period 3 or below (P, S, Cl, etc.) can expand their octets.
Always verify the row of the central atom on the periodic table before finalizing a structure.
- Evaluate and Minimize Formal Charge
. A structure with formal charges closest to zero is generally more stable.
If the central atom is in Period 3 or higher and carries a positive formal charge next to negatively charged terminal atoms, share a lone pair to form a double bond until formal charges are minimized.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationStart from the single-bonded skeleton: has 1 lone pair and three single bonds (total 8 electrons, ). Each has 3 lone pairs ().
Convert one lone pair from one oxygen into a second bonding pair with sulfur, forming one double bond.
Recalculate formal charges: Double-bonded oxygen has . Central sulfur has 10 valence electrons around it and . The two single-bonded oxygens each retain .
(a) ; (b) Lewis structure with one double bond, two single bonds, and one lone pair on sulfur; (c) (1) double bond, (2) single bonds, (3) lone pair, (4) Formal charge .
03 The student converts all three S-O bonds into S=O double bonds, expanding the octet excessively and violating the octet rule for oxygen or overcounting valence electrons.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You expanded the octet excessively to set every oxygen atom's formal charge to . In an oxyanion, negative formal charges should reside on the more electronegative oxygen atoms rather than forcing a charge onto the less electronegative central sulfur atom.
- Step 4Correct
Because your Lewis structure incorporated three double bonds instead of one, your counts for double bonds, single bonds, and the central sulfur atom's formal charge were all affected by the initial bonding error.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou executed the analytical titration stoichiometry flawlessly to find the molarity of .
You counted the total number of valence electrons for the sulfite ion accurately as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou prioritized zeroing out formal charges on terminal oxygen atoms rather than minimizing the formal charge on the central sulfur atom, neglecting the principle that negative formal charges must reside on the more electronegative terminal atoms.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluate Electronegativity in Polyatomic Anions
For any anion carrying a net charge , negative formal charges should reside on the more electronegative atoms (such as oxygen) rather than a less electronegative central atom.
Leave formal charges on terminal oxygen atoms until the overall ionic charge is accounted for, rather than forcing negative charge onto the central sulfur.
- Target Formal Charge Zero for Central Period 3 Atoms
. For a neutral or positive central sulfur atom with a lone pair (), setting bonds gives .
Convert only enough oxygen lone pairs into double bonds to reduce the central atom's formal charge to .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationStart with a single-bonded skeleton: place central with three single bonds, three lone pairs on each oxygen, and one lone pair on sulfur ( electrons used).
Compute the initial formal charges: each single-bonded oxygen has , and central sulfur has .
Convert exactly one lone pair from one oxygen into an double bond. This adjusts that oxygen to and brings the sulfur to .
Leave the remaining two oxygens as single bonds with formal charges of each, which appropriately carries the overall charge on the more electronegative atoms.
(a) ; (b) Sulfite with one double bond, two single bonds, and one lone pair on ; (c) (1) , (2) , (3) , (4)
Lock it in
How do you relate moles of base to moles of diprotic acid at the second equivalence point?
. Memory cue: 'Second equivalence point' means both ionizable protons have reacted.
Similar question
A sample of oxalic acid (, diprotic) requires of to reach the second equivalence point. Calculate the molarity of the oxalic acid.
Answer
. Key steps: . Because it is at the 2nd equivalence point, . .
Draw the formal-charge-minimized Lewis structure of the thiosulfate ion, (with one central S bonded to three O atoms and one terminal S atom). State the formal charge on the central S atom.
Answer
Central S has lone pairs, two double bonds (one and one , or two ), and two single bonds to O. Total bonds to central , so .
For the chlorate ion (), determine: (1) total valence electrons, (2) the number of double bonds in the formal-charge-minimized Lewis structure, and (3) the formal charge of the central chlorine atom.
Answer
(1) valence electrons; (2) double bonds; (3) (wait, chlorine has valence electrons: ). Key steps: Base structure with 3 single bonds gives . Forming two double bonds reduces to .