Resources
A sample of solid calcium carbonate () is subjected to two sequential procedures. In Procedure A, the solid is pulverized using an agate mortar until its average particle diameter decreases from to . In Procedure B, the pulverized sample is heated to in an open crucible, undergoing thermal decomposition into solid calcium oxide () and carbon dioxide gas (). (a) Classify each procedure as either a physical change or a chemical change. (b) Determine the target quantitative variable: the theoretical percentage change in solid mass, , observed in the crucible during Procedure B (use molar masses: , , ).
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Procedure A is a physical change; Procedure B is a chemical change. (b) The theoretical percentage change in solid mass during Procedure B is .
Steps
Calculate the Molar Masses
Part (a): Classifying the Procedures
- Procedure A (Grinding/Pulverizing):
- Observation: The particle size of solid calcium carbonate () decreases from to .
- Classification: Physical change.
- Reasoning: Pulverizing changes only the physical state of subdivision (surface area and particle diameter) without altering the internal chemical identity or chemical bonds of calcium carbonate. No new substances are formed.
- Procedure B (Thermal Decomposition):
- Observation: Solid is heated to , yielding solid calcium oxide () and carbon dioxide gas ().
- Classification: Chemical change.
- Reasoning: Chemical bonds are broken and new bonds are formed, transforming the original compound into two entirely distinct chemical substances with different properties.
Part (b): Calculating the Percentage Change in Solid Mass
Using the given atomic masses:
Write the Balanced Chemical Equation
From stoichiometry, of () decomposes to form of solid () and releases of gaseous () into the surroundings.
Determine the Theoretical Solid Mass Change
Because the crucible is open, the gas escapes, leaving only solid in the crucible.
The change in solid mass per mole of is:
Notice that this lost mass corresponds exactly to the escaped gas:
Calculate the Percentage Change
The percentage change in solid mass is independent of the initial sample mass:
(Alternatively, for of : the moles of are . The remaining mass of is . The mass change is , giving .)
Common Pitfall: Forgetting the negative sign. A decrease in mass represents a negative percentage change ().
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that the change is a mass loss and computes the percentage change as a positive value by using the magnitude or subtracting initial from final in reverse.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Procedure A is a physical change. Procedure B is a chemical change.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You calculated the percentage change using a positive mass value instead of the signed difference . Because the crucible loses mass when carbon dioxide gas escapes, the solid mass decreases, giving a negative change of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished between physical and chemical changes.
You calculated the relevant molar masses and the stoichiometric mass loss with complete accuracy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou used the positive magnitude of the escaped gas mass rather than defining the mass change as final solid mass minus initial solid mass.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating percentage change as an unsigned ratio of lost quantity rather than strictly evaluating the signed formula .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Signed Change Definition
Any change represented by is strictly defined as , not .
Always substitute the final state first and initial state second: a decrease must produce a negative value.
- Open Crucible Mass Loss
When a gas is released from an open container, the remaining solid mass decreases, meaning .
Check the physical reality of the experiment: if the sample gets lighter, verify that your percentage change carries a negative sign.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the initial and final molar masses of the solid phase: (solid ) and (solid ).
Calculate the change in solid mass: .
Compute the percentage change: .
(a) Procedure A is a physical change; Procedure B is a chemical change. (b) The theoretical percentage change in solid mass during Procedure B is .
02 The student assumes mass is conserved in the crucible because of the law of conservation of mass, overlooking that carbon dioxide gas escapes the open system.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Procedure A is a physical change. ⟹ Procedure B is a chemical change.
- Step 2
By mass conservation, total mass after reaction = mass before reaction ⟹ m(final) = 12.0 g
CorrectWhile total mass in the universe is conserved, the crucible is an open container. The gaseous product escapes into the surrounding air, leaving only solid in the crucible.
- Step 3Correct
Because the remaining solid mass was evaluated incorrectly in the previous step, your calculation resulted in a change instead of the expected mass loss of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished between a physical change and a chemical change based on whether new substances were formed.
You remembered the formula for percentage change.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the open crucible as a closed system, assuming the measured solid mass must stay constant because of mass conservation, while overlooking the loss of gaseous reaction products.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Open vs. Closed Systems
The law of conservation of mass applies to the entire closed system. In an open container, any evolved gas escapes, reducing the measured mass inside the vessel.
Always check whether any products are in the gas state and whether the container is open to the atmosphere.
- Solid Mass Stoichiometry
For a thermal decomposition , the remaining solid mass corresponds exclusively to solid product .
Calculate the moles of the solid reactant, relate them via stoichiometric coefficients to the solid product, and convert to grams using the molar mass of the solid product.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the balanced reaction: .
Calculate the molar masses: and .
Determine the moles of initial : .
Find the final solid mass of : .
Compute the percentage change: .
(a) Procedure A is a physical change; Procedure B is a chemical change. (b)
03 The student divides the mass change by the final solid mass instead of the initial mass when calculating the percentage change.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Procedure A is a physical change. Procedure B is a chemical change.
- Step 2
= 100.09 = 56.08 m = -44.01
- Step 3
m% = -44.01 / 56.08 100% = -78.5%
Correctm_{}% = 100% = 100% -44.0%_
You divided by the final solid molar mass () instead of the initial solid molar mass (). The base of any percentage change formula is always the initial value.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the physical and chemical changes in part (a).
You calculated the molar masses of and with high precision.
You correctly determined that the reaction loses as escaping gas.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally placed the remaining solid mass () in the denominator instead of the starting mass ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the reference state (initial value) with the product state (final value) when computing relative fractional or percentage change.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Reference Base for Percentage Change
Percentage change always compares the difference to the original starting value: .
Always double-check the denominator before calculating: ensure it matches the initial starting quantity.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubstitute the mass change () and initial molar mass () into the formula: .
Evaluate the fraction: .
(a) Procedure A is a physical change; Procedure B is a chemical change. (b) The theoretical percentage change in solid mass during Procedure B is .
Lock it in
How is the change in a physical or chemical quantity and its percentage change mathematically defined?
and . A decrease always yields a negative value.
Similar question
A piece of copper metal is heated in air and reacts completely with oxygen to form solid copper(II) oxide according to . (a) Is this a physical or chemical change? (b) Calculate the theoretical percentage change in solid mass, , given atomic masses and .
Answer
(a) Chemical change, because new chemical bonds form producing . (b) . One mole of solid () gains solid mass to become one mole of (). .
A block of dry ice (solid ) at is left in an open beaker at room temperature until has sublimed into gas. (a) Classify sublimation as a physical or chemical change. (b) Determine the percentage change in solid mass, , remaining in the beaker.
Answer
(a) Physical change, because sublimation changes only the physical state without altering the molecular identity of . (b) . Remaining mass . .
Solid sodium hydrogen carbonate decomposes upon heating: . A student heats an open crucible containing pure until decomposition is complete. Calculate the theoretical percentage change in solid mass, . (Use molar masses: , ).
Answer
. Two moles of initial solid reactant have mass . The remaining solid is one mole of () because gaseous and escape. .