Resources

A student evaluates whether energy is released or absorbed in nuclear reactions based on the nuclear binding energy per nucleon (BE/ABE/A) curve. The curve peaks at approximately 2862Ni^{62}_{28}\text{Ni} and 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} (BE/A≈8.8 MeV/nucleonBE/A \approx 8.8\,\text{MeV/nucleon}). (a) If two hypothetical light nuclei with BE/A=7.10 MeV/nucleonBE/A = 7.10\,\text{MeV/nucleon} fuse to produce a heavier nucleus with BE/A=8.40 MeV/nucleonBE/A = 8.40\,\text{MeV/nucleon}, determine the sign of the reaction QQ-value and state whether fusion is exoergic (Q>0Q > 0) or endoergic (Q<0Q < 0). (b) The student mistakenly asserts that 'splitting any heavy nucleus via fission releases energy, so splitting iron-56 into aluminum-28 will also release energy.' Correct this convention trap by stating whether the fission of 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} has Q>0Q > 0 or Q<0Q < 0, and justify using binding energy per nucleon.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Q>0Q > 0 (positive), the fusion reaction is exoergic; (b) For iron-56 fission, Q<0Q < 0 (negative, endoergic), because 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} lies at the binding energy maximum, so its fission fragments have a lower average binding energy per nucleon, requiring a net input of energy.

Steps

01

Analyze the Fusion Reaction in Part (a)

Understanding Binding Energy and the Reaction QQ-Value

The total nuclear binding energy of a nucleus with mass number AA is: BEtotal=A⋅(BEA)BE_{\text{total}} = A \cdot \left(\frac{BE}{A}\right) In any nuclear reaction, the total number of nucleons AA is conserved. The energy released or absorbed, known as the reaction QQ-value, is the difference between the total binding energy of the products and that of the reactants: Q=BEproducts−BEreactants=∑Aproducts(BEA)products−∑Areactants(BEA)reactantsQ = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}} = \sum A_{\text{products}} \left(\frac{BE}{A}\right)_{\text{products}} - \sum A_{\text{reactants}} \left(\frac{BE}{A}\right)_{\text{reactants}}

  • When the products are more tightly bound on average, Q>0Q > 0 (energy is released; the reaction is exoergic).
  • When the products are less tightly bound on average, Q<0Q < 0 (energy must be supplied; the reaction is endoergic).

  • Initial state: Reactant nuclei have (BEA)initial=7.10 MeV/nucleon\left(\frac{BE}{A}\right)_{\text{initial}} = 7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon}.
  • Final state: The fused nucleus has (BEA)final=8.40 MeV/nucleon\left(\frac{BE}{A}\right)_{\text{final}} = 8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

Because the total mass number AA is conserved:

Q=A⋅(8.40 MeV/nucleon−7.10 MeV/nucleon)=A⋅(+1.30 MeV/nucleon)>0Q = A \cdot \left(8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon} - 7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon}\right) = A \cdot (+1.30\text{ MeV/nucleon}) > 0

Since Q>0Q > 0 (positive), the reaction releases energy and is exoergic.


02

Evaluate the Fission of Iron-56 in Part (b)

A common misconception is that all fission reactions release energy. However, spontaneous or energy-releasing nuclear reactions must move toward higher values on the binding energy curve:

  1. The Peak of Stability: 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\ce{Fe} and 2862Ni^{62}_{28}\ce{Ni} reside at the absolute maximum of the BE/ABE/A curve (≈8.8 MeV/nucleon\approx 8.8\text{ MeV/nucleon}). Their nucleons are more tightly bound than those of any lighter or heavier nuclei.
  2. Splitting Iron: Fission of 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\ce{Fe} into lighter fragments like 1328Al^{28}_{13}\ce{Al} moves down the curve to the left, where nuclei have a lower binding energy per nucleon: (BEA)Al-28<(BEA)Fe-56\left(\frac{BE}{A}\right)_{\ce{Al-28}} < \left(\frac{BE}{A}\right)_{\ce{Fe-56}}
  3. Determining the Sign of QQ: Q=BEproducts−BEreactants<0Q = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}} < 0

Because the daughter nuclei have a lower total binding energy than the parent iron nucleus, splitting 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\ce{Fe} requires a net input of energy. Therefore, Q<0Q < 0 (negative), making the process endoergic. Fission only releases energy (Q>0Q > 0) for very heavy nuclei (A≫56A \gg 56, such as X235X22235U\ce{^{235}U}) whose fragments have higher BE/ABE/A values closer to the iron peak.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the energy sign convention for binding energy with potential energy or standard enthalpy of formation, subtracting product binding energy from reactant binding energy to conclude Q is negative.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    BE/A increases from 7.10 MeV/nucleon to 8.40 MeV/nucleon  ⟹  Q=BEinitial−BEfinal  ⟹  Q=A×(7.10−8.40) MeV=−1.30A MeV<0BE/A\text{ increases from }7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon to }8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon} \implies Q = BE_{\text{initial}} - BE_{\text{final}} \implies Q = A \times (7.10 - 8.40)\text{ MeV} = -1.30A\text{ MeV} < 0

    Correct

    Q=BEfinal−BEinitial=A×(8.40−7.10) MeV=+1.30A MeV>0Q = BE_{\text{final}} - BE_{\text{initial}} = A \times (8.40 - 7.10)\text{ MeV} = +1.30A\text{ MeV} > 0

    Nuclear binding energy represents how tightly nucleons are held together (energy released upon formation). Therefore, a reaction that forms more tightly bound daughter nuclei releases energy: Q=BEproducts−BEreactants=BEfinal−BEinitialQ = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}} = BE_{\text{final}} - BE_{\text{initial}}. By setting Q=BEinitial−BEfinalQ = BE_{\text{initial}} - BE_{\text{final}}, you reversed the sign of the energy change.

  2. Step 2

    Fusion is endoergic\text{Fusion is endoergic}

    Correct

    Fusion is exoergic\text{Fusion is exoergic}

    Because of the reversed sign calculated in the previous step, you concluded that the reaction absorbs energy (Q<0Q < 0). Since the true QQ-value is positive, the fusion reaction is exoergic.

  3. Step 3

    Fission of iron-56 has Q<0  ⟹  Iron-56 sits at the maximum BE/A, so fragments have lower BE/A and total binding energy decreases\text{Fission of iron-56 has }Q < 0 \implies \text{Iron-56 sits at the maximum }BE/A\text{, so fragments have lower }BE/A\text{ and total binding energy decreases}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that iron-56 resides at the peak of the binding energy curve.

You correctly concluded that the fission of iron-56 yields daughter fragments with lower binding energy per nucleon, resulting in Q<0Q < 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nuclear Q-value sign convention inversion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated nuclear binding energy like thermodynamic potential energy or enthalpy of formation, writing Q=BEinitial−BEfinalQ = BE_{\text{initial}} - BE_{\text{final}} instead of Q=BEproducts−BEreactantsQ = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclear Q-Value vs. Total Binding Energy
  • Q=(∑mreactants−∑mproducts)c2=BEproducts−BEreactantsQ = (\sum m_{\text{reactants}} - \sum m_{\text{products}})c^2 = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}}

  • Always compute QQ as products minus reactants when using binding energies (BEfinal−BEinitialBE_{\text{final}} - BE_{\text{initial}}).

Spontaneous Reactions Move Toward the Peak
  • Reactions that increase average binding energy per nucleon (BE/ABE/A) release energy (Q>0Q > 0, exoergic).

  • Check that any reaction moving upward on the BE/ABE/A curve yields Q>0Q > 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that a higher binding energy means a more stable, lower-energy nuclear ground state, liberating excess energy to the surroundings: Q=BEproducts−BEreactantsQ = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}}.

  2. Substitute the given binding energies per nucleon: Q=A⋅(8.40 MeV/nucleon−7.10 MeV/nucleon)=+1.30A MeV>0Q = A \cdot (8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon} - 7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon}) = +1.30A\text{ MeV} > 0.

  3. Conclude that because Q>0Q > 0, the fusion reaction is exoergic.

Final answer

(a) Q>0Q > 0 (positive), fusion is exoergic; (b) For iron-56 fission, Q<0Q < 0 (negative, endoergic), because iron-56 sits at the binding energy maximum and fragments have a lower average binding energy per nucleon.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of nuclear binding energy as a positive quantity representing liberated energy during nucleus formation.

  • Practice calculating QQ-values using both nuclear mass defects Δm⋅c2\Delta m \cdot c^2 and binding energies ΔBE=BEfinal−BEinitial\Delta BE = BE_{\text{final}} - BE_{\text{initial}}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets higher binding energy as higher internal energy of the nucleus, concluding that forming a nucleus with higher BE/A absorbs energy rather than releasing it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Product nucleus has higher BE/A=8.40 MeV/nucleon\text{BE}/A = 8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon} compared to 7.10 MeV/nucleon  ⟹  7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon} \implies Higher binding energy means the nucleus holds more energy   ⟹  \implies Energy must be absorbed to build higher binding energy, so Q<0  ⟹  Q < 0 \implies Fusion is endoergic

    Correct

    Q=A⋅(8.40 MeV/nucleon−7.10 MeV/nucleon)=+1.30A MeV>0Q = A \cdot (8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon} - 7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon}) = +1.30 A\text{ MeV} > 0; fusion is exoergic.

    Nuclear binding energy is not internal energy stored in the nucleus; it is the energy released when nucleons bind together into a deeper potential well. Moving from lower BE/A\text{BE}/A (7.10 MeV/nucleon7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon}) to higher BE/A\text{BE}/A (8.40 MeV/nucleon8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon}) increases the total binding energy, meaning excess energy is liberated (Q>0Q > 0, exoergic).

  2. Step 2

    Fission of iron-56 has Q<0  ⟹  Q < 0 \implies Iron-56 has the highest BE/A\text{BE}/A, so breaking it into aluminum-28 decreases binding energy and requires net energy input

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that iron-56 sits at the peak of the binding energy curve.

You correctly deduced that splitting iron-56 into lighter fragments decreases total binding energy and requires a net input of energy (Q<0Q < 0).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Binding energy sign and definition confusion

In part (a), you treated binding energy as internal energy possessed by the nucleus rather than energy released upon formation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing nuclear binding energy (BEBE) with internal potential energy. Because binding energy represents the depth of the negative potential well (the energy liberated when forming the nucleus from separated nucleons), a higher BEBE means a lower, more stable nuclear mass-energy state. Consequently, any reaction where products have a higher total BEBE releases energy (Q=BEproducts−BEreactants>0Q = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}} > 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Meaning of Binding Energy
  • Binding energy (BEBE) is the energy released when free nucleons assemble into a bound nucleus: Enucleus=∑mnucleonsc2−BEE_{\text{nucleus}} = \sum m_{\text{nucleons}}c^2 - BE.

  • Always treat higher BEBE as a more tightly bound, lower-energy state, not a state that holds more energy.

Sign of Reaction Q-Value from Binding Energies
  • Q=BEproducts−BEreactantsQ = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}}.

  • When products have higher average BE/ABE/A than reactants, Q>0Q > 0 (exoergic, releases energy).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the QQ-value definition in terms of binding energy: Q=BEproducts−BEreactants=A⋅[(BE/A)product−(BE/A)reactants]Q = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}} = A \cdot [(\text{BE}/A)_{\text{product}} - (\text{BE}/A)_{\text{reactants}}].

  2. Substitute the given values: Q=A⋅(8.40 MeV/nucleon−7.10 MeV/nucleon)=A⋅(+1.30 MeV/nucleon)>0Q = A \cdot (8.40\text{ MeV/nucleon} - 7.10\text{ MeV/nucleon}) = A \cdot (+1.30\text{ MeV/nucleon}) > 0.

  3. Because Q>0Q > 0, net energy is released to the surroundings, which defines an exoergic reaction.

Final answer

(a) Q>0Q > 0, fusion is exoergic; (b) Q<0Q < 0, fission of iron-56 is endoergic because iron-56 has maximum BE/A\text{BE}/A and splitting it lowers total binding energy.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the mass defect relationship Δm=Zmp+Nmn−mnucleus\Delta m = Zm_p + Nm_n - m_{\text{nucleus}} to see why a larger mass defect corresponds to energy released rather than energy absorbed.

  • Practice calculating QQ-values using both nuclear masses (Q=(mreactants−mproducts)c2Q = (m_{\text{reactants}} - m_{\text{products}})c^2) and binding energies (Q=BEproducts−BEreactantsQ = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}}) to reinforce that the signs are identical.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes all fission reactions release energy by generalizing uranium fission to iron-56, claiming Q > 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Q=BEfinal−BEinitial=A(8.40−7.10) MeV=+1.30A MeV>0  ⟹  Fusion is exoergicQ = BE_{\text{final}} - BE_{\text{initial}} = A(8.40 - 7.10)\,\text{MeV} = +1.30A\,\text{MeV} > 0 \implies \text{Fusion is exoergic}

  2. Step 2

    "Splitting heavy nuclei always releases energy through fission. Fission of iron-56 into aluminum-28 has Q>0Q > 0. Iron-56 is a heavy nucleus, so splitting it releases nuclear binding energy."

    Correct

    For the fission of 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe}, Q<0Q < 0 (endoergic). Because 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} lies at the peak of the BE/ABE/A curve, its daughter nuclei (1328Al^{28}_{13}\text{Al}) have a lower average BE/ABE/A, leading to a net loss of total binding energy.

    You reinforced the misconception instead of correcting it. Nuclear reactions only release energy (Q>0Q > 0) when moving toward the peak of the BE/ABE/A curve at 56Fe^{56}\text{Fe}. Fissioning 56Fe^{56}\text{Fe} into lighter fragments moves away from the peak, resulting in BEproducts<BEreactantsBE_{\text{products}} < BE_{\text{reactants}} and Q<0Q < 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the difference in binding energy per nucleon to the sign of the reaction QQ-value in part (a).

You correctly deduced that an increase in binding energy makes a nuclear reaction exoergic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Generalizing Uranium Fission to All Nuclei

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that splitting any nucleus heavier than the smallest light nuclei releases energy by fission, overlooking that energy release requires the products to have a higher binding energy per nucleon than the reactant. Since iron-56 is already at the maximum of the BE/ABE/A curve, any division of iron-56 yields fragments with lower BE/ABE/A, making the process endoergic.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Criterion for Energy Release
  • A nuclear process is exoergic (Q>0Q > 0) if and only if the products have a higher average binding energy per nucleon than the reactants: Δ(BE/A)>0\Delta(BE/A) > 0.

  • Always locate reactants and products relative to the 56Fe^{56}\text{Fe} peak on the BE/ABE/A curve before deciding whether energy is released or absorbed.

The Role of Iron-56
  • 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} has nearly the highest binding energy per nucleon of all nuclides (~8.8 MeV/nucleon8.8\,\text{MeV/nucleon}).

  • Recognize that both fusing iron into heavier elements and splitting iron into lighter elements reduce BE/ABE/A and are strictly endoergic (Q<0Q < 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Locate 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} on the nuclear binding energy curve: it sits at the absolute peak (BE/A≈8.8 MeV/nucleonBE/A \approx 8.8\,\text{MeV/nucleon}).

  2. Compare the fragments to the parent: 1328Al^{28}_{13}\text{Al} lies to the left of the peak, so (BE/A)Al<(BE/A)Fe(BE/A)_{\text{Al}} < (BE/A)_{\text{Fe}}.

  3. Calculate the reaction energy sign: Q=BEproducts−BEreactants=A[(BE/A)products−(BE/A)reactants]<0Q = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}} = A\left[(BE/A)_{\text{products}} - (BE/A)_{\text{reactants}}\right] < 0.

Final answer

(a) Q>0Q > 0, fusion is exoergic; (b) Q<0Q < 0 (endoergic) for the fission of 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe}, because iron-56 is at the peak of the binding energy curve, so splitting it yields fragments with lower binding energy per nucleon.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the shape of the binding energy per nucleon (BE/ABE/A) versus mass number (AA) curve, noting why it peaks around A≈56–62A \approx 56\text{--}62.

  • Practice identifying whether nuclear reactions (fusion or fission) are exoergic or endoergic by checking whether products climb toward or fall away from the iron peak.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two deuterium nuclei (12H^{2}_{1}\text{H}, BE/A=1.11 MeV/nucleonBE/A = 1.11\text{ MeV/nucleon}) fuse into a helium-4 nucleus (24He^{4}_{2}\text{He}, BE/A=7.07 MeV/nucleonBE/A = 7.07\text{ MeV/nucleon}). Calculate the reaction QQ-value and state whether it is exoergic or endoergic.

Answer

Q=+23.84 MeVQ = +23.84\text{ MeV} (exoergic). Total initial BE=4×1.11=4.44 MeVBE = 4 \times 1.11 = 4.44\text{ MeV}; total final BE=4×7.07=28.28 MeVBE = 4 \times 7.07 = 28.28\text{ MeV}; Q=28.28−4.44=+23.84 MeV>0Q = 28.28 - 4.44 = +23.84\text{ MeV} > 0.

02

A uranium-235 nucleus (BE/A=7.59 MeV/nucleonBE/A = 7.59\text{ MeV/nucleon}) undergoes fission into two fragments with an average BE/A=8.50 MeV/nucleonBE/A = 8.50\text{ MeV/nucleon}, releasing 2 neutrons (BE=0BE = 0). Determine the sign of QQ and calculate the energy released per fission.

Answer

Q=+210.55 MeVQ = +210.55\text{ MeV} (Q>0Q > 0, exoergic). Reactant BE=235×7.59=1783.65 MeVBE = 235 \times 7.59 = 1783.65\text{ MeV}; product fragment nucleons total 233233, so product BE=233×8.50=1980.50 MeVBE = 233 \times 8.50 = 1980.50\text{ MeV}; Q=1980.50−1783.65=+196.85 MeVQ = 1980.50 - 1783.65 = +196.85\text{ MeV} (or ≈+214 MeV\approx +214\text{ MeV} if using 235235 nucleons).

03

Explain using the binding energy curve why fusing two 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} nuclei into a heavier nucleus (A=112A = 112) requires an external energy input (Q<0Q < 0).

Answer

Q<0Q < 0 because 2656Fe^{56}_{26}\text{Fe} sits at the global peak of the BE/ABE/A curve (≈8.8 MeV/nucleon\approx 8.8\text{ MeV/nucleon}). Any nucleus with A=112A = 112 has a lower BE/ABE/A (≈8.5 MeV/nucleon\approx 8.5\text{ MeV/nucleon}), so BEfinal<BEinitialBE_{\text{final}} < BE_{\text{initial}}, making the fusion process endoergic.

Loading workspace…