Resources

For the binary ionic compound copper(I) sulfide, write its empirical chemical formula, and determine the mole ratio of transition metal cations to monoatomic anions present in the neutral crystal lattice.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Formula: Cu2S\text{Cu}_2\text{S}; Cation-to-anion mole ratio: 2:12:1

Steps

01

Identify the Constituent Ions

  1. Cation (Transition Metal): The Roman numeral in copper(I) indicates the oxidation state and charge of the copper ion: CuX+\ce{Cu+} (Pitfall: The Roman numeral represents the ionic charge of the metal, not the number of metal atoms in the formula).
  2. Anion (Nonmetal): Sulfur is a Group 16 element with six valence electrons. It gains two electrons to achieve a stable noble gas configuration, forming the monoatomic sulfide anion: SX2−\ce{S^2-}

02

Balance the Electrical Charges

An ionic compound is electrically neutral, meaning the total positive charge from the cations must balance the total negative charge from the anions:

Total positive charge+Total negative charge=0\text{Total positive charge} + \text{Total negative charge} = 0

Let n(CuX+)n(\ce{Cu+}) be the number of copper(I) cations and n(SX2−)n(\ce{S^2-}) be the number of sulfide anions:

n(CuX+)⋅(+1)+n(SX2−)⋅(−2)=0n(\ce{Cu+}) \cdot (+1) + n(\ce{S^2-}) \cdot (-2) = 0

n(CuX+)=2⋅n(SX2−)n(\ce{Cu+}) = 2 \cdot n(\ce{S^2-})

To obtain the smallest whole-number ratio:

  • n(CuX+)=2n(\ce{Cu+}) = 2
  • n(SX2−)=1n(\ce{S^2-}) = 1

03

Determine the Formula and Mole Ratio

  • Empirical Chemical Formula: Writing the cation first followed by the anion gives: CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}
  • Mole Ratio: The ratio of transition metal cations (CuX+\ce{Cu+}) to monoatomic anions (SX2−\ce{S^2-}) in the neutral crystal lattice is: Cation-to-anion mole ratio=2:1\text{Cation-to-anion mole ratio} = 2:1

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the Roman numeral (I) as representing the subscript of copper rather than its ionic charge, assuming Cu²⁺ and S²⁻ in a 1:1 ratio to form CuS.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Copper (I) means one copper: Cu  ⟹  Sulfide ion is SX2−  ⟹  Copper ion is CuX2+\text{Copper (I) means one copper: } \ce{Cu} \implies \text{Sulfide ion is } \ce{S^2-} \implies \text{Copper ion is } \ce{Cu^2+}

    Correct

    Copper(I) cation is CuX+;Sulfide anion is SX2−\text{Copper(I) cation is } \ce{Cu+}; \quad \text{Sulfide anion is } \ce{S^2-}

    You correctly identified the charge of the sulfide anion as −2-2. However, in Stock system nomenclature, the Roman numeral (I)\text{(I)} indicates the oxidation state and charge of the transition metal cation (+1+1), not the number of copper atoms.

  2. Step 2

    Charges +2 and −2 balance: CuS\text{Charges } +2 \text{ and } -2 \text{ balance: } \ce{CuS}

    Correct

    2(+1)+1(−2)=0  ⟹  CuX2S2(+1) + 1(-2) = 0 \implies \ce{Cu2S}

    Your charge balancing followed logically from using a CuX2+\ce{Cu^2+} ion, but because the actual cation is CuX+\ce{Cu+}, you need two CuX+\ce{Cu+} ions to balance one SX2−\ce{S^2-} anion.

  3. Step 3

    Ratio of CuX2+ to SX2−=1:1\text{Ratio of } \ce{Cu^2+} \text{ to } \ce{S^2-} = 1:1

    Correct

    Ratio of CuX+ to SX2−=2:1\text{Ratio of } \ce{Cu+} \text{ to } \ce{S^2-} = 2:1

    Because the neutral lattice requires two CuX+\ce{Cu+} cations for every one SX2−\ce{S^2-} anion, the correct mole ratio of cations to anions is 2:12:1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that sulfur forms a sulfide anion with a −2-2 charge (SX2−\ce{S^2-}).

You correctly understood the principle of electroneutrality that the total positive charge must equal the total negative charge.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nomenclature Misinterpretation

You treated the Roman numeral (I)\text{(I)} as the subscript/count of copper atoms and assumed copper's charge was +2+2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing Roman numerals in transition metal names with chemical subscripts instead of recognizing them as the oxidation state and charge of the cation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Roman Numeral Meaning
  • In ionic nomenclature, the Roman numeral in parentheses denotes the positive charge of the preceding transition metal cation, never its quantity.

  • Always convert 'Metal(N)' directly into MXN+\ce{M^{N+}} before writing any subscripts.

Electroneutrality Balancing
  • The sum of positive and negative charges in an empirical unit cell must equal zero: n(cation)⋅q++n(anion)⋅q−=0n(\text{cation}) \cdot q_+ + n(\text{anion}) \cdot q_- = 0.

  • Find the least common multiple of the charges to determine the minimal integer subscripts.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Interpret 'copper(I)' as a copper ion with a +1+1 charge: CuX+\ce{Cu+}.

  2. Pair CuX+\ce{Cu+} with the sulfide anion SX2−\ce{S^2-}.

  3. Balance the net charge: 2(+1)+1(−2)=02(+1) + 1(-2) = 0, requiring two CuX+\ce{Cu+} cations per SX2−\ce{S^2-} anion.

  4. Write the empirical formula as CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}.

  5. State the cation-to-anion mole ratio as 2:12:1.

Final answer

Formula: CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}; Cation-to-anion mole ratio: 2:12:1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice naming and formula writing for transition metals with multiple oxidation states (e.g., iron(II) vs. iron(III)).

  • Write out the explicit ion symbols with charges (e.g., CuX+\ce{Cu+} and SX2−\ce{S^2-}) before combining them into a chemical formula.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student reverses the cation and anion charges by assigning Cu²⁺ and S⁻, resulting in the incorrect formula CuS₂ and an inverted mole ratio of 1:2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Copper (I) sulfide: CuX2+ and SX−\text{Copper (I) sulfide: } \ce{Cu^2+} \text{ and } \ce{S-}

    Correct

    CuX+ and SX2−\ce{Cu+} \text{ and } \ce{S^2-}

    The Roman numeral (I) directly indicates a +1+1 charge for copper, giving CuX+\ce{Cu+}. Sulfur is in Group 16 and needs two electrons to form a stable octet, forming the sulfide ion SX2−\ce{S^2-}.

  2. Step 2

    Cross charges: CuX1SX2  ⟹  Formula=CuSX2\text{Cross charges: } \ce{Cu1S2} \implies \text{Formula} = \ce{CuS2}

    Correct

    CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}

    Although you applied the criss-cross procedure correctly to your assumed charges, balancing the correct ions (CuX+\ce{Cu+} and SX2−\ce{S^2-}) requires two CuX+\ce{Cu+} ions for every one SX2−\ce{S^2-} ion, yielding CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}.

  3. Step 3

    Ratio of CuX2+ to SX−=1:2\text{Ratio of } \ce{Cu^2+} \text{ to } \ce{S-} = 1:2

    Correct

    2:12:1

    This ratio was derived from your incorrect formula subscripts. For neutral CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}, the ratio of CuX+\ce{Cu+} cations to SX2−\ce{S^2-} anions is 2:12:1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the criss-cross method to balance ionic charges into an empirical formula.

You correctly related the formula subscripts to the cation-to-anion mole ratio.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect ionic charges assigned from compound name

Assigning CuX2+\ce{Cu^2+} instead of CuX+\ce{Cu+} and SX−\ce{S-} instead of SX2−\ce{S^2-}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You misidentified the charge indicated by the Stock notation Roman numeral (I) and assigned a −1-1 charge to sulfur rather than determining its −2-2 charge from Group 16 of the periodic table.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Roman Numerals in Chemical Names
  • The Roman numeral in parentheses indicates the exact positive charge of the transition metal cation.

  • Translate copper(I) directly to CuX+\ce{Cu+} and copper(II) to CuX2+\ce{Cu^2+}.

Anion Charge from Periodic Table Group
  • Main-group nonmetals form monoatomic anions with a charge equal to Group Number−18\text{Group Number} - 18.

  • Locate sulfur in Group 16: 16−18=−216 - 18 = -2, so sulfide is SX2−\ce{S^2-}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the correct ions: copper(I) is CuX+\ce{Cu+} and sulfide is SX2−\ce{S^2-}.

  2. Balance the total charge: 2(+1)+1(−2)=02(+1) + 1(-2) = 0, giving the formula CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}.

  3. Read the subscripts to find the cation-to-anion mole ratio: 2:12:1.

Final answer

Formula: CuX2S\ce{Cu2S}; Cation-to-anion mole ratio: 2:12:1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how Stock system Roman numerals represent ionic charge rather than atom counts.

  • Practice determining monoatomic anion charges using periodic table group numbers.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student determines the correct formula Cu₂S but reports the ratio of anions to cations instead of transition metal cations to monoatomic anions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Copper(I) is CuX+,Sulfide is SX2−\text{Copper(I) is } \ce{Cu+}, \text{Sulfide is } \ce{S^2-}

  2. Step 2

    Need two CuX+ for one SX2−:CuX2S\text{Need two } \ce{Cu+} \text{ for one } \ce{S^2-} : \ce{Cu2S}

  3. Step 3

    Anion to cation ratio=1:2\text{Anion to cation ratio} = 1:2

    Correct

    Cation to anion ratio=2:1\text{Cation to anion ratio} = 2:1

    You inverted the requested ratio order; the prompt asks for the mole ratio of transition metal cations to monoatomic anions, which is 2:12:1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the Roman numeral (I) denotes a +1+1 charge for the copper cation.

You correctly found the charge of the sulfide anion from sulfur's group number.

You balanced the positive and negative charges to obtain the neutral formula Cu2S\text{Cu}_2\text{S}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted ratio order

You wrote the anion-to-cation ratio instead of the requested cation-to-anion ratio.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You calculated the relative quantities of ions accurately from the formula subscripts, but did not match the specific antecedent-to-consequent order specified in the problem statement.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ratio Order Verification
  • In a ratio of AA to BB, the quantity of AA must be written first: n(A):n(B)n(A) : n(B).

  • Always underline the requested order in the question prompt before writing down the final numerical ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the requested order: cations (copper) to anions (sulfur).

  2. Write the ratio as n(CuX+):n(SX2−)=2:1n(\ce{Cu+}) : n(\ce{S^2-}) = 2 : 1.

Final answer

Formula: Cu2S\text{Cu}_2\text{S}; Cation-to-anion mole ratio: 2:12:1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check question prompts for specified ratio order (A to B versus B to A).

  • Practice writing ionic formulas and converting subscript counts directly into cation:anion ratios.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Write the empirical chemical formula and determine the cation-to-anion mole ratio for iron(III) sulfide.

Answer

Empirical formula: FeX2SX3\ce{Fe2S3}; Cation-to-anion mole ratio: 2:32:3. Key steps: Iron(III) gives FeX3+\ce{Fe^3+} and sulfide gives SX2−\ce{S^2-}. The least common multiple of 33 and 22 is 66, requiring two FeX3+\ce{Fe^3+} ions (+6+6) and three SX2−\ce{S^2-} ions (−6-6).

02

Write the empirical chemical formula and determine the cation-to-anion mole ratio for lead(IV) oxide.

Answer

Empirical formula: PbOX2\ce{PbO2}; Cation-to-anion mole ratio: 1:21:2. Key steps: Lead(IV) gives PbX4+\ce{Pb^4+} and oxide gives OX2−\ce{O^2-}. Balancing charges: 1(+4)+2(−2)=01(+4) + 2(-2) = 0, giving the simplified empirical formula PbOX2\ce{PbO2}.

03

A sample contains a binary ionic compound formed between gold(III) and nitride ions. Write the empirical formula and find the cation-to-anion mole ratio.

Answer

Empirical formula: AuN\ce{AuN}; Cation-to-anion mole ratio: 1:11:1. Key steps: Gold(III) provides AuX3+\ce{Au^3+} and nitride provides NX3−\ce{N^3-}. The +3+3 and −3-3 charges balance in a direct 1:11:1 ratio.

Loading workspace…