Resources

A student inspecting the standard phase diagram of carbon dioxide (CO2\text{CO}_2) observes that its triple point is at Tt=216.6 KT_t = 216.6\text{ K} and Pt=5.11 atmP_t = 5.11\text{ atm}. The student incorrectly predicts: 'Because dry ice is kept at standard atmospheric pressure (1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}), if we place it inside a sealed, non-expandable rigid metal box and warm it to room temperature (298 K298\text{ K}), it will melt into liquid carbon dioxide as soon as the temperature surpasses the triple-point temperature.' Explain why this intuition fails by identifying: (a) what happens to the pressure inside a sealed rigid vessel as dry ice warms and sublimes, and (b) the thermodynamic requirement regarding pressure and the triple point that must be satisfied for liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 to stably exist.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Sublimation in a fixed volume causes a rapid increase in system pressure that can easily exceed 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}, allowing the trajectory to cross above the triple point pressure into the liquid or supercritical domain rather than staying at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}; (b) Stable liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 can only exist if the system pressure is maintained at or above the triple-point pressure (P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm}). At P<5.11 atmP < 5.11\text{ atm}, the liquid phase is thermodynamically unstable at all temperatures.

Steps

01

Understanding the Role of Pressure in a Sealed, Rigid Vessel (Part a)

To evaluate the student's prediction, we analyze the phase diagram of carbon dioxide (COX2\ce{CO2}) and the behavior of a closed, rigid system.

  • The Student's Flawed Assumption: The student incorrectly treats the process as isobaric (constant pressure at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}), as if the dry ice were sitting in an open room.
  • Actual Physical Behavior: A rigid metal box has a constant volume (V=constantV = \text{constant}). When solid COX2\ce{CO2} absorbs heat, some of it sublimes into gaseous COX2\ce{CO2}.
  • According to the ideal gas approximation, P=nRTVP = \frac{nRT}{V} Generating gas moles (nn) within a confined volume, coupled with an increasing temperature (TT), causes the internal pressure (PP) to rise drastically.
  • As long as enough mass of COX2\ce{CO2} is present, this self-pressurization rapidly drives the system pressure far above the initial 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}, quickly exceeding the triple-point pressure of 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}. Therefore, the thermodynamic path on a P–TP\text{--}T diagram is not a horizontal line at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}, but rather a steep curve rising upward and rightward into the high-pressure region.

02

The Thermodynamic Condition for Stable Liquid COX2\ce{CO2} (Part b)

  • The Meaning of the Triple Point: The triple point of COX2\ce{CO2} (Tt=216.6 KT_t = 216.6\text{ K}, Pt=5.11 atmP_t = 5.11\text{ atm}) marks the minimum pressure and temperature at which the liquid phase can exist in equilibrium with solid and gas.
  • Behavior at Low Pressures (P<5.11 atmP < 5.11\text{ atm}): If pressure were held strictly below 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm} (such as at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} in an open container), heating solid dry ice causes direct sublimation into gas at 194.7 K194.7\text{ K} (−78.5∘C-78.5^\circ\text{C}). At no temperature can liquid COX2\ce{CO2} stably form below 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}, because the solid-gas coexistence curve completely separates the solid and vapor phases below this threshold.
  • Condition for Liquid Formation: For liquid COX2\ce{CO2} to stably exist, the pressure must be equal to or greater than the triple-point pressure: P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm} along with a temperature between the triple point and the critical point (216.6 K≤T≤304.1 K216.6\text{ K} \le T \le 304.1\text{ K}).

Common Pitfall to Avoid

Do not assume that reaching the triple-point temperature alone (T≥TtT \ge T_t) is sufficient to form a liquid. Phase state is a function of both state variables, (T,P)(T, P). Surpassing Tt=216.6 KT_t = 216.6\text{ K} at P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm} simply yields warm COX2\ce{CO2} gas, never liquid. Liquid forms only because the sealed container allows the pressure to rise past 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses a rigid sealed container with an open isobaric system, believing pressure remains fixed at 1.00 atm regardless of warming and sublimation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Vessel is sealed at atmospheric pressure   ⟹  \implies Pressure stays constant at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}

    Correct

    In a rigid, sealed container of fixed volume (V=constantV = \text{constant}), warming solid dry ice causes sublimation, increasing gas moles (nn) and temperature (TT), which causes the internal pressure P=nRTVP = \frac{nRT}{V} to rise significantly above 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}.

    You treated the sealed rigid container as an isobaric (constant-pressure) system. Because the container is rigid and closed, converting solid dry ice into gas forces more moles of gas into a fixed volume, driving the internal pressure upward.

  2. Step 2

    Liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 requires P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm}

  3. Step 3

    Since pressure is below 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}, it cannot form a liquid

    Correct

    As sublimation raises the pressure above 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}, the system trajectory moves into the region where liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 can stably form once T≥216.6 KT \ge 216.6\text{ K}.

    Your conclusion that liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 cannot form was directly affected by your earlier incorrect assumption that pressure stays fixed below 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the triple-point pressure threshold of 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm} needed for stable liquid CO2\text{CO}_2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isobaric vs. isochoric confusion in closed systems

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused a sealed, rigid isochoric (constant-volume) vessel with an open isobaric (constant-pressure) system, assuming that sealing a vessel at atmospheric pressure locks its pressure permanently at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} even when phase change and heating generate additional gas moles.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Closed Rigid Vessel Dynamics
  • In a sealed, rigid container, volume is fixed (V=constantV = \text{constant}). Phase changes producing gas ($ Δ\Delta n_{gas\text{gas}} > 0)combinedwithheating() combined with heating ( Δ\Delta T > 0)increasepressurevia) increase pressure via P ≈\approx nRTV\frac{nRT}{V}$._

  • Check boundary conditions: ask whether the boundary is movable/open (constant PP) or rigid/sealed (constant VV, changing PP).

Phase Diagram State Coordinates
  • A phase is determined by both state variables (T,P)(T, P). The path of a closed system on a P–TP\text{--}T diagram is not automatically horizontal (isobaric).

  • Trace the path on the P–TP\text{--}T diagram by accounting for both temperature change and pressure evolution simultaneously.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that the rigid metal box has a constant volume (V=constantV = \text{constant}).

  2. Apply the ideal gas relationship P=nRTVP = \frac{nRT}{V}: as dry ice warms and sublimes into gas, both ngasn_{\text{gas}} and TT increase, causing pressure to rise rapidly well beyond 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}.

  3. Combine this rising pressure with the condition P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm}: because pressure can exceed 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}, the thermodynamic path crosses into the liquid region once T≥216.6 KT \ge 216.6\text{ K}.

Final answer

(a) In a sealed rigid vessel, sublimation and warming generate gas moles in a fixed volume, causing internal pressure to increase rapidly and exceed 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}; (b) For liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 to stably exist, the system pressure must satisfy P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between isochoric (rigid, sealed) and isobaric (open or movable piston) processes.

  • Practice sketching thermodynamic paths on phase diagrams for systems with changing pressure.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly assumes that exceeding the triple-point temperature alone is the thermodynamic requirement for liquid formation, neglecting the pressure threshold.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Sublimation produces COX2\ce{CO2} gas in a fixed volume   ⟹  \implies Internal pressure increases above 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}

  2. Step 2

    Only temperature needs to exceed 216.6 K  ⟹  216.6\text{ K} \implies Liquid COX2\ce{CO2} forms at any pressure once T>216.6 KT > 216.6\text{ K}

    Correct

    For liquid COX2\ce{CO2} to stably exist, the pressure must be equal to or greater than the triple-point pressure (P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm}), with temperature between the triple point and critical point (216.6 K≤T≤304.1 K216.6\text{ K} \le T \le 304.1\text{ K}). Below 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}, liquid COX2\ce{CO2} is thermodynamically unstable at all temperatures.

    A phase state depends on both temperature and pressure. On a phase diagram, the liquid region does not exist below the triple-point pressure line (Pt=5.11 atmP_t = 5.11\text{ atm}). If P<5.11 atmP < 5.11\text{ atm}, warming above 216.6 K216.6\text{ K} simply produces gas.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly analyzed the sealed rigid vessel to deduce that gas generation increases the internal pressure above 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neglecting the pressure threshold of the triple point

You treated phase changes as depending solely on temperature rather than the coexistence of both temperature and pressure coordinates.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You misunderstood the thermodynamic definition of the triple point on a P–TP\text{--}T phase diagram. The triple point (Tt,PtT_t, P_t) sets the absolute minimum pressure (P≥PtP \ge P_t) required for the liquid phase to exist in equilibrium; temperature alone cannot induce liquefaction if pressure remains below PtP_t.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Triple-Point Boundary Check
  • Liquid phase exists only at pressures at or above the triple-point pressure (P≥PtP \ge P_t).

  • Always check both the PP and TT coordinates on a phase diagram before predicting a phase transition to a liquid.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Locate the liquid region on the COX2\ce{CO2} phase diagram; notice that the bottom boundary of the liquid region terminates at the triple point (Tt=216.6 KT_t = 216.6\text{ K}, Pt=5.11 atmP_t = 5.11\text{ atm}).

  2. Recognize that below Pt=5.11 atmP_t = 5.11\text{ atm}, the sublimation curve directly separates the solid and gas phases, meaning liquid cannot stably exist at any temperature.

  3. State the pressure condition: the system pressure must satisfy P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm} for liquid COX2\ce{CO2} to form.

Final answer

(a) Sublimation in a rigid vessel generates gas moles, rapidly increasing the internal pressure well above 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} (crossing 5.11 atm5.11\text{ atm}). (b) Liquid COX2\ce{CO2} can only stably exist if the pressure meets or exceeds the triple-point pressure (P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice tracing isobaric (P=constantP = \text{constant}) heating paths at pressures below and above the triple point on phase diagrams.

  • Review the distinction between 1D temperature thresholds (like normal boiling points) and 2D state coordinates (T,P)(T, P) required by phase equilibrium.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of dry ice is heated in an open beaker at standard atmospheric pressure (1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}). Describe the phase transition that occurs as it reaches 194.7 K194.7\text{ K} (−78.5∘C-78.5^\circ\text{C}) and explain why no liquid is observed.

Answer

The dry ice undergoes direct sublimation from solid to vapor. Liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 cannot form because the external pressure (1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}) is strictly below the triple-point pressure (Pt=5.11 atmP_t = 5.11\text{ atm}), meaning the solid-gas coexistence line is crossed directly without encountering a stable liquid phase.

02

A 10.0 L10.0\text{ L} rigid, evacuated cylinder is charged with 0.50 mol0.50\text{ mol} of dry ice and sealed. The cylinder is warmed to 250 K250\text{ K}, causing all the dry ice to sublime into gas. Using the ideal gas law (R=0.0821 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K)R = 0.0821\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K})), calculate the final pressure in the cylinder and determine whether liquid CO2\text{CO}_2 could stably form if more dry ice were added.

Answer

P=nRTV=(0.50 mol)(0.0821 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K))(250 K)10.0 L=1.03 atmP = \frac{nRT}{V} = \frac{(0.50\text{ mol})(0.0821\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(250\text{ K})}{10.0\text{ L}} = 1.03\text{ atm}. Because 1.03 atm<5.11 atm1.03\text{ atm} < 5.11\text{ atm}, all CO2\text{CO}_2 remains vapor. However, adding sufficient dry ice would generate enough gas moles to drive P≥5.11 atmP \ge 5.11\text{ atm}, enabling stable liquid formation once vapor-liquid equilibrium is established at T=250 KT = 250\text{ K}.

03

Water has a triple point at Tt=273.16 KT_t = 273.16\text{ K} (0.01∘C0.01^\circ\text{C}) and Pt=0.00603 atmP_t = 0.00603\text{ atm}. Contrast the behavior of solid ice warmed at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} with solid dry ice warmed at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}, and explain the fundamental difference using their respective triple-point pressures.

Answer

At 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}, ice melts into liquid water because 1.00 atm>Pt(H2O)=0.00603 atm1.00\text{ atm} > P_t(\text{H}_2\text{O}) = 0.00603\text{ atm}, so the isobaric path crosses the solid-liquid melting curve. In contrast, dry ice sublimes directly into gas at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} because 1.00 atm<Pt(CO2)=5.11 atm1.00\text{ atm} < P_t(\text{CO}_2) = 5.11\text{ atm}, where the liquid phase cannot exist at any temperature.

Loading workspace…