Resources
Element is in Period , Group , and Element is in Period , Group . (a) Determine the number of valence electrons for a neutral atom of and a neutral atom of . (b) Using Lewis dot principles based on valence electrons, state the empirical chemical formula of the neutral ionic compound formed when reacts completely with . (c) If of element reacts completely with excess , calculate the theoretical mass in grams of the resulting ionic compound.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Element () has valence electrons; Element () has valence electrons; (b) ; (c) of (using molar mass ).
Steps
Part (a): Determining Valence Electrons
- Locate the elements on the periodic table:
- Element is in Period , Group . The group number for main-group elements in Groups and directly gives the number of valence electrons. Element is magnesium (), which has valence electrons (electron configuration: ).
- Element is in Period , Group . For main-group elements in Groups through , the number of valence electrons is given by . Thus, . Element is chlorine (), which has valence electrons (electron configuration: ).
Part (b): Deducing the Empirical Formula
-
Octet Rule and Ion Formation:
- A neutral atom of readily transfers its valence electrons to achieve a stable noble-gas configuration (), forming the divalent cation .
- Each neutral atom of has valence electrons and needs electron to complete its octet (), forming the chloride anion .
-
Balancing Charge for Neutrality:
- An ionic compound must have an overall electrical charge of zero:
- One ion ( charge) requires two ions ( charge) to balance:
- Therefore, the empirical chemical formula is .
Common Pitfall: Avoid writing charges in the final empirical formula (e.g., do not write ). The empirical formula of a neutral compound should only show the lowest whole-number ratio of element symbols with numerical subscripts.
Part (c): Calculating the Theoretical Mass
-
Write the stoichiometric relationship:
- The balanced chemical reaction between magnesium and chlorine gas is:
- Since chlorine is in excess, magnesium () is the limiting reactant. The mole ratio of to is :
-
Calculate the molar mass of :
- Atomic mass of
- Atomic mass of
-
Compute the mass produced:
- Rounding to three significant figures gives of .
Typical errors
01 The student equalizes subscripts directly 1:1 instead of balancing ionic charges based on valence electron loss and gain, resulting in the incorrect formula AB and a downstream theoretical mass of 8.96 g.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Valence electrons for Valence electrons for
- Step 2
shares with in a ratio Empirical formula =
Correct(or )
Element is an alkaline earth metal that loses valence electrons to form an cation, while Element is a halogen that gains electron to form a anion. Balancing charges for overall electrical neutrality requires two ions for every one ion, giving the empirical formula (specifically ).
- Step 3
is (), is () Molar mass of
CorrectYour stoichiometric multiplication and element identification were executed properly, but the numerical mass was affected by using the molar mass of instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly deduced the number of valence electrons for both main-group elements from their group numbers.
You correctly identified elements and as magnesium and chlorine and looked up their accurate atomic masses.
You correctly applied stoichiometric mass calculation using moles and molar mass.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed the two elements combine by sharing electrons in an arbitrary ratio instead of determining ion charges from valence electron loss/gain and balancing total charge to achieve electrical neutrality.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Determine Ion Charges from Valence Electrons
Metals in Groups 1–3 lose all valence electrons to form cations (); nonmetals in Groups 15–17 gain electrons to complete an octet ().
Assign Element (Group 2) a charge of and Element (Group 17) a charge of .
- Balance Charges for Electrical Neutrality
In a neutral ionic formula , the sum of charges must be zero: .
Combine one with two to give the neutral formula .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the ion formed by Element (Group 2): loses (or ).
Write the ion formed by Element (Group 17): gains (or ).
Balance the charges to form a neutral ionic compound: (empirical formula: ).
Calculate the correct molar mass: .
Calculate theoretical mass: .
(a) has valence electrons, has valence electrons; (b) ; (c)
02 The student swaps the charges when writing the chemical formula, writing A₂B instead of AB₂, which leads to an incorrect molar mass and theoretical yield.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
has valence electrons has valence electrons
- Step 2
forms and forms Criss-cross charges gives formula
Correct(or )
You correctly determined the ionic charges as and , but you swapped the resulting subscripts. The magnitude from belongs as the subscript of , requiring two anions to balance one cation to achieve electrical neutrality.
- Step 3
is (), is () Molar mass of
CorrectYour stoichiometric logic was internally consistent with your formula , but the resulting molar mass and theoretical yield were incorrect because of the subscript error in the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly determined that an element in Group has valence electrons and an element in Group has valence electrons.
You correctly identified that Element loses electrons to form and Element gains electron to form .
You correctly identified magnesium and chlorine and used valid molar mass values.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisMisapplying the criss-cross method by assigning the numerical magnitude of the cation's charge to the cation itself rather than to the counter-ion, resulting in an unbalanced overall charge.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Net Charge Neutrality Check
The sum of all positive and negative charges in a neutral ionic formula unit must equal zero: .
Always verify: for and , one requires two ions to reach zero: , giving .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationBalance the charges: , which gives the empirical formula , or .
Calculate the correct molar mass of : .
Determine the moles of product formed: since produces , .
Calculate the mass of the ionic compound: .
(a) Element has valence electrons; Element has valence electrons; (b) (or ); (c)
03 The student misidentifies the elements as Period 2 instead of Period 3 (taking A as Be and B as F), leading to an incorrect molar mass of 47.01 g/mol and theoretical mass of 7.05 g.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
A has 2 valence electrons B has 7 valence electrons
- Step 2
A loses 2 electrons to form B gains 1 electron to form
- Step 3
A is Be () and B is F () Molar mass of
Correctin Period 3, Group 2 is (); in Period 3, Group 17 is ()
You misidentified the Period 3 elements as Period 2 elements. Remember that Period 1 contains and , Period 2 contains and , and Period 3 contains and .
- Step 4
= 0.150 47.01 = 7.05
Correctm = 0.150 95.21 = 14.3
Your multiplication step was carried out correctly, but the result is affected by using the incorrect molar mass from the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the number of valence electrons for both main-group elements.
You correctly determined the ion charges and the stoichiometric ratio for the neutral ionic compound.
You set up the mass calculation formula correctly using moles times molar mass.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou skipped Period 1 ( and ) when counting down the periodic table rows, causing you to choose Period 2 elements ( and ) instead of Period 3 elements ( and ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Counting Periods on the Periodic Table
Periods correspond to horizontal rows numbered through , starting with row containing only Hydrogen and Helium.
Always verify the row number starting from row (), row ( to ), and row ( to ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify Element in Period 3, Group 2 as Magnesium (, atomic mass ).
Identify Element in Period 3, Group 17 as Chlorine (, atomic mass ).
Calculate the correct molar mass of : .
Multiply moles by molar mass: .
of
Lock it in
How do you determine the charge on a main-group metal ion and a nonmetal ion from their valence electron counts?
Main-group metals lose all valence electrons to form cations with charge equal to their valence count; nonmetals gain electrons to reach an octet, forming anions with charge equal to .
Similar question
Element is in Period 3, Group 1, and Element is in Period 3, Group 16. State the number of valence electrons for each neutral atom and write the empirical formula of the neutral ionic compound they form.
Answer
has valence electron and forms ; has valence electrons and forms . Balancing charges requires two for every , giving the empirical formula (or ).
Element is in Period 3, Group 13, and Element is in Period 2, Group 16. If of element reacts completely with excess , determine the empirical formula of the compound and calculate its theoretical mass in grams. (Atomic masses: , )
Answer
forms and forms , giving empirical formula (or ). Since produce , yields . Molar mass of . Theoretical mass .
An unknown metal is in Period 4, Group 2. It reacts completely with nitrogen gas (Group 15) to form an ionic nitride compound. Write the empirical formula of the nitride and calculate the mass of product formed when of metal reacts with excess nitrogen. (Atomic mass of , )
Answer
Metal forms and nitrogen forms , yielding the neutral formula (or ). Moles of . From stoichiometry, yield , so moles of . Molar mass of . Theoretical mass .