Resources

Consider the chlorides of the third-period elements: sodium chloride (NaCl\text{NaCl}), magnesium chloride (MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2), aluminum chloride (AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3), and silicon tetrachloride (SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4). (a) Using the electronegativity difference Δχ\Delta\chi (where χCl=3.16\chi_{\text{Cl}} = 3.16, χNa=0.93\chi_{\text{Na}} = 0.93, χMg=1.31\chi_{\text{Mg}} = 1.31, χAl=1.61\chi_{\text{Al}} = 1.61, and χSi=1.90\chi_{\text{Si}} = 1.90) and Fajans' rules (polarizing power of the cation qr2\frac{q}{r^2}), identify which compound represents the critical threshold where bonding transitions from predominantly ionic network behavior to molecular behavior at standard temperature. (b) Support your classification using their standard physical properties: NaCl\text{NaCl} (melting point 801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}), MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 (melting point 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}), AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 (sublimes at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} as dimer Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6), and SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 (boiling point 57.6 ∘C57.6\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}, liquid at 25 ∘C25\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 represents the critical threshold boundary. With Δχ=1.55\Delta\chi = 1.55 and a small, highly charged Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} cation with high polarizing power (sim118 e/nm2\\sim 118\text{ e}/\text{nm}^2), significant covalent character is induced by polarization of the chloride electron clouds, transitioning from an extended ionic lattice toward discrete molecular units. (b) While NaCl\text{NaCl} and MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 form true high-melting ionic networks (801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} and 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}), AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 undergoes low-temperature sublimation at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} to form discrete volatile covalent dimers (Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6), confirming the boundary transition before reaching the purely discrete tetrahedral molecular liquid SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 (b.p. 57.6 ∘C57.6\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}).

Steps

Part (a): Identifying the Transition Threshold Using Bonding Principles

To determine where the transition from an ionic network to molecular behavior occurs, examine both the electronegativity difference and the polarization effects described by Fajans' rules across the third-period chlorides.

  1. Electronegativity Difference (Δχ\Delta\chi): Using the given Pauling values (χCl=3.16\chi_{\ce{Cl}} = 3.16):

    • For NaCl\ce{NaCl}: Δχ=3.16−0.93=2.23\Delta\chi = 3.16 - 0.93 = 2.23
    • For MgClX2\ce{MgCl2}: Δχ=3.16−1.31=1.85\Delta\chi = 3.16 - 1.31 = 1.85
    • For AlClX3\ce{AlCl3}: Δχ=3.16−1.61=1.55\Delta\chi = 3.16 - 1.61 = 1.55
    • For SiClX4\ce{SiCl4}: Δχ=3.16−1.90=1.26\Delta\chi = 3.16 - 1.90 = 1.26

    A common rule of thumb places the boundary between predominantly ionic and polar covalent character near Δχ≈1.7\Delta\chi \approx 1.7 to 2.02.0. Here, NaCl\ce{NaCl} and MgClX2\ce{MgCl2} are clearly on the ionic side, while SiClX4\ce{SiCl4} is on the covalent side. The value for AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} (Δχ=1.55\Delta\chi = 1.55) sits directly in the intermediate transition zone.

  2. Fajans' Rules and Cation Polarizing Power: Fajans' rules state that covalent character increases when a small, highly charged cation distorts (polarizes) the electron cloud of a large, polarizable anion (ClX−\ce{Cl-}).

    • The polarizing power is proportional to charge density: Charge Density∝qr2\text{Charge Density} \propto \frac{q}{r^2}
    • Moving across Period 3 from NaX+\ce{Na+} (+1+1, large radius) to MgX2+\ce{Mg^2+} (+2+2, intermediate radius) to AlX3+\ce{Al^3+} (+3+3, small ionic radius ≈53.5 pm\approx 53.5\text{ pm}), the formal charge triples while ionic radius contracts significantly.
    • As a result, AlX3+\ce{Al^3+} possesses an exceptionally high polarizing power (≈118 e⋅nm−2\approx 118\text{ e}\cdot\text{nm}^{-2}). It pulls the valence electron clouds of adjacent chloride ions into the internuclear region, introducing substantial covalent character into the bonds.

Therefore, AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} represents the critical threshold boundary where the compound transitions from an extended ionic lattice to discrete molecular behavior.


Part (b): Evidence from Standard Physical Properties

The macroscopic physical properties of these compounds reflect the underlying shift from giant network structures held by non-directional electrostatic forces to discrete molecular units held only by weak intermolecular forces:

  1. Giant Ionic Networks (NaCl\ce{NaCl} and MgClX2\ce{MgCl2}):

    • NaCl\ce{NaCl} has a high melting point of 801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\ce{C}.
    • MgClX2\ce{MgCl2} has a high melting point of 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\ce{C}.
    • Both form rigid, three-dimensional ionic crystal lattices. Melting them requires overcoming strong electrostatic attractions between oppositely charged ions in every dimension.
  2. The Boundary Compound (AlClX3\ce{AlCl3}):

    • In the solid state at room temperature, AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} forms a layered coordination network with high covalent character.
    • Upon gentle heating, it does not melt into a typical ionic liquid; instead, it sublimes at just 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\ce{C} to form discrete dimeric gas molecules (AlX2ClX6\ce{Al2Cl6}), in which aluminum achieves an octet via coordinate covalent (dative) bonds from bridging chlorides.
    • This drastic drop in thermal stability and volatility confirms that the extended lattice is fragile and readily breaks down into discrete covalent units.
  3. Discrete Molecular Compound (SiClX4\ce{SiCl4}):

    • SiClX4\ce{SiCl4} consists entirely of discrete tetrahedral molecules bound internally by covalent bonds and held to one another only by weak London dispersion forces.
    • Consequently, it is a volatile liquid at room temperature (25 ∘C25\text{ }^{\circ}\ce{C}) with a low boiling point of 57.6 ∘C57.6\text{ }^{\circ}\ce{C}.

Thus, the sharp drop in phase transition temperatures from MgClX2\ce{MgCl2} (714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\ce{C}) to AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} (sublimes at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\ce{C}) directly substantiates that AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} is the transitional compound between ionic networks and molecular substances.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student relies solely on a rigid electronegativity threshold (Δχ > 2.0 or 1.7) without considering cation polarizing power from Fajans' rules, erroneously concluding the transition occurs at MgCl2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δχ(NaCl)=3.16−0.93=2.23\Delta\chi(\text{NaCl}) = 3.16 - 0.93 = 2.23 ⟹\Longrightarrow Δχ(MgCl2)=3.16−1.31=1.85\Delta\chi(\text{MgCl}_2) = 3.16 - 1.31 = 1.85 ⟹\Longrightarrow Δχ(AlCl3)=3.16−1.61=1.55\Delta\chi(\text{AlCl}_3) = 3.16 - 1.61 = 1.55 ⟹\Longrightarrow Δχ(SiCl4)=3.16−1.90=1.26\Delta\chi(\text{SiCl}_4) = 3.16 - 1.90 = 1.26

  2. Step 2

    Compounds with Δχ<2.0\Delta\chi < 2.0 are predominantly covalent. MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 has Δχ=1.85<2.0\Delta\chi = 1.85 < 2.0, so MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 is the critical transition threshold.

    Correct

    Evaluate both Δχ\Delta\chi and cation polarizing power (qr2\frac{q}{r^2}). While Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+} has modest polarizing power, Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} has a very high charge density (small radius ≈53.5 pm\approx 53.5\text{ pm}, formal charge +3+3) that strongly distorts the Cl−\text{Cl}^- electron cloud, making AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 the critical threshold compound between ionic and molecular behavior.

    You relied solely on an arbitrary electronegativity cutoff without evaluating cation polarizing power via Fajans' rules. The +3+3 charge and small radius of Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} induce substantial covalency, placing the critical boundary at AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3, not MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2.

  3. Step 3

    NaCl\text{NaCl} has a melting point of 801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}, showing ionic network behavior. MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 melts at 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}, which marks the start of lower stability and the shift away from purely ionic bonding toward molecular behavior. AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 sublimes at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} and SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 boils at 57.6 ∘C57.6\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} as typical covalent molecules.

    Correct

    NaCl\text{NaCl} (801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) and MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 (714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) both exhibit high melting points characteristic of giant ionic lattices. The drastic discontinuity occurs at AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3, which sublimes at only 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} into discrete Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6 dimers, confirming that AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 is the physical transition threshold before the purely molecular liquid SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 (b.p. 57.6 ∘C57.6\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}).

    Because you selected MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 in the previous step, you interpreted its high melting point of 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} as a shift toward molecular behavior. In reality, 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} reflects an extensive 3D ionic lattice, and the true structural break occurs at AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3, which sublimes at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated all four electronegativity differences using the given values.

You recognized that physical phase change temperatures reflect underlying lattice stability versus molecular interactions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Fajans' Rules and Rigid Electronegativity Cutoff

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated electronegativity difference as an absolute dividing line rather than combining it with Fajans' rules (cation polarizing power, proportional to qr2\frac{q}{r^2}). This caused you to miss the polarizing effect of Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} and misinterpret the thermal data for MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Applying Fajans' Rules alongside Electronegativity
  • Bond type is a continuum influenced by both Δχ\Delta\chi and anion polarization. Cations with high charge density (qr2\frac{q}{r^2}) polarize large anions, introducing substantial covalent character even when Δχ\Delta\chi appears moderately high.

  • Always evaluate cation charge and ionic radius (qr2\frac{q}{r^2}) whenever a metal cation has a high oxidation state (+3+3 or higher).

Interpreting Phase-Transition Discontinuities
  • A transition from giant network behavior to discrete molecular units causes an order-of-magnitude drop in phase-change temperatures (hundreds of degrees), not a minor decrease.

  • Look for the sharpest drop in melting or sublimation points (from 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} in MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 down to 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} in AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3) to locate the network-to-molecular transition.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate or compare cation charge density: Na+\text{Na}^+ (+1+1, large radius), Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+} (+2+2, moderate radius), and Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} (+3+3, small radius).

  2. Note that Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} has an exceptionally high polarizing power (∝qr2\propto \frac{q}{r^2}), which severely polarizes the electron cloud of Cl−\text{Cl}^-, imparting strong covalent character.

  3. Identify AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 as the critical boundary between ionic lattices and discrete molecular structures.

  4. Correlate this with the physical data: NaCl\text{NaCl} (801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) and MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 (714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) form robust ionic networks, while AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 undergoes low-temperature sublimation at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} into volatile Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6 dimers.

Final answer

(a) AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 is the critical transition threshold because the high charge density and polarizing power of Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} induce substantial covalent character into the Al−Cl\text{Al}-\text{Cl} bonds. (b) The physical data confirm this: NaCl\text{NaCl} and MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 melt at high temperatures (801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} and 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) as giant ionic networks, whereas AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 sublimes at just 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} to form discrete Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6 covalent dimers.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Fajans' rules to understand how cation charge density influences partial covalency in metal halides.

  • Practice distinguishing giant network solids from molecular solids using phase change data and structural formulas.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies SiCl4 as the transition threshold by assuming that the transition requires being a liquid at standard conditions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δχ(NaCl)=2.23\Delta\chi(\text{NaCl}) = 2.23, Δχ(MgCl2)=1.85\Delta\chi(\text{MgCl}_2) = 1.85, Δχ(AlCl3)=1.55\Delta\chi(\text{AlCl}_3) = 1.55, Δχ(SiCl4)=1.26\Delta\chi(\text{SiCl}_4) = 1.26

  2. Step 2

    NaCl\text{NaCl}, MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2, and AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 are all solids at standard temperature. SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 is the only compound that is a liquid at 25 ∘C25\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} and has the lowest Δχ=1.26\Delta\chi = 1.26. Therefore, SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 is the critical threshold where bonding transitions to molecular behavior.

    Correct

    AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 has Δχ=1.55\Delta\chi = 1.55 and a small, highly charged Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} cation with high polarizing power (qr2\frac{q}{r^2}). This strongly polarizes the chloride electron clouds, inducing significant covalent character and making AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 the critical threshold where bonding transitions toward molecular behavior.

    You did not account for Fajans' rules. The +3+3 charge and small ionic radius of Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} give it a very high charge density, which heavily polarizes Cl−\text{Cl}^- ions and introduces substantial covalent character, making AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 the critical boundary compound rather than SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4.

  3. Step 3

    NaCl\text{NaCl} (mp 801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}), MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 (mp 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}), and AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 (sublimes at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) are all solid lattice networks. SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 is a liquid at 25 ∘C25\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} with a boiling point of 57.6 ∘C57.6\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}. Because SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4 is the first substance that is not a solid at standard conditions, it represents the transition to molecular behavior.

    Correct

    NaCl\text{NaCl} (801 ∘C801\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) and MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 (714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) have high melting points characteristic of true giant ionic lattices. In contrast, AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 sublimes at just 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} to form discrete molecular dimers (Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6). This dramatic drop in thermal transition temperature proves that AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 represents the boundary where molecular behavior emerges.

    Being a solid at room temperature does not imply a giant ionic lattice. The sharp drop from MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 (melting at 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) to AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 (subliming at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} to yield discrete Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6 molecules) marks the transition to molecular behavior before reaching the fully molecular liquid SiCl4\text{SiCl}_4.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated all four electronegativity differences using the given Pauling values.

You recognized that phase and transition temperatures reflect underlying structural differences among the compounds.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Physical State with Lattice Type

No slip detected; you followed a consistent reasoning path based on whether the compound is liquid at standard conditions.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that transition to molecular behavior requires a change of state to liquid or gas at 25 ∘C25\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}, ignoring how cation polarizing power (Fajans' rules) and low sublimation temperatures reveal molecular character in solids.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cation Polarizing Power (Fajans' Rules)
  • A cation with high charge density (qr2\frac{q}{r^2}) heavily distorts adjacent anion electron clouds, conferring significant covalent character.

  • Always evaluate the charge density of the cation alongside Δχ\Delta\chi when determining ionic versus covalent character.

Phase Transition Temperature vs. Room-Temperature State
  • A low sublimation temperature (such as 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) into discrete gas molecules signifies weak intermolecular forces, not a robust giant ionic network.

  • Compare relative melting and sublimation temperatures across the series rather than checking only whether a substance is solid at 25 ∘C25\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate cation polarizing power: Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} has a formal charge of +3+3 and a small ionic radius, giving it high polarizing power (qr2\frac{q}{r^2}) that distorts Cl−\text{Cl}^- electron clouds into covalent sharing.

  2. Identify the transition threshold: AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 marks the boundary where polar covalent/molecular character replaces an extended ionic lattice.

  3. Correlate with physical properties: While NaCl\text{NaCl} and MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 melt well above 700 ∘C700\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}, AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 sublimes at just 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} to give discrete Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6 dimers, confirming molecular character.

Final answer

(a) AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 represents the critical threshold where bonding transitions from ionic network to molecular behavior due to its intermediate Δχ=1.55\Delta\chi = 1.55 and the high polarizing power of Al3+\text{Al}^{3+}. (b) The dramatic drop in phase-change temperature from MgCl2\text{MgCl}_2 (mp 714 ∘C714\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) to AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3 (sublimation at 180 ∘C180\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} as discrete Al2Cl6\text{Al}_2\text{Cl}_6 dimers) confirms that extended ionic bonding breaks down at AlCl3\text{AlCl}_3.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Fajans' rules and practice ranking cations by polarizing power (qr2\frac{q}{r^2}).

  • Examine the structures and volatility of halides across Period 3 to see how sublimation correlates with discrete molecular units.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Compare the melting behaviors of beryllium chloride (BeCl2\text{BeCl}_2, melting point 405 ∘C405\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) and calcium chloride (CaCl2\text{CaCl}_2, melting point 772 ∘C772\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}). Using Fajans' rules, explain why BeCl2\text{BeCl}_2 has a much lower melting point despite both having Group 2 +2+2 cations.

Answer

Be2+\text{Be}^{2+} has a much smaller ionic radius (31 pm31\text{ pm}) than Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+} (100 pm100\text{ pm}). By Fajans' rules, polarizing power is proportional to qr2\frac{q}{r^2}, so Be2+\text{Be}^{2+} strongly polarizes the Cl−\text{Cl}^- electron cloud. This imparts high covalent character and creates a fragile chain structure that melts at 405 ∘C405\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}, unlike the giant ionic lattice of CaCl2\text{CaCl}_2 (772 ∘C772\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}).

02

Titanium forms two chlorides: TiCl2\text{TiCl}_2 (solid melting at 1035 ∘C1035\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}) and TiCl4\text{TiCl}_4 (colorless liquid boiling at 136 ∘C136\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}). Using cation oxidation states and Fajans' rules, determine which compound is predominantly ionic and which is molecular.

Answer

In TiCl2\text{TiCl}_2, the cation is Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+}, which has moderate polarizing power and forms an extended ionic network with a high melting point (1035 ∘C1035\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}). In TiCl4\text{TiCl}_4, the formal +4+4 state gives Ti4+\text{Ti}^{4+} extreme polarizing power, pulling chloride electron density completely into shared covalent bonds to produce discrete tetrahedral TiCl4\text{TiCl}_4 molecules that boil at 136 ∘C136\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C}.

03

Consider lithium iodide (LiI\text{LiI}) and potassium chloride (KCl\text{KCl}). Both have Δχ≈1.6−2.2\Delta\chi \approx 1.6 - 2.2. Use Fajans' rules (considering both cation polarizing power and anion polarizability) to predict which compound exhibits greater covalent character and lower melting point.

Answer

LiI\text{LiI} exhibits greater covalent character and a lower melting point (449 ∘C449\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} vs. 770 ∘C770\text{ }^{\circ}\text{C} for KCl\text{KCl}). Li+\text{Li}^+ is very small, giving it high polarizing power, while I−\text{I}^- has a large, easily distorted electron cloud (high polarizability). Together, these maximize polarization and covalent character.

Loading workspace…