Resources

In the Born-Meyer equation for lattice energy, the short-range Born repulsive potential is expressed as Bexp⁡(−rρ)B \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right), where ρ≈34.5 pm\rho \approx 34.5\text{ pm} represents the compressibility constant of the electron clouds. The total molar potential energy of a 1:11:1 ionic lattice at internuclear separation rr is U(r)=−NAMz2e24πε0r+NABexp⁡(−rρ)U(r) = -\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r} + N_A B \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right), where MM is the Madelung constant. (a) Derive the algebraic expression for the pre-exponential constant BB in terms of equilibrium distance r0r_0, MM, zz, ee, ε0\varepsilon_0, and ρ\rho by applying the equilibrium condition dUdr∣r=r0=0\left.\frac{dU}{dr}\right|_{r=r_0} = 0. (b) Evaluate the limiting behavior of the repulsive energy fraction Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} as r0→∞r_0 \to \infty, and determine this fractional contribution for a crystal with r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right). (b) As r0→∞r_0 \to \infty, Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0→0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0} \to 0; for r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm}, ρr0=34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\frac{\rho}{r_0} = \frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122 (12.2%12.2\% of the attractive Coulombic energy).

Steps

Part (a): Deriving the Expression for Constant BB

  1. Write the total potential energy function: The total potential energy per mole of a 1:11:1 ionic crystal as a function of internuclear distance rr is: U(r)=−NAMz2e24πε0r+NABexp⁡(−rρ)U(r) = - \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r} + N_A B \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) where the first term represents the long-range attractive electrostatic (Coulombic) energy Uatt(r)U_{\text{att}}(r) and the second term represents the short-range Born repulsive energy Urep(r)U_{\text{rep}}(r).
  2. Differentiate with respect to rr: Applying standard differentiation rules (ddr(r−1)=−r−2\frac{d}{dr}(r^{-1}) = -r^{-2} and ddrexp⁡(−rρ)=−1ρexp⁡(−rρ)\frac{d}{dr}\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) = -\frac{1}{\rho}\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right)): dUdr=NAMz2e24πε0r2−NABρexp⁡(−rρ)\frac{dU}{dr} = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} - \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right)
  3. Apply the equilibrium condition: At the equilibrium internuclear distance r=r0r = r_0, the net force on the ions is zero, meaning the potential energy is at a minimum: dUdr∣r=r0=0\left.\frac{dU}{dr}\right|_{r=r_0} = 0 NAMz2e24πε0r02−NABρexp⁡(−r0ρ)=0\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} - \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) = 0
  4. Solve for BB: Divide both sides by NAN_A and equate attractive and repulsive force components: Bρexp⁡(−r0ρ)=Mz2e24πε0r02\frac{B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) = \frac{M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} Multiply by ρ\rho and divide by exp⁡(−r0ρ)\exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) (equivalent to multiplying by exp⁡(r0ρ)\exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)): B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)

Part (b): Evaluating the Repulsive Energy Fraction

  1. Substitute BB back into the repulsive energy term: Evaluate the repulsive potential energy at the equilibrium distance r0r_0: Urep(r0)=NABexp⁡(−r0ρ)=NA[Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)]exp⁡(−r0ρ)U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = N_A B \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) = N_A \left[\frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)\right] \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) Urep(r0)=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2}
  2. Find the ratio of repulsive energy to attractive energy magnitude: The magnitude of the attractive potential energy at equilibrium is: ∣Uatt(r0)∣=NAMz2e24πε0r0|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)| = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0} Taking the ratio of the two terms: Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02NAMz2e24πε0r0=ρr0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2}}{\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0}} = \frac{\rho}{r_0}
  3. Determine the limiting behavior: As r0→∞r_0 \to \infty: lim⁡r0→∞Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=lim⁡r0→∞ρr0=0\lim_{r_0 \to \infty} \frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \lim_{r_0 \to \infty} \frac{\rho}{r_0} = 0 Physical interpretation: For very large interionic distances, the repulsive contribution becomes negligible compared to the Coulombic attraction because electron-cloud overlap decays exponentially with distance, much faster than the inverse-first-power Coulomb potential.
  4. Calculate the ratio for r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm}: Given ρ≈34.5 pm\rho \approx 34.5\text{ pm}: ρr0=34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\frac{\rho}{r_0} = \frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122 This indicates that at equilibrium, the repulsive energy offsets approximately 12.2%12.2\% of the attractive electrostatic energy, resulting in a net lattice energy of U(r0)=Uatt(r0)(1−ρr0)≈0.878 Uatt(r0)U(r_0) = U_{\text{att}}(r_0)\left(1 - \frac{\rho}{r_0}\right) \approx 0.878\, U_{\text{att}}(r_0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to apply the chain rule when differentiating exp(-r/ρ), omitting the factor of 1/ρ and leading to an incorrect expression for B and subsequent ratio.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dUdr=NAMz2e24πε0r2−NABexp⁡(−rρ)\frac{dU}{dr} = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} - N_A B \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right)

    Correct

    dUdr=NAMz2e24πε0r2−NABρexp⁡(−rρ)\frac{dU}{dr} = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} - \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right)

    You differentiated the Coulombic term correctly, but you omitted the factor of 1ρ\frac{1}{\rho} when taking the derivative of the exponential term exp⁡(−rρ)\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) via the chain rule.

  2. Step 2

    dUdr∣r=r0=0  ⟹  NAMz2e24πε0r02=NABexp⁡(−r0ρ)  ⟹  B=Mz2e24πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)\left.\frac{dU}{dr}\right|_{r=r_0} = 0 \implies \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} = N_A B \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) \implies B = \frac{M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)

    Correct

    B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)

    You correctly set the derivative to zero and solved for BB following your algebraic expression, but your result is missing the factor of ρ\rho from the differentiation error in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Urep(r0)=NABexp⁡(−r0ρ)=NAMz2e24πε0r02  ⟹  Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=1r0U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = N_A B \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \implies \frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{1}{r_0}

    Correct

    Urep(r0)=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02  ⟹  Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \implies \frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0}

    You accurately substituted your BB and took the ratio of repulsive to attractive potential energy, but because BB was missing ρ\rho, your ratio became 1r0\frac{1}{r_0} rather than the dimensionless ratio ρr0\frac{\rho}{r_0}.

  4. Step 4

    As r0→∞, lim⁡(1r0)=0  ⟹  For r0=282 pm:1282≈0.00355\text{As } r_0 \to \infty,\, \lim\left(\frac{1}{r_0}\right) = 0 \implies \text{For } r_0 = 282\text{ pm}: \frac{1}{282} \approx 0.00355

    Correct

    As r0→∞, lim⁡r0→∞(ρr0)=0  ⟹  For r0=282 pm:34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\text{As } r_0 \to \infty,\, \lim_{r_0 \to \infty}\left(\frac{\rho}{r_0}\right) = 0 \implies \text{For } r_0 = 282\text{ pm}: \frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122

    You correctly evaluated the limit and performed the arithmetic for your formula, but the numerical value differs because the true ratio includes the numerator ρ=34.5 pm\rho = 34.5\text{ pm}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the total lattice potential energy as the sum of attractive and repulsive components.

You accurately identified and applied the equilibrium condition dUdr∣r=r0=0\left.\frac{dU}{dr}\right|_{r=r_0} = 0.

You carried through clean algebraic substitutions and limit evaluations according to your derived formulas.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of chain rule factor in exponential differentiation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the derivative of exp⁡(−rρ)\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) as −exp⁡(−rρ)-\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) rather than −1ρexp⁡(−rρ)-\frac{1}{\rho}\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right), forgetting to multiply by the derivative of the exponent with respect to rr.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Chain Rule on Exponentials
  • ddr[exp⁡(kr)]=kexp⁡(kr)\frac{d}{dr}\left[\exp(k r)\right] = k \exp(k r), so for k=−1ρk = -\frac{1}{\rho}, ddr[exp⁡(−rρ)]=−1ρexp⁡(−rρ)\frac{d}{dr}\left[\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right)\right] = -\frac{1}{\rho}\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right).

  • Always explicitly write out the inner derivative of the argument of an exponential function before simplifying.

Dimensional Consistency Check
  • Any ratio of two quantities with identical units (such as Urep∣Uatt∣\frac{U_{\text{rep}}}{|U_{\text{att}}|}) must be dimensionless.

  • Check your final ratio: 1r0\frac{1}{r_0} has units of pm−1\text{pm}^{-1}, which signals that a length factor such as ρ\rho was lost in the numerator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Differentiate U(r)U(r) with respect to rr, correctly applying the chain rule to the exponential term: dUdr=NAMz2e24πε0r2−NABρexp⁡(−rρ)\frac{dU}{dr} = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} - \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right).

  2. Set dUdr∣r=r0=0\left.\frac{dU}{dr}\right|_{r=r_0} = 0: NAMz2e24πε0r02=NABρexp⁡(−r0ρ)\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} = \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right).

  3. Multiply both sides by ρexp⁡(r0ρ)\rho \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) and divide by NAN_A to isolate BB: B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right).

  4. Substitute BB into Urep(r0)=NABexp⁡(−r0ρ)=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = N_A B \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2}.

  5. Divide by ∣Uatt(r0)∣=NAMz2e24πε0r0|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)| = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0} to get Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0}.

  6. Evaluate the limit as r0→∞r_0 \to \infty: lim⁡r0→∞ρr0=0\lim_{r_0 \to \infty} \frac{\rho}{r_0} = 0.

  7. Compute the value for r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm}: 34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122 (12.2%12.2\%).

Final answer

(a) B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right); (b) As r0→∞r_0 \to \infty, Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0→0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0} \to 0, and for r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm}, the fraction is 34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122 (12.2%12.2\%).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice differentiating exponential functions with scaled arguments of the form e−x/ae^{-x/a} to solidify chain rule mechanics.

  • Perform dimensional analysis on intermediate and final algebraic expressions to catch missing constants immediately.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student differentiates the attractive term 1/r incorrectly as -1/r instead of -1/r², causing a missing power of r₀ in the denominator of B.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ddr(−1r)=1r  ⟹  dUdr=NAMz2e24πε0r−NABρexp⁡(−rρ)=0\frac{d}{dr}\left(-\frac{1}{r}\right) = \frac{1}{r} \implies \frac{dU}{dr} = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r} - \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) = 0

    Correct

    dUdr=NAMz2e24πε0r2−NABρexp⁡(−rρ)=0\frac{dU}{dr} = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} - \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) = 0

    You differentiated −1r=−r−1-\frac{1}{r} = -r^{-1} incorrectly as 1r\frac{1}{r}. By the power rule, ddr(−r−1)=−(−1)r−2=1r2\frac{d}{dr}\left(-r^{-1}\right) = -(-1)r^{-2} = \frac{1}{r^2}.

  2. Step 2

    NAMz2e24πε0r0=NABρexp⁡(−r0ρ)  ⟹  B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r0exp⁡(r0ρ)\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0} = \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) \implies B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)

    Correct

    B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)

    Your algebraic isolation of BB followed your derivative consistently, but the missing power in r02r_0^2 propagated from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Urep(r0)=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r0U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0}, ∣Uatt(r0)∣=NAMz2e24πε0r0  ⟹  Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρ|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)| = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0} \implies \frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \rho

    Correct

    Urep(r0)=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02  ⟹  Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \implies \frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0}

    Because Urep(r0)U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) inherited r0r_0 instead of r02r_0^2 in the denominator, taking the ratio with ∣Uatt(r0)∣|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)| resulted in ρ\rho rather than the dimensionless fraction ρr0\frac{\rho}{r_0}.

  4. Step 4

    As r0→∞,lim⁡ρ=34.5 pm;For r0=282 pm,ratio=34.5\text{As } r_0 \to \infty, \lim \rho = 34.5\text{ pm}; \text{For } r_0 = 282\text{ pm}, \text{ratio} = 34.5

    Correct

    lim⁡r0→∞ρr0=0\lim_{r_0 \to \infty} \frac{\rho}{r_0} = 0; For r0=282 pm,ρr0=34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\text{For } r_0 = 282\text{ pm}, \frac{\rho}{r_0} = \frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122

    Carrying forward ρ\rho led to a ratio that kept units of length and did not depend on r0r_0, preventing you from evaluating the correct asymptotic limit and fractional percentage.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the equilibrium condition where the first derivative of potential energy equals zero.

You differentiated the exponential Born repulsion term correctly with respect to rr.

You accurately identified the method for finding the repulsive-to-attractive energy ratio at equilibrium.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Power rule differentiation error on inverse powers

You treated the derivative of −1r-\frac{1}{r} as 1r\frac{1}{r} rather than 1r2\frac{1}{r^2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misapplying the power rule to negative exponents by failing to decrease the exponent by 11, converting −r−1-r^{-1} to r−1r^{-1} instead of +r−2+r^{-2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power Rule on Negative Exponents
  • For any power rnr^n, ddr(rn)=nrn−1\frac{d}{dr}(r^n) = n r^{n-1}. For n=−1n = -1, ddr(−r−1)=−(−1)r−2=1r2\frac{d}{dr}(-r^{-1}) = -(-1)r^{-2} = \frac{1}{r^2}.

  • Always rewrite reciprocal terms in explicit exponent form r−1r^{-1} before taking derivatives so you remember to subtract 11 from the power.

Dimensional Analysis of Ratios
  • The ratio of two energies Urep∣Uatt∣\frac{U_{\text{rep}}}{|U_{\text{att}}|} must be strictly dimensionless.

  • Check the units of your derived ratio: ρ\rho has units of meters (or pm), while ρr0\frac{\rho}{r_0} is dimensionless.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Rewrite the Coulomb term as −NAMz2e24πε0r−1-\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} r^{-1}. Differentiating yields +NAMz2e24πε0r2+\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2}.

  2. Equate the attractive force to the repulsive force at r0r_0: NAMz2e24πε0r02=NABρexp⁡(−r0ρ)\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} = \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right).

  3. Solve for BB: B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right).

  4. Substitute BB into Urep(r0)U_{\text{rep}}(r_0): Urep(r0)=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2}.

  5. Divide by ∣Uatt(r0)∣=NAMz2e24πε0r0|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)| = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0} to get Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0}.

Final answer

(a) B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right); (b) As r0→∞r_0 \to \infty, the ratio approaches 00; for r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm}, the ratio is 34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122 (12.2%12.2\%).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice taking first and second derivatives of inverse power functions like r−1r^{-1}, r−2r^{-2}, and r−nr^{-n}.

  • Use dimensional analysis as a rapid sanity check whenever you derive a physical ratio or constant.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the ratio of repulsive energy to attractive energy, evaluating |U_att(r₀)|/U_rep(r₀) instead of U_rep(r₀)/|U_att(r₀)|.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    dUdr=NAMz2e24πε0r2−NABρexp⁡(−rρ)  ⟹  \frac{dU}{dr} = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2} - \frac{N_A B}{\rho} \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\rho}\right) \implies At r=r0r=r_0, dUdr=0  ⟹  NAMz2e24πε0r02=NABρexp⁡(−r0ρ)\frac{dU}{dr} = 0 \implies \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} = \frac{N_A B}{\rho}\exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)

  2. Step 2

    B=Mz2e2ρ4πε0r02exp⁡(r0ρ)B = \frac{M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right)

  3. Step 3

    Urep(r0)=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2} and ∣Uatt(r0)∣=NAMz2e24πε0r0|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)| = \frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0}

  4. Step 4

    Fraction=∣Uatt(r0)∣Urep(r0)=r0ρ\text{Fraction} = \frac{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|}{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)} = \frac{r_0}{\rho}

    Correct

    Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=NAMz2e2ρ4πε0r02NAMz2e24πε0r0=ρr0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2 \rho}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0^2}}{\frac{N_A M z^2 e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r_0}} = \frac{\rho}{r_0}

    You inverted the fraction. The problem asked for the repulsive energy fraction Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|}, which should have the repulsive term in the numerator and the attractive magnitude in the denominator, yielding ρr0\frac{\rho}{r_0} rather than r0ρ\frac{r_0}{\rho}.

  5. Step 5

    As r0→∞,  lim⁡(r0ρ)=∞  ⟹  For r0=282 pm:  28234.5≈8.17\text{As } r_0 \to \infty,\; \lim\left(\frac{r_0}{\rho}\right) = \infty \implies \text{For } r_0 = 282\text{ pm}:\; \frac{282}{34.5} \approx 8.17

    Correct

    lim⁡r0→∞ρr0=0  ⟹  For r0=282 pm:  34.5 pm282 pm≈0.122\lim_{r_0 \to \infty} \frac{\rho}{r_0} = 0 \implies \text{For } r_0 = 282\text{ pm}:\; \frac{34.5\text{ pm}}{282\text{ pm}} \approx 0.122

    Because your ratio expression was inverted in the previous step, your limit evaluated to ∞\infty instead of 00, and your numerical evaluation gave the reciprocal value ≈8.17\approx 8.17 instead of ≈0.122\approx 0.122.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You differentiated both the power-law and exponential potential energy terms accurately.

You solved for the pre-exponential constant BB cleanly and without algebraic error.

You determined the correct algebraic expressions for both individual energy components at equilibrium.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted target ratio

You accidentally placed the attractive potential in the numerator and the repulsive potential in the denominator when setting up the ratio.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the part-to-whole or relative fractional contribution definition with its reciprocal, leading to an unphysical limit where repulsion appears to dominate completely at infinite separation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fraction Definition
  • The fractional contribution of quantity AA relative to quantity BB is always AB\frac{A}{B}.

  • Always verify which quantity is specified as the numerator before taking the ratio.

Physical Boundary Check
  • At very large distances (r0→∞r_0 \to \infty), electron clouds do not overlap, so the repulsive fraction must approach zero, not infinity.

  • Check the limiting behavior of your expression against physical intuition: if r0→∞r_0 \to \infty, repulsion must vanish relative to long-range Coulomb attraction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the requested ratio with repulsive energy in the numerator: Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0}.

  2. Evaluate the limit as r0→∞r_0 \to \infty: lim⁡r0→∞ρr0=0\lim_{r_0 \to \infty} \frac{\rho}{r_0} = 0.

  3. Substitute r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm} and ρ=34.5 pm\rho = 34.5\text{ pm}: 34.5282≈0.122\frac{34.5}{282} \approx 0.122 (12.2%12.2\%).

Final answer

Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=ρr0→0\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{\rho}{r_0} \to 0 as r0→∞r_0 \to \infty; for r0=282 pmr_0 = 282\text{ pm}, the fraction is approximately 0.1220.122.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check that your calculated fraction makes physical sense: repulsive energy should be a minor offsetting correction (around 10%–15%) to attractive Coulomb energy at equilibrium.

  • Re-read the question prompt carefully to confirm the numerator and denominator placement for all requested dimensionless ratios.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

For a potential energy function V(r)=−Ar+Cexp⁡(−rλ)V(r) = -\frac{A}{r} + C \exp\left(-\frac{r}{\lambda}\right), find the algebraic condition relating AA, CC, and λ\lambda at the equilibrium bond distance r=r0r = r_0 where dVdr∣r=r0=0\left.\frac{dV}{dr}\right|_{r=r_0} = 0.

Answer

C=Aλr02exp⁡(r0λ)C = \frac{A \lambda}{r_0^2} \exp\left(\frac{r_0}{\lambda}\right). Differentiating gives dVdr=Ar2−Cλexp⁡(−rλ)=0\frac{dV}{dr} = \frac{A}{r^2} - \frac{C}{\lambda}\exp\left(-\frac{r}{\lambda}\right) = 0, so Cλexp⁡(−r0λ)=Ar02\frac{C}{\lambda}\exp\left(-\frac{r_0}{\lambda}\right) = \frac{A}{r_0^2}.

02

In the Born-Landé model, the repulsive term is B′rn\frac{B'}{r^n} instead of an exponential. The total potential is U(r)=−Ar+B′rnU(r) = -\frac{A}{r} + \frac{B'}{r^n}. Express B′B' in terms of AA, nn, and r0r_0 using dUdr∣r=r0=0\left.\frac{dU}{dr}\right|_{r=r_0} = 0, and find the ratio Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|}.

Answer

B′=Ar0n−1nB' = \frac{A r_0^{n-1}}{n}, and Urep(r0)∣Uatt(r0)∣=1n\frac{U_{\text{rep}}(r_0)}{|U_{\text{att}}(r_0)|} = \frac{1}{n}. Setting Ar02−nB′r0n+1=0\frac{A}{r_0^2} - \frac{n B'}{r_0^{n+1}} = 0 yields B′=Ar0n−1nB' = \frac{A r_0^{n-1}}{n}. Substituting into Urep(r0)=Anr0U_{\text{rep}}(r_0) = \frac{A}{n r_0} gives Urep∣Uatt∣=1n\frac{U_{\text{rep}}}{|U_{\text{att}}|} = \frac{1}{n}.

03

A crystal has equilibrium distance r0=314 pmr_0 = 314\text{ pm} and softness parameter ρ=34.0 pm\rho = 34.0\text{ pm}. Using the Born-Meyer equation U(r0)=Uatt(r0)(1−ρr0)U(r_0) = U_{\text{att}}(r_0)\left(1 - \frac{\rho}{r_0}\right), calculate the percentage of Coulombic attraction that is offset by Pauli repulsion at equilibrium, and the resulting net lattice energy if Uatt(r0)=−820 kJ/molU_{\text{att}}(r_0) = -820\text{ kJ/mol}.

Answer

Offset is 10.8%10.8\%, net U(r0)≈−731 kJ/molU(r_0) \approx -731\text{ kJ/mol}. Fraction ρr0=34.0314≈0.1083\frac{\rho}{r_0} = \frac{34.0}{314} \approx 0.1083 (10.83%10.83\%). Then U(r0)=−820×(1−0.1083)≈−731.2 kJ/molU(r_0) = -820 \times (1 - 0.1083) \approx -731.2\text{ kJ/mol}.

Loading workspace…