Resources
A student is asked to predict precipitation when equal volumes ( each) of and are mixed. The student claims that a precipitate of will form because 'chlorides and hydroxides are generally insoluble.' (a) Evaluate whether a precipitate actually forms using standard solubility rules for Group 2 hydroxides, ammonium salts, and alkali/alkaline earth chlorides. (b) Identify the spectator ions in this mixture. (c) Write the net ionic equation, if any, that occurs upon mixing.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) No precipitate forms; both (soluble chloride) and (soluble weak base / aqueous ) remain dissolved in water; (b) Spectator ions are and ; (c) (acid-base neutralization, not a precipitation reaction)
Steps
List the Ions Present and Test for Potential Precipitates
When aqueous solutions of barium hydroxide, , and ammonium chloride, , are mixed, the completely dissociated ions initially present in the mixture are:
A double-displacement (metathesis) process could potentially pair these ions into two new combinations:
-
and to form :
- Solubility rule: Most chloride salts () are soluble in water, with the standard exceptions being , , and .
- Barium chloride, , is an alkaline earth chloride that is readily soluble. Therefore, does not precipitate.
-
and :
- Solubility rule: All common ammonium salts () are fully soluble.
- Rather than forming an insoluble solid, ammonium hydroxide exists as dissolved aqueous ammonia and water: .
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse general rules for hydroxides with alkaline earth hydroxides. While many transition metal hydroxides are insoluble, Group 2 hydroxides become increasingly soluble down the column, and is soluble. Furthermore, chlorides are overwhelmingly soluble, not insoluble.
Conclusion for (a): No precipitate forms; both and remain dissolved in aqueous solution.
Determine the Actual Reaction (Net Ionic Equation)
Although no precipitation reaction occurs, an acid-base neutralization takes place between the weak acid cation and the strong base anion :
Conclusion for (c): The net ionic equation is:
Identify the Spectator Ions
Spectator ions are those that remain dissolved as free hydrated ions on both the reactant and product sides without participating in any chemical transformation or phase change.
- and do not participate in bond breaking, bond formation, or phase changes.
Conclusion for (b): The spectator ions are and .
Typical errors
01 The student misremembers solubility rules by incorrectly classifying barium chloride as an insoluble precipitate like silver or lead chloride.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
and combine to form insoluble . A precipitate of forms.
CorrectNo precipitate forms. Barium chloride () is a soluble chloride salt, and ammonium salts remain completely soluble in aqueous solution.
You treated barium chloride as an insoluble precipitate. Standard solubility rules state that most chloride salts are soluble in water, with common exceptions limited to , , and . Because is an alkaline earth metal, remains completely dissolved.
- Step 2
and remain in solution. Spectator ions are and .
CorrectThe spectator ions are and .
You inverted the spectator and reacting species. Because and do not form a precipitate or react chemically, they remain unreacted as spectator ions. Meanwhile, and engage in an acid-base neutralization.
- Step 3Correct
You wrote a precipitation equation for barium chloride. Since no precipitate forms, the actual chemical transformation taking place is the transfer of a proton from the weak acid to the strong base .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the possible cation-anion combinations formed upon mixing the two solutions.
You balanced the stoichiometric coefficients properly in your proposed chemical equation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip occurred; this stems from misremembering the general solubility rule for chloride salts.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou classified chlorides as generally insoluble rather than generally soluble, leading you to predict a solid precipitate where none exists and preventing you from recognizing the acid-base reaction between and .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Chloride Salt Solubility
Almost all metal chlorides () are soluble in water, except those formed with silver (), lead(II) (), and mercury(I) ().
Always recall that Group 1 and Group 2 chlorides, including and , dissolve completely in water.
- Ammonium and Hydroxide Interaction
The combination of and undergoes an acid-base neutralization to form aqueous ammonia and liquid water rather than precipitating: .
Check whether mixed ions can engage in a proton-transfer reaction even if no solid precipitate forms.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationList all dissolved ions present initially: , , , and .
Evaluate potential ion combinations: with gives , which is soluble; with forms soluble aqueous species. Thus, no precipitate forms.
Identify the actual reaction: acts as a Bronsted-Lowry acid and acts as a base, yielding .
Identify spectator ions: and undergo no chemical change and are the spectator ions.
(a) No precipitate forms; (b) Spectator ions: and ; (c) Net ionic equation:
02 The student correctly concludes that no precipitate forms but overlooks the acid-base neutralization between ammonium and hydroxide, claiming that all ions are spectators and no reaction occurs.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is soluble and ammonium salts are soluble. No precipitate forms.
- Step 2
All ions remain dissolved as free ions. Spectator ions are , , , and .
CorrectSpectator ions are and .
While and do not react, acts as a weak acid and transfers a proton to . Because they participate in a chemical change, they are not spectator ions.
- Step 3
No reaction occurs.
CorrectMixing a weak acid cation () with a strong base anion () produces an acid-base neutralization reaction that generates aqueous ammonia and water.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that barium chloride is soluble in water.
You correctly recognized that ammonium salts are soluble and do not precipitate.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed that the absence of a solid precipitate implies that all ions remain unaffected in solution.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisFocusing solely on precipitation rules (metathesis forming an insoluble solid) while overlooking Brønsted-Lowry acid-base proton transfer reactions between conjugate acid-base pairs (such as and ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check for Multiple Reaction Types
Aqueous metathesis includes precipitation (solid formation), neutralization (water/weak electrolyte formation), and gas evolution.
Whenever solutions are mixed, test for acid-base proton transfer between weak acid cations (like ) and hydroxide () in addition to solubility rules.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the ions present: , , , and .
Check for acid-base chemistry: is a weak acid and is a strong base, so they react: .
Eliminate the reacting ions to determine spectator ions: only and remain unchanged.
(a) No precipitate forms; (b) Spectator ions are and ; (c)
03 The student confuses the solubility rule for hydroxides, incorrectly treating Ba(OH)2 as insoluble and concluding that it precipitates out of solution.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You treated as an insoluble precipitate. However, is a soluble strong base (the solubility of Group 2 hydroxides increases down the group), and it was already completely dissolved in the reactant solution. The new ion combinations are (a soluble chloride) and (which remains in solution as aqueous ammonia and water), so no precipitate forms.
- Step 2Correct
You designated as a spectator ion because it does not form a solid precipitate. However, acts as a weak acid and reacts with dissolved hydroxide ions (). The ions that undergo no chemical transformation or phase change are and .
- Step 3Correct
You wrote a precipitation net ionic equation for barium hydroxide. Because remains soluble, the true chemical process is a Brønsted-Lowry acid-base neutralization between the ammonium cation and hydroxide anion to yield aqueous ammonia and liquid water.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that ammonium salts and chloride ions do not combine to form an insoluble solid.
You correctly balanced the chemical charges and stoichiometry in the formula .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou classified as insoluble even though it was provided as a dissolved aqueous reactant.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou applied a broad generalization that 'hydroxides are insoluble' without accounting for the Group 2 solubility trend, where heavier alkaline earth hydroxides (specifically and ) are soluble. Additionally, you assumed mixing two solutions must produce a precipitate, overlooking the possibility of an aqueous acid-base neutralization.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Group 2 Hydroxide Solubility Trend
Hydroxide solubility in Group 2 increases moving down the periodic table: is sparingly soluble, is slightly soluble, while and are soluble strong bases.
Always verify whether a hydroxide belongs to the lower alkaline earth metals (, ) before marking it insoluble.
- Evaluate All Reaction Modes
When mixing electrolyte solutions, consider both precipitation (formation of an insoluble salt) and acid-base neutralization (transfer of between weak acids/bases).
Check if an ammonium cation (, a weak acid) is paired with hydroxide (, a strong base) to yield .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationList all dissolved ions present initially: , , , and .
Test potential new combinations: with forms , which is soluble; with does not form a solid precipitate.
Identify the actual reaction: donates a proton to , producing .
Identify spectator ions: and do not react and remain unchanged in solution.
(a) No precipitate forms; both and remain dissolved. (b) Spectator ions are and . (c) .
Lock it in
What are the common exceptions to the rule that chloride () salts are soluble in water?
, , and . All other common chlorides, including alkaline earth chlorides like , are soluble.
Similar question
Predict whether a precipitate forms when aqueous solutions of potassium chloride, , and lead(II) nitrate, , are mixed. If a precipitate forms, write its chemical formula and the net ionic equation.
Answer
Yes, a precipitate forms. The insoluble product is lead(II) chloride, . The net ionic equation is .
A student mixes equal volumes of and . Identify all precipitates that form and write the balanced net ionic equation for the reaction.
Answer
Two precipitates form: (insoluble sulfate) and (insoluble transition metal hydroxide). Net ionic equation: .
A solution contains and is mixed with an equal volume of . (a) Does a precipitate form? (b) Identify the spectator ions. (c) Write the net ionic equation.
Answer
(a) No precipitate forms; all species remain dissolved. (b) The spectator ions are and . (c) The net ionic equation is the acid-base neutralization: .