Resources

An aqueous beaker contains a saturated solution of calcium sulfate in equilibrium with solid: CaSO4(s)⇌Ca2+(aq)+SO42−(aq)\text{CaSO}_4(s) \rightleftharpoons \text{Ca}^{2+}(aq) + \text{SO}_4^{2-}(aq) (ΔHdissolution∘<0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} < 0, exothermic). A student proposes three separate actions to increase the mass of CaSO4(s)\text{CaSO}_4(s) precipitate: (1) Adding 0.10 M Na2SO4(aq)0.10\text{ M } \text{Na}_2\text{SO}_4(aq); (2) Heating the solution from 20∘C20^\circ\text{C} to 60∘C60^\circ\text{C}; (3) Adding 50 mL50\text{ mL} of pure distilled water. (a) For each action, predict whether the mass of solid precipitate increases, decreases, or remains unchanged, citing Le Chatelier's principle and solubility rules. (b) Explain the counter-intuitive effect observed in action (2) compared to typical solid dissolutions.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Action (1): Mass of solid increases due to the common-ion effect ([SO42−][\text{SO}_4^{2-}] increases, shifting equilibrium left); Action (2): Mass of solid increases because dissolution is exothermic (heat acts as a product, so increasing temperature shifts equilibrium left); Action (3): Mass of solid decreases as additional solvent allows more solid to dissolve until saturation is restored; (b) Unlike most solids whose dissolution is endothermic, CaSO4\text{CaSO}_4 exhibits retrograde solubility (exothermic dissolution), meaning heating forces additional precipitation.

Steps

Part (a): Predicting the Effect of Each Action

The dissolution equilibrium and its thermochemical equation are:

CaSOX4(s)⇌CaX2+(aq)+SOX4X2−(aq)+heat(ΔHdissolution∘<0)\ce{CaSO4(s) <=> Ca^2+(aq) + SO4^2-(aq) + \text{heat}} \quad (\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} < 0)

The solubility product quotient is given by Qsp=[CaX2+][SOX4X2−]Q_{sp} = [\ce{Ca^2+}][\ce{SO4^2-}].

  1. Action (1): Adding 0.10 M NaX2SOX4(aq)0.10\text{ M }\ce{Na2SO4(aq)}

    • Effect on solid mass: Increases
    • Basis: Sodium sulfate (NaX2SOX4\ce{Na2SO4}) is a highly soluble salt that dissociates completely into 2 NaX+(aq)\ce{2 Na+(aq)} and SOX4X2−(aq)\ce{SO4^2-(aq)}. Adding it abruptly increases the concentration of the common ion, [SOX4X2−][\ce{SO4^2-}], causing Qsp>KspQ_{sp} > K_{sp}. By Le Chatelier's principle, the system shifts to the left to consume the excess sulfate ions, precipitating additional CaSOX4(s)\ce{CaSO4(s)}.
  2. Action (2): Heating the solution from 20∘C20^\circ\text{C} to 60∘C60^\circ\text{C}

    • Effect on solid mass: Increases
    • Basis: Because the dissolution process is exothermic (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0), heat can be treated as a product on the right side of the equilibrium expression. According to Le Chatelier's principle, increasing the temperature adds thermal energy to the system, driving the equilibrium in the endothermic direction (to the left) to absorb heat. As a result, KspK_{sp} decreases, and more CaSOX4(s)\ce{CaSO4(s)} precipitates out of solution.
  3. Action (3): Adding 50 mL50\text{ mL} of pure distilled water

    • Effect on solid mass: Decreases
    • Basis: Adding pure solvent increases the total solution volume, immediately diluting the dissolved ions and lowering both [CaX2+][\ce{Ca^2+}] and [SOX4X2−][\ce{SO4^2-}]. This causes the reaction quotient to drop below the solubility product constant (Qsp<KspQ_{sp} < K_{sp}). In response, Le Chatelier's principle dictates a shift to the right (the forward direction), dissolving some of the existing solid CaSOX4(s)\ce{CaSO4(s)} until the solution becomes saturated again.

Part (b): Explanation of the Counter-Intuitive Temperature Effect

  • Typical Solid Dissolutions: For the vast majority of ionic salts (such as NaCl\ce{NaCl} or KNOX3\ce{KNO3}), the lattice energy required to break apart the ionic crystal is greater than the hydration energy released when ions interact with water. Consequently, the dissolution is endothermic (ΔHdissolution∘>0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} > 0), and heating increases solubility.
  • Calcium Sulfate Behavior: For CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4}, the hydration of the small, highly charged divalent ions (CaX2+\ce{Ca^2+} and SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-}) releases an unusually large amount of hydration energy that exceeds the lattice energy. Thus, the overall dissolution is exothermic (ΔHdissolution∘<0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} < 0). This results in retrograde solubility (solubility decreases as temperature rises). Heating the mixture drives the reverse reaction, causing additional solid to precipitate rather than dissolve.

Common Pitfall to Avoid

Do not assume that all solids dissolve more readily at elevated temperatures. Always verify the sign of ΔHdissolution∘\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} before applying Le Chatelier's principle to temperature shifts.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies Le Chatelier's principle to exothermic dissolution by assuming heating always increases solubility like typical solids, concluding that solid mass decreases in Action (2).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Action 1: Increases, common ion SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-} shifts equilibrium left.

  2. Step 2

    Action 2: Decreases, heating provides energy that breaks the lattice and dissolves more solid.

    Correct

    Action 2: Increases solid mass because dissolution is exothermic (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0); heating shifts equilibrium in the endothermic direction (left).

    Because the dissolution is exothermic (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0), heat acts as a product. By Le Chatelier's principle, raising the temperature drives the equilibrium to the left, which precipitates more CaSOX4(s)\ce{CaSO4(s)} rather than dissolving it.

  3. Step 3

    Action 3: Decreases, adding water dilutes the ions so more solid dissolves.

  4. Step 4

    Dissolving solids is generally favored at higher temperatures because thermal energy helps break the crystal lattice, so the solid dissolves instead of precipitating.

    Correct

    Most salts dissolve endothermically (ΔH∘>0\Delta H^\circ > 0), so heating increases solubility. In contrast, CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} dissolves exothermically (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0) due to large hydration energy, resulting in retrograde solubility where heating forces precipitation.

    You described the general intuition for typical endothermic dissolutions, but the prompt asked you to explain why CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} exhibits the opposite (counter-intuitive) behavior: its exothermic dissolution means its solubility decreases with increasing temperature (retrograde solubility).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Le Chatelier's principle to the common-ion effect in Action 1.

You correctly predicted that dilution drives the equilibrium forward to dissolve more solid in Action 3.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equilibrium Enthalpy Sign Neglect

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You relied on everyday intuition about thermal energy breaking lattices rather than checking the explicitly stated sign of ΔHdissolution∘<0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} < 0, which makes heat a product rather than a reactant.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Enthalpy Sign First
  • Dissolution can be endothermic (ΔH∘>0\Delta H^\circ > 0, heat is a reactant) or exothermic (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0, heat is a product).

  • Always look for the sign of ΔH∘\Delta H^\circ before predicting the temperature effect on solubility.

Apply Le Chatelier's Principle to Heat
  • Adding heat to an exothermic equilibrium (Solid⇌Ions+Heat\text{Solid} \rightleftharpoons \text{Ions} + \text{Heat}) shifts the reaction to the left, decreasing solubility.

  • Treat heat explicitly as a product on the right side when ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the thermochemical equilibrium: CaSOX4(s)⇌CaX2+(aq)+SOX4X2−(aq)+heat\ce{CaSO4(s) <=> Ca^2+(aq) + SO4^2-(aq)} + \text{heat} since ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0.

  2. Apply Le Chatelier's principle for a temperature increase (20∘C→60∘C20^\circ\text{C} \to 60^\circ\text{C}): the system consumes added heat by shifting left.

  3. Conclude that shifting left increases the mass of CaSOX4(s)\ce{CaSO4(s)} precipitate.

  4. Explain Part (b): while most salts have ΔHdissolution∘>0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} > 0 (lattice energy exceeds hydration energy), CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} has ΔHdissolution∘<0\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} < 0 (hydration energy exceeds lattice energy), giving it retrograde solubility.

Final answer

(a) Action 1: Increases; Action 2: Increases; Action 3: Decreases. (b) Typical salts dissolve endothermically, so heating dissolves more solid; CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} dissolves exothermically (retrograde solubility), so heating drives precipitation.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice writing 'heat' as a reactant or product directly into the equilibrium equation based on ΔH∘\Delta H^\circ.

  • Review the balance between lattice energy and hydration enthalpy that determines the overall sign of ΔHdissolution∘\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses adding water to a saturated solution with shifting the reaction to the left, incorrectly believing that increasing total volume pushes more solid out of solution.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1
    1. Increases, adding SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-} shifts equilibrium left.
  2. Step 2
    1. Increases, reaction is exothermic so heating shifts equilibrium left.
  3. Step 3
    1. Increases, adding 50 mL50\text{ mL} water expands the volume and forces more precipitate to form.
    Correct

    Action (3): Mass of precipitate decreases. Adding water dilutes the dissolved ions, lowering [Ca2+][\text{Ca}^{2+}] and [SO42−][\text{SO}_4^{2-}] so that Qsp<KspQ_{sp} < K_{sp}. The equilibrium shifts right to dissolve more solid until saturation is re-established.

    Adding pure water increases the solvent volume and lowers ion concentrations. To restore equilibrium, solid CaSO4\text{CaSO}_4 must dissolve, reducing the precipitate mass.

  4. Step 4

    Most solids have endothermic dissolution where solubility rises with temperature, but calcium sulfate is exothermic, so solubility decreases as temperature increases.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly predicted and justified the common-ion effect when sodium sulfate is added.

You correctly used the negative enthalpy of dissolution to deduce that heating favors precipitation.

You clearly contrasted retrograde solubility with standard endothermic solid dissolution.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Dilution effect on heterogeneous solubility equilibrium

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated expanding solution volume as a stress that squeezes or forces solid out of solution, confusing solvent dilution with a gas-phase volume decrease. Adding solvent dilutes aqueous species (Qsp<KspQ_{sp} < K_{sp}), which drives further dissolution of the undissolved solid.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate Ion Concentration via Dilution
  • Adding pure solvent increases total volume VV, which immediately reduces ion molarities: [ion]=ndissolvedV[\text{ion}] = \frac{n_{\text{dissolved}}}{V}.

  • Calculate or compare the new concentrations immediately after solvent addition before the system shifts.

Compare $Q_{sp}$ with $K_{sp}$
  • If [Ca2+][\text{Ca}^{2+}] and [SO42−][\text{SO}_4^{2-}] drop, then Qsp=[Ca2+][SO42−]<KspQ_{sp} = [\text{Ca}^{2+}][\text{SO}_4^{2-}] < K_{sp}.

  • Recognize that Qsp<KspQ_{sp} < K_{sp} requires the forward reaction (dissolution) to proceed, consuming solid precipitate until Qsp=KspQ_{sp} = K_{sp} again.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Adding 50 mL50\text{ mL} of water increases the volume of the solution without adding any solute ions.

  2. The concentrations of Ca2+(aq)\text{Ca}^{2+}(aq) and SO42−(aq)\text{SO}_4^{2-}(aq) immediately decrease upon dilution.

  3. Because [Ca2+][\text{Ca}^{2+}] and [SO42−][\text{SO}_4^{2-}] decrease, the reaction quotient becomes less than the equilibrium constant: Qsp<KspQ_{sp} < K_{sp}.

  4. By Le Chatelier's principle, the system responds by shifting in the forward direction (to the right) to restore ion concentrations, dissolving additional CaSO4(s)\text{CaSO}_4(s).

Final answer

The mass of solid precipitate decreases.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how solvent dilution affects QQ versus KK in heterogeneous equilibria containing pure solids.

  • Remember that solid phases do not exert concentration stress; only the aqueous ions change concentration when water is added.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets that Na2SO4 is completely soluble and dissociates to supply the common ion SO4²⁻, concluding that Action (1) has no effect on the equilibrium.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Remains unchanged, NaX2SOX4\ce{Na2SO4} contains spectator ions that do not participate in the CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} equilibrium.

    Correct

    Mass of solid increases: soluble NaX2SOX4\ce{Na2SO4} dissociates to increase [SOX4X2−][\ce{SO4^2-}], shifting equilibrium left via the common-ion effect.

    You treated all ions in NaX2SOX4\ce{Na2SO4} as spectator ions. Because NaX2SOX4\ce{Na2SO4} is highly soluble, it fully dissociates into 2 NaX+(aq)\ce{2 Na+(aq)} and SOX4X2−(aq)\ce{SO4^2-(aq)}. The added SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-} is a common ion that raises Qsp>KspQ_{sp} > K_{sp}, driving the equilibrium to the left and increasing the mass of precipitate.

  2. Step 2

    Increases, because ΔH<0\Delta H < 0, heat acts as a product and increasing temperature shifts equilibrium to the left.

  3. Step 3

    Decreases, adding water dilutes the ions so more CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} dissolves.

  4. Step 4

    Most solid dissolutions are endothermic so solubility increases upon heating, but CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} has an exothermic dissolution, meaning solubility decreases when heated.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Le Chatelier's principle to temperature changes for an exothermic reaction.

You correctly recognized that dilution lowers ion concentrations and prompts further dissolution of the solid.

You provided a sound conceptual explanation distinguishing endothermic dissolution from retrograde solubility.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Common-ion omission

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You classified the entire added salt NaX2SOX4\ce{Na2SO4} as spectator ions rather than identifying that SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-} is identical to one of the constituent ions in the dissolution equilibrium.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Dissociated Ions
  • Soluble ionic compounds dissociate into separate cations and anions in water.

  • Always write out the dissociation equation of any added soluble salt to check whether either ion matches an ion in the equilibrium.

Evaluate the Common-Ion Effect
  • Introducing an ion already present in a solubility equilibrium increases its concentration, shifting the position of equilibrium toward the solid precipitate.

  • When an added salt shares an ion with the precipitate, increase that ion's concentration in QspQ_{sp} and shift the equilibrium to the left.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the dissociation of the added salt: NaX2SOX4(s)→2 NaX+(aq)+SOX4X2−(aq)\ce{Na2SO4(s) -> 2 Na+(aq) + SO4^2-(aq)}.

  2. Identify SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^2-} as an ion shared directly with CaSOX4(s)⇌CaX2+(aq)+SOX4X2−(aq)\ce{CaSO4(s) <=> Ca^2+(aq) + SO4^2-(aq)}.

  3. Adding 0.10 M NaX2SOX40.10\text{ M }\ce{Na2SO4} significantly increases [SOX4X2−][\ce{SO4^2-}], making Qsp>KspQ_{sp} > K_{sp}.

  4. By Le Chatelier's principle, the equilibrium shifts to the left to consume the excess sulfate.

  5. Therefore, the mass of CaSOX4(s)\ce{CaSO4(s)} precipitate increases.

Final answer

(a) Action (1): Mass of solid increases; Action (2): Mass of solid increases; Action (3): Mass of solid decreases. (b) Most solid dissolutions are endothermic and dissolve more when heated, but CaSOX4\ce{CaSO4} dissolves exothermically, so heating shifts the equilibrium toward the solid (retrograde solubility).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before deciding whether an added compound is inert, split it into its component ions and compare each one against the ions in the KspK_{sp} expression.

  • Practice identifying common ions in mixed-electrolyte solutions to quickly spot shifts in sparingly soluble salt equilibria.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Cerium(III) sulfate, CeX2(SOX4)X3\ce{Ce2(SO4)3}, has an exothermic heat of dissolution (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0). Predict whether the concentration of CeX3+(aq)\ce{Ce^3+(aq)} in a saturated solution in contact with solid will increase, decrease, or remain unchanged when the solution is heated from 25∘C25^\circ\text{C} to 75∘C75^\circ\text{C}. Justify using Le Chatelier's principle.

Answer

The concentration of CeX3+(aq)\ce{Ce^3+(aq)} decreases. For an exothermic dissolution, heat is a product: CeX2(SOX4)X3(s)⇌2 CeX3+(aq)+3 SOX4X2−(aq)+heat\ce{Ce2(SO4)3(s) <=> 2 Ce^3+(aq) + 3 SO4^2-(aq) + \text{heat}}. Raising temperature shifts equilibrium left toward the solid, lowering dissolved ion concentrations.

02

A saturated solution of AgCl(s)\ce{AgCl(s)} has ΔHdissolution∘=+65.5 kJ/mol\Delta H^\circ_{\text{dissolution}} = +65.5\text{ kJ/mol}. A student carries out two actions: (a) adding 0.05 M NaCl(aq)0.05\text{ M }\ce{NaCl(aq)}, and (b) raising the temperature. Predict whether the mass of AgCl(s)\ce{AgCl(s)} precipitate increases or decreases in each case.

Answer

(a) Mass increases: adding common ion ClX−\ce{Cl-} increases Qsp>KspQ_{sp} > K_{sp}, shifting equilibrium left. (b) Mass decreases: because dissolution is endothermic (ΔH∘>0\Delta H^\circ > 0), adding heat shifts equilibrium right to absorb heat, dissolving more solid.

03

The dissolution of gas COX2(g)⇌COX2(aq)\ce{CO2(g) <=> CO2(aq)} is exothermic (ΔH∘<0\Delta H^\circ < 0), while dissolution of NHX4NOX3(s)\ce{NH4NO3(s)} is endothermic (ΔH∘>0\Delta H^\circ > 0). You warm an open beaker containing both a saturated solution of carbon dioxide and excess solid ammonium nitrate. Predict the phase change direction for each solute and explain using thermodynamic principles.

Answer

COX2\ce{CO2} gas bubbles out of solution (decreased solubility), while additional NHX4NOX3(s)\ce{NH4NO3(s)} dissolves (increased solubility). Warming drives exothermic equilibria in reverse (toward gaseous COX2\ce{CO2}) and drives endothermic equilibria forward (toward aqueous NHX4X+\ce{NH4+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-} ions).

Loading workspace…