Resources

Consider the nitronium ion, NO2+\text{NO}_2^+, and the nitrite ion, NO2−\text{NO}_2^-. For each species, draw the dominant Lewis resonance structure(s) that minimize formal charges while strictly adhering to the octet rule without exceeding an octet on nitrogen. For each ion, determine the number of single and double bonds present in the dominant structure(s) and identify which ion represents the boundary threshold where nitrogen must maintain an unshared electron pair that alters the overall bond order.

Answer and steps

Final answer

For NO2+\text{NO}_2^+: 00 single bonds, 22 double bonds (bond order = 2.02.0, no lone pairs on N\text{N}). For NO2−\text{NO}_2^-: 11 single bond and 11 double bond per resonance contributor (average bond order = 1.51.5, with 11 lone pair on N\text{N}). The threshold ion with a central lone pair altering bond order is NO2−\text{NO}_2^-.

Steps

01

Count the total valence electrons for each ion

  • For the nitronium ion (NOX2X+\ce{NO2+}): Valence electrons=5 (from N)+2×6 (from O)−1 (for the positive charge)=16 electrons (8 pairs)\text{Valence electrons} = 5\,(\text{from }\ce{N}) + 2 \times 6\,(\text{from }\ce{O}) - 1\,(\text{for the positive charge}) = 16\text{ electrons (8 pairs)}
  • For the nitrite ion (NOX2X−\ce{NO2-}): Valence electrons=5 (from N)+2×6 (from O)+1 (for the negative charge)=18 electrons (9 pairs)\text{Valence electrons} = 5\,(\text{from }\ce{N}) + 2 \times 6\,(\text{from }\ce{O}) + 1\,(\text{for the negative charge}) = 18\text{ electrons (9 pairs)}

02

Determine the dominant Lewis structure for NOX2X+\ce{NO2+}

  1. Connect the central nitrogen atom to each oxygen atom with a single bond (O−N−O\ce{O-N-O}), using 44 electrons.
  2. Complete the octets of the terminal oxygen atoms with three lone pairs each, using 1212 electrons. All 1616 valence electrons are now placed.
  3. Nitrogen currently has only 44 electrons (two bonding pairs). To satisfy the octet rule on nitrogen without exceeding it, each oxygen atom shares one of its lone pairs to form double bonds: [:O¨=N=O¨:]X+\ce{[:\ddot{O}=N=\ddot{O}:]^{+}}
  4. Formal Charges:
    • Central N\ce{N}: 5−4 bonds−0 lone electrons=+15 - 4\text{ bonds} - 0\text{ lone electrons} = +1
    • Each terminal O\ce{O}: 6−2 bonds−4 lone electrons=06 - 2\text{ bonds} - 4\text{ lone electrons} = 0
  5. Bond count and bond order:
    • Single bonds: 00
    • Double bonds: 22
    • Bond order: 2.02.0 (with 00 lone pairs on the central nitrogen atom).

03

Determine the dominant Lewis structures for NOX2X−\ce{NO2-}

  1. With 1818 valence electrons, NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} has two more electrons than NOX2X+\ce{NO2+}.
  2. Forming single bonds (O−N−O\ce{O-N-O}) and completing both oxygen octets uses 1616 electrons. The remaining 22 electrons form one unshared lone pair on the central nitrogen atom.
  3. Nitrogen now has 66 valence electrons (22 bonding pairs and 11 lone pair). To fulfill its octet, only one oxygen atom donates a lone pair to form a double bond.
  4. This results in two equivalent resonance contributors: [:O¨=N⋅⋅−O¨:]X− ⟷[:O¨−N⋅⋅=O¨:]X−\ce{[:\ddot{O}=\overset{\displaystyle\Large\cdot\cdot}{N}-\ddot{O}:]^{-} \longleftrightarrow [:\ddot{O}-\overset{\displaystyle\Large\cdot\cdot}{N}=\ddot{O}:]^{-}}
  5. Formal Charges:
    • Double-bonded O\ce{O}: 6−2−4=06 - 2 - 4 = 0
    • Single-bonded O\ce{O}: 6−1−6=−16 - 1 - 6 = -1
    • Central N\ce{N}: 5−3−2=05 - 3 - 2 = 0
  6. Bond count and bond order:
    • In each dominant contributor, there is 11 single bond and 11 double bond.
    • The average N−O\ce{N-O} bond order is 1+22=1.5\frac{1 + 2}{2} = 1.5.

04

Identify the boundary threshold ion

  • In NOX2X+\ce{NO2+}, nitrogen has no lone pairs, allowing it to form two complete double bonds (bond order =2.0= 2.0).
  • In NOX2X−\ce{NO2-}, the addition of an electron pair forces nitrogen to host a nonbonding lone pair. Because nitrogen is a second-row element, it cannot expand its valence shell beyond 88 electrons. Accommodating this lone pair forces one N−O\ce{N-O} linkage to become a single bond in any given contributor, reducing the average bond order from 2.02.0 to 1.51.5.
  • Therefore, NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} represents the boundary threshold where nitrogen must maintain an unshared electron pair that alters the overall bond order.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student miscounts the valence electrons of NO2- by subtracting an electron for the negative charge instead of adding one, resulting in identical bonding to NO2+.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    NO2+ valence electrons=5+12−1=16  ⟹  [O=N=O]+  ⟹  Single bonds: 0, Double bonds: 2\text{NO}_2^+ \text{ valence electrons} = 5 + 12 - 1 = 16 \implies [\text{O}=\text{N}=\text{O}]^+ \implies \text{Single bonds: } 0,\text{ Double bonds: } 2

  2. Step 2

    NO2− valence electrons=5+12−1=16\text{NO}_2^- \text{ valence electrons} = 5 + 12 - 1 = 16

    Correct

    NO2− valence electrons=5+2(6)+1=18\text{NO}_2^- \text{ valence electrons} = 5 + 2(6) + 1 = 18

    For an anion with a −1-1 charge, you must add an electron rather than subtract one. The total should be 5+12+1=18 valence electrons5 + 12 + 1 = 18\text{ valence electrons}.

  3. Step 3

    Structure: \text{Structure: } [O\text{O}=N\text{N}=O\text{O}]^-   ⟹  \implies Single bonds: \text{Single bonds: } 0, Double bonds: \text{ Double bonds: } 2

    Correct

    Resonance: \text{Resonance: } [:\ddot{O\text{O}}=N..\overset{..}{\text{N}}-\ddot{O\text{O}}:]^- \longleftrightarrow [:\ddot{O\text{O}}-N..\overset{..}{\text{N}}=\ddot{O\text{O}}:]^-   ⟹  \implies 1 single bond, \text{ single bond, } 1 double bond\text{ double bond}

    Because of the miscounted valence electrons, you gave NO2−\text{NO}_2^- the same structure as NO2+\text{NO}_2^+. With 1818 valence electrons, nitrogen retains one nonbonding lone pair, yielding resonance structures with 11 single bond and 11 double bond.

  4. Step 4

    Neither ion maintains an unshared electron pair on nitrogen because both have 16 valence electrons and linear double-bonded structures.\text{Neither ion maintains an unshared electron pair on nitrogen because both have 16 valence electrons and linear double-bonded structures.}

    Correct

    NO\text{NO}2^-  is the threshold ion, maintaining one lone pair on nitrogen and lowering the average bond order to \text{ is the threshold ion, maintaining one lone pair on nitrogen and lowering the average bond order to } 1.5.

    Because nitrite has 1818 valence electrons, nitrogen accommodates an unshared electron pair, making NO2−\text{NO}_2^- the boundary threshold species.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the 1616 valence electrons of the nitronium cation NO2+\text{NO}_2^+.

You correctly determined that NO2+\text{NO}_2^+ contains 00 single bonds and 22 double bonds.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign inversion in ionic valence electron count

You subtracted 11 for the negative charge on NO2−\text{NO}_2^- instead of adding 11.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating cation and anion electron-counting conventions caused you to assign 1616 electrons to NO2−\text{NO}_2^-, missing the central lone pair that dictates its bent geometry and fractional bond order.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ionic Valence Electron Adjustment
  • Total valence e−=∑(neutral valence e−)−(positive charge)+(negative charge)\text{Total valence } e^- = \sum(\text{neutral valence } e^-) - (\text{positive charge}) + (\text{negative charge})

  • Always add electrons for negative charges (anions) and subtract electrons for positive charges (cations).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate total valence electrons: 5 (N)+2×6 (O)+1 (charge)=18 electrons5\,(\text{N}) + 2 \times 6\,(\text{O}) + 1\,(\text{charge}) = 18\text{ electrons} (99 pairs).

  2. Form single N−O\text{N}-\text{O} bonds and satisfy terminal oxygen octets: uses 2+2+12=16 electrons2 + 2 + 12 = 16\text{ electrons}.

  3. Place the remaining 2 electrons2\text{ electrons} on the central nitrogen atom as a lone pair.

  4. To satisfy nitrogen's octet without exceeding 88 valence electrons, form one double bond with either oxygen atom: [:O¨=N..−O¨:]−⟷[:O¨−N..=O¨:]−[:\ddot{\text{O}}=\overset{..}{\text{N}}-\ddot{\text{O}}:]^- \longleftrightarrow [:\ddot{\text{O}}-\overset{..}{\text{N}}=\ddot{\text{O}}:]^-.

  5. Count bonds: each contributor has 1 single bond1\text{ single bond} and 1 double bond1\text{ double bond} (average bond order 1.51.5).

Final answer

For NO2+\text{NO}_2^+: 00 single bonds, 22 double bonds. For NO2−\text{NO}_2^-: 11 single bond, 11 double bond (bond order 1.51.5, with 11 lone pair on N\text{N}). Threshold ion: NO2−\text{NO}_2^-.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice writing an explicit charge-adjustment sign (e.g., +1 e−+1\,e^- for anions, −1 e−-1\,e^- for cations) before summing total valence electrons.

  • Check that species with different overall charges do not end up with identical valence electron counts unless their neutral formulas differ appropriately.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student expands the octet of nitrogen in NO2- to give two double bonds while retaining the nitrogen lone pair, violating the octet rule.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    NOX2X+\ce{NO2+} valence electrons =5+12−1=16= 5 + 12 - 1 = 16 ⟹\Longrightarrow Single bonds: 00, Double bonds: 22 ⟹\Longrightarrow Structure: [O=N=O]+[\ce{O=N=O}]^+

  2. Step 2

    NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} valence electrons =5+12+1=18= 5 + 12 + 1 = 18 ⟹\Longrightarrow Structure has a lone pair on N\ce{N} and two double bonds to oxygen: [:N(=O)X2]−[:\ce{N(=O)2}]^- ⟹\Longrightarrow Single bonds: 00, Double bonds: 22

    Correct

    NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} has 1818 valence electrons. To satisfy the octet rule on nitrogen without exceeding 88 electrons (11 lone pair +3+ 3 bonding pairs), each resonance structure has 11 single bond and 11 double bond: [:O¨=N ⋅  ⋅ −O¨:]−⟷[:O¨−N ⋅  ⋅ =O¨:]−[\ce{:\ddot{O}=\overset{..}{N}-\ddot{O}:}]^- \longleftrightarrow [\ce{:\ddot{O}-\overset{..}{N}=\ddot{O}:}]^-.

    You gave nitrogen one lone pair (22 nonbonding electrons) and two double bonds (88 bonding electrons), which totals 1010 valence electrons around nitrogen. Because nitrogen is in period 2, it lacks available dd-orbitals and cannot expand its octet beyond 88 electrons.

  3. Step 3

    NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} maintains an unshared electron pair on nitrogen, but it has 22 double bonds like NOX2X+\ce{NO2+}.

    Correct

    NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} is the threshold ion where the unshared pair on N\ce{N} forces one N−O\ce{N-O} bond to be single, lowering the bond order from 2.02.0 to 1.51.5.

    You correctly recognized that NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} carries the central unshared pair, but because of your earlier octet violation, you concluded that the bond order remains 2.02.0 rather than being reduced to 1.51.5.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly counted the total valence electrons for both ions (1616 for NOX2X+\ce{NO2+} and 1818 for NOX2X−\ce{NO2-}).

You correctly identified the linear structure and bond counts for NOX2X+\ce{NO2+} as having 00 single bonds and 22 double bonds.

You correctly identified that NOX2X−\ce{NO2-} is the ion that must hold an unshared pair of electrons on the central nitrogen.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Octet rule violation (hypervalent second-row element)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You allowed nitrogen to exceed its octet by drawing two double bonds in addition to a central lone pair (1010 valence electrons). Second-row elements (C, N, O, F) cannot expand their octet under any circumstances. Therefore, placing a lone pair on nitrogen forces one N−O\ce{N-O} bond to remain a single bond.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Strict Octet Cap for Period 2 Elements
  • Second-row elements (B\ce{B}, C\ce{C}, N\ce{N}, O\ce{O}, F\ce{F}) have only 2s2s and 2p2p valence orbitals, so they can never accommodate more than 88 valence electrons (44 pairs).

  • Always sum both nonbonding electrons and bonding pairs around N\ce{N}: Total electrons=2×(lone pairs)+2×(bonds)≤8\text{Total electrons} = 2 \times (\text{lone pairs}) + 2 \times (\text{bonds}) \le 8.

Lone Pair / Bond Order Trade-Off
  • When a central atom with a full octet gains an unshared electron pair, the maximum number of covalent bonds it can form decreases by 11 per lone pair added.

  • For nitrogen with 11 lone pair (22 electrons), only 66 electrons (33 pairs) remain for bonding, meaning it can form at most 33 bonds (either 11 single +1+ 1 double, or 11 triple bond).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Count total valence electrons for NOX2X−\ce{NO2-}: 5+2(6)+1=185 + 2(6) + 1 = 18 electrons (99 pairs).

  2. Connect O−N−O\ce{O-N-O} with single bonds (22 pairs) and place 33 lone pairs on each terminal oxygen (66 pairs), using 88 pairs total.

  3. Place the remaining 9th9\text{th} pair as a lone pair on the central nitrogen.

  4. Nitrogen now has 22 bonds +1+ 1 lone pair =6= 6 valence electrons. Convert exactly ONE terminal oxygen lone pair into a double bond so nitrogen reaches an octet of 88 electrons (11 lone pair +1+ 1 single bond +1+ 1 double bond).

  5. Calculate the bond counts and bond order: each dominant resonance structure has 11 single bond and 11 double bond, yielding an average bond order of 1.51.5.

Final answer

For NOX2X+\ce{NO2+}: 00 single bonds, 22 double bonds (bond order =2.0= 2.0, 00 lone pairs on N\ce{N}). For NOX2X−\ce{NO2-}: 11 single bond and 11 double bond per resonance contributor (average bond order =1.5= 1.5, 11 lone pair on N\ce{N}). The threshold ion with a central lone pair altering bond order is NOX2X−\ce{NO2-}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the octet limit for period 2 elements to ensure you never draw hypervalent structures for C\ce{C}, N\ce{N}, O\ce{O}, or F\ce{F}.

  • Practice drawing resonance structures for other triatomic species with central period 2 atoms, such as OX3\ce{O3} and NX3X−\ce{N3-}.

  • Check formal charges and octet counts systematically after completing any Lewis structure.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine the total valence electrons, number of single and double bonds in the dominant resonance contributor(s), and the formal charge on the central atom for the cyanate ion, OCN−\text{OCN}^-.

Answer

Total valence electrons: 6 (O)+4 (C)+5 (N)+1 (charge)=16 e−6\,(\text{O}) + 4\,(\text{C}) + 5\,(\text{N}) + 1\,(\text{charge}) = 16\,e^-. The dominant structure that minimizes formal charges with octets satisfied is [:O¨=C=N¨:]−[:\ddot{\text{O}}=\text{C}=\ddot{\text{N}}:]^- or [:O¨−C≡N:]−[:\ddot{\text{O}}-\text{C}\equiv\text{N}:]^-. For the double-bonded form: 00 single bonds, 22 double bonds (or 11 single and 11 triple in the major contributor). The central carbon has 00 lone pairs and a formal charge of 4−4=04 - 4 = 0.

02

Compare the sulfur dioxide molecule (SO2\text{SO}_2) and the sulfite ion (SO32−\text{SO}_3^{2-}). Calculate the valence electrons for each and state the number of nonbonding lone pairs on the central sulfur atom in each species.

Answer

For SO2\text{SO}_2: 6+2(6)=18 e−6 + 2(6) = 18\,e^-, giving 11 nonbonding lone pair on S\text{S}. For SO32−\text{SO}_3^{2-}: 6+3(6)+2=26 e−6 + 3(6) + 2 = 26\,e^-, giving 11 nonbonding lone pair on S\text{S} with three single S−O\text{S}-\text{O} bonds in its strict octet structure (or resonance with one double bond).

03

Consider the nitrogen oxide family: NO+\text{NO}^+, NO2+\text{NO}_2^+, and NO3−\text{NO}_3^-. Calculate the total valence electron count for each ion, draw their dominant resonance forms, and rank them in order of decreasing average N−O\text{N}-\text{O} bond order.

Answer

NO+\text{NO}^+: 5+6−1=10 e−5 + 6 - 1 = 10\,e^-, structure [:N≡O:]+[:\text{N}\equiv\text{O}:]^+, bond order =3.0= 3.0.\nNO2+\text{NO}_2^+: 5+12−1=16 e−5 + 12 - 1 = 16\,e^-, structure [:O¨=N=O¨:]+[:\ddot{\text{O}}=\text{N}=\ddot{\text{O}}:]^+, bond order =2.0= 2.0.\nNO3−\text{NO}_3^-: 5+18+1=24 e−5 + 18 + 1 = 24\,e^-, three resonance contributors each with 22 single and 11 double bond, average bond order =1+1+23=1.33= \frac{1+1+2}{3} = 1.33.\nRanking: NO+(3.0)>NO2+(2.0)>NO3−(1.33)\text{NO}^+ (3.0) > \text{NO}_2^+ (2.0) > \text{NO}_3^- (1.33).

Loading workspace…