Resources
Compare the noble gas fluorides xenon difluoride () and xenon tetrafluoride () with their respective group-16 analogues, oxygen difluoride () and sulfur tetrafluoride (). Both and contain highly polar bonds (). For each of the four species, determine the steric number of the central atom, the number of lone pairs, and the resulting molecular geometry. Identify the critical geometric symmetry threshold (inversion center or vector cancellation) that renders and strictly nonpolar () while their analogues and remain polar ().
Answer and steps
Final answer
: steric number ( bonds, equatorial lone pairs), linear geometry (), centrosymmetric with opposing equal bond dipoles, so (nonpolar). In contrast, : steric number ( bonds, lone pairs), bent geometry (), lacks inversion symmetry, giving (polar). : steric number ( bonds, trans axial lone pairs), square planar geometry (), contains a center of inversion () where the four in-plane bond dipoles cancel in opposing pairs, giving (nonpolar). In contrast, : steric number ( bonds, equatorial lone pair), asymmetric seesaw geometry (), resulting in a nonzero vector sum (polar).
Steps
Comparison of the Difluorides: vs.
Understanding Molecular Polarity
A molecule is nonpolar () if its individual bond dipole vectors and lone-pair dipole contributions sum vectorially to zero: A sufficient condition for a molecule to be nonpolar is the presence of an inversion center ( symmetry), or any point group with orthogonal axes of symmetry that cause opposing dipole vectors of equal magnitude to cancel completely.
Xenon Difluoride ()
- Valence Electron Count: contributes valence electrons, and each contributes , giving a total of valence electrons.
- Steric Number (SN): The central forms single bonds to fluorine and holds lone pairs:
- Lone Pair Placement & Molecular Geometry: According to VSEPR theory, lone pairs occupy the less crowded equatorial positions ( apart) to minimize repulsion. The two fluorine atoms occupy axial positions ( apart), yielding a linear geometry (point group ).
- Dipole Cancellation: The central sits at an inversion center (). The two identical, highly polar bond dipoles point in exactly opposite directions (), and the three equatorial lone pairs cancel symmetrically in a plane:
Oxygen Difluoride ()
- Valence Electron Count: contributes valence electrons, and each contributes , giving a total of valence electrons.
- Steric Number (SN): The central forms single bonds and has lone pairs:
- Molecular Geometry: With two bonding pairs and two lone pairs, the molecule adopts a bent geometry (point group ) with a bond angle of approximately .
- Dipole Cancellation: lacks an inversion center. The two polar bond dipoles add constructively rather than cancelling, producing a permanent net dipole moment:
Comparison of the Tetrafluorides: vs.
Xenon Tetrafluoride ()
- Valence Electron Count: contributes valence electrons, and fluorines contribute , totaling valence electrons.
- Steric Number (SN): The central forms bonds and retains lone pairs:
- Lone Pair Placement & Molecular Geometry: To minimize strong lone pair–lone pair repulsion ( interactions), the two lone pairs occupy trans (axial) positions ( apart). The four fluorine atoms lie in the equatorial plane, creating a square planar geometry (point group ).
- Dipole Cancellation: The molecule possesses an inversion center () at the xenon nucleus. The four in-plane bond dipoles cancel out in opposing pairs ( across the square plane), and the two axial lone pairs cancel each other:
Sulfur Tetrafluoride ()
- Valence Electron Count: contributes valence electrons, and fluorines contribute , totaling valence electrons.
- Steric Number (SN): The central forms bonds and has lone pair:
- Lone Pair Placement & Molecular Geometry: The single lone pair occupies an equatorial position to minimize repulsions, producing an asymmetric seesaw geometry (point group ).
- Dipole Cancellation: The axial bonds are slightly bent away from the lone pair (angle ), and the equatorial bond angle is compressed to . Due to this asymmetry and the lack of an inversion center, the bond dipoles and the lone-pair contribution do not cancel:
Common Pitfall to Avoid
- Assuming polar bonds guarantee a polar molecule: A large electronegativity difference () ensures bond polarity, but high geometric symmetry (such as centrosymmetric linear or square planar ) forces opposing dipole vectors to cancel completely, rendering the overall molecule nonpolar.
Typical errors
01 The student ignores the central atom's nonbonding valence electrons and assumes molecular geometry matches the number of bonded atoms.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: bonds, steric number , lone pairs, linear
Correct: bonds, lone pairs, steric number , linear geometry ()
You found the correct linear molecular geometry, but your electron counting is incorrect. Xenon possesses valence electrons; after forming single bonds to fluorine, nonbonding electrons remain on , forming equatorial lone pairs. This gives a steric number of (trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry), not .
- Step 2
: bonds, steric number , lone pairs, tetrahedral
Correct: bonds, lone pairs, steric number , square planar geometry ()
You omitted the nonbonding valence electrons on xenon. With valence electrons and single bonds, xenon retains nonbonding electrons ( lone pairs). The steric number is (octahedral electron geometry), placing the two lone pairs trans to each other and yielding a square planar molecular geometry.
- Step 3
: bonds, steric number , lone pairs, linear
Correct: bonds, lone pairs, steric number , bent geometry ()
You treated oxygen as having zero lone pairs. Oxygen has valence electrons; using for bonding leaves nonbonding electrons ( lone pairs). The steric number is , producing a bent molecular geometry with a bond angle of approximately .
- Step 4
: bonds, steric number , lone pairs, tetrahedral
Correct: bonds, lone pair, steric number , seesaw geometry ()
You omitted the lone pair on sulfur. Sulfur has valence electrons; using for single bonds leaves nonbonding electrons ( equatorial lone pair). The steric number is , resulting in an asymmetric seesaw geometry rather than tetrahedral.
- Step 5
Tetrahedral and linear molecules with identical outer atoms cancel dipoles by symmetry, but and should also cancel, failing to explain why only compounds are nonpolar.
Correct() and () possess an inversion center (), so opposing bond dipoles cancel completely (). In contrast, (bent, ) and (seesaw, ) lack an inversion center, leading to nonzero vector sums ().
You correctly reasoned that ideal linear and tetrahedral geometries with identical peripheral atoms cancel bond dipoles, but your conclusion was trapped by the flawed geometries from earlier steps. Once lone pairs are included, is bent and is seesaw (both ), lacking an inversion center, while () and () possess centrosymmetric inversion centers () where opposing dipoles cancel.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the number of covalent bonds formed by the central atom in all four molecules.
You understood that high geometric symmetry with identical outer atoms causes individual bond dipoles to cancel vectorially.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the steric number directly to the number of bonded atoms and set lone pairs to zero across all four molecules.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou did not calculate the remaining nonbonding valence electrons on the central atom before determining electron-pair geometry and molecular shape via VSEPR theory.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Valence Electron Inventory
For a neutral molecule with single terminal bonds: , where is the group valence electron count of the central atom.
Always find group valence electrons first (Xe: , O: , S: ) and subtract bonding electrons before assigning steric number.
- Inversion Symmetry vs. Net Dipole
A molecule is strictly nonpolar () if it contains an inversion center () or orthogonal symmetry elements where all opposing bond and lone-pair dipole vectors cancel.
Check whether every atom and lone pair has an identical counterpart reflected through the central nucleus (e.g., in and in have ; in and does not).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount valence electrons and find lone pairs on each central atom: .
For : , . linear ().
For : , . bent ().
For : , . square planar ().
For : , . seesaw ().
Evaluate symmetry: and contain a center of inversion (), so opposing bond dipoles cancel exactly (). and belong to with no inversion center, leaving permanent net dipole moments ().
: , lone pairs, linear (), nonpolar () due to inversion center . : , lone pairs, bent (), polar (). : , lone pairs, square planar (), nonpolar () due to inversion center . : , lone pair, seesaw (), polar ().
02 The student confuses the electron-pair geometry with molecular geometry for structures containing lone pairs.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: steric number , lone pairs; : steric number , lone pairs; : steric number , lone pairs; : steric number , lone pair
- Step 2
: geometry = trigonal bipyramidal; : geometry = octahedral; : geometry = tetrahedral; : geometry = trigonal bipyramidal
Correct: linear; : square planar; : bent; : seesaw
You wrote down the electron-pair (electron domain) geometries rather than the molecular geometries. Molecular geometry describes the spatial arrangement of the bonded nuclei only, excluding the lone pairs from the final shape name.
- Step 3
Trigonal bipyramidal and octahedral arrangements have vector cancellation and inversion symmetry, so and are predicted nonpolar, but this incorrectly predicts and to be nonpolar regular geometries.
Correct(linear, ) and (square planar, ) both possess an inversion center () where identical opposing bond dipoles cancel completely (). In contrast, (bent, ) and (seesaw, ) lack an inversion center, so their bond dipoles add vectorially to yield a permanent net dipole moment ().
Because you used the electron geometries rather than the molecular shapes, your symmetry evaluation could not explain why and are nonpolar while and are polar.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the steric numbers for all four species.
You identified the correct number of lone pairs on each central atom.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou substituted the parent electron-pair geometry in place of the molecular geometry. Remember that molecular geometry only names the geometric figure formed by the bonded atoms, after placing lone pairs in their most stable positions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish electron geometry from molecular geometry
Electron geometry accounts for all electron domains (bonds and lone pairs). Molecular geometry describes only the spatial arrangement of the bonded peripheral atoms.
Once you determine the steric number and place lone pairs into the lowest-energy sites (equatorial in trigonal bipyramidal, trans in octahedral), name the shape defined solely by the remaining peripheral atoms.
- Use molecular shape for inversion and dipole cancellation
A molecule is nonpolar if it possesses an inversion center () or a symmetry point group where all bond dipole vectors cancel vectorially to zero.
Check whether every peripheral atom has an identical counterpart directly through the center of inversion (). If it does, the bond dipoles cancel out completely.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration: with equatorial lone pairs leaves axial fluorines apart, giving a linear geometry ().
: with trans axial lone pairs leaves coplanar fluorines, giving a square planar geometry ().
: with lone pairs leaves bonded fluorines at , giving a bent geometry ().
: with equatorial lone pair leaves an asymmetric seesaw geometry ().
Evaluate symmetry: and contain an inversion center (), so opposing bond dipoles cancel (). and lack inversion symmetry, so their bond dipoles add constructively ().
: linear, nonpolar (); : bent, polar (); : square planar, nonpolar (); : seesaw, polar ().
03 The student places the lone pairs of XeF4 in adjacent positions rather than trans positions, resulting in a polar seesaw-like or asymmetric geometry.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: steric number , lone pairs, linear
- Step 2
: steric number , lone pairs placed cis/adjacent, unsymmetrical square pyramidal
Correct: steric number ( bonding pairs, trans lone pairs), square planar geometry ()
In an octahedral electron domain arrangement (steric number ), lone pair–lone pair repulsion is minimized when the two lone pairs occupy trans positions ( apart) rather than cis/adjacent positions ( apart). This gives a square planar geometry, not square pyramidal.
- Step 3
: steric number , lone pairs, bent : steric number , lone pair, seesaw
- Step 4
has opposing linear bonds with vector cancellation, but lacks an inversion center due to cis lone pairs, erroneously predicting is polar.
Correcthas collinear opposing bonds (), and has an inversion center () in a square planar framework (), so both have (nonpolar). (bent) and (seesaw) lack inversion symmetry, so their dipoles do not cancel (polar).
Your symmetry analysis for is correct. However, because you previously assigned cis lone pairs to , you concluded that it lacks an inversion center; in reality, trans lone pairs preserve a center of inversion () where opposite in-plane bond dipoles cancel out completely.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the steric numbers and lone pair counts for all four molecules.
You accurately identified the linear geometry and bond dipole vector cancellation for .
You correctly determined the bent geometry of and the seesaw geometry of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou placed the two lone pairs of adjacent to each other ( cis) instead of opposite each other ( trans).
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisMisjudging VSEPR repulsive hierarchies in steric number 6 systems by failing to prioritize minimizing lone pair–lone pair interactions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- VSEPR Repulsion Hierarchy
Lone pair–lone pair (LP–LP) repulsion is significantly stronger than lone pair–bonding pair (LP–BP) and bonding pair–bonding pair (BP–BP) repulsions.
Always place multiple lone pairs as far apart as possible (e.g., trans in an octahedral arrangement) to eliminate destabilizing LP–LP repulsions.
- Inversion Center Test for Polarity
A molecule possessing an inversion center () must have a net dipole moment of zero ().
For square planar molecules (), verify that reflecting any atom through the central nucleus reaches an identical atom, guaranteeing vector cancellation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the electron domain geometry of : (octahedral).
Place the two lone pairs apart in axial/trans positions to minimize LP–LP repulsion, leaving all four fluorine atoms in a single equatorial plane.
Identify the molecular geometry as square planar ().
Apply symmetry operations: the square planar geometry possesses an inversion center () at the xenon nucleus, meaning each bond dipole has an equal and opposite partner across the center.
Conclude that all bond dipoles and lone pair vectors cancel out (, strictly nonpolar).
adopts a square planar geometry () because its two lone pairs occupy trans positions ( apart) to minimize repulsion. It possesses an inversion center () where opposing bond dipoles cancel out completely, yielding .
Lock it in
How do you calculate the number of lone pairs on a central atom with group valence in a neutral molecule with single bonds?
. The steric number is then .
Similar question
For the triiodide ion (), determine the steric number of the central iodine atom, the number of lone pairs on it, its molecular geometry, and whether it has a permanent net dipole moment.
Answer
Central has valence electrons. It forms single bonds, leaving nonbonding electrons ( equatorial lone pairs). , giving a linear molecular geometry (). Because it is centrosymmetric (inversion center ), the opposing bond dipoles cancel, so (nonpolar).
Compare chlorine trifluoride () and boron trifluoride (). Determine their steric numbers, molecular geometries, and state whether each is polar or nonpolar.
Answer
: has valence electrons, forms bonds, lone pairs (). Geometry is trigonal planar (); bond dipoles cancel at , so (nonpolar). : has valence electrons, forms bonds, leaving electrons ( lone pairs, ). Geometry is T-shaped (); lacking inversion symmetry, the dipoles do not cancel, so (polar).
Phosphorus pentafluoride () and bromine pentafluoride () both have five fluorine atoms attached to a central atom. Determine the steric number and molecular geometry for each, and explain which one has a permanent net dipole moment.
Answer
: has valence electrons, bonds, lone pairs (). Molecular geometry is trigonal bipyramidal (). The three equatorial dipoles () and two axial dipoles () cancel completely, so (nonpolar). : has valence electrons, bonds, lone pair (). Molecular geometry is square pyramidal (). It lacks an inversion center and the axial dipole is unbalanced, so (polar).