Resources
A student measures the electrical conductivity of pure liquid hydrogen chloride () at and records a value of . However, when of the same gas is bubbled into of distilled water at , the conductivity spikes to . (a) Explain this observation by contrasting the bonding nature of pure anhydrous with its behavior in aqueous solution. (b) Explain why a solid salt such as calcium chloride () cannot conduct electricity at , but exhibits high electrical conductivity () when heated to (molten state), while molten molecular sulfur () does not conduct at any temperature.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Pure anhydrous is a molecular substance consisting of neutral polar covalent molecules with no free ions or mobile electrons, resulting in negligible conductivity. When dissolved in water, it undergoes chemical ionization (), generating high concentrations of mobile solvated ions that conduct electric current. (b) In solid , and ions are locked into fixed positions within the rigid crystal lattice and cannot translate. Upon melting at , the ionic lattice breaks down, freeing ions to move under an applied electric field. In contrast, molten remains composed of neutral covalent octatomic rings with no formal charges or free electrons, remaining nonconductive.
Steps
Part (a): Electrical Conductivity of Anhydrous vs. Aqueous
- Understand the requirement for electrical conduction: For any substance to conduct electricity, it must contain mobile charged particles—either delocalized electrons (as in metals) or mobile ions (as in electrolytes).
-
Analyze pure anhydrous liquid :
- Liquid at is a molecular covalent compound.
- It consists of individual, neutral polar molecules () held together solely by dipole-dipole attractions and London dispersion forces.
- Because it contains only neutral molecules and lacks free-moving ions or delocalized electrons, its conductivity is negligible ().
-
Analyze aqueous (hydrochloric acid):
- Water () is a highly polar solvent that chemically reacts with hydrogen chloride via an acid-base ionization reaction:
- Dissolving of () in of water results in a solution of hydronium ions () and chloride ions ().
- These solvated ions are freely mobile in solution. Under an applied electric potential, cations migrate toward the cathode and anions migrate toward the anode, causing the conductivity to spike sharply to .
Part (b): Conductivity of (Solid vs. Molten) and Molten
-
Solid calcium chloride ( at ):
- is an ionic compound composed of alternating and ions bound in a rigid three-dimensional crystal lattice by strong electrostatic attractions.
- Although charged particles are present, they are locked into fixed positions within the lattice and can only vibrate; they cannot translate or migrate. Therefore, solid cannot conduct electricity.
-
Molten calcium chloride ( at ):
- Upon heating above its melting point (), sufficient thermal energy is supplied to overcome the strong electrostatic attractions, breaking down the rigid crystal lattice.
- The and ions gain translational mobility, moving freely through the liquid phase to carry an electric current ().
-
Molten molecular sulfur ():
- Sulfur is a molecular covalent substance composed of neutral, octatomic crown-shaped rings held to one another by weak London dispersion forces.
- Melting sulfur breaks only the intermolecular forces between separate molecules (or opens rings into neutral polymeric chains at higher temperatures), without producing ions or releasing electrons.
- Because no charged particles are generated at any temperature, molten sulfur remains completely nonconductive.
Key Pitfall: Do not confuse dissolving with melting. Melting an ionic compound frees pre-existing ions from a lattice. Dissolving a covalent gas like requires a chemical reaction with a polar solvent (ionization) to generate ions from neutral molecules.
Typical errors
01 The student misclassifies anhydrous HCl as an ionic compound and assumes it cannot conduct merely because it lacks water rather than recognizing its covalent nature.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Liquid is an ionic compound made of and ions. Without water, the ions are tightly bound together and cannot dissociate to conduct electricity. Adding water allows the and ions to dissociate and move freely, increasing conductivity.
CorrectPure anhydrous is a polar covalent molecular substance consisting of neutral molecules held by intermolecular forces, with no free ions or mobile electrons (). When dissolved in water, it undergoes chemical ionization (), generating mobile and ions that conduct electric current.
You misclassified liquid as an ionic compound containing pre-existing and ions. Because hydrogen and chlorine are both nonmetals with a moderate electronegativity difference, forms neutral polar covalent molecules. Ions do not exist in pure liquid ; they are generated only when chemically reacts with water molecules (ionization), forming hydronium and chloride ions.
- Step 2
Solid is ionic with ions fixed in place in a crystal lattice. Melting frees and ions to move and carry current.
- Step 3
Molten is a covalent molecular liquid with no free ions, so it cannot conduct.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that electrical conduction requires mobile charged particles.
You accurately explained that solid ionic lattices immobilize ions, whereas melting frees them to conduct electricity.
You correctly classified molten sulfur as a covalent molecular liquid lacking free ions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused ionic dissociation (the separation of pre-existing ions from an ionic lattice) with covalent ionization (the chemical reaction between neutral polar molecules and water to generate new ions). Because acids form ions in water, it is easy to assume they are made of ions in the pure state, but hydrogen halides are neutral covalent molecules when pure.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dissociation vs. Ionization
Ionic compounds already contain ions in the pure solid or molten state and simply separate (dissociate) in water. Molecular acids (, ) contain neutral covalent molecules in the pure state and only form ions by chemically reacting with water (ionization).
Before analyzing conductivity, check the bonding of the pure substance: two nonmetals generally form covalent molecules with no pre-existing ions, so liquid or gaseous acids cannot conduct electricity.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationPure liquid consists of neutral molecules held together by dipole-dipole attractions and London dispersion forces.
Because there are no free-moving ions or delocalized electrons, pure liquid has negligible conductivity ().
When gas dissolves in water, it chemically reacts with polar water molecules: .
The resulting mobile hydronium () and chloride () ions migrate under an applied electric field, causing the electrical conductivity to spike to .
(a) Pure anhydrous is a molecular substance consisting of neutral polar covalent molecules with no free ions, resulting in negligible conductivity. In aqueous solution, it undergoes chemical ionization () to produce mobile solvated ions that conduct electricity.
02 The student confuses ionic conduction with metallic conduction by claiming molten CaCl2 conducts via free-moving delocalized electrons.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Pure liquid is a covalent compound consisting of neutral molecules, so it has no ions to conduct electricity. When bubbled into water, reacts with water to form mobile and ions that conduct current.
- Step 2
Solid has ions locked in a rigid crystal lattice with no free charge carriers.
- Step 3
When heated to , the bonds break and release delocalized valence electrons that flow freely.
CorrectHeating past its melting point disrupts the ionic lattice, allowing and ions to move freely to conduct electricity.
Melting an ionic compound frees pre-existing ions ( and ) to move through the liquid. It does not produce delocalized electrons, which are characteristic of metallic bonding.
- Step 4
Molten holds its electrons tightly in covalent bonds and has no free electrons to conduct.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished between neutral covalent molecules in pure and the solvated ions generated upon aqueous ionization.
You explained that ions in a solid ionic crystal cannot move to conduct electricity.
You recognized that molten sulfur remains nonconducting because it lacks free mobile charge carriers.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the mechanism of electrical conduction in molten ionic salts (mobile cations and anions) with that of metals (delocalized sea of electrons).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify the charge carrier by substance type
Conduction in metals occurs via delocalized electrons; conduction in molten or aqueous ionic compounds occurs via mobile ions (cations and anions).
Whenever you explain conduction in a molten salt, attribute current flow to the translation of positive and negative ions, never to free electrons.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState that is an ionic compound consisting of and ions.
Explain that thermal energy at overcomes the electrostatic forces holding the crystal lattice together.
Conclude that the freed cations and anions move toward opposite electrodes to carry the electric current.
Upon melting at , the rigid ionic crystal lattice breaks down, freeing and ions to migrate under an electric field.
Lock it in
What is the key difference between ionic 'dissociation' and covalent 'ionization'?
Dissociation separates pre-existing ions from an ionic lattice (e.g., ). Ionization creates new ions when neutral covalent molecules react chemically with water (e.g., ).
Similar question
Pure liquid ammonia () at has very low electrical conductivity, but adding a small amount of water slightly increases its conductivity. Explain this observation by identifying the bonding in pure liquid ammonia and the process occurring upon adding water.
Answer
Pure is a covalent molecular compound composed of neutral molecules, so it lacks mobile ions or delocalized electrons to conduct electricity. When water is added, a chemical ionization reaction occurs: . The resulting mobile ammonium and hydroxide ions allow the solution to conduct electricity.
Contrast the electrical conductivity of solid sodium hydroxide (), molten sodium hydroxide at , and solid sodium metal () at . Specify the charge carriers responsible for conduction in each case where conductivity is observed.
Answer
Solid is an ionic compound where and ions are locked in fixed lattice positions, so it does not conduct. Molten conducts because the ionic lattice is broken and and ions are free to move (charge carriers = mobile ions). Solid conducts electricity via metallic bonding with delocalized valence electrons moving through the cation lattice (charge carriers = mobile/delocalized electrons).
Consider three pure liquids: carbon tetrachloride (), hydrogen fluoride (), and molten potassium bromide (). (a) Predict which liquid will have high electrical conductivity and identify its charge carriers. (b) Explain why the remaining two liquids have negligible electrical conductivity, noting any differences in their intermolecular forces.
Answer
(a) Molten has high electrical conductivity because melting breaks the ionic lattice, releasing mobile and ions to carry current. (b) Pure liquid and pure liquid are both covalent molecular substances composed of neutral molecules with no mobile charge carriers. They differ in their intermolecular forces: nonpolar is held only by London dispersion forces, whereas polar is held by strong hydrogen bonds and dipole-dipole attractions, but neither liquid contains free ions.