Resources

Consider a sample of gas transitioning between two fixed states: State A (PA=4.00 atmP_A = 4.00\text{ atm}, VA=1.00 LV_A = 1.00\text{ L}, TA=300 KT_A = 300\text{ K}) and State B (PB=1.00 atmP_B = 1.00\text{ atm}, VB=4.00 LV_B = 4.00\text{ L}, TB=300 KT_B = 300\text{ K}). For an ideal gas, internal energy depends solely on temperature, meaning ΔUA→B=0\Delta U_{A \to B} = 0. Pathway 1 is a reversible isothermal expansion where the work is given by w1=−nRTln⁡(VBVA)=−PAVAln⁡(VBVA)w_1 = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_B}{V_A}\right) = -P_A V_A \ln\left(\frac{V_B}{V_A}\right). Pathway 2 is an irreversible single-stage expansion against a constant threshold boundary pressure equal to the final pressure, Pext=PB=1.00 atmP_{\text{ext}} = P_B = 1.00\text{ atm}. Calculate the difference in heat exchanged with the surroundings between these two pathways, Δq=q1−q2\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 (in J\text{J}), thereby demonstrating the boundary between reversible and irreversible path-dependent work. (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J})

Answer and steps

Final answer

Δq=+258 J\Delta q = +258\text{ J}

Steps

01

Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics

According to the First Law of Thermodynamics: ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w

Since the temperature is constant at 300 K300\text{ K} and the internal energy of an ideal gas depends solely on temperature: ΔUA→B=0\Delta U_{A \to B} = 0

Therefore, for any isothermal process between these two states: q=−wq = -w

This relationship allows us to determine the heat absorbed by calculating the work done along each path.


02

Calculate Work and Heat for Pathway 1 (Reversible Expansion)

For a reversible isothermal expansion, the external pressure matches the internal pressure at every instant: w1=−PAVAln⁡(VBVA)w_1 = -P_A V_A \ln\left(\frac{V_B}{V_A}\right)

Substitute the given values: w1=−(4.00 atm)(1.00 L)ln⁡(4.00 L1.00 L)=−4.00ln⁡(4) L⋅atmw_1 = -(4.00\text{ atm})(1.00\text{ L}) \ln\left(\frac{4.00\text{ L}}{1.00\text{ L}}\right) = -4.00 \ln(4)\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

Using ln⁡(4)≈1.3863\ln(4) \approx 1.3863: w1≈−4.00×1.3863=−5.545 L⋅atmw_1 \approx -4.00 \times 1.3863 = -5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

The heat absorbed in Pathway 1 is: q1=−w1=+5.545 L⋅atmq_1 = -w_1 = +5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}


03

Calculate Work and Heat for Pathway 2 (Irreversible Expansion)

For an irreversible expansion against a constant external pressure Pext=1.00 atmP_{\text{ext}} = 1.00\text{ atm}: w2=−PextΔV=−Pext(VB−VA)w_2 = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_B - V_A)

Substitute the given values: w2=−(1.00 atm)(4.00 L−1.00 L)=−3.00 L⋅atmw_2 = -(1.00\text{ atm})(4.00\text{ L} - 1.00\text{ L}) = -3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

The heat absorbed in Pathway 2 is: q2=−w2=+3.00 L⋅atmq_2 = -w_2 = +3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}


04

Find the Difference in Heat Exchanged (Δq\Delta q)

The difference in heat absorbed between the reversible and irreversible pathways is: Δq=q1−q2=5.545 L⋅atm−3.00 L⋅atm=2.545 L⋅atm\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = 5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} - 3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 2.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

Convert this difference from L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm} to Joules using the conversion factor 1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J}: Δq=2.545 L⋅atm×101.325JL⋅atm≈+258 J\Delta q = 2.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \times 101.325\frac{\text{J}}{\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}} \approx +258\text{ J}

Key Takeaway: While internal energy ΔU\Delta U is a state function (independent of the path, ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 for both), heat qq and work ww are path-dependent functions. The reversible pathway performs the maximum expansion work on the surroundings, requiring more heat input (+258 J+258\text{ J}) from the surroundings compared to the irreversible single-stage expansion.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the sign convention of the first law by assuming q = w instead of q = -w when ΔU = 0, resulting in negative heat values and an opposite sign for Δq.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔU=q−w=0, so q=w\Delta U = q - w = 0\text{, so } q = w

    Correct

    ΔU=q+w=0  ⟹  q=−w\Delta U = q + w = 0 \implies q = -w

    In standard chemistry sign convention, the First Law of Thermodynamics is written as ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w, where ww represents work done on the system (w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV). Because ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 for an isothermal process of an ideal gas, q=−wq = -w rather than q=wq = w.

  2. Step 2

    w1=−PA⋅VA⋅ln⁡(VB/VA)=−4.00⋅ln⁡(4)  ⟹  w1=−5.545 L⋅atmw_1 = -P_A \cdot V_A \cdot \ln(V_B/V_A) = -4.00 \cdot \ln(4) \implies w_1 = -5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

  3. Step 3

    q1=w1=−5.545×101.325 J=−561.9 Jq_1 = w_1 = -5.545 \times 101.325\text{ J} = -561.9\text{ J}

    Correct

    q1=−w1=−(−5.545 L⋅atm)×101.325JL⋅atm=+561.9 Jq_1 = -w_1 = -(-5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}) \times 101.325\frac{\text{J}}{\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}} = +561.9\text{ J}

    Your arithmetic and conversion factor are correct, but this step carries forward the incorrect sign relationship from Step 1.

  4. Step 4

    w2=−Pext⋅(VB−VA)=−1.00⋅(4.00−1.00)  ⟹  w2=−3.00 L⋅atmw_2 = -P_{\text{ext}} \cdot (V_B - V_A) = -1.00 \cdot (4.00 - 1.00) \implies w_2 = -3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

  5. Step 5

    q2=w2=−3.00×101.325 J=−304.0 Jq_2 = w_2 = -3.00 \times 101.325\text{ J} = -304.0\text{ J}

    Correct

    q2=−w2=−(−3.00 L⋅atm)×101.325JL⋅atm=+304.0 Jq_2 = -w_2 = -(-3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}) \times 101.325\frac{\text{J}}{\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}} = +304.0\text{ J}

    Your calculation is arithmetically sound, but the negative sign propagates from setting q=wq = w in Step 1.

  6. Step 6

    Δq=q1−q2=−561.9−(−304.0)=−257.9 J\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = -561.9 - (-304.0) = -257.9\text{ J}

    Correct

    Δq=q1−q2=561.9 J−304.0 J=+258 J\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = 561.9\text{ J} - 304.0\text{ J} = +258\text{ J}

    Your subtraction is computed correctly from your values, but the final sign is negative due to the earlier sign error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the integral formula for reversible isothermal work.

You accurately calculated irreversible constant-pressure expansion work.

You used the correct unit conversion factor between L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm} and Joules.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Thermodynamic Sign Convention Confusion

You accidentally paired the chemistry work formula w=−Pext ΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\,\Delta V with the physics First Law equation ΔU=q−w\Delta U = q - w, resulting in a double-negative error.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Mixing conventions between chemistry and physics: in chemistry, work is defined as energy transferred to the system (w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV), which requires the First Law to be ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w. When the gas expands, it does work on the surroundings (w<0w < 0), so the system must absorb heat from the surroundings (q>0q > 0) to keep its internal energy constant.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
First Law Sign Consistency
  • When using w=−Pext ΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\,\Delta V, the First Law is ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w.

  • Always pair w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV with ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w, so that when ΔU=0\Delta U = 0, q=−wq = -w.

Physical Reality Check for Expansion
  • An ideal gas expanding isothermally performs work on the surroundings and must absorb heat to maintain temperature.

  • Verify that during isothermal expansion, w<0w < 0 and q>0q > 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the standard First Law equation: ΔU=q+w=0  ⟹  q=−w\Delta U = q + w = 0 \implies q = -w.

  2. Substitute w1=−5.545 L⋅atmw_1 = -5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}: q1=−(−5.545 L⋅atm)=+5.545 L⋅atm=+561.9 Jq_1 = -(-5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}) = +5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = +561.9\text{ J}.

  3. Substitute w2=−3.00 L⋅atmw_2 = -3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}: q2=−(−3.00 L⋅atm)=+3.00 L⋅atm=+304.0 Jq_2 = -(-3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}) = +3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = +304.0\text{ J}.

  4. Calculate the difference: Δq=q1−q2=+561.9 J−(+304.0 J)=+258 J\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = +561.9\text{ J} - (+304.0\text{ J}) = +258\text{ J}.

Final answer

Δq=+258 J\Delta q = +258\text{ J}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the IUPAC convention for the First Law of Thermodynamics (ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w).

  • Perform a physical check on every isothermal expansion problem: if the gas expands, work is done by the system (w<0w < 0) and heat enters the system (q>0q > 0).

  • Practice isolating path functions (qq and ww) from state functions (ΔU\Delta U and ΔH\Delta H) to reinforce conceptual clarity.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly uses the initial pressure PA instead of the constant external opposing pressure Pext = PB when calculating work for the irreversible expansion.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔU=0 implies q=−w\Delta U = 0 \text{ implies } q = -w

  2. Step 2

    w1=−4.00∗1.00∗ln⁡(4.001.00)=−5.545 L⋅atm  ⟹  q1=−w1=5.545∗101.325 J=561.9 Jw_1 = -4.00 * 1.00 * \ln\left(\frac{4.00}{1.00}\right) = -5.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \implies q_1 = -w_1 = 5.545 * 101.325\text{ J} = 561.9\text{ J}

  3. Step 3

    w2=−PA∗(VB−VA)=−4.00∗(4.00−1.00)=−12.00 L⋅atmw_2 = -P_A * (V_B - V_A) = -4.00 * (4.00 - 1.00) = -12.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

    Correct

    w2=−Pext(VB−VA)=−(1.00 atm)(4.00 L−1.00 L)=−3.00 L⋅atmw_2 = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_B - V_A) = -(1.00\text{ atm})(4.00\text{ L} - 1.00\text{ L}) = -3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

    Expansion work against surroundings is defined by the external opposing pressure PextP_{\text{ext}}, which is given as PB=1.00 atmP_B = 1.00\text{ atm}, not the gas's initial pressure PAP_A.

  4. Step 4

    q2=−w2=12.00∗101.325 J=1215.9 Jq_2 = -w_2 = 12.00 * 101.325\text{ J} = 1215.9\text{ J}

    Correct

    q2=−w2=3.00 L⋅atm×101.325JL⋅atm=+304.0 Jq_2 = -w_2 = 3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \times 101.325\frac{\text{J}}{\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}} = +304.0\text{ J}

    Your conversion method is correct, but the value is affected by using the incorrect work w2w_2 from Step 3.

  5. Step 5

    Δq=q1−q2=561.9−1215.9=−654.0 J\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = 561.9 - 1215.9 = -654.0\text{ J}

    Correct

    Δq=q1−q2=561.9 J−304.0 J=+258 J\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = 561.9\text{ J} - 304.0\text{ J} = +258\text{ J}

    Your subtraction followed through from your earlier values, but the final numerical result is affected by the error in q2q_2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 for an isothermal process of an ideal gas, giving q=−wq = -w.

You correctly used the logarithmic formula to calculate reversible expansion work w1w_1.

You accurately converted units from L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm} to Joules.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong pressure in irreversible work calculation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted the gas's initial internal pressure PAP_A into the formula for irreversible expansion work instead of the constant external opposing pressure Pext=PBP_{\text{ext}} = P_B. Irreversible boundary work is determined strictly by the pressure opposing the system's boundary during expansion, w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Opposing Pressure Rule
  • wirrev=−PextΔVw_{\text{irrev}} = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V

  • Always identify the external opposing pressure PextP_{\text{ext}} applied by the surroundings rather than the internal pressure of the system.

Maximum Work Criterion
  • ∣wrev∣≥∣wirrev∣|w_{\text{rev}}| \ge |w_{\text{irrev}}|

  • Check your magnitudes: a reversible expansion always yields the maximum possible work done on the surroundings. If your irreversible expansion gives ∣w2∣>∣w1∣|w_2| > |w_1|, re-check your choice of pressure.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute Pext=PB=1.00 atmP_{\text{ext}} = P_B = 1.00\text{ atm} into the irreversible work formula: w2=−(1.00 atm)(4.00 L−1.00 L)=−3.00 L⋅atmw_2 = -(1.00\text{ atm})(4.00\text{ L} - 1.00\text{ L}) = -3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}.

  2. Compute the irreversible heat absorbed: q2=−w2=+3.00 L⋅atm=3.00×101.325 J≈304.0 Jq_2 = -w_2 = +3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 3.00 \times 101.325\text{ J} \approx 304.0\text{ J}.

  3. Subtract the two heat quantities: Δq=q1−q2=561.9 J−304.0 J=+257.9 J≈+258 J\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = 561.9\text{ J} - 304.0\text{ J} = +257.9\text{ J} \approx +258\text{ J}.

Final answer

Δq=+258 J\Delta q = +258\text{ J}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between internal gas pressure PintP_{\text{int}} and external surrounding pressure PextP_{\text{ext}} across different thermodynamic processes.

  • Always use the maximum work principle (∣wrev∣>∣wirrev∣|w_{\text{rev}}| > |w_{\text{irrev}}| for expansion) as a sanity check before calculating net heat.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the heat values correctly in units of L·atm but forgets to convert the final answer to Joules using the given conversion factor.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ΔU=q+w=0, so q=−w\Delta U = q + w = 0\text{, so } q = -w

  2. Step 2

    w1=−(4.00)(1.00)×ln⁡(4.001.00)=−4.00×ln⁡(4)≈−5.55 L⋅atm  ⟹  q1=5.55 L⋅atmw_1 = -(4.00)(1.00) \times \ln\left(\frac{4.00}{1.00}\right) = -4.00 \times \ln(4) \approx -5.55\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \implies q_1 = 5.55\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

  3. Step 3

    w2=−1.00×(4.00−1.00)=−3.00 L⋅atm  ⟹  q2=3.00 L⋅atmw_2 = -1.00 \times (4.00 - 1.00) = -3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \implies q_2 = 3.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

  4. Step 4

    Δq=q1−q2=5.55−3.00=2.55 L⋅atm\Delta q = q_1 - q_2 = 5.55 - 3.00 = 2.55\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

    Correct

    Δq=(q1−q2)×101.325 J/(L⋅atm)=2.545 L⋅atm×101.325 J/(L⋅atm)≈+258 J\Delta q = (q_1 - q_2) \times 101.325\text{ J}/(\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}) = 2.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \times 101.325\text{ J}/(\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}) \approx +258\text{ J}

    You calculated the numerical difference correctly in L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}, but you missed multiplying by the conversion factor 1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J} to report the final answer in Joules.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related heat and work using the First Law of Thermodynamics for an isothermal process.

You accurately evaluated the logarithmic expression for reversible work in Pathway 1.

You correctly used the constant external pressure formula for irreversible expansion in Pathway 2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted unit conversion

You stopped calculating once you found the difference in L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm} without checking the units specified in the question prompt.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated thermodynamic work calculations as complete upon finding PΔVP\Delta V quantities, overlooking that energy values derived from pressure-volume variables in imperial/standard atmospheric units must be scaled to SI units (Joules) for standard reporting.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Audit
  • 1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J}

  • Always circle the target unit in the prompt before starting, and perform dimensional analysis on the final line before boxing your answer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take your heat difference in liter-atmospheres: Δq=2.545 L⋅atm\Delta q = 2.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}.

  2. Multiply by the conversion factor: Δq=2.545 L⋅atm×101.325JL⋅atm=257.87 J\Delta q = 2.545\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \times 101.325\frac{\text{J}}{\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}} = 257.87\text{ J}.

Final answer

Δq=+258 J\Delta q = +258\text{ J}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review target units requested in thermodynamics problems before writing the final boxed answer.

  • Practice converting pressure-volume work quantities between L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm} and J\text{J} routinely.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} of an ideal gas expands isothermally at 298 K298\text{ K} from 2.00 L2.00\text{ L} to 6.00 L6.00\text{ L} against a constant external pressure of 1.50 atm1.50\text{ atm}. Calculate ww and qq for this process in Joules (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J}).

Answer

w=−608 Jw = -608\text{ J}, q=+608 Jq = +608\text{ J}. Work is w=−PextΔV=−(1.50 atm)(6.00−2.00 L)=−6.00 L⋅atm=−607.95 Jw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V = -(1.50\text{ atm})(6.00 - 2.00\text{ L}) = -6.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = -607.95\text{ J}. Since ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 for an isothermal ideal gas expansion, q=−w=+608 Jq = -w = +608\text{ J}.

02

An ideal gas undergoes a two-step isothermal expansion at 300 K300\text{ K} from (4.00 atm,1.00 L)(4.00\text{ atm}, 1.00\text{ L}) to (1.00 atm,4.00 L)(1.00\text{ atm}, 4.00\text{ L}). Step A expands against Pext=2.00 atmP_{\text{ext}} = 2.00\text{ atm} until V=2.00 LV = 2.00\text{ L}. Step B expands against Pext=1.00 atmP_{\text{ext}} = 1.00\text{ atm} until V=4.00 LV = 4.00\text{ L}. Calculate the total heat absorbed qtwo-stepq_{\text{two-step}} in Joules, and compare it to the single-stage expansion heat q2=+304 Jq_2 = +304\text{ J}.

Answer

qtwo-step=+405 Jq_{\text{two-step}} = +405\text{ J}, which is 101 J101\text{ J} greater than the single-stage expansion. Work done is w=−[2.00(2.00−1.00)+1.00(4.00−2.00)]=−(2.00+2.00)=−4.00 L⋅atm=−405.3 Jw = -[2.00(2.00 - 1.00) + 1.00(4.00 - 2.00)] = -(2.00 + 2.00) = -4.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = -405.3\text{ J}. Since ΔU=0\Delta U = 0, q=−w=+405 Jq = -w = +405\text{ J}.

03

Show mathematically that for any isothermal expansion of an ideal gas from VAV_A to VBV_B (VB>VAV_B > V_A), the heat absorbed along a reversible path (qrevq_{\text{rev}}) is strictly greater than the heat absorbed along a single-stage constant external pressure path (qirrevq_{\text{irrev}} where Pext=PBP_{\text{ext}} = P_B).

Answer

qrev−qirrev>0q_{\text{rev}} - q_{\text{irrev}} > 0. Since ΔU=0\Delta U = 0, q=−wq = -w. Reversible heat is qrev=nRTln⁡(VB/VA)q_{\text{rev}} = nRT\ln(V_B/V_A). Single-stage irreversible heat is qirrev=PB(VB−VA)=nRT(1−VA/VB)q_{\text{irrev}} = P_B(V_B - V_A) = nRT(1 - V_A/V_B). Letting x=VB/VA>1x = V_B/V_A > 1, the difference is nRT(ln⁡x−1+1/x)nRT(\ln x - 1 + 1/x). For all x>1x > 1, the function f(x)=ln⁡x−1+1/x>0f(x) = \ln x - 1 + 1/x > 0 because f(1)=0f(1) = 0 and f′(x)=1/x−1/x2=(x−1)/x2>0f'(x) = 1/x - 1/x^2 = (x - 1)/x^2 > 0. Thus, qrev>qirrevq_{\text{rev}} > q_{\text{irrev}}.

Loading workspace…