Resources

A standard fission process of 92235U^{235}_{92}\text{U} releases approximately 200.0 MeV200.0\,\text{MeV} per fission event across its 236236 total nucleons, whereas the fusion reaction 12H+13H→24He+01n^{2}_{1}\text{H} + ^{3}_{1}\text{H} \rightarrow ^{4}_{2}\text{He} + ^{1}_{0}\text{n} releases 17.59 MeV17.59\,\text{MeV} per reaction event across its 55 reacting nucleons. Rather than comparing total energy per single reaction event, determine the ratio of the energy yield per unit mass of fusion fuel to the energy yield per unit mass of fission fuel: Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}}. Express this dimensionless ratio to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.15\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.15

Steps

01

Calculate the specific energy for nuclear fission

To compare the efficiency of nuclear fuels, we calculate their specific energy (the energy released per unit mass). Because the mass of an atomic nucleus is directly proportional to its total number of nucleons (protons and neutrons), the energy yield per unit mass is proportional to the energy released per nucleon.

In the given fission reaction, 200.0 MeV200.0\text{ MeV} of energy is generated by a system involving a total of 236236 nucleons (235U^{235}\text{U} plus the incident neutron):

Energy per nucleonfission=200.0 MeV236 nucleons≈0.8475 MeV/nucleon\text{Energy per nucleon}_{\text{fission}} = \frac{200.0\text{ MeV}}{236\text{ nucleons}} \approx 0.8475\text{ MeV/nucleon}

02

Calculate the specific energy for nuclear fusion

In the deuterium-tritium (X12X2122H+X13X2123H\ce{^{2}_{1}H} + \ce{^{3}_{1}H}) fusion reaction, 17.59 MeV17.59\text{ MeV} of energy is generated across a total of 55 nucleons (2+3=52 + 3 = 5 nucleons):

Energy per nucleonfusion=17.59 MeV5 nucleons=3.518 MeV/nucleon\text{Energy per nucleon}_{\text{fusion}} = \frac{17.59\text{ MeV}}{5\text{ nucleons}} = 3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}

03

Compute the ratio of specific energies

Divide the specific energy of fusion by the specific energy of fission:

Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=17.59 MeV5 nucleons200.0 MeV236 nucleons\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{\frac{17.59\text{ MeV}}{5\text{ nucleons}}}{\frac{200.0\text{ MeV}}{236\text{ nucleons}}}

Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=3.5180.847458≈4.1512\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{3.518}{0.847458} \approx 4.1512

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.15\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.15

Common Pitfall: Do not simply compare the raw energy output per single event (200.0 MeV200.0\text{ MeV} vs. 17.59 MeV17.59\text{ MeV}). Although a single fission event releases over 1111 times more energy than a single fusion event, uranium nuclei are much heavier. Per unit mass (or per nucleon), fusion yields more than 44 times as much energy as fission.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student directly divides the total energy released per single reaction event without dividing by the reacting mass or number of nucleons.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Specific Energyfusion/Specific Energyfission=17.59 MeV/200.0 MeV\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}} / \text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}} = 17.59\text{ MeV} / 200.0\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=17.59 MeV/5 nucleons200.0 MeV/236 nucleons\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{17.59\text{ MeV} / 5\text{ nucleons}}{200.0\text{ MeV} / 236\text{ nucleons}}

    You divided the total energy per fusion event by the total energy per fission event directly. Specific energy measures energy per unit mass (or energy per nucleon), so you need to divide each reaction energy by its total number of reacting nucleons first.

  2. Step 2

    =0.0880= 0.0880

    Correct

    =3.518 MeV/nucleon0.8475 MeV/nucleon≈4.15= \frac{3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}}{0.8475\text{ MeV/nucleon}} \approx 4.15

    Your arithmetic correctly evaluated 17.59/200.017.59 / 200.0, but the value comes from the omitted nucleon counts in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly placed the fusion term in the numerator and the fission term in the denominator.

You rounded your computed quotient accurately to three significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating total event energy with specific energy

You treated the total energy released per event as if it were already specific energy.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked that 'specific energy' means energy released per unit mass. Because atomic mass is directly proportional to nucleon count, you must normalize the energy by the reacting nucleons (55 for fusion, 236236 for fission) before comparing them.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the definition of specific energy
  • Specific Energy=Total Energy ReleasedMass of Reactants∝Total Energy ReleasedNumber of Nucleons\text{Specific Energy} = \frac{\text{Total Energy Released}}{\text{Mass of Reactants}} \propto \frac{\text{Total Energy Released}}{\text{Number of Nucleons}}

  • Always divide the energy released in an individual reaction by the total number of reacting nucleons before forming a specific-energy ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate specific energy (per nucleon) for fusion: 17.59 MeV5 nucleons=3.518 MeV/nucleon\frac{17.59\text{ MeV}}{5\text{ nucleons}} = 3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

  2. Calculate specific energy (per nucleon) for fission: 200.0 MeV236 nucleons≈0.84746 MeV/nucleon\frac{200.0\text{ MeV}}{236\text{ nucleons}} \approx 0.84746\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

  3. Take the ratio of the two specific energies: 3.5180.84746≈4.1512\frac{3.518}{0.84746} \approx 4.1512.

Final answer

Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.15\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.15

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between 'energy per event' and 'specific energy (energy per mass)'.

  • Practice identifying the total number of reacting nucleons on both sides of a nuclear equation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the requested ratio and calculates the specific energy of fission fuel relative to fusion fuel instead.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Energy per nucleon (fusion)=17.595=3.518 MeV/nucleon\text{Energy per nucleon (fusion)} = \frac{17.59}{5} = 3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}

  2. Step 2

    Energy per nucleon (fission)=200.0236=0.8475 MeV/nucleon\text{Energy per nucleon (fission)} = \frac{200.0}{236} = 0.8475\text{ MeV/nucleon}

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=0.84753.518=0.241\text{Ratio} = \frac{0.8475}{3.518} = 0.241

    Correct

    Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=3.518 MeV/nucleon0.8475 MeV/nucleon≈4.15\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}}{0.8475\text{ MeV/nucleon}} \approx 4.15

    The prompt asked for Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}}, with fusion in the numerator and fission in the denominator. You calculated fissionfusion\frac{\text{fission}}{\text{fusion}} instead.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that specific energy (energy per unit mass) is proportional to energy released per nucleon.

You correctly calculated the energy yield per nucleon for the deuterium-tritium fusion reaction.

You correctly calculated the energy yield per nucleon for the uranium-235 fission reaction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted ratio comparison

You set up the ratio upside down as fissionfusion\frac{\text{fission}}{\text{fusion}} rather than the requested fusionfission\frac{\text{fusion}}{\text{fission}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the exact order specified in 'ratio of A to B' formulations (extratioofA to B=AB ext{ratio of } A \text{ to } B = \frac{A}{B}), leading to an inverted fraction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verifying Ratio Order
  • The phrase 'ratio of AA to BB' mathematically defines AB\frac{A}{B}.

  • Always write out the symbolic formula quantity1quantity2\frac{\text{quantity}_1}{\text{quantity}_2} with explicit labels before substituting numerical values.

Physical Reality Check
  • Nuclear fusion yields significantly higher energy per unit mass (per nucleon) than nuclear fission.

  • Check if your calculated ratio fusionfission\frac{\text{fusion}}{\text{fission}} is greater than 11. If it is less than 11, the fraction is inverted.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the requested ratio format: Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}}.

  2. Substitute the calculated values: 3.518 MeV/nucleon0.847458 MeV/nucleon≈4.1512\frac{3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}}{0.847458\text{ MeV/nucleon}} \approx 4.1512.

  3. Round to three significant figures: 4.154.15.

Final answer

Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.15\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.15

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the requested algebraic ratio with labels before substituting numbers.

  • Perform a conceptual check on comparisons between fusion and fission specific energies (fusion is always higher per unit mass).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses the mass number of uranium-235 (235 nucleons) instead of the total reacting nucleons in the compound nucleus (236 nucleons) for the fission process.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Specific energy (fusion)=3.518 MeV/nucleon\text{Specific energy (fusion)} = 3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}

  2. Step 2

    Specific energy (fission)=200.0235=0.8511 MeV/nucleon\text{Specific energy (fission)} = \frac{200.0}{235} = 0.8511\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    Correct

    Specific energy (fission)=200.0 MeV236 nucleons≈0.8475 MeV/nucleon\text{Specific energy (fission)} = \frac{200.0\text{ MeV}}{236\text{ nucleons}} \approx 0.8475\text{ MeV/nucleon}

    You used 235235 nucleons from 235U^{235}\text{U} alone instead of the total 236236 reacting nucleons specified in the problem statement, which includes the incident neutron forming the compound nucleus 236U∗^{236}\text{U}^*.

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=3.5180.8511=4.13\text{Ratio} = \frac{3.518}{0.8511} = 4.13

    Correct

    Ratio=3.5180.847458≈4.15\text{Ratio} = \frac{3.518}{0.847458} \approx 4.15

    Your division method and rounding were carried out accurately, but the result was altered by using 0.8511 MeV/nucleon0.8511\text{ MeV/nucleon} from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that specific energy is proportional to energy released per nucleon.

You accurately calculated the specific energy for the fusion reaction as 3.518 MeV/nucleon3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

You set up the ratio of specific energies correctly and rounded properly to three significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of incident nucleon in total reacting mass

You divided by 235235 instead of 236236 nucleons when calculating the specific energy of fission.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You focused on the mass number of isolated uranium-235 (A=235A = 235) rather than counting all nucleons entering the reaction, overlooking the incident thermal neutron that initiates fission (235+1=236235 + 1 = 236).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Total Reacting Nucleons
  • In induced nuclear reactions, specific energy must account for all reacting particles on the reactant side: Atotal=∑AreactantsA_{\text{total}} = \sum A_{\text{reactants}}.

  • Check whether the reaction requires an incident particle (such as a neutron), and use the total nucleon count of the initiating system rather than just the target nucleus.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate the fission specific energy using the total reacting nucleons: Specific Energyfission=200.0 MeV236 nucleons≈0.84746 MeV/nucleon\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}} = \frac{200.0\text{ MeV}}{236\text{ nucleons}} \approx 0.84746\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

  2. Divide the fusion specific energy by the corrected fission specific energy: Ratio=3.518 MeV/nucleon0.84746 MeV/nucleon≈4.1512\text{Ratio} = \frac{3.518\text{ MeV/nucleon}}{0.84746\text{ MeV/nucleon}} \approx 4.1512.

  3. Round the resulting dimensionless ratio to three significant figures.

Final answer

Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.15\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.15

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always tally the mass numbers of all reactants before dividing total QQ-value by mass or nucleon count.

  • Verify whether a fission reaction is spontaneous (A=AnucleusA = A_{\text{nucleus}}) or neutron-induced (A=Anucleus+1A = A_{\text{nucleus}} + 1).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A deuterium-deuterium (D-D) fusion branch releases 3.27 MeV3.27\text{ MeV} across 44 reacting nucleons (12H+12H→23He+01n^{2}_{1}\text{H} + ^{2}_{1}\text{H} \rightarrow ^{3}_{2}\text{He} + ^{1}_{0}\text{n}). Calculate its specific energy in MeV/nucleon\text{MeV/nucleon} to three significant figures.

Answer

0.818 MeV/nucleon0.818\text{ MeV/nucleon}. Divide 3.27 MeV3.27\text{ MeV} by 4 nucleons4\text{ nucleons} to get 0.8175 MeV/nucleon0.8175\text{ MeV/nucleon}, which rounds to 0.818 MeV/nucleon0.818\text{ MeV/nucleon}.

02

Compare the specific energy of the D-D fusion branch from the previous question (0.8175 MeV/nucleon0.8175\text{ MeV/nucleon}) to a fission process yielding 0.8475 MeV/nucleon0.8475\text{ MeV/nucleon}. Determine the ratio Specific EnergyD-D fusionSpecific Energyfission\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{D-D fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} to three significant figures.

Answer

0.9650.965. Divide the two specific energies: 0.8175 MeV/nucleon0.8475 MeV/nucleon≈0.9646\frac{0.8175\text{ MeV/nucleon}}{0.8475\text{ MeV/nucleon}} \approx 0.9646, which rounds to 0.9650.965.

03

Suppose reaction A releases 28.3 MeV28.3\text{ MeV} involving 44 nucleons, and reaction B releases 180.0 MeV180.0\text{ MeV} involving 240240 nucleons. Determine which reaction has the higher specific energy and find the ratio of Reaction A's specific energy to Reaction B's specific energy to three significant figures.

Answer

Reaction A has the higher specific energy, with a ratio of 9.439.43. Reaction A yields 28.3 MeV4 nucleons=7.075 MeV/nucleon\frac{28.3\text{ MeV}}{4\text{ nucleons}} = 7.075\text{ MeV/nucleon}. Reaction B yields 180.0 MeV240 nucleons=0.750 MeV/nucleon\frac{180.0\text{ MeV}}{240\text{ nucleons}} = 0.750\text{ MeV/nucleon}. The ratio is 7.0750.750≈9.43\frac{7.075}{0.750} \approx 9.43.

Loading workspace…