Resources

Consider two identical sealed, rigid 1.00 L1.00\text{ L} flasks at 25.0∘C25.0^\circ\text{C} and 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}. Flask A contains pure helium gas (He\text{He}, atomic mass =4.003 g/mol= 4.003\text{ g/mol}), while Flask B contains pure sulfur hexafluoride gas (SF6\text{SF}_6, molar mass =146.06 g/mol= 146.06\text{ g/mol}). Counter to a common misconception that heavier gas molecules take up more volume and thus have fewer particles under identical conditions: (a) compare the total number of gas molecules present in Flask A versus Flask B, and (b) calculate the ratio of the total number of individual atoms in Flask B to Flask A, as well as the ratio of the total mass of Flask B's gas to Flask A's gas.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Flask A and Flask B contain the exact same number of gas molecules: 2.46×1022 molecules2.46 \times 10^{22}\text{ molecules}, (b) Atom ratio (Flask B/Flask A)=7.00\text{Atom ratio } (\text{Flask B}/\text{Flask A}) = 7.00, Mass ratio (Flask B/Flask A)=36.5\text{Mass ratio } (\text{Flask B}/\text{Flask A}) = 36.5

Steps

Part (a): Total Number of Gas Molecules

  1. Apply Avogadro's Law and the Ideal Gas Law
    Avogadro's Law states that equal volumes of all gases at the same temperature and pressure contain an equal number of particles (molecules). Under the ideal gas equation: PV=nRT  ⟹  n=PVRTPV = nRT \implies n = \frac{PV}{RT} Because both flasks share identical pressure (P=1.00 atmP = 1.00\text{ atm}), volume (V=1.00 LV = 1.00\text{ L}), and absolute temperature (T=25.0+273.15=298.15 KT = 25.0 + 273.15 = 298.15\text{ K}), both flasks must contain the exact same number of moles of gas, regardless of the chemical identity or size of the gas molecules.
  2. Calculate the Number of Moles (nn)
    Using the ideal gas constant R=0.08206 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K)R = 0.08206\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}): n=(1.00 atm)(1.00 L)(0.08206 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K))(298.15 K)≈0.04087 moln = \frac{(1.00\text{ atm})(1.00\text{ L})}{(0.08206\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298.15\text{ K})} \approx 0.04087\text{ mol}
  3. Convert Moles to Molecules
    Multiply the number of moles by Avogadro's number (NA=6.022×1023 molecules/molN_{\text{A}} = 6.022 \times 10^{23}\text{ molecules/mol}): N=n⋅NA=(0.04087 mol)(6.022×1023 molecules/mol)≈2.46×1022 moleculesN = n \cdot N_{\text{A}} = (0.04087\text{ mol})(6.022 \times 10^{23}\text{ molecules/mol}) \approx 2.46 \times 10^{22}\text{ molecules}

    Key Takeaway and Common Pitfall: Although SFX6\ce{SF6} molecules are physically much larger and heavier than He\ce{He} atoms, the actual volume of the gas particles themselves is negligible compared to the vast empty space between them. Therefore, Flask A and Flask B contain the exact same number of gas molecules: 2.46×1022 molecules2.46 \times 10^{22}\text{ molecules}.


Part (b): Ratio of Total Atoms and Total Mass

  1. Atom Ratio (Flask B/Flask A\text{Flask B}/\text{Flask A})

    • Flask A contains monatomic helium (He\ce{He}), meaning each gas particle is 11 atom: Atoms per particle in Flask A=1\text{Atoms per particle in Flask A} = 1
    • Flask B contains sulfur hexafluoride (SFX6\ce{SF6}), where each molecule consists of 11 sulfur atom and 66 fluorine atoms: Atoms per molecule in Flask B=1+6=7\text{Atoms per molecule in Flask B} = 1 + 6 = 7

    Because both flasks contain an identical total number of gas molecules (NN): Atom ratio (Flask BFlask A)=7⋅N1⋅N=7.00\text{Atom ratio } \left(\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}\right) = \frac{7 \cdot N}{1 \cdot N} = 7.00

  2. Mass Ratio (Flask B/Flask A\text{Flask B}/\text{Flask A})
    The total mass of a gas is given by m=n⋅Mm = n \cdot M, where MM is the molar mass. Since the number of moles nn is identical in both flasks: Mass ratio (Flask BFlask A)=n⋅MSFX6n⋅MHe=MSFX6MHe\text{Mass ratio } \left(\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}\right) = \frac{n \cdot M_{\ce{SF6}}}{n \cdot M_{\ce{He}}} = \frac{M_{\ce{SF6}}}{M_{\ce{He}}}

    Substitute the given molar masses: Mass ratio=146.06 g/mol4.003 g/mol≈36.488≈36.5\text{Mass ratio} = \frac{146.06\text{ g/mol}}{4.003\text{ g/mol}} \approx 36.488 \approx 36.5

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly treats SF₆ as containing 6 atoms rather than 7 atoms by counting only the fluorine atoms and omitting sulfur.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    PV=nRT  ⟹  nA=nB because P,V,T are identical  ⟹  Number of molecules in Flask A=number of molecules in Flask BPV = nRT \implies n_A = n_B\text{ because } P, V, T\text{ are identical} \implies \text{Number of molecules in Flask A} = \text{number of molecules in Flask B}

  2. Step 2

    Atoms per molecule: He has \text{Atoms per molecule: He has } 1 atom, \text{ atom, } \ce{SF6}$$\text{ has } 6 atoms\text{ atoms}   ⟹  \implies Ratio of atoms (B to A)\text{Ratio of atoms (B to A)} = 61\frac{6}{1} = 6$$

    Correct

    Atoms per molecule: He has \text{Atoms per molecule: He has } 1 atom, \text{ atom, } \ce{SF6}$$\text{ has } 1 + 6 = 7 atoms\text{ atoms}   ⟹  \implies Ratio of atoms (B to A)\text{Ratio of atoms (B to A)} = 71\frac{7}{1} = 7.00$$

    You counted only the 66 fluorine atoms in SFX6\ce{SF6}. The chemical formula SFX6\ce{SF6} has an implicit subscript of 11 on sulfur, giving 1+6=71 + 6 = 7 total atoms per molecule.

  3. Step 3

    Mass ratio (B to A)\text{Mass ratio (B to A)} = 36.49

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the ideal gas relationship to deduce that both flasks contain the same number of moles and molecules.

You correctly identified helium as a monatomic gas with 11 atom per particle.

You correctly calculated the ratio of total gas mass using the respective molar masses.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of implicit subscript in molecular formula

You took the subscript 66 on fluorine as the total atom count for SFX6\ce{SF6}, forgetting to include the single sulfur atom.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking that an element symbol written without an explicit numeric subscript represents exactly one atom rather than zero atoms.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Count all constituent atoms
  • Every element symbol in a chemical formula without a subscript has an implicit subscript of 11.

  • Sum the explicit subscripts plus 11 for each unscripted element: for AXx B\ce{A_x B}, the atom count is x+1x + 1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify all elements in SFX6\ce{SF6}: 11 sulfur atom and 66 fluorine atoms.

  2. Sum the atoms per molecule: 1+6=7 atoms/molecule1 + 6 = 7\text{ atoms/molecule}.

  3. Compute the atom ratio: 7 atoms in B1 atom in A=7.00\frac{7\text{ atoms in B}}{1\text{ atom in A}} = 7.00.

Final answer

(a) Flask A and Flask B have the same number of molecules (2.46×10222.46 \times 10^{22}), (b) Atom ratio =7.00= 7.00, Mass ratio =36.5= 36.5 (or 36.4936.49)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice breaking down chemical formulas into individual element counts before calculating atom ratios.

  • Remember that an unwritten subscript means 11, never 00.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes that heavier gas molecules occupy more volume per mole, concluding that Flask B has fewer molecules than Flask A.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    SFX6 molecules are much larger and heavier than He atoms  ⟹  Larger molecules take up more space in 1.00 L  ⟹  Flask A contains more gas molecules than Flask B\ce{SF6}\text{ molecules are much larger and heavier than }\ce{He}\text{ atoms} \implies \text{Larger molecules take up more space in } 1.00\text{ L} \implies \text{Flask A contains more gas molecules than Flask B}

    Correct

    Flask A and Flask B contain the exact same number of gas molecules: n=PVRT≈0.0409 mol  ⟹  N=2.46×1022 molecules\text{Flask A and Flask B contain the exact same number of gas molecules: } n = \frac{PV}{RT} \approx 0.0409\text{ mol} \implies N = 2.46 \times 10^{22}\text{ molecules}

    You treated gas molecules as if their physical particle size determines the volume of the gas. Under the ideal gas law (PV=nRTPV = nRT) and Avogadro's law, equal volumes of gases at identical temperature and pressure contain the exact same number of moles and molecules, because the volume of the particles themselves is negligible compared to the distance between them.

  2. Step 2

    Ratio of atoms cannot be determined without molecule numbers\text{Ratio of atoms cannot be determined without molecule numbers}

    Correct

    Atom ratio (Flask BFlask A)=7⋅N1⋅N=7.00\text{Atom ratio } \left(\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}\right) = \frac{7 \cdot N}{1 \cdot N} = 7.00

    Because Part (a) led you to believe the flasks had different, unknown numbers of molecules, you concluded the atom ratio was indeterminate. Since both flasks actually contain the same number of molecules NN, the ratio depends purely on the chemical formula: 7 atoms per SFX67\text{ atoms per }\ce{SF6} molecule versus 1 atom per He1\text{ atom per }\ce{He} atom, giving a ratio of 7.007.00.

  3. Step 3

    Mass ratio (B to A)=146.064.003=36.49\text{Mass ratio (B to A)} = \frac{146.06}{4.003} = 36.49

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the molar masses of both substances and set up the mass ratio as the quotient of their molar masses.

You performed the mass ratio arithmetic accurately to obtain 36.4936.49.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Avogadro's hypothesis violation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated individual molecular size with macroscopic gas volume, overlooking Avogadro's law which states that gas volume at fixed temperature and pressure depends solely on the number of particles, not on particle size or mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Avogadro's Law
  • Equal volumes of ideal gases at the same temperature and pressure contain equal numbers of particles (V∝nV \propto n).

  • Whenever two gases share the same PP, VV, and TT, immediately set their mole counts and molecule counts equal before looking at particle size or mass.

Atoms per Molecule vs. Molecules
  • Total atoms equal (molecules)×(atoms per molecule)(\text{molecules}) \times (\text{atoms per molecule}).

  • Count the subscripts in each chemical formula (e.g., 11 for He\ce{He}, 1+6=71 + 6 = 7 for SFX6\ce{SF6}) to compare atom counts whenever molecule counts are identical.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the ideal gas law: n=PVRT=(1.00 atm)(1.00 L)(0.08206 L⋅atm/(mol⋅K))(298.15 K)=0.04087 moln = \frac{PV}{RT} = \frac{(1.00\text{ atm})(1.00\text{ L})}{(0.08206\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}/(\text{mol}\cdot\text{K}))(298.15\text{ K})} = 0.04087\text{ mol}.

  2. Convert moles to molecules using Avogadro's number: N=(0.04087 mol)(6.022×1023 molecules/mol)=2.46×1022 moleculesN = (0.04087\text{ mol})(6.022 \times 10^{23}\text{ molecules/mol}) = 2.46 \times 10^{22}\text{ molecules}. Both flasks have the same number of molecules.

  3. Calculate the atom ratio: each SFX6\ce{SF6} has 7 atoms7\text{ atoms} and each He\ce{He} has 1 atom1\text{ atom}, so the ratio is 7×2.46×10221×2.46×1022=7.00\frac{7 \times 2.46 \times 10^{22}}{1 \times 2.46 \times 10^{22}} = 7.00.

Final answer

(a) Flask A and Flask B contain the exact same number of gas molecules: 2.46×1022 molecules2.46 \times 10^{22}\text{ molecules}; (b) Atom ratio=7.00\text{Atom ratio} = 7.00, Mass ratio=36.5\text{Mass ratio} = 36.5

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the kinetic molecular theory assumption that real particle volume is negligible compared to total gas volume under standard conditions.

  • Practice distinguishing between total gas molecules (determined by PV=nRTPV = nRT) and total individual atoms (determined by chemical stoichiometry).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the mass ratio or atomic ratio by calculating Flask A to Flask B instead of Flask B to Flask A.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Both flasks have identical P,V, and T, so nA=nB  ⟹  Molecules in Flask A=Molecules in Flask B\text{Both flasks have identical } P, V, \text{ and } T, \text{ so } n_A = n_B \implies \text{Molecules in Flask A} = \text{Molecules in Flask B}

  2. Step 2

    He has 1 atom/molecule,SFX6 has 7 atoms/molecule  ⟹  Ratio of atoms=17=0.143\text{He has } 1\text{ atom/molecule}, \ce{SF6}\text{ has } 7\text{ atoms/molecule} \implies \text{Ratio of atoms} = \frac{1}{7} = 0.143

    Correct

    Atom ratio (Flask BFlask A)=71=7.00\text{Atom ratio } \left(\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}\right) = \frac{7}{1} = 7.00

    You correctly determined the number of atoms per particle for each gas, but you divided Flask A by Flask B. The question asked for the ratio of Flask B to Flask A, which is 71=7.00\frac{7}{1} = 7.00.

  3. Step 3

    Mass ratio=4.003146.06=0.0274\text{Mass ratio} = \frac{4.003}{146.06} = 0.0274

    Correct

    Mass ratio (Flask BFlask A)=146.06 g/mol4.003 g/mol≈36.5\text{Mass ratio } \left(\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}\right) = \frac{146.06\text{ g/mol}}{4.003\text{ g/mol}} \approx 36.5

    You correctly used the molar masses of the two gases, but you inverted the fraction by calculating Flask AFlask B\frac{\text{Flask A}}{\text{Flask B}} instead of Flask BFlask A\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Avogadro's law to conclude that identical conditions yield equal numbers of gas molecules.

You correctly counted 1 atom1\text{ atom} per He\ce{He} particle and 7 atoms7\text{ atoms} per SFX6\ce{SF6} molecule.

You correctly identified that the mass ratio simplifies to the ratio of their molar masses because the mole amounts are equal.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted comparison ratio

You inverted the numerator and denominator in part (b), evaluating Flask AFlask B\frac{\text{Flask A}}{\text{Flask B}} rather than Flask BFlask A\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misreading the directional phrasing 'ratio of X to Y', which always corresponds to XY\frac{X}{Y}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Translate 'Ratio of X to Y'
  • The mathematical translation of 'the ratio of quantity XX to quantity YY' is always XY\frac{X}{Y}, with XX in the numerator and YY in the denominator.

  • Before writing numbers, write out the explicit word fraction, such as Flask BFlask A\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the target ratio with explicit labels: Atom ratio=Atoms in Flask BAtoms in Flask A=71=7.00\text{Atom ratio} = \frac{\text{Atoms in Flask B}}{\text{Atoms in Flask A}} = \frac{7}{1} = 7.00.

  2. Write the target mass ratio with explicit labels: Mass ratio=Mass of Flask BMass of Flask A=MSFX6MHe=146.06 g/mol4.003 g/mol≈36.5\text{Mass ratio} = \frac{\text{Mass of Flask B}}{\text{Mass of Flask A}} = \frac{M_{\ce{SF6}}}{M_{\ce{He}}} = \frac{146.06\text{ g/mol}}{4.003\text{ g/mol}} \approx 36.5.

Final answer

(a) Both flasks contain the exact same number of gas molecules (2.46×1022 molecules2.46 \times 10^{22}\text{ molecules}). (b) Atom ratio (Flask B/Flask A)=7.00\text{Atom ratio } (\text{Flask B}/\text{Flask A}) = 7.00, Mass ratio (Flask B/Flask A)=36.5\text{Mass ratio } (\text{Flask B}/\text{Flask A}) = 36.5.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write an explicit labeled fraction like Flask BFlask A\frac{\text{Flask B}}{\text{Flask A}} before plugging in values to prevent accidental inversion.

  • Reread the question statement to verify whether the prompt asked for 'B to A' or 'A to B'.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two identical 2.00 L2.00\text{ L} containers at the same temperature and pressure contain neon gas (Ne\ce{Ne}) and carbon tetrachloride vapor (CClX4\ce{CCl4}), respectively. What is the ratio of total atoms in the CClX4\ce{CCl4} container to total atoms in the Ne\ce{Ne} container?

Answer

Ratio =5.00= 5.00. By Avogadro's law, equal volumes contain equal numbers of molecules (NN). Neon is monatomic (11 atom/molecule), and CClX4\ce{CCl4} contains 1 C+4 Cl=51\text{ C} + 4\text{ Cl} = 5 atoms/molecule. Therefore, the ratio of total atoms is 5N1N=5.00\frac{5N}{1N} = 5.00.

02

A sample contains 0.50 mol0.50\text{ mol} of phosphorus trichloride (PClX3\ce{PCl3}) and another sample contains 0.40 mol0.40\text{ mol} of dinitrogen tetroxide (NX2OX4\ce{N2O4}). Which sample contains more total atoms, and how many moles of atoms does each have?

Answer

NX2OX4\ce{N2O4} contains more atoms (2.4 mol2.4\text{ mol} vs. 2.0 mol2.0\text{ mol}). Each PClX3\ce{PCl3} molecule has 1+3=41 + 3 = 4 atoms, so 0.50 mol×4=2.0 mol0.50\text{ mol} \times 4 = 2.0\text{ mol} of atoms. Each NX2OX4\ce{N2O4} molecule has 2+4=62 + 4 = 6 atoms, so 0.40 mol×6=2.4 mol0.40\text{ mol} \times 6 = 2.4\text{ mol} of atoms.

03

Flask 1 contains 1.00 g1.00\text{ g} of methane gas (CHX4\ce{CH4}, molar mass =16.04 g/mol= 16.04\text{ g/mol}), and Flask 2 contains 1.00 g1.00\text{ g} of ammonia gas (NHX3\ce{NH3}, molar mass =17.03 g/mol= 17.03\text{ g/mol}). Calculate the ratio of the total number of atoms in Flask 1 to Flask 2.

Answer

Ratio ≈1.33\approx 1.33. Moles of CHX4=1.0016.04≈0.06234 mol\ce{CH4} = \frac{1.00}{16.04} \approx 0.06234\text{ mol}; each molecule has 1+4=51 + 4 = 5 atoms, yielding 0.06234×5≈0.3117 mol0.06234 \times 5 \approx 0.3117\text{ mol} of atoms. Moles of NHX3=1.0017.03≈0.05872 mol\ce{NH3} = \frac{1.00}{17.03} \approx 0.05872\text{ mol}; each molecule has 1+3=41 + 3 = 4 atoms, yielding 0.05872×4≈0.2349 mol0.05872 \times 4 \approx 0.2349\text{ mol} of atoms. The ratio is 0.31170.2349≈1.33\frac{0.3117}{0.2349} \approx 1.33.

Loading workspace…